Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Science

Coulomb crystallization of highly charged ions

L. Schmöger, Oscar O. Versolato, M. Schwarz, M. Kohnen, A. Windberger, Baptist Piest, Stefanie Feuchtenbeiner, J. Pedregosa-Gutierrez, Tobias Leopold, P. Micke, Anders Kragh Hansen, Thomas M. Baumann, Michael Drewsen, J. Ullrich, Piet O. Schmidt, J. R. Crespo López-Urrutia

Published Mar 12, 2015• 137 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Control over the motional degrees of freedom of atoms, ions, and molecules in a field-free environment enables unrivalled measurement accuracies but has yet to be applied to highly charged ions (HCIs), which are of particular interest to future atomic clock designs and searches for physics beyond the Standard Model. Here, we report on the Coulomb crystallization of HCIs (specifically (40)Ar(13+)) produced in an electron beam ion trap and retrapped in a cryogenic linear radiofrequency trap by means of sympathetic motional cooling through Coulomb interaction with a directly laser-cooled ensemble of Be(+) ions. We also demonstrate cooling of a single Ar(13+) ion by a single Be(+) ion-the prerequisite for quantum logic spectroscopy with a potential 10(-19) accuracy level. Achieving a seven-orders-of-magnitude decrease in HCI temperature starting at megakelvin down to the millikelvin range removes the major obstacle for HCI investigation with high-precision laser spectroscopy.

DOI
10.1126/science.aaa2960

Related papers

Quantum Logic Spectroscopy of Highly Charged Ions

P. Micke

Fundamental interactions and symmetries define the structure and properties of all matter, in particular of its small and diverse visible constituents—the atoms. The study of their distinctive spectra through precision spectroscopy is therefore a vital tool to advance our understanding of nature. Highly charged ions (HCIs) constitute the largest fraction of all atoms since every atom has as many charge states as electrons it can bind. Although most of the matter on Earth is neutral, HCIs are ubiquitous in the universe and their systematic study is essential not only for atomic physics but eminently for astrophysics, nuclear physics, and fusion research, among others. Recently, HCIs have been identified as ideal candidates for sensitive tests of physics beyond the Standard Model of particle physics and for use in future high-accuracy optical atomic clocks. However, the realization of such proposals has been hindered by the hitherto constrained laboratory control and limited spectroscopic accuracy of about parts-per-million fractional uncertainty levels. This thesis reports the first coherent laser spectroscopy of HCIs, boosting the achievable spectroscopic precision by eight orders of magnitude compared to traditional spectroscopy methods. The 2P1/2–2P3/2 fine-structure ground-state transition in highly charged 40Ar13+ at an optical wavelength of 441 nm was chosen as a proof-of-principle case. A single ion of this species was isolated from a megakelvin-hot plasma cloud and co-trapped together with a laser-cooled singly charged 9Be+ ion in a two-ion crystal, confined in the harmonic potential of a cryogenic linear Paul trap. This coupled quantum-mechanical system was then cooled to its ground state of axial motion, corresponding to the lowest temperature of a HCI ever achieved. The spectroscopy was realized by implementing quantum logic techniques which allow preparation of the quantum state of the HCI and to map its electronic state after spectroscopy onto the 9Be+ logic ion in order to detect it there with high efficiency through electron shelving. In addition to the increase of spectroscopic precision, the excited-state lifetime and g-factor were measured—the latter one to unprecedented accuracy, resolving effects from special relativity, interelectronic interactions, and quantum electrodynamics. Moreover, it settled a discrepancy between theoretical predictions. The demonstrated techniques are not limited to the specific 40Ar13+ species but universally applicable to other HCIs. Thereby, this work unlocks the potential of HCIs for unrivaled tests of fundamental physics, the search for new physics—such as a 5th force, variations of fundamental constants and dark matter candidates—as well as the use of HCIs in novel optical atomic clocks.

•Jan 1, 2020•1 citation

Coulomb crystallization of xenon highly charged ions in a laser-cooled Ca+ matrix

Leonid Prokhorov, Aaron A. Smith, Mingyao Xu +17 more

We report on the sympathetic cooling and Coulomb crystallization of xenon highly charged ions (HCIs) with laser-cooled Ca$^+$ ions. The HCIs are produced in a compact electron beam ion trap, then charge selected, decelerated, and finally injected into a cryogenic linear Paul trap. There, they are captured into $^{40}$Ca$^+$ Coulomb crystals, and co-crystallized within them, causing dark voids in their fluorescence images. Fine control over the number of trapped ions and HCIs allows us to realize mixed-species crystals with arbitrary ordering patterns. By investigating Xe$^{q+}$--Ca$^+$ strings, we confirm the HCI charge states, measure their lifetime and characterize the mixed-species motional modes. Our system effectively combines the established quantum control toolbox for Ca$^+$ with the rich set of atomic properties of Xe highly charged ions, providing a resourceful platform for optical frequency metrology, searches for signatures of new physics, and quantum information science.

physics.atom-phCross-listedarXiv:2512.12266•Physical Review A•Dec 16, 2025•3 citations

Coulomb crystallization of highly charged Ni 12 + ions in a linear Paul trap

Shao-Long Chen, Zhi-qiang Zhou, Guo-sheng Zhang +4 more

Optical clocks have garnered widespread attention due to their unparalleled precision in the fields of time-frequency standards, geodetic measurements, and fundamental physics research. Among recent advances, highly charged ion (HCI)-based optical clocks have attracted significant scientific interest owing to their remarkable insensitivity to electromagnetic perturbations and enhanced sensitivity to potential variations of the fine-structure constant $(\ensuremath{\alpha})$. Although the recent successful demonstration of an ${\mathrm{Ar}}^{13+}$ optical clock has validated the feasibility of HCI-based systems, ${\mathrm{Ni}}^{12+}$ (featuring an ultranarrow clock transition linewidth) stands out as a superior candidate for achieving HCI optical clocks with ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}19}$ level uncertainty and stability. In this work, we report the Coulomb crystallization of highly charged nickel ions (Ni-HCIs). Through a precise deceleration and sympathetic cooling protocol in a room-temperature linear Paul trap, high-energy Ni-HCI bunches were sympathetically cooled from megakelvin energies down to the hundred-millikelvin range using laser-cooled ${\mathrm{Be}}^{+}$ ions. This work represents a pivotal step toward the realization of an optical clock based on ${\mathrm{Ni}}^{12+}$ ion.

arXiv:2504.19182•Physical Review A•Nov 18, 2025•4 citations

A cryogenic radio-frequency ion trap for quantum logic spectroscopy of highly charged ions

T. Leopold, S. A. King, P. Micke +5 more

A cryogenic radio-frequency ion trap system designed for quantum logic spectroscopy of highly charged ions (HCI) is presented. It includes a segmented linear Paul trap, an in-vacuum imaging lens, and a helical resonator. We demonstrate ground state cooling of all three modes of motion of a single 9Be+ ion and determine their heating rates as well as excess axial micromotion. The trap shows one of the lowest levels of electric field noise published to date. We investigate the magnetic-field noise suppression in cryogenic shields made from segmented copper, the resulting magnetic field stability at the ion position and the resulting coherence time. Using this trap in conjunction with an electron beam ion trap and a deceleration beamline, we have been able to trap single highly charged Ar13+ (Ar XIV) ions concurrently with single Be+ ions, a key prerequisite for the first quantum logic spectroscopy of a HCI. This major stepping stone allows us to push highly-charged-ion spectroscopic precision from the gigahertz to the hertz level and below.

arXiv:1901.03082•Review of Scientific Instruments•Jul 1, 2019•55 citations

Coulomb crystals in a cryogenic Paul trap for sympathetic cooling of molecular ions and highly charged ions

A. Windberger, M. Schwarz, Oscar O. Versolato +11 more

Electron beam ion traps used for spectroscopy of highly charged ions (HCI) produce a deep trapping potential leading to high temperatures of the stored ions, and thus limiting the achievable spectral resolution. A novel device at the Max-Planck-Institut für Kernphysik, the Cryogenic linear Paul Trap Experiment (CryPTEx), attached to an electron beam ion trap, provides a new experimental platform to overcome these limitations. The trap assembly operates at a temperature of 4 K and offers optical access for quantum manipulation and imaging of the trapped ions. Since forbidden optical transitions in HCI do not support direct laser cooling, sympathetic cooling with Coulomb crystals of singly charged ions such as Be+ or Mg+ will be applied in order to reach the natural linewidth of optical forbidden transitions in HCI of interest. With the added advantage of long ion trapping times resulting from residual gas pressures of H2 at 4 K below 10−15 mbar, CryPTEx has been commissioned in collaboration with the Ion Trap Group in Århus using rovibrationally cooled MgH+ ions. Strong suppression of the black body radiation at the trap center, ion storage times of about 28 hours, and largely enhanced population of the rovibrational ground state were achieved.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2013•5 citations

Coulomb crystallization of highly charged ions

L. Schmöger, Oscar O. Versolato, M Schwarz +13 more

Sympathetic Coulomb crystallization of highly charged ions, retrapped in a cryogenic radiofrequency trap, is demonstrated by an over seven orders-of-magnitude decrease in motional temperature.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Sep 7, 2015•11 citations
Control over the motional degrees of freedom of atoms, ions, and molecules in a field-free environment enables unrivalled measurement accuracies but has yet to be applied to highly charged ions (HCIs), which are of particular interest to future atomic clock designs and searches for physics beyond the Standard Model. Here, we report on the Coulomb crystallization of HCIs (specifically (40)Ar(13+)) produced in an electron beam ion trap and retrapped in a cryogenic linear radiofrequency trap by means of sympathetic motional cooling through Coulomb interaction with a directly laser-cooled ensemble of Be(+) ions. We also demonstrate cooling of a single Ar(13+) ion by a single Be(+) ion-the prerequisite for quantum logic spectroscopy with a potential 10(-19) accuracy level. Achieving a seven-orders-of-magnitude decrease in HCI temperature starting at megakelvin down to the millikelvin range removes the major obstacle for HCI investigation with high-precision laser spectroscopy.
Fundamental interactions and symmetries define the structure and properties of all matter, in particular of its small and diverse visible constituents—the atoms. The study of their distinctive spectra through precision spectroscopy is therefore a vital tool to advance our understanding of nature. Highly charged ions (HCIs) constitute the largest fraction of all atoms since every atom has as many charge states as electrons it can bind. Although most of the matter on Earth is neutral, HCIs are ubiquitous in the universe and their systematic study is essential not only for atomic physics but eminently for astrophysics, nuclear physics, and fusion research, among others. Recently, HCIs have been identified as ideal candidates for sensitive tests of physics beyond the Standard Model of particle physics and for use in future high-accuracy optical atomic clocks. However, the realization of such proposals has been hindered by the hitherto constrained laboratory control and limited spectroscopic accuracy of about parts-per-million fractional uncertainty levels. This thesis reports the first coherent laser spectroscopy of HCIs, boosting the achievable spectroscopic precision by eight orders of magnitude compared to traditional spectroscopy methods. The 2P1/2–2P3/2 fine-structure ground-state transition in highly charged 40Ar13+ at an optical wavelength of 441 nm was chosen as a proof-of-principle case. A single ion of this species was isolated from a megakelvin-hot plasma cloud and co-trapped together with a laser-cooled singly charged 9Be+ ion in a two-ion crystal, confined in the harmonic potential of a cryogenic linear Paul trap. This coupled quantum-mechanical system was then cooled to its ground state of axial motion, corresponding to the lowest temperature of a HCI ever achieved. The spectroscopy was realized by implementing quantum logic techniques which allow preparation of the quantum state of the HCI and to map its electronic state after spectroscopy onto the 9Be+ logic ion in order to detect it there with high efficiency through electron shelving. In addition to the increase of spectroscopic precision, the excited-state lifetime and g-factor were measured—the latter one to unprecedented accuracy, resolving effects from special relativity, interelectronic interactions, and quantum electrodynamics. Moreover, it settled a discrepancy between theoretical predictions. The demonstrated techniques are not limited to the specific 40Ar13+ species but universally applicable to other HCIs. Thereby, this work unlocks the potential of HCIs for unrivaled tests of fundamental physics, the search for new physics—such as a 5th force, variations of fundamental constants and dark matter candidates—as well as the use of HCIs in novel optical atomic clocks.
We report on the sympathetic cooling and Coulomb crystallization of xenon highly charged ions (HCIs) with laser-cooled Ca+^++ ions. The HCIs are produced in a compact electron beam ion trap, then charge selected, decelerated, and finally injected into a cryogenic linear Paul trap. There, they are captured into 40^{40}40Ca+^++ Coulomb crystals, and co-crystallized within them, causing dark voids in their fluorescence images. Fine control over the number of trapped ions and HCIs allows us to realize mixed-species crystals with arbitrary ordering patterns. By investigating Xeq+^{q+}q+--Ca+^++ strings, we confirm the HCI charge states, measure their lifetime and characterize the mixed-species motional modes. Our system effectively combines the established quantum control toolbox for Ca+^++ with the rich set of atomic properties of Xe highly charged ions, providing a resourceful platform for optical frequency metrology, searches for signatures of new physics, and quantum information science.
Optical clocks have garnered widespread attention due to their unparalleled precision in the fields of time-frequency standards, geodetic measurements, and fundamental physics research. Among recent advances, highly charged ion (HCI)-based optical clocks have attracted significant scientific interest owing to their remarkable insensitivity to electromagnetic perturbations and enhanced sensitivity to potential variations of the fine-structure constant $(\ensuremath{\alpha})$. Although the recent successful demonstration of an Ar13+{\mathrm{Ar}}^{13+}Ar13+ optical clock has validated the feasibility of HCI-based systems, Ni12+{\mathrm{Ni}}^{12+}Ni12+ (featuring an ultranarrow clock transition linewidth) stands out as a superior candidate for achieving HCI optical clocks with ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}19}$ level uncertainty and stability. In this work, we report the Coulomb crystallization of highly charged nickel ions (Ni-HCIs). Through a precise deceleration and sympathetic cooling protocol in a room-temperature linear Paul trap, high-energy Ni-HCI bunches were sympathetically cooled from megakelvin energies down to the hundred-millikelvin range using laser-cooled Be+{\mathrm{Be}}^{+}Be+ ions. This work represents a pivotal step toward the realization of an optical clock based on Ni12+{\mathrm{Ni}}^{12+}Ni12+ ion.
A cryogenic radio-frequency ion trap system designed for quantum logic spectroscopy of highly charged ions (HCI) is presented. It includes a segmented linear Paul trap, an in-vacuum imaging lens, and a helical resonator. We demonstrate ground state cooling of all three modes of motion of a single 9Be+ ion and determine their heating rates as well as excess axial micromotion. The trap shows one of the lowest levels of electric field noise published to date. We investigate the magnetic-field noise suppression in cryogenic shields made from segmented copper, the resulting magnetic field stability at the ion position and the resulting coherence time. Using this trap in conjunction with an electron beam ion trap and a deceleration beamline, we have been able to trap single highly charged Ar13+ (Ar XIV) ions concurrently with single Be+ ions, a key prerequisite for the first quantum logic spectroscopy of a HCI. This major stepping stone allows us to push highly-charged-ion spectroscopic precision from the gigahertz to the hertz level and below.
Electron beam ion traps used for spectroscopy of highly charged ions (HCI) produce a deep trapping potential leading to high temperatures of the stored ions, and thus limiting the achievable spectral resolution. A novel device at the Max-Planck-Institut für Kernphysik, the Cryogenic linear Paul Trap Experiment (CryPTEx), attached to an electron beam ion trap, provides a new experimental platform to overcome these limitations. The trap assembly operates at a temperature of 4 K and offers optical access for quantum manipulation and imaging of the trapped ions. Since forbidden optical transitions in HCI do not support direct laser cooling, sympathetic cooling with Coulomb crystals of singly charged ions such as Be+ or Mg+ will be applied in order to reach the natural linewidth of optical forbidden transitions in HCI of interest. With the added advantage of long ion trapping times resulting from residual gas pressures of H2 at 4 K below 10−15 mbar, CryPTEx has been commissioned in collaboration with the Ion Trap Group in Århus using rovibrationally cooled MgH+ ions. Strong suppression of the black body radiation at the trap center, ion storage times of about 28 hours, and largely enhanced population of the rovibrational ground state were achieved.