Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Classical Concepts and Quantal Inequivalences

F. S. Levin

Published Dec 3, 2001• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Chapter 1 was concerned with the need for a quantal description of microscopic phenomena. The thrust of Chapter 3 is an analysis and comparison of a classical and a quantum system; some mathematical generalizations of the analysis are presented as well. Chapter 4 provides an introduction to Hilbert-space concepts that are the mathematical framework of quantum theory, while, in Chapter 5, the axioms of quantum mechanics for pure states are stated and illustrated. The present chapter is intended to be a bridge between those chapters and Chapter 1. Here we review many of the concepts of classical mechanics that have relevance in quantum mechanics. Equally important, if not more so, we stress the lack of equivalence between a number of classical concepts and their quantal counterparts. This inequivalence is emphasized because of the vocabulary common to classical and quantum mechanics. Classical physics is, of course, the source for much of the vocabulary in quantum physics. However, the ways in which the words are used in the two domains often differ substantially, while the concepts are almost necessarily not identical. Some classical concepts have no direct quantal counterparts. For example, velocity and force are not primary quantal entities. This fact means that the quantal definitions of linear and angular momentum cannot be the same as those in classical mechanics. Similarly, the concept of a “state” in classical physics – the collection of the generalized positions and generalized velocities or momenta – does not carry over to quantum physics.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9781139164177.003

Related papers

Introduction to Elementary Quantum Mechanics and Stability of the First Kind

Élliott H. Lieb, Robert Seiringer

In this second chapter we will review the basic mathematical and physical facts about quantum mechanics and establish physical units and notation. Those readers already familiar with the subject can safely jump to the next chapter. An attempt has been made to make the presentation in this chapter as elementary as possible, and yet present the basic facts that will be needed later. There are many beautiful and important topics which will not be touched upon such as self-adjointness of Schrödinger operators, the general mathematical structure of quantum mechanics and the like. These topics are well described in other works, e.g.. Much of the following can be done in a Euclidean space of arbitrary dimension, but in this chapter the dimension of the Euclidean space is taken to be three-which is the physical case-unless otherwise stated. We do this to avoid confusion and, occasionally, complications that arise in the computation of mathematical constants. The interested reader can easily generalize what is done here to the R d , d > 3 case. Likewise, in the next chapters we mostly consider N particles, with spatial coordinates in R 3 , so that the total spatial dimension is 3 N . A Brief Review of the Connection Between Classical and Quantum Mechanics Considering the range of validity of quantum mechanics, it is not surprising that its formulation is more complicated and abstract than classical mechanics. Nevertheless, classical mechanics is a basic ingredient for quantum mechanics. One still talks about position, momentum and energy which are notions from Newtonian mechanics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 5, 2009•0 citations

Introduction to Quantum Mechanics

J. W. Bray

This chapter is intended for nonpractitioners in the field with a technical background but not necessarily at the doctoral level and so minimizes equations and the more specialized jargon. The chapter starts with a brief history of quantum mechanics. The important basic concepts of quantum mechanics are discussed, and some commonly used terms and common quantum experiments are introduced. The difference between quantum and “classical” physics is discussed. The role of quantum theory in modern physics is explained. A number of applications of quantum phenomena are discussed with some emphasis on the three areas of the US National Quantum Initiative: quantum computing, quantum sensing, and quantum communications. Finally, the various interpretations of quantum mechanics with respect to its meanings for physical reality are touched upon. At this writing, quantum technologies are receiving increased emphasis and funding in several areas both in the US and several other nations, which is discussed.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 24, 2025•1 citation

Quantum mechanics

Carlo Rovelli C

Quantum mechanics (QM) is not just a theory of micro-objects: it is our current fundamental theory of motion. It expresses a deeper understanding of Nature than classical mechanics. Precisely as classical mechanics, the conventional formulation of QM describes evolution of states and observables in time. Precisely as classical mechanics, this is not sufficient to deal with general relativistic systems, because these systems do not describe evolution in time; they describe correlations between observables. Therefore, a formulation of QM slightly more general than the conventional one – or a quantum version of the relativistic classical mechanics discussed in the previous chapter – is needed. In this chapter I discuss the possibility of such a formulation. In the last section I discuss the general physical interpretation of QM.QM can be formulated in a number of more or less equivalent formalisms: canonical (Hilbert spaces and self-adjoint operators), covariant (Feynman's sum-over-histories), algebraic (states as linear functionals over an abstract algebra of observables) and others. Generally, but not always, we are able to translate these formalisms into one another, but often what is easy in one formulation is difficult in another. A generalrelativistic sum-over-histories formalism has been developed by Jim Hartle. Here I focus on the canonical formalism, because the canonical formalism has provided the mathematical completeness and precision needed to explicitly construct the mathematical apparatus of quantum gravity. Later I will consider alternative formalisms.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 15, 2004•0 citations

Description of a Physical System

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

The measure of greatness in a scientific idea is the extent to which it stimulates thought and opens up new lines of research. —P. A. M. Dirac From our day-to-day experience, we develop our notion of reality. However, our perception of physical properties, such as position and momentum, needs refinement to describe natural phenomena correctly. In this chapter we introduce fundamental principles of the quantum theory that does so with enduring cogency. The laws of nature that govern the functioning of the physical universe cannot be accounted for using classical physics of Newton, Lagrange, and Hamilton. Foundational principles and mathematical structure of quantum theory are introduced in this chapter. 1.1 Quantum versus Classical Physics Theories In classical physics, the mechanical state of a system is represented by a point in the position– velocity phase space, or equivalently in the position–momentum phase space. The entire theoretical formalism of Newtonian–Lagrangian–Hamiltonian mechanics is based on this Galilean conjecture. The classical hypothesis seems appropriate in a large number of physical situations that concern our day-to-day experiences. With this ansatz, the temporal evolution of a system is described by the trajectory of the point in the phase space. The trajectory is obtained from the equation of motion that governs the time dependence of position and velocity, represented respectively by q and (or alternatively the time dependence of position and momentum, represented respectively by q and p ). The alternative equations of motion – Newton’s, Lagrange’s, and Hamilton's – are equivalent. Their applicability must be reconciled with the upper limit on accuracy with which conjugate physical properties of an object, viz. position and momentum , are simultaneously measured. There is, however, an inverse relation between the accuracy of simultaneous measurement of these two properties. The more accurately you measure either, the less accurately can you measure the other. The act of measuring either of the conjugate properties requires an observation. Observations resulting in accurate measurements of conjugate variables are, however, not compatible with each other. Heisenberg's principle of uncertainty is the quantitative expression of this law of nature. It is expressed as a rigorous mathematical inequality that is neatly written in a compact form. Nonetheless, we refrain from advancing its mathematical expression too soon. It has no classical analogue. It cannot be written in any terms of what we are familiar with from classical mechanics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•1 citation

2. Basic quantum physics

Arnold Neumaier

Quantum physics consists of a formal core that is universally agreed upon (basically being a piece of mathematics with suggestive names for concepts matching related concepts of experimental culture) and an interpretational halo (trying to make this relation more precise) that remains highly disputed even after more than 90 years of modern quantum physics. The latter is the subject of the interpretation of quantum mechanics (see Part II), where many interpretations coexist and compete for the attention of those interested in what quantum physics really means. In this chapter, an axiomatic introduction to the undisputed formal core of quantum physics is given. The axioms described present nonrelativistic quantum statistical mechanics in the Schrödinger picture. The relativistic case is outside the scope of these axioms, as it must be treated by quantum field theory; see Chapter 7. As in any axiomatic setting (necessary for a formal discipline), there are a number of different but equivalent sets of axioms or postulates that can be used to define formal quantum physics. Since they are equivalent, their choice is a matter of convenience. The choice presented here is a formulation featuring three aspects: It emphasises the similarity of quantum mechanics and classical mechanics, gives most direct access to statistical mechanics, and is free from allusions to measurement. The reason for the first is that this similarity serves as a guide to meaning. From the axiomatic setting for quantum mechanics presented below, classical mechanics (in the Koopman setting discussed in Section 7.10) is obtained by simply restricting the operators to be diagonal, so that all operations happen pointwise on the diagonal elements. Thus, multiplication is commutative, and one can identify operators and functions. In particular, the density operator degenerates into a probability density. Therefore, the quantum case appears as a generalization of the classical case allowing for noncommutativity, so that both q-observables and the density operator are (usually infinite-dimensional) operators. The reason for the second is that statistical mechanics is the main tool for applications of quantum physics to the macroscopic systems we are familiar with. The reason for the third is that realistic measurements constitute a complex process involving macroscopic detectors, hence should be explained by quantum statistical mechanics rather than be part of the axiomatic foundations themselves. (This is in marked contrast to other foundations, and distinguishes the present system of axioms.)

De Gruyter eBooks•Oct 24, 2019•0 citations

The classical limit

Peter Holland

Conceptual and formal problems Many of the problems surrounding the interpretation of quantum mechanics stem from the absence of a sufficiently general and physically transparent analysis of the connection with the domain in which classical concepts are assumed to apply. It is the purpose of this chapter to describe with the aid of a few examples how the quantum potential approach provides a context within which the conceptual and formal issues raised by this problem may be clarified. A key question is to explain how the state or context dependence which is so characteristic of the quantum domain turns into state independence at a certain level, characterized as ‘classical’. To illustrate one aspect of the conceptual problem we recall that in Bohr's interpretation the validity of classical concepts is already presupposed since, it is suggested, it is only in terms of these that one can unambiguously communicate the results of experiments in the quantum domain. Thus, classical physics must be considered as prior to quantum mechanics and the latter is a generalization of the former in that it provides a new set of laws governing the application of classical concepts. According to this view, any procedure by which classical mechanics is recovered from quantum mechanics as a mathematical limit can only be a demonstration of consistency with the already postulated epistemological relation between the two theories and not as a ‘derivation’ of classical mechanics from quantum mechanics (George, Prigogine & Rosenfeld, 1972).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 13, 1993•0 citations
Chapter 1 was concerned with the need for a quantal description of microscopic phenomena. The thrust of Chapter 3 is an analysis and comparison of a classical and a quantum system; some mathematical generalizations of the analysis are presented as well. Chapter 4 provides an introduction to Hilbert-space concepts that are the mathematical framework of quantum theory, while, in Chapter 5, the axioms of quantum mechanics for pure states are stated and illustrated. The present chapter is intended to be a bridge between those chapters and Chapter 1. Here we review many of the concepts of classical mechanics that have relevance in quantum mechanics. Equally important, if not more so, we stress the lack of equivalence between a number of classical concepts and their quantal counterparts. This inequivalence is emphasized because of the vocabulary common to classical and quantum mechanics. Classical physics is, of course, the source for much of the vocabulary in quantum physics. However, the ways in which the words are used in the two domains often differ substantially, while the concepts are almost necessarily not identical. Some classical concepts have no direct quantal counterparts. For example, velocity and force are not primary quantal entities. This fact means that the quantal definitions of linear and angular momentum cannot be the same as those in classical mechanics. Similarly, the concept of a “state” in classical physics – the collection of the generalized positions and generalized velocities or momenta – does not carry over to quantum physics.
In this second chapter we will review the basic mathematical and physical facts about quantum mechanics and establish physical units and notation. Those readers already familiar with the subject can safely jump to the next chapter. An attempt has been made to make the presentation in this chapter as elementary as possible, and yet present the basic facts that will be needed later. There are many beautiful and important topics which will not be touched upon such as self-adjointness of Schrödinger operators, the general mathematical structure of quantum mechanics and the like. These topics are well described in other works, e.g.. Much of the following can be done in a Euclidean space of arbitrary dimension, but in this chapter the dimension of the Euclidean space is taken to be three-which is the physical case-unless otherwise stated. We do this to avoid confusion and, occasionally, complications that arise in the computation of mathematical constants. The interested reader can easily generalize what is done here to the R d , d > 3 case. Likewise, in the next chapters we mostly consider N particles, with spatial coordinates in R 3 , so that the total spatial dimension is 3 N . A Brief Review of the Connection Between Classical and Quantum Mechanics Considering the range of validity of quantum mechanics, it is not surprising that its formulation is more complicated and abstract than classical mechanics. Nevertheless, classical mechanics is a basic ingredient for quantum mechanics. One still talks about position, momentum and energy which are notions from Newtonian mechanics.
This chapter is intended for nonpractitioners in the field with a technical background but not necessarily at the doctoral level and so minimizes equations and the more specialized jargon. The chapter starts with a brief history of quantum mechanics. The important basic concepts of quantum mechanics are discussed, and some commonly used terms and common quantum experiments are introduced. The difference between quantum and “classical” physics is discussed. The role of quantum theory in modern physics is explained. A number of applications of quantum phenomena are discussed with some emphasis on the three areas of the US National Quantum Initiative: quantum computing, quantum sensing, and quantum communications. Finally, the various interpretations of quantum mechanics with respect to its meanings for physical reality are touched upon. At this writing, quantum technologies are receiving increased emphasis and funding in several areas both in the US and several other nations, which is discussed.
Quantum mechanics (QM) is not just a theory of micro-objects: it is our current fundamental theory of motion. It expresses a deeper understanding of Nature than classical mechanics. Precisely as classical mechanics, the conventional formulation of QM describes evolution of states and observables in time. Precisely as classical mechanics, this is not sufficient to deal with general relativistic systems, because these systems do not describe evolution in time; they describe correlations between observables. Therefore, a formulation of QM slightly more general than the conventional one – or a quantum version of the relativistic classical mechanics discussed in the previous chapter – is needed. In this chapter I discuss the possibility of such a formulation. In the last section I discuss the general physical interpretation of QM.QM can be formulated in a number of more or less equivalent formalisms: canonical (Hilbert spaces and self-adjoint operators), covariant (Feynman's sum-over-histories), algebraic (states as linear functionals over an abstract algebra of observables) and others. Generally, but not always, we are able to translate these formalisms into one another, but often what is easy in one formulation is difficult in another. A generalrelativistic sum-over-histories formalism has been developed by Jim Hartle. Here I focus on the canonical formalism, because the canonical formalism has provided the mathematical completeness and precision needed to explicitly construct the mathematical apparatus of quantum gravity. Later I will consider alternative formalisms.
The measure of greatness in a scientific idea is the extent to which it stimulates thought and opens up new lines of research. —P. A. M. Dirac From our day-to-day experience, we develop our notion of reality. However, our perception of physical properties, such as position and momentum, needs refinement to describe natural phenomena correctly. In this chapter we introduce fundamental principles of the quantum theory that does so with enduring cogency. The laws of nature that govern the functioning of the physical universe cannot be accounted for using classical physics of Newton, Lagrange, and Hamilton. Foundational principles and mathematical structure of quantum theory are introduced in this chapter. 1.1 Quantum versus Classical Physics Theories In classical physics, the mechanical state of a system is represented by a point in the position– velocity phase space, or equivalently in the position–momentum phase space. The entire theoretical formalism of Newtonian–Lagrangian–Hamiltonian mechanics is based on this Galilean conjecture. The classical hypothesis seems appropriate in a large number of physical situations that concern our day-to-day experiences. With this ansatz, the temporal evolution of a system is described by the trajectory of the point in the phase space. The trajectory is obtained from the equation of motion that governs the time dependence of position and velocity, represented respectively by q and (or alternatively the time dependence of position and momentum, represented respectively by q and p ). The alternative equations of motion – Newton’s, Lagrange’s, and Hamilton's – are equivalent. Their applicability must be reconciled with the upper limit on accuracy with which conjugate physical properties of an object, viz. position and momentum , are simultaneously measured. There is, however, an inverse relation between the accuracy of simultaneous measurement of these two properties. The more accurately you measure either, the less accurately can you measure the other. The act of measuring either of the conjugate properties requires an observation. Observations resulting in accurate measurements of conjugate variables are, however, not compatible with each other. Heisenberg's principle of uncertainty is the quantitative expression of this law of nature. It is expressed as a rigorous mathematical inequality that is neatly written in a compact form. Nonetheless, we refrain from advancing its mathematical expression too soon. It has no classical analogue. It cannot be written in any terms of what we are familiar with from classical mechanics.
Quantum physics consists of a formal core that is universally agreed upon (basically being a piece of mathematics with suggestive names for concepts matching related concepts of experimental culture) and an interpretational halo (trying to make this relation more precise) that remains highly disputed even after more than 90 years of modern quantum physics. The latter is the subject of the interpretation of quantum mechanics (see Part II), where many interpretations coexist and compete for the attention of those interested in what quantum physics really means. In this chapter, an axiomatic introduction to the undisputed formal core of quantum physics is given. The axioms described present nonrelativistic quantum statistical mechanics in the Schrödinger picture. The relativistic case is outside the scope of these axioms, as it must be treated by quantum field theory; see Chapter 7. As in any axiomatic setting (necessary for a formal discipline), there are a number of different but equivalent sets of axioms or postulates that can be used to define formal quantum physics. Since they are equivalent, their choice is a matter of convenience. The choice presented here is a formulation featuring three aspects: It emphasises the similarity of quantum mechanics and classical mechanics, gives most direct access to statistical mechanics, and is free from allusions to measurement. The reason for the first is that this similarity serves as a guide to meaning. From the axiomatic setting for quantum mechanics presented below, classical mechanics (in the Koopman setting discussed in Section 7.10) is obtained by simply restricting the operators to be diagonal, so that all operations happen pointwise on the diagonal elements. Thus, multiplication is commutative, and one can identify operators and functions. In particular, the density operator degenerates into a probability density. Therefore, the quantum case appears as a generalization of the classical case allowing for noncommutativity, so that both q-observables and the density operator are (usually infinite-dimensional) operators. The reason for the second is that statistical mechanics is the main tool for applications of quantum physics to the macroscopic systems we are familiar with. The reason for the third is that realistic measurements constitute a complex process involving macroscopic detectors, hence should be explained by quantum statistical mechanics rather than be part of the axiomatic foundations themselves. (This is in marked contrast to other foundations, and distinguishes the present system of axioms.)
Conceptual and formal problems Many of the problems surrounding the interpretation of quantum mechanics stem from the absence of a sufficiently general and physically transparent analysis of the connection with the domain in which classical concepts are assumed to apply. It is the purpose of this chapter to describe with the aid of a few examples how the quantum potential approach provides a context within which the conceptual and formal issues raised by this problem may be clarified. A key question is to explain how the state or context dependence which is so characteristic of the quantum domain turns into state independence at a certain level, characterized as ‘classical’. To illustrate one aspect of the conceptual problem we recall that in Bohr's interpretation the validity of classical concepts is already presupposed since, it is suggested, it is only in terms of these that one can unambiguously communicate the results of experiments in the quantum domain. Thus, classical physics must be considered as prior to quantum mechanics and the latter is a generalization of the former in that it provides a new set of laws governing the application of classical concepts. According to this view, any procedure by which classical mechanics is recovered from quantum mechanics as a mathematical limit can only be a demonstration of consistency with the already postulated epistemological relation between the two theories and not as a ‘derivation’ of classical mechanics from quantum mechanics (George, Prigogine & Rosenfeld, 1972).