Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0105325

Critical indices of Anderson transition: something is wrong with numerical results

Игорь Михайлович Суслов

Published May 16, 2001• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Numerical results for Anderson transition are critically discussed. A simple procedure to deal with corrections to scaling is suggested. With real uncertainties taken into account, the raw data are in agreement with a value $ν=1$ for the critical index of the correlation length in three dimensions.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.cond-mat/0105325

Related papers

Reply to Suslov

Keith Slevin, Tomi Ohtsuki

In a recent submission to this archive arXiv:cond-mat/0105325, Suslov has claimed that our recent numerical estimate of the critical exponent of the Anderson transition $\nu=1.57\pm.02$ is in error and that the available numerical data are consistent with a value of $\nu=1$. We contest this claim and demonstrate using Suslov's own scaling procedure that $\nu\ne 1$

•Jun 1, 2001•0 citations

Static Phenomena Near Critical Points: Theory and Experiment

Leo P. Kadanoff, WOLFGANG GöTZE, DAVID HAMBLEN +7 more

This paper compares theory and experiment for behavior very near critical points. The primary experimental results are the “critical indices” which describe singularities in various thermodynamic derivatives and correlation functions. These indices are tabulated and compared with theory. The basic theoretical ideas are introduced via the molecular field approach, which brings in the concept of an order parameter and suggests that there are close relations among different phase transition problems. Although this theory is qualitatively correct it is quantitatively wrong, it predicts the wrong values of the critical indices. Another theoretical approach, the “scaling law” concept, which predicts relations among these indices, is described. The experimental evidence for and against the scaling laws is assessed. It is suggested that the scaling laws provide a promising approach to understanding phenomena near the critical point, but that they are by no means proved or disproved by the existing experimental data.

World scientific series on nonlinear science, series A•Oct 1, 1993•15 citations

On the Theory of Phase Transitions by the Collective Variables Methods

Jaroslav Ilnytskyi, Mykhailo P. Kozlovskii, I. R. Yukhnovskii

We calculate relatively accurate critical indices within the collective variables method applied to the phase transitions theory. Discussion on stability of the results and low-level comparison with the other approaches is made.

International Journal of Modern Physics B•Mar 30, 1997•3 citations

Numerical investigations of scaling at the Anderson transition DISORDER, PHASE COHERENCE AND ELECTRON CORRELATIONS

Tobias Brandes, Stefan Kettemann

•Jan 1, 2003•0 citations

Static Phenomena Near Critical Points: Theory and Experiment

Leo P. Kadanoff, W. Götze, D.G. Hamblen +7 more

This paper compares theory and experiment for behavior very near critical points. The primary experimental results are the "critical indices" which describe singularities in various thermodynamic derivatives and correlation functions. These indices are tabulated and compared with theory. The basic theoretical ideas are introduced via the molecular field approach, which brings in the concept of an order parameter and suggests that there are close relations among different phase transition problems. Although this theory is qualitatively correct it is quantitatively wrong, it predicts the wrong values of the critical indices. Another theoretical approach, the "scaling law" concept, which predicts relations among these indices, is described. The experimental evidence for and against the scaling laws is assessed. It is suggested that the scaling laws provide a promising approach to understanding phenomena near the critical point, but that they are by no means proved or disproved by the existing experimental data.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Apr 1, 1967•1,617 citations

Finite-size scaling from the self-consistent theory of localization

I. M. Suslov

Accepting the validity of Vollhardt and Wölfle’s self-consistent theory of localization, we derive the finite-size scaling procedure used for studying the critical behavior in the d-dimensional case and based on the consideration of auxiliary quasi-1D systems. The obtained scaling functions for d = 2 and d = 3 are in good agreement with numerical results: it signifies the absence of substantial contradictions with the Vollhardt and Wölfle theory on the level of raw data. The results ν = 1.3–1.6, usually obtained at d = 3 for the critical exponentν of the correlation length, are explained by the fact that dependence L + L 0 with L 0 > 0 (L is the transversal size of the system) is interpreted as L 1/ν with ν > 1. The modified scaling relations are derived for dimensions d ≥ 4; this demonstrates the incorrectness of the conventional treatment of data for d = 4 and d = 5, but establishes the constructive procedure for such a treatment. The consequences for other finite-size scaling variants are discussed.

arXiv:1104.0432•Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 2012•8 citations
Numerical results for Anderson transition are critically discussed. A simple procedure to deal with corrections to scaling is suggested. With real uncertainties taken into account, the raw data are in agreement with a value ν=1ν=1ν=1 for the critical index of the correlation length in three dimensions.
In a recent submission to this archive arXiv:cond-mat/0105325, Suslov has claimed that our recent numerical estimate of the critical exponent of the Anderson transition ν=1.57±.02\nu=1.57\pm.02ν=1.57±.02 is in error and that the available numerical data are consistent with a value of ν=1\nu=1ν=1. We contest this claim and demonstrate using Suslov's own scaling procedure that ν≠1\nu\ne 1ν=1
This paper compares theory and experiment for behavior very near critical points. The primary experimental results are the “critical indices” which describe singularities in various thermodynamic derivatives and correlation functions. These indices are tabulated and compared with theory. The basic theoretical ideas are introduced via the molecular field approach, which brings in the concept of an order parameter and suggests that there are close relations among different phase transition problems. Although this theory is qualitatively correct it is quantitatively wrong, it predicts the wrong values of the critical indices. Another theoretical approach, the “scaling law” concept, which predicts relations among these indices, is described. The experimental evidence for and against the scaling laws is assessed. It is suggested that the scaling laws provide a promising approach to understanding phenomena near the critical point, but that they are by no means proved or disproved by the existing experimental data.
This paper compares theory and experiment for behavior very near critical points. The primary experimental results are the "critical indices" which describe singularities in various thermodynamic derivatives and correlation functions. These indices are tabulated and compared with theory. The basic theoretical ideas are introduced via the molecular field approach, which brings in the concept of an order parameter and suggests that there are close relations among different phase transition problems. Although this theory is qualitatively correct it is quantitatively wrong, it predicts the wrong values of the critical indices. Another theoretical approach, the "scaling law" concept, which predicts relations among these indices, is described. The experimental evidence for and against the scaling laws is assessed. It is suggested that the scaling laws provide a promising approach to understanding phenomena near the critical point, but that they are by no means proved or disproved by the existing experimental data.
Accepting the validity of Vollhardt and Wölfle’s self-consistent theory of localization, we derive the finite-size scaling procedure used for studying the critical behavior in the d-dimensional case and based on the consideration of auxiliary quasi-1D systems. The obtained scaling functions for d = 2 and d = 3 are in good agreement with numerical results: it signifies the absence of substantial contradictions with the Vollhardt and Wölfle theory on the level of raw data. The results ν = 1.3–1.6, usually obtained at d = 3 for the critical exponentν of the correlation length, are explained by the fact that dependence L + L 0 with L 0 > 0 (L is the transversal size of the system) is interpreted as L 1/ν with ν > 1. The modified scaling relations are derived for dimensions d ≥ 4; this demonstrates the incorrectness of the conventional treatment of data for d = 4 and d = 5, but establishes the constructive procedure for such a treatment. The consequences for other finite-size scaling variants are discussed.