Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Progress of Theoretical Physics

Quantal Logic vs Classical Logic

Nagahiro Saito

Published Oct 1, 2006• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Two methods for the description of physical phenomena, microscopic and macroscopic, are necessary to understand the physical world. We now have two examples. The first one is mechanical, whether classical or quantal, vs thermodynamic treatments, which are characterized by reversibility and irreversibility, respectively. Another one is quantal vs classical theories, which have different forms of logic and lead to various paradoxes in measurement processes. To understand these contradicting aspects, it should be noted that in both cases, chaos and measurement are involved inevitably, and averages over small regions of space and time for measurement are required. In this way, chaos mediates between the two methods of description. We have already made an attempt to treat the former example in terms of ergodicity. In this paper the latter example will be treated with the theory of quantum measurement and the EPR paradox in mind.

DOI
10.1143/ptp.116.615

Related papers

Chaos and Quantum Mechanics

Salman Habib, Tanmoy Bhattacharya A, Benjamin D. Greenbaum +3 more

The relationship between chaos and quantum mechanics has been somewhat uneasy--even stormy, in the minds of some people. However, much of the confusion may stem from inappropriate comparisons using formal analyses. In contrast, our starting point here is that a complete dynamical description requires a full understanding of the evolution of measured systems, necessary to explain actual experimental results. This is of course true, both classically and quantum mechanically. Because the evolution of the physical state is now conditioned on measurement results, the dynamics of such systems is intrinsically nonlinear even at the level of distribution functions. Due to this feature, the physically more complete treatment reveals the existence of dynamical regimes--such as chaos--that have no direct counterpart in the linear (unobserved) case. Moreover, this treatment allows for understanding how an effective classical behavior can result from the dynamics of an observed quantum system, both at the level of trajectories as well as distribution functions. Finally, we have the striking prediction that time-series from measured quantum systems can be chaotic far from the classical regime, with Lyapunov exponents differing from their classical values. These predictions can be tested in next-generation experiments.

arXiv:quant-ph/0505085•Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences•Jun 1, 2005•27 citations

On the Theory of Measurement in Quantum Mechanical Systems

Loyal Durand

This paper is concerned with the description of the process of measurement within the context of a quantum theory of the physical world. It is noted that quantum mechanics permits a quasi-classical description (classical in the limited sense implied by the correspondence principle of Bohr) of those macroscopic phenomena in terms of which the observer forms his perceptions. Thus, the process of measurement in quantum mechanics can be understood on the quasi-classical level by transcribing from the strictly classical observables of Newtonian physics to their quasi-classical counterparts the known rules for the measurement of the former. The remaining physical problem is the delineation of the circumstances in which the correlation of a peculiarly quantum mechanical observable A with a classically measurable observable B can result in a significant measurement of A. This is undertaken within the context of quantum theory. The resulting clarification of the process of measurement has important implications relative to the philosophic interpretation of quantum mechanics.

Philosophy of Science•Apr 1, 1960•10 citations

Time, decoherence, and ‘reversible’ measurements

Philip C. E. Stamp

Introduction In this chapter I attempt to review a few somewhat loosely connected themes, which figure in recent work by physicists on decoherence and irreversibility in quantum mechanics. The looseness is forced upon us by the subject – any proper discussion inevitably drags in questions about thermodynamic reversibility and the various arrows of time, about the foundations of quantum mechanics and quantum measurement, about the nature of quantum coherence, and about the relationship between quantum and classical mechanics. There are inevitably many gaps in our understanding of these questions, both for the physicist and for the philosopher. Some philosophers may feel that the subject is too immature to be interesting to them – that it is not yet ripe for philosophical analysis. Indeed I have recently heard the opinion expressed that quantum mechanics in its entirety was still not amenable to such analysis – that if the physicists could not yet understand it, there was no point in philosophers trying! I hope this feeling is not too widespread amongst philosophers of science – I suspect that it may arise in part because the philosophical community (along with a good part of the scientific community) is unaware of some important advances that have been made in the last decade in understanding the physics of quantum processes at the macroscopic level, as well as the relation between classical and quantum mechanics. Much of the chapter is therefore unashamedly tutorial in nature; however, given the wide range of topics covered, I imagine that even physicists will find at least some of the material to be novel.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 24, 1995•6 citations

Theory of Quantum Measurement in Terms of Quantum Chaos

Nobuhiko Saitô

Quantum non-integrable systems have pseudochaos in the phase of the eigenfunctions. In particular, correlation function of wave functions at two different points disappears, when observation process, which requires space and/or time average over a small range, is taken into account. This gives rise to the realization of decoherence in measuring processes. By virtue of this property of quantum chaos, various problems and paradoxes are explained in the framework of conventional quantum mechanics. The subjects treated here are the duality of wave and particle, the wave function collapse in measurement, Stern–Gerlach experiments, Schrödinger's cat paradox, the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox and quantum Zeno effect.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Jun 15, 2004•1 citation

Logic and Complementarity

T. Bergstein

From the preceding exposition it follows that the quantum statistical representation of an individual atomic system does not imply any renunciation regarding further knowledge about the system. On the contrary the statistical character of quantum physics directly reflects the fundamental non-causal appearance of quantal recordings, and through the discovery of the complementarity of quantal phenomena a complete but necessarily statistical description of the atom has been accomplished. Furthermore quantum physics has afforded a statistical description of macroscopic bodies through their representation as assemblies of huge numbers of identical atomic systems, and, apart from accounting in a more fundamental way for the properties already described in classical physics(the correspondence principle, p. 36), quantum statistics explains several macroscopic phenomena which cannot be understood within the conceptual frame of classical physics only. It must be maintained, however, that when observing the properties of individual atomic objects the macroscopic observational apparatus cannot be represented in terms of atomic constituents because this would destroy the unambiguity of the description. The observational apparatus fulfils its basic function of being the spacetime frame of reference for the quantal recordings precisely through its description in classical physics alone. However, when refraining from the analysis of individual quantal processes it is possible to apply quantum statistics to macroscopic phenomena, that is, the causality of classical physical phenomena can be interpreted in the quantum formalism as the statistical result of the interplay of enormous numbers of atomic processes. It is possible, then, to talk of statistical causality as a fundamental aspect of physical reality.

•Jan 1, 1972•0 citations

Classical Concepts and Quantal Inequivalences

F. S. Levin

Chapter 1 was concerned with the need for a quantal description of microscopic phenomena. The thrust of Chapter 3 is an analysis and comparison of a classical and a quantum system; some mathematical generalizations of the analysis are presented as well. Chapter 4 provides an introduction to Hilbert-space concepts that are the mathematical framework of quantum theory, while, in Chapter 5, the axioms of quantum mechanics for pure states are stated and illustrated. The present chapter is intended to be a bridge between those chapters and Chapter 1. Here we review many of the concepts of classical mechanics that have relevance in quantum mechanics. Equally important, if not more so, we stress the lack of equivalence between a number of classical concepts and their quantal counterparts. This inequivalence is emphasized because of the vocabulary common to classical and quantum mechanics. Classical physics is, of course, the source for much of the vocabulary in quantum physics. However, the ways in which the words are used in the two domains often differ substantially, while the concepts are almost necessarily not identical. Some classical concepts have no direct quantal counterparts. For example, velocity and force are not primary quantal entities. This fact means that the quantal definitions of linear and angular momentum cannot be the same as those in classical mechanics. Similarly, the concept of a “state” in classical physics – the collection of the generalized positions and generalized velocities or momenta – does not carry over to quantum physics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 3, 2001•0 citations
Two methods for the description of physical phenomena, microscopic and macroscopic, are necessary to understand the physical world. We now have two examples. The first one is mechanical, whether classical or quantal, vs thermodynamic treatments, which are characterized by reversibility and irreversibility, respectively. Another one is quantal vs classical theories, which have different forms of logic and lead to various paradoxes in measurement processes. To understand these contradicting aspects, it should be noted that in both cases, chaos and measurement are involved inevitably, and averages over small regions of space and time for measurement are required. In this way, chaos mediates between the two methods of description. We have already made an attempt to treat the former example in terms of ergodicity. In this paper the latter example will be treated with the theory of quantum measurement and the EPR paradox in mind.
The relationship between chaos and quantum mechanics has been somewhat uneasy--even stormy, in the minds of some people. However, much of the confusion may stem from inappropriate comparisons using formal analyses. In contrast, our starting point here is that a complete dynamical description requires a full understanding of the evolution of measured systems, necessary to explain actual experimental results. This is of course true, both classically and quantum mechanically. Because the evolution of the physical state is now conditioned on measurement results, the dynamics of such systems is intrinsically nonlinear even at the level of distribution functions. Due to this feature, the physically more complete treatment reveals the existence of dynamical regimes--such as chaos--that have no direct counterpart in the linear (unobserved) case. Moreover, this treatment allows for understanding how an effective classical behavior can result from the dynamics of an observed quantum system, both at the level of trajectories as well as distribution functions. Finally, we have the striking prediction that time-series from measured quantum systems can be chaotic far from the classical regime, with Lyapunov exponents differing from their classical values. These predictions can be tested in next-generation experiments.
This paper is concerned with the description of the process of measurement within the context of a quantum theory of the physical world. It is noted that quantum mechanics permits a quasi-classical description (classical in the limited sense implied by the correspondence principle of Bohr) of those macroscopic phenomena in terms of which the observer forms his perceptions. Thus, the process of measurement in quantum mechanics can be understood on the quasi-classical level by transcribing from the strictly classical observables of Newtonian physics to their quasi-classical counterparts the known rules for the measurement of the former. The remaining physical problem is the delineation of the circumstances in which the correlation of a peculiarly quantum mechanical observable A with a classically measurable observable B can result in a significant measurement of A. This is undertaken within the context of quantum theory. The resulting clarification of the process of measurement has important implications relative to the philosophic interpretation of quantum mechanics.
Introduction In this chapter I attempt to review a few somewhat loosely connected themes, which figure in recent work by physicists on decoherence and irreversibility in quantum mechanics. The looseness is forced upon us by the subject – any proper discussion inevitably drags in questions about thermodynamic reversibility and the various arrows of time, about the foundations of quantum mechanics and quantum measurement, about the nature of quantum coherence, and about the relationship between quantum and classical mechanics. There are inevitably many gaps in our understanding of these questions, both for the physicist and for the philosopher. Some philosophers may feel that the subject is too immature to be interesting to them – that it is not yet ripe for philosophical analysis. Indeed I have recently heard the opinion expressed that quantum mechanics in its entirety was still not amenable to such analysis – that if the physicists could not yet understand it, there was no point in philosophers trying! I hope this feeling is not too widespread amongst philosophers of science – I suspect that it may arise in part because the philosophical community (along with a good part of the scientific community) is unaware of some important advances that have been made in the last decade in understanding the physics of quantum processes at the macroscopic level, as well as the relation between classical and quantum mechanics. Much of the chapter is therefore unashamedly tutorial in nature; however, given the wide range of topics covered, I imagine that even physicists will find at least some of the material to be novel.
Quantum non-integrable systems have pseudochaos in the phase of the eigenfunctions. In particular, correlation function of wave functions at two different points disappears, when observation process, which requires space and/or time average over a small range, is taken into account. This gives rise to the realization of decoherence in measuring processes. By virtue of this property of quantum chaos, various problems and paradoxes are explained in the framework of conventional quantum mechanics. The subjects treated here are the duality of wave and particle, the wave function collapse in measurement, Stern–Gerlach experiments, Schrödinger's cat paradox, the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen paradox and quantum Zeno effect.
From the preceding exposition it follows that the quantum statistical representation of an individual atomic system does not imply any renunciation regarding further knowledge about the system. On the contrary the statistical character of quantum physics directly reflects the fundamental non-causal appearance of quantal recordings, and through the discovery of the complementarity of quantal phenomena a complete but necessarily statistical description of the atom has been accomplished. Furthermore quantum physics has afforded a statistical description of macroscopic bodies through their representation as assemblies of huge numbers of identical atomic systems, and, apart from accounting in a more fundamental way for the properties already described in classical physics(the correspondence principle, p. 36), quantum statistics explains several macroscopic phenomena which cannot be understood within the conceptual frame of classical physics only. It must be maintained, however, that when observing the properties of individual atomic objects the macroscopic observational apparatus cannot be represented in terms of atomic constituents because this would destroy the unambiguity of the description. The observational apparatus fulfils its basic function of being the spacetime frame of reference for the quantal recordings precisely through its description in classical physics alone. However, when refraining from the analysis of individual quantal processes it is possible to apply quantum statistics to macroscopic phenomena, that is, the causality of classical physical phenomena can be interpreted in the quantum formalism as the statistical result of the interplay of enormous numbers of atomic processes. It is possible, then, to talk of statistical causality as a fundamental aspect of physical reality.
Chapter 1 was concerned with the need for a quantal description of microscopic phenomena. The thrust of Chapter 3 is an analysis and comparison of a classical and a quantum system; some mathematical generalizations of the analysis are presented as well. Chapter 4 provides an introduction to Hilbert-space concepts that are the mathematical framework of quantum theory, while, in Chapter 5, the axioms of quantum mechanics for pure states are stated and illustrated. The present chapter is intended to be a bridge between those chapters and Chapter 1. Here we review many of the concepts of classical mechanics that have relevance in quantum mechanics. Equally important, if not more so, we stress the lack of equivalence between a number of classical concepts and their quantal counterparts. This inequivalence is emphasized because of the vocabulary common to classical and quantum mechanics. Classical physics is, of course, the source for much of the vocabulary in quantum physics. However, the ways in which the words are used in the two domains often differ substantially, while the concepts are almost necessarily not identical. Some classical concepts have no direct quantal counterparts. For example, velocity and force are not primary quantal entities. This fact means that the quantal definitions of linear and angular momentum cannot be the same as those in classical mechanics. Similarly, the concept of a “state” in classical physics – the collection of the generalized positions and generalized velocities or momenta – does not carry over to quantum physics.