Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics

The Dick effect for an optical frequency standard

Audrey Quessada, Richard P. Kovacich, I. Courtillot, Andr  Clairon, Giorgio Santarelli, P. Lemonde

Published Apr 1, 2003• 107 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We present an analysis of the frequency stability degradation of an optical atomic frequency standard which is operated sequentially, and that is caused by the frequency noise of the laser used to interrogate the clock transition. This is an extension to optical frequencies of the 'Dick effect' already studied in atomic microwave frequency standards. It is shown that the simple concept of laser linewidth is not the relevant parameter to estimate the frequency stability degradation. Rather, the details of the laser frequency noise spectral density must be accounted for together with the parameters of the interrogation method. We compute the optical Dick effect in the case of a four pulse Ramsey–Bordé interferometer. We show that it may be minimized by optimizing the time sequence so that only the Fourier frequencies with minimum laser noise are sampled. Finally, we evaluate the degradation which would be obtained with one of our lasers used as an interrogation oscillator. This laser reaches a white noise floor S ν ( f ) = 10 −2 Hz 2 /Hz at a Fourier frequency of 100 Hz. We show that with this particular laser, a relative frequency stability of the order of 10 −16 in a 1 s averaging time can be reached using realistic experimental parameters.

DOI
10.1088/1464-4266/5/2/373

Related papers

Dick Effect in a Microwave Frequency Standard Based on Laser-Cooled 113 Cd+ Ions

Jianwei Zhang, K. Miao, Lijun Wang

The Dick effect is one of the main limits to the frequency stability of a passive frequency standard, especially for the fountain clock and ion clock operated in pulsed mode which require unavoidable dead time during interrogation. Here we measure the phase noise of the interrogation oscillator applied in the microwave frequency standard based on laser-cooled 113 Cd + ions, and analyze the Allan deviation limited by the Dick effect. The results indicate that the Dick effect is one of the key issues for the cadmium ion clock to reach expected frequency stability. This problem can be resolved by interrogating the local oscillator continuously with two ion traps.

Chinese Physics Letters•Jan 1, 2015•13 citations

Minimizing the dick effect in an optical lattice clock

Philip G. Westergaard, Jérôme Lodewyck, P. Lemonde

We discuss the minimization of the Dick effect in an optical lattice clock. We show that optimizing the time sequence of operation of the clock can lead to a significant reduction of the clock stability degradation by the frequency noise of the interrogation laser. By using a nondestructive detection of the atoms, we are able to recycle most of the atoms between cycles and consequently to strongly reduce the time spent capturing the atoms in each cycle. With optimized parameters, we expect a fractional Allan deviation better than 2 x 10(-16tau-1/2) for the lattice clock.

arXiv:0909.0909•IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics Ferroelectrics and Frequency Control•Mar 1, 2010•60 citations

Optimization of the Dick effect in an optical lattice clock

Philip G. Westergaard, Jérôme Lodewyck, P. Lemonde

We discuss the optimization of the Dick effect in an optical lattice clock. We show that optimizing the time sequence of operation of the clock can lead to a significant reduction of the clock stability degradation by the frequency noise of the interrogation laser. By using a non-destructive detection of the atoms, we are able to recycle most of the atoms between cycles and consequently to strongly reduce the time spent capturing the atoms in each cycle. With optimized parameters, we expect a fractional Allan deviation better than 2 middot 10-16tau-1/2for the lattice clock.

Joint Conference of the European Frequency and Time Forum and IEEE International Frequency Control Symposium (EFTF/IFCS)•Apr 1, 2009•0 citations

Zero-Dead-Time Strontium Lattice Clock with a Stability at 10 − 19 Level

Xiao-Yong Liu, Peng Liu, Jie Li +20 more

Optical atomic clocks play a crucial role in fundamental physics, relativistic geodesy, and the future redefinition of the Systeme International second. Standard operation relies on cyclic interrogation sequences, which alternate between atomic interrogation and dead time used for state preparation and readout. This approach introduces the Dick effect, where laser frequency noise aliases onto the atomic transition frequency. Although reducing laser noise improves clock stability, the Dick effect remains a key limitation. In this Letter, we demonstrate a zero-dead-time optical clock based on two interleaved ensembles of cold ^{87}Sr atoms. Our system significantly suppresses this noise and achieves a fractional frequency instability at the 10^{-19} level between 10 000 and 20 000 s over repeated measurements, with a best value of 2.9×10^{-19} at τ=20000 s. The estimated long-term stability based on the combined data of these measurements reaches 2.5×10^{-19} at 1 day. These results represent a more than ninefold improvement over a conventional single-ensemble clock, highlighting its potential for next-generation timekeeping applications.

arXiv:2509.15100•Physical Review Letters•Nov 26, 2025•15 citations

Frequency noise processes in a strontium ion optical clock

G. P. Barwood, Guozheng Huang, S. A. King +2 more

Abstract A recent comparison of the frequencies of a pair of optical clocks based on the 674 nm 2 S 1/2 – 2 D 5/2 optical clock transition in 88 Sr + has highlighted the need to understand factors affecting frequency instability. We have developed statistical models to show that our clock is capable of reaching the quantum projection noise limit; for our clock using 100 ms probe pulses, this is ∼3 × 10 −15 /√ τ . However, this optical clock uses atomic transitions with a linear Zeeman shift, which can lead to a degradation in stability in the presence of magnetic field noise. We show that this generally leads to an increase in white frequency noise, even in cases dominated by magnetic field flicker or random walk noise. By taking into account both the quantum projection and magnetic field noise we are able to explain our observed frequency instabilities. This analysis will relate to any optical clock with a linear Zeeman shift where cancellation of this shift is achieved by interrogating pairs of components. Furthermore, implementing automatic control of lasers and minimization of micromotion requires pausing of the frequency servo occasionally; this leads to only a small degradation of frequency stability.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Jan 13, 2015•14 citations

Dick effect in a pulsed atomic clock using coherent population trapping

Jean-Marie Danet, M. Lours, Stéphane Guérandel +1 more

The Dick effect can be a limitation of the achievable frequency stability of a passive atomic frequency standard when the ancillary frequency source is only periodically sampled. Here, we analyze the Dick effect for a pulsed vapor cell clock using coherent population trapping (CPT). Because of its specific interrogation process without atomic preparation nor detection outside of the Ramsey pulses, it exhibits an original shape of the sensitivity function to phase noise of the oscillator. Numerical calculations using a three-level atom model are successfully compared with measurements; an approximate formula of the sensitivity function is given as an easy-to-use tool. A comparison of our CPT clock sensitivity to phase noise with a clock of the same duty cycle using a two-level system reveals a higher sensitivity in the CPT case. The influence of a free-evolution time variation and of a detection duration lengthening on this sensitivity is studied. Finally, this study permitted the choice of an adapted quartz oscillator and allowed an improvement of the clock fractional frequency stability at the level of 3.2 x 10-13at 1 s.

arXiv:1406.6673•IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics Ferroelectrics and Frequency Control•Apr 1, 2014•66 citations
We present an analysis of the frequency stability degradation of an optical atomic frequency standard which is operated sequentially, and that is caused by the frequency noise of the laser used to interrogate the clock transition. This is an extension to optical frequencies of the 'Dick effect' already studied in atomic microwave frequency standards. It is shown that the simple concept of laser linewidth is not the relevant parameter to estimate the frequency stability degradation. Rather, the details of the laser frequency noise spectral density must be accounted for together with the parameters of the interrogation method. We compute the optical Dick effect in the case of a four pulse Ramsey–Bordé interferometer. We show that it may be minimized by optimizing the time sequence so that only the Fourier frequencies with minimum laser noise are sampled. Finally, we evaluate the degradation which would be obtained with one of our lasers used as an interrogation oscillator. This laser reaches a white noise floor S ν ( f ) = 10 −2 Hz 2 /Hz at a Fourier frequency of 100 Hz. We show that with this particular laser, a relative frequency stability of the order of 10 −16 in a 1 s averaging time can be reached using realistic experimental parameters.
The Dick effect is one of the main limits to the frequency stability of a passive frequency standard, especially for the fountain clock and ion clock operated in pulsed mode which require unavoidable dead time during interrogation. Here we measure the phase noise of the interrogation oscillator applied in the microwave frequency standard based on laser-cooled 113 Cd + ions, and analyze the Allan deviation limited by the Dick effect. The results indicate that the Dick effect is one of the key issues for the cadmium ion clock to reach expected frequency stability. This problem can be resolved by interrogating the local oscillator continuously with two ion traps.
We discuss the minimization of the Dick effect in an optical lattice clock. We show that optimizing the time sequence of operation of the clock can lead to a significant reduction of the clock stability degradation by the frequency noise of the interrogation laser. By using a nondestructive detection of the atoms, we are able to recycle most of the atoms between cycles and consequently to strongly reduce the time spent capturing the atoms in each cycle. With optimized parameters, we expect a fractional Allan deviation better than 2 x 10(-16tau-1/2) for the lattice clock.
We discuss the optimization of the Dick effect in an optical lattice clock. We show that optimizing the time sequence of operation of the clock can lead to a significant reduction of the clock stability degradation by the frequency noise of the interrogation laser. By using a non-destructive detection of the atoms, we are able to recycle most of the atoms between cycles and consequently to strongly reduce the time spent capturing the atoms in each cycle. With optimized parameters, we expect a fractional Allan deviation better than 2 middot 10-16tau-1/2for the lattice clock.
Optical atomic clocks play a crucial role in fundamental physics, relativistic geodesy, and the future redefinition of the Systeme International second. Standard operation relies on cyclic interrogation sequences, which alternate between atomic interrogation and dead time used for state preparation and readout. This approach introduces the Dick effect, where laser frequency noise aliases onto the atomic transition frequency. Although reducing laser noise improves clock stability, the Dick effect remains a key limitation. In this Letter, we demonstrate a zero-dead-time optical clock based on two interleaved ensembles of cold ^{87}Sr atoms. Our system significantly suppresses this noise and achieves a fractional frequency instability at the 10^{-19} level between 10 000 and 20 000 s over repeated measurements, with a best value of 2.9×10^{-19} at τ=20000 s. The estimated long-term stability based on the combined data of these measurements reaches 2.5×10^{-19} at 1 day. These results represent a more than ninefold improvement over a conventional single-ensemble clock, highlighting its potential for next-generation timekeeping applications.
Abstract A recent comparison of the frequencies of a pair of optical clocks based on the 674 nm 2 S 1/2 – 2 D 5/2 optical clock transition in 88 Sr + has highlighted the need to understand factors affecting frequency instability. We have developed statistical models to show that our clock is capable of reaching the quantum projection noise limit; for our clock using 100 ms probe pulses, this is ∼3 × 10 −15 /√ τ . However, this optical clock uses atomic transitions with a linear Zeeman shift, which can lead to a degradation in stability in the presence of magnetic field noise. We show that this generally leads to an increase in white frequency noise, even in cases dominated by magnetic field flicker or random walk noise. By taking into account both the quantum projection and magnetic field noise we are able to explain our observed frequency instabilities. This analysis will relate to any optical clock with a linear Zeeman shift where cancellation of this shift is achieved by interrogating pairs of components. Furthermore, implementing automatic control of lasers and minimization of micromotion requires pausing of the frequency servo occasionally; this leads to only a small degradation of frequency stability.
The Dick effect can be a limitation of the achievable frequency stability of a passive atomic frequency standard when the ancillary frequency source is only periodically sampled. Here, we analyze the Dick effect for a pulsed vapor cell clock using coherent population trapping (CPT). Because of its specific interrogation process without atomic preparation nor detection outside of the Ramsey pulses, it exhibits an original shape of the sensitivity function to phase noise of the oscillator. Numerical calculations using a three-level atom model are successfully compared with measurements; an approximate formula of the sensitivity function is given as an easy-to-use tool. A comparison of our CPT clock sensitivity to phase noise with a clock of the same duty cycle using a two-level system reveals a higher sensitivity in the CPT case. The influence of a free-evolution time variation and of a detection duration lengthening on this sensitivity is studied. Finally, this study permitted the choice of an adapted quartz oscillator and allowed an improvement of the clock fractional frequency stability at the level of 3.2 x 10-13at 1 s.