Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Birkhäuser Basel eBooks

Max Born and Wiener’s Thoughts on Quantum Mechanics and Unified Field Theory

P. R. Masani

Published Jan 1, 1990• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

From 1922 to 1927 Wiener traveled to Europe practically every summer. He found these trips intellectually refreshing and enjoyed the company of interesting people he met. During the 1920s his work was much better appreciated in Europe than in America, and he got considerably more encouragement from mathematicians abroad than he did from those at home, most of whom hardly knew him. During these visits, Wiener worked. The words: “The kind of work I do can be done anywhere. Why should I be less capable of reflecting about my problems on the Potsdam bridge than at home?” are Einstein’s (cf. P. Frank {F4, p. 147}), but could have been Wiener’s. His ideas on quantum mechanics were formed in the course of such travels and participation in seminar discussions in Europe.

DOI
10.1007/978-3-0348-9252-0_10

Related papers

Heisenberg and the Creation of Quantum Mechanics (1925)

S. Brandt

Abstract There is a certain similarity in the early lives of Planck and of Heisenberg [1,2]. Both had fathers who were professors at the University of Munich, both visited the Maximilians-Gymnasium in Munich, and both went to see a professor in Munich to seek advice for their studies. We have mentioned at the beginning of the Prologue how Jolly in vain tried to dissuade Planck from studying physics. Heisenberg, in his autobiographic book [3], which is devised as a series of conversations, tells us of a similar experience. In the autumn of 1920, when he was about to enter the university, his first choice was mathematics. He wanted not only to do course work but also learn about problems of current interest. This, he thought, he could do best by participating in a professor’s seminar usually reserved to advanced students and Ph.D. candidates. He asked for an interview with Lindemann , the most distinguished mathematician in Munich, who was famous for having proved that the number π is transcendental. But the old professor and the young student found no understanding, partly because Lindemann’s dog noisily interfered. The result was that Heisenberg opted for theoretical physics and went to ask Sommerfeld to be admitted to his seminar. Sommerfeld agreed. At that time Pauli, only a year older than Heisenberg, was already actively doing research under Sommerfeld. The two young men became life-long friends.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 22, 1992•0 citations

Max Born

A. Cook

Max Born was one of the small group of theoretical physicists who established the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics in the 1920s. Born himself recognized that Heisenberg had the crucial idea that the variables in quantum mechanics should be observable quantities, not classical coordinates that were not observable. Heisenberg proposed to take instead quantities that were related to the transitions between states of an atom. The photograph shows Max Born (Copyright © Anne Meitner)

Notes and Records the Royal Society Journal of the History of Science•May 22, 2002•1 citation

Albert Einstein to Hedi and Max Born

Albert Einstein

Translated by Irene Born Newton-John; closing comment by Max Born. 1 1. M. Born, The Born—Einstein Letters 1916-1955: Friendship, Politics and Physics in Uncertain Times, Macmillan, New York (2005), p. 79. Letter © Hebrew University of Jerusalem. This letter antedates by a year or two the “new” quantum mechanics of Werner Heisenberg, Max Born, Pasqual Jordan, and Erwin Schrödinger. Einstein begins with a response to a letter about Japan by Born’s wife, Hedi—a letter that has since been lost. But then, as he would for the next 30 years, Einstein launches into his differences with Max on the interpretation of quantum phenomena. If atomic phenomena are truly random, he grumbles, he’d rather be a croupier. Berlin, 29 April 1924Dear Borns,Your letter, dear Mrs. Born, was really excellent. Indeed, what causes the sense of well-being inspired by Japanese society and art is that the individual is so harmoniously integrated into his wider environment that he derives his experiences not from the self, but mainly from the community. Each of us longed for this when we were young, but we had to resign ourselves to its impossibility. For, of all the communities available to us there is not one I would want to devote myself to, except for the society of the true searchers, which has very few living members at any time.… Bohr’s opinion about radiation is of great interest. But I should not want to be forced into abandoning strict causality without defending it more strongly than I have so far. I find the idea quite intolerable that an electron exposed to radiation should choose, of its own free will, not only its moment to jump off, but also its direction. In that case, I would rather be a cobbler, or even an employee in a gaming house, than a physicist. Certainly my attempts to give tangible form to the quanta have foundered again and again, but I am far from giving up hope. And even if it never works, there is always that consolation that this lack of success is entirely mine. … With best wishes.YoursEinstein… Your pretty remark [Mrs. Born, about subject unknown] makes me want to stroke your head, if that is at all permissible in the case of a married lady. Max Born’s 1969 comments:’ The letter from my wife to which Einstein replied is missing. The basic reason for the dispute between [Einstein and me] on the validity of statistical laws was as follows: Einstein was firmly convinced that physics can supply us with knowledge of the objectively existing world. Together with many other physicists, I have been gradually converted, as a result of experiences in the field of atomic quantum phenomena, to the point of view that this is not so. At any given moment, our knowledge of the objective world is only a crude approximation from which, by applying certain rules such as the probability laws of quantum mechanics, we can predict unknown (e.g. future) conditions. REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. M. Born, The Born—Einstein Letters 1916-1955: Friendship, Politics and Physics in Uncertain Times, Macmillan, New York (2005), p. 79. Letter © Hebrew University of Jerusalem. Google Scholar© 2005 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Nov 1, 2005•0 citations

Quantum Physics

Suman Seth

This article discusses the history of quantum physics, beginning with an analysis of the process through which a community of quantum theorists and experimentalists came into being. In particular, it traces the roots and fruits of Max Planck’s papers in irreversible processes in nature. It proceeds by exploring the origin and subsequent development of Niels Bohr’s so-called ‘planetary model’ of the atom, focusing on the extension of the model by Arnold Sommerfeld and members of his school as well to Bohr’s use of his principles of correspondence and adiabatic invariance. It also considers the post-war years, as the problems of atomic spectroscopy sparked the development of new methodological approaches to quantum theory. Finally, it offers a history of the two distinct new forms of quantum mechanics put forward in the mid-1920s: Werner Heisenberg, Max Born, and Pascual Jordan’s matrix mechanics, and Erwin Schrödinger’s wave mechanics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jul 6, 2017•3 citations

A new fixed point for Mottness

Jinchao Zhao

Understanding electronic behavior in solids remains a central challenge in condensed matter physics.Historically, Landau's Fermi liquid theory, BCS superconductor theory, and Bloch's electron band theory have provided robust frameworks for describing electronic states in conventional metals, superconductors, insulators, and semiconductors.However, these frameworks fail to fully account for the physics observed in strongly correlated electron systems, notably Mott insulators and their doped counterparts, which exhibit unconventional superconductivity and novel topological phases.This thesis reflects not only my own efforts and ideas but also the invaluable guidance, collaboration, and support of many people.My journey in Champaign-Urbana began in 2019, just before the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.The first class I attended at the University of Illinois was PHYS 561: Condensed Matter Physics II, taught by Dr. Philip Phillips.It remains the most inspiring course I have ever taken.I was fortunate that Philip responded to my initial inquiry right away.Looking back, choosing to work with him was one of the smartest decisions I made.Throughout my time at UIUC, Philip provided not only deep physical insights but also clear physical intuition.Working with him was a unique and rewarding experience.We often walked into each other's offices like colleagues and friends, discussing ideas freely.These interactions have definitely shaped my intellectual approach and working style.The mathematical depth of our research was greatly enriched by Dr. Gabriele La Nave, whose breadth of knowledge initially overwhelmed me.Yet over time, I was able to keep up, and we developed into a productive and balanced team.I also want to express my sincere appreciation to Dr. Barry Bradlyn for the countless discussions-via Zoom or phone-whenever Philip and I found ourselves puzzled.Barry was often the final word that helped us move forward.It wasn't until I was planning my graduation that I fully appreciated the privilege of being part of such an intellectually vibrant community.The nearly daily seminars and colloquia-featuring both experimentalists and theorists-broadened my mind in ways I hadn't anticipated.I am especially grateful to the organizers and speakers who made these events possible.The life as a PhD student during and after the pandemic was also enlightened by the v wonderful people in the Engineering Sciences Building.Whenever I encountered a difficult problem, it was always a good idea to take a walk through the building.More often than not, I would stumble upon someone willing to talk, offering a fresh perspective that led to real progress.I would like to thank Edwin Huang, Peizhi Mai, Penghao Zhu, Jacopo Gliozzi, Kevin Kleiner, Xuchen Cao,

•Jul 13, 2025•0 citations

Max Born

Nevill Francis Mott

Max Born was a scientist of the greatest distinction who presided over the Göttingen school of theoretical physics in its most famous days, when from 1925 onwards a brilliant group suddenly saw its way to formulate a set of laws for the behaviour of inanimate matter which has served us well up to the present time. This set of laws, which from the very beginning was called quantum mechanics and for part of which Born was awarded the Nobel prize much later (in 1954), is what he will be remembered for and what he would probably have wanted to be remembered for.

Physics Bulletin•Jul 1, 1982•0 citations
From 1922 to 1927 Wiener traveled to Europe practically every summer. He found these trips intellectually refreshing and enjoyed the company of interesting people he met. During the 1920s his work was much better appreciated in Europe than in America, and he got considerably more encouragement from mathematicians abroad than he did from those at home, most of whom hardly knew him. During these visits, Wiener worked. The words: “The kind of work I do can be done anywhere. Why should I be less capable of reflecting about my problems on the Potsdam bridge than at home?” are Einstein’s (cf. P. Frank {F4, p. 147}), but could have been Wiener’s. His ideas on quantum mechanics were formed in the course of such travels and participation in seminar discussions in Europe.
Abstract There is a certain similarity in the early lives of Planck and of Heisenberg [1,2]. Both had fathers who were professors at the University of Munich, both visited the Maximilians-Gymnasium in Munich, and both went to see a professor in Munich to seek advice for their studies. We have mentioned at the beginning of the Prologue how Jolly in vain tried to dissuade Planck from studying physics. Heisenberg, in his autobiographic book [3], which is devised as a series of conversations, tells us of a similar experience. In the autumn of 1920, when he was about to enter the university, his first choice was mathematics. He wanted not only to do course work but also learn about problems of current interest. This, he thought, he could do best by participating in a professor’s seminar usually reserved to advanced students and Ph.D. candidates. He asked for an interview with Lindemann , the most distinguished mathematician in Munich, who was famous for having proved that the number π is transcendental. But the old professor and the young student found no understanding, partly because Lindemann’s dog noisily interfered. The result was that Heisenberg opted for theoretical physics and went to ask Sommerfeld to be admitted to his seminar. Sommerfeld agreed. At that time Pauli, only a year older than Heisenberg, was already actively doing research under Sommerfeld. The two young men became life-long friends.
Translated by Irene Born Newton-John; closing comment by Max Born. 1 1. M. Born, The Born—Einstein Letters 1916-1955: Friendship, Politics and Physics in Uncertain Times, Macmillan, New York (2005), p. 79. Letter © Hebrew University of Jerusalem. This letter antedates by a year or two the “new” quantum mechanics of Werner Heisenberg, Max Born, Pasqual Jordan, and Erwin Schrödinger. Einstein begins with a response to a letter about Japan by Born’s wife, Hedi—a letter that has since been lost. But then, as he would for the next 30 years, Einstein launches into his differences with Max on the interpretation of quantum phenomena. If atomic phenomena are truly random, he grumbles, he’d rather be a croupier. Berlin, 29 April 1924Dear Borns,Your letter, dear Mrs. Born, was really excellent. Indeed, what causes the sense of well-being inspired by Japanese society and art is that the individual is so harmoniously integrated into his wider environment that he derives his experiences not from the self, but mainly from the community. Each of us longed for this when we were young, but we had to resign ourselves to its impossibility. For, of all the communities available to us there is not one I would want to devote myself to, except for the society of the true searchers, which has very few living members at any time.… Bohr’s opinion about radiation is of great interest. But I should not want to be forced into abandoning strict causality without defending it more strongly than I have so far. I find the idea quite intolerable that an electron exposed to radiation should choose, of its own free will, not only its moment to jump off, but also its direction. In that case, I would rather be a cobbler, or even an employee in a gaming house, than a physicist. Certainly my attempts to give tangible form to the quanta have foundered again and again, but I am far from giving up hope. And even if it never works, there is always that consolation that this lack of success is entirely mine. … With best wishes.YoursEinstein… Your pretty remark [Mrs. Born, about subject unknown] makes me want to stroke your head, if that is at all permissible in the case of a married lady. Max Born’s 1969 comments:’ The letter from my wife to which Einstein replied is missing. The basic reason for the dispute between [Einstein and me] on the validity of statistical laws was as follows: Einstein was firmly convinced that physics can supply us with knowledge of the objectively existing world. Together with many other physicists, I have been gradually converted, as a result of experiences in the field of atomic quantum phenomena, to the point of view that this is not so. At any given moment, our knowledge of the objective world is only a crude approximation from which, by applying certain rules such as the probability laws of quantum mechanics, we can predict unknown (e.g. future) conditions. REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. M. Born, The Born—Einstein Letters 1916-1955: Friendship, Politics and Physics in Uncertain Times, Macmillan, New York (2005), p. 79. Letter © Hebrew University of Jerusalem. Google Scholar© 2005 American Institute of Physics.
This article discusses the history of quantum physics, beginning with an analysis of the process through which a community of quantum theorists and experimentalists came into being. In particular, it traces the roots and fruits of Max Planck’s papers in irreversible processes in nature. It proceeds by exploring the origin and subsequent development of Niels Bohr’s so-called ‘planetary model’ of the atom, focusing on the extension of the model by Arnold Sommerfeld and members of his school as well to Bohr’s use of his principles of correspondence and adiabatic invariance. It also considers the post-war years, as the problems of atomic spectroscopy sparked the development of new methodological approaches to quantum theory. Finally, it offers a history of the two distinct new forms of quantum mechanics put forward in the mid-1920s: Werner Heisenberg, Max Born, and Pascual Jordan’s matrix mechanics, and Erwin Schrödinger’s wave mechanics.
Understanding electronic behavior in solids remains a central challenge in condensed matter physics.Historically, Landau's Fermi liquid theory, BCS superconductor theory, and Bloch's electron band theory have provided robust frameworks for describing electronic states in conventional metals, superconductors, insulators, and semiconductors.However, these frameworks fail to fully account for the physics observed in strongly correlated electron systems, notably Mott insulators and their doped counterparts, which exhibit unconventional superconductivity and novel topological phases.This thesis reflects not only my own efforts and ideas but also the invaluable guidance, collaboration, and support of many people.My journey in Champaign-Urbana began in 2019, just before the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.The first class I attended at the University of Illinois was PHYS 561: Condensed Matter Physics II, taught by Dr. Philip Phillips.It remains the most inspiring course I have ever taken.I was fortunate that Philip responded to my initial inquiry right away.Looking back, choosing to work with him was one of the smartest decisions I made.Throughout my time at UIUC, Philip provided not only deep physical insights but also clear physical intuition.Working with him was a unique and rewarding experience.We often walked into each other's offices like colleagues and friends, discussing ideas freely.These interactions have definitely shaped my intellectual approach and working style.The mathematical depth of our research was greatly enriched by Dr. Gabriele La Nave, whose breadth of knowledge initially overwhelmed me.Yet over time, I was able to keep up, and we developed into a productive and balanced team.I also want to express my sincere appreciation to Dr. Barry Bradlyn for the countless discussions-via Zoom or phone-whenever Philip and I found ourselves puzzled.Barry was often the final word that helped us move forward.It wasn't until I was planning my graduation that I fully appreciated the privilege of being part of such an intellectually vibrant community.The nearly daily seminars and colloquia-featuring both experimentalists and theorists-broadened my mind in ways I hadn't anticipated.I am especially grateful to the organizers and speakers who made these events possible.The life as a PhD student during and after the pandemic was also enlightened by the v wonderful people in the Engineering Sciences Building.Whenever I encountered a difficult problem, it was always a good idea to take a walk through the building.More often than not, I would stumble upon someone willing to talk, offering a fresh perspective that led to real progress.I would like to thank Edwin Huang, Peizhi Mai, Penghao Zhu, Jacopo Gliozzi, Kevin Kleiner, Xuchen Cao,
Max Born was a scientist of the greatest distinction who presided over the Göttingen school of theoretical physics in its most famous days, when from 1925 onwards a brilliant group suddenly saw its way to formulate a set of laws for the behaviour of inanimate matter which has served us well up to the present time. This set of laws, which from the very beginning was called quantum mechanics and for part of which Born was awarded the Nobel prize much later (in 1954), is what he will be remembered for and what he would probably have wanted to be remembered for.