Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Reply to Suslov

Keith Slevin, Tomi Ohtsuki

Published Jun 1, 2001• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

In a recent submission to this archive arXiv:cond-mat/0105325, Suslov has claimed that our recent numerical estimate of the critical exponent of the Anderson transition $\nu=1.57\pm.02$ is in error and that the available numerical data are consistent with a value of $\nu=1$. We contest this claim and demonstrate using Suslov's own scaling procedure that $\nu\ne 1$

Related papers

Critical indices of Anderson transition: something is wrong with numerical results

Игорь Михайлович Суслов

Numerical results for Anderson transition are critically discussed. A simple procedure to deal with corrections to scaling is suggested. With real uncertainties taken into account, the raw data are in agreement with a value $ν=1$ for the critical index of the correlation length in three dimensions.

arXiv:cond-mat/0105325•May 16, 2001•12 citations

Reply to "Common on `Superfluidity in the interior-gap states'"

Shin-Tza Wu, Sungkit Yip

We show that the recent Comment by Liu and Wilczek (cond-mat/0304632) on our work (PRA 67, 053603) is incorrect.

arXiv:cond-mat/0305675•May 29, 2003•1 citation

Reply to Comment on ``Scaling of the quasiparticle spectrum for d-wave superconductors''

Steven H. Simon, Patrick A. Lee

Volovik and Kopnin make two seperate points regarding our recent paper (S. H. Simon and P. A. Lee, PRL 78, 1548 (1997); cond-mat/9611133). First they note that the scaling regime we address in our paper is limited by the curvature of the Fermi surface, and secondly they note that the crossover scale derived in our paper is incorrect. These points are valid and are discussed in this reply. With the exception of the incorrectly predicted crossover scale, the results of our paper remain unchanged.

arXiv:cond-mat/9705039•May 6, 1997•1 citation

Comment on arXiv:1301.3829 and Reply to 'Comment on "Can disorder really enhance superconductivity?"' arXiv:1501.05148 by I.M. Suslov

James Mayoh, Antonio M. García-García

In arXiv:1301.3829 and arXiv:1501.05148 I. M. Suslov proposes a theoretical description for the interplay between disorder and superconductivity that, among other things, claims to predict situations where superconductivity is enhanced by disorder. In this comment we show that Suslov's results do not make any sound predictions relating to this problem. Suslov also suggests that the percolation approach recently employed by the authors to compute the global critical temperature of inhomogeneous superconductors induced by weak multifractality is not satisfactory. We refute Suslov's opinion using simple ideas from the Bardeen-Cooper-Schiaffer (BCS) theory of superconductivity. More importantly we stress that our theory makes quantitative analytical predictions for observables such as the global critical temperature and the spatial distribution of the order parameter. Our work can therefore be easily confirmed or disproved through either numerical or experimental study.

arXiv:1502.06282•Feb 22, 2015•1 citation

Comment on "High Precision Measurement of the Thermal Exponent for the three-dimensional XY Universality Class"

K. S. D. Beach

A recent paper [Burovski et al., cond-mat/0507352] reports on a new, high-accuracy simulation of the classical phi^4 model (in the three-dimensional XY universality class). The authors claim that a careful scaling analysis of their data gives nu = 0.6711(1) for the thermal critical exponent. If correct, this would neatly resolve the discrepancy between numerical simulations and experiments on 4He. There is reason, however, to doubt the accuracy of the result. A re-analysis of the data yields a significantly higher value of nu, one that is consistent with other Monte Carlo studies.

arXiv:cond-mat/0507541•Jul 22, 2005•5 citations

Comment on "critical dynamics of a vortex-loop model for the superconducting transition" [2] (multiple letters)

Jack Lidmar, Vivek Aji, Nigel D. Goldenfeld

Physical Review Letters•Sep 2, 2002•0 citations
In a recent submission to this archive arXiv:cond-mat/0105325, Suslov has claimed that our recent numerical estimate of the critical exponent of the Anderson transition ν=1.57±.02\nu=1.57\pm.02ν=1.57±.02 is in error and that the available numerical data are consistent with a value of ν=1\nu=1ν=1. We contest this claim and demonstrate using Suslov's own scaling procedure that ν≠1\nu\ne 1ν=1
Numerical results for Anderson transition are critically discussed. A simple procedure to deal with corrections to scaling is suggested. With real uncertainties taken into account, the raw data are in agreement with a value ν=1ν=1ν=1 for the critical index of the correlation length in three dimensions.
In arXiv:1301.3829 and arXiv:1501.05148 I. M. Suslov proposes a theoretical description for the interplay between disorder and superconductivity that, among other things, claims to predict situations where superconductivity is enhanced by disorder. In this comment we show that Suslov's results do not make any sound predictions relating to this problem. Suslov also suggests that the percolation approach recently employed by the authors to compute the global critical temperature of inhomogeneous superconductors induced by weak multifractality is not satisfactory. We refute Suslov's opinion using simple ideas from the Bardeen-Cooper-Schiaffer (BCS) theory of superconductivity. More importantly we stress that our theory makes quantitative analytical predictions for observables such as the global critical temperature and the spatial distribution of the order parameter. Our work can therefore be easily confirmed or disproved through either numerical or experimental study.
A recent paper [Burovski et al., cond-mat/0507352] reports on a new, high-accuracy simulation of the classical phi^4 model (in the three-dimensional XY universality class). The authors claim that a careful scaling analysis of their data gives nu = 0.6711(1) for the thermal critical exponent. If correct, this would neatly resolve the discrepancy between numerical simulations and experiments on 4He. There is reason, however, to doubt the accuracy of the result. A re-analysis of the data yields a significantly higher value of nu, one that is consistent with other Monte Carlo studies.