Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0507541

Comment on "High Precision Measurement of the Thermal Exponent for the three-dimensional XY Universality Class"

K. S. D. Beach

Published Jul 22, 2005• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A recent paper [Burovski et al., cond-mat/0507352] reports on a new, high-accuracy simulation of the classical phi^4 model (in the three-dimensional XY universality class). The authors claim that a careful scaling analysis of their data gives nu = 0.6711(1) for the thermal critical exponent. If correct, this would neatly resolve the discrepancy between numerical simulations and experiments on 4He. There is reason, however, to doubt the accuracy of the result. A re-analysis of the data yields a significantly higher value of nu, one that is consistent with other Monte Carlo studies.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.cond-mat/0507541

Related papers

Critical behaviour of the three-dimensional XY universality class

Campostrini M, Hasenbusch M, Pelissetto A +2 more

We improve the theoretical estimates of the critical exponents for the three-dimensional XY universality class. We fine alpha=-0.0146(8), gamma =1.3177(5), nu =0.671 55(27), eta =0.0380(4), beta =0.3485(2), and delta =4.780(2). We observe a discrepancy with the most recent experimental estimate of alpha; this discrepancy calls for further theoretical and experimental investigations. Our results are obtained by combining Monte Carlo simulations based on finite-size scaling methods, and high-temperature expansions. Two improved models (with suppressed leading scaling corrections) are selected by Monte Carlo computation. The critical exponents are computed from high-temperature expansions specialized to these improved models. By the same technique we determine the coefficients of the small-magnetization expansion of the equation of state. This expansion is extended analytically by means of approximate parametric representations, obtaining the equation of state in the whole critical region. We also determine the specific-heat amplitude ratio.

•Jan 1, 2001•0 citations

Critical behavior of the three-dimensional XY universality class

Massimo Campostrini B, Martin Hasenbusch B, Andrea Pelissetto C +2 more

We improve the theoretical estimates of the critical exponents for the three-dimensional $\mathrm{XY}$ universality class. We find $\ensuremath{\alpha}=\ensuremath{-}0.0146(8),$ $\ensuremath{\gamma}=1.3177(5),$ $\ensuremath{\nu}=0.67155(27),$ $\ensuremath{\eta}=0.0380(4),$ $\ensuremath{\beta}=0.3485(2),$ and $\ensuremath{\delta}=4.780(2).$ We observe a discrepancy with the most recent experimental estimate of $\ensuremath{\alpha};$ this discrepancy calls for further theoretical and experimental investigations. Our results are obtained by combining Monte Carlo simulations based on finite-size scaling methods, and high-temperature expansions. Two improved models (with suppressed leading scaling corrections) are selected by Monte Carlo computation. The critical exponents are computed from high-temperature expansions specialized to these improved models. By the same technique we determine the coefficients of the small-magnetization expansion of the equation of state. This expansion is extended analytically by means of approximate parametric representations, obtaining the equation of state in the whole critical region. We also determine the specific-heat amplitude ratio.

arXiv:cond-mat/0010360•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•May 2, 2001•415 citations

High-precision Monte Carlo study of the three-dimensional XY model on GPU

Ti-Yen Lan, Yun-Da Hsieh, Ying-Jer Kao

We perform large-scale Monte Carlo simulations of the classical XY model on a three-dimensional $L\times L \times L$ cubic lattice using the graphics processing unit (GPU). By the combination of Metropolis single-spin flip, over-relaxation and parallel-tempering methods, we simulate systems up to L=160. Performing the finite-size scaling analysis, we obtain estimates of the critical exponents for the three-dimensional XY universality class: $α=-0.01293(48)$ and $ν=0.67098(16)$. Our estimate for the correlation-length exponent $ν$, in contrast to previous theoretical estimates, agrees with the most recent experimental estimate $ν_{\rm exp}=0.6709(1)$ at the superfluid transition of $^4$He in a microgravity environment.

arXiv:1211.0780•Nov 5, 2012•6 citations

High-precision measurement of the thermal exponent for the three-dimensional XY universality class

Evgeni Burovski, Jonathan L. Machta, Nikolay V. Prokof'ev +1 more

Simulation results are reported for the critical point of the two-component ${\ensuremath{\phi}}^{4}$ field theory. The correlation-length exponent is measured to high precision with the result $\ensuremath{\nu}=0.6717(3)$. This value is in agreement with recent simulation results [Campostrini et al., Phys. Rev. B 63, 214503 (2001)] and marginally agrees with the most recent space-based measurements of the superfluid transition in $^{4}\mathrm{He}$ [Lipa et al., Phys. Rev. B 68, 174518 (2003)].

arXiv:cond-mat/0507352•Physical Review B•Oct 3, 2006•77 citations

High-precision Monte Carlo study of the 3DXY-universality class

M Hasenbusch, T Török

We present a Monte Carlo study of the two-component 4 model on the simple cubic lattice in three dimensions. By suitable tuning of the coupling constant, , we eliminate leading-order corrections to scaling. High-statistics simulations using finite-size scaling techniques yield = 0.6723(3)[8] and = 0.0381(2)[2], where the statistical and systematical errors are given in the first and second bracket, respectively. These results are more precise than any previous theoretical estimate of the critical exponents for the 3D XY universality class.

arXiv:cond-mat/9904408•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 26, 1999•115 citations

The three-dimensionalXYuniversality class: a high precision Monte Carlo estimate of the universal amplitude ratioA+/A−

Martin Hasenbusch B

We simulate the improved three-dimensional two-component ϕ 4 model on the simple cubic lattice in the low and the high temperature phase for reduced temperatures down to | T − T c |/ T c ≈ 0.0017 on lattices of size up to 350 3 . Our new results for the internal energy and the specific heat are combined with the accurate estimates of β c and data for the internal energy and the specific heat at β c recently obtained in Campostrini et al (2006 Preprint cond-mat/0605083 ). We find R α = (1 − A + / A − )/α = 4.01(5), where α is the critical exponent of the specific heat and A ± is the amplitude of the specific heat in the high and the low temperature phase, respectively.

arXiv:cond-mat/0607189•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Aug 25, 2006•13 citations
A recent paper [Burovski et al., cond-mat/0507352] reports on a new, high-accuracy simulation of the classical phi^4 model (in the three-dimensional XY universality class). The authors claim that a careful scaling analysis of their data gives nu = 0.6711(1) for the thermal critical exponent. If correct, this would neatly resolve the discrepancy between numerical simulations and experiments on 4He. There is reason, however, to doubt the accuracy of the result. A re-analysis of the data yields a significantly higher value of nu, one that is consistent with other Monte Carlo studies.
We improve the theoretical estimates of the critical exponents for the three-dimensional XY universality class. We fine alpha=-0.0146(8), gamma =1.3177(5), nu =0.671 55(27), eta =0.0380(4), beta =0.3485(2), and delta =4.780(2). We observe a discrepancy with the most recent experimental estimate of alpha; this discrepancy calls for further theoretical and experimental investigations. Our results are obtained by combining Monte Carlo simulations based on finite-size scaling methods, and high-temperature expansions. Two improved models (with suppressed leading scaling corrections) are selected by Monte Carlo computation. The critical exponents are computed from high-temperature expansions specialized to these improved models. By the same technique we determine the coefficients of the small-magnetization expansion of the equation of state. This expansion is extended analytically by means of approximate parametric representations, obtaining the equation of state in the whole critical region. We also determine the specific-heat amplitude ratio.
We improve the theoretical estimates of the critical exponents for the three-dimensional XY\mathrm{XY}XY universality class. We find $\ensuremath{\alpha}=\ensuremath{-}0.0146(8),$ $\ensuremath{\gamma}=1.3177(5),$ $\ensuremath{\nu}=0.67155(27),$ $\ensuremath{\eta}=0.0380(4),$ $\ensuremath{\beta}=0.3485(2),$ and $\ensuremath{\delta}=4.780(2).$ We observe a discrepancy with the most recent experimental estimate of $\ensuremath{\alpha};$ this discrepancy calls for further theoretical and experimental investigations. Our results are obtained by combining Monte Carlo simulations based on finite-size scaling methods, and high-temperature expansions. Two improved models (with suppressed leading scaling corrections) are selected by Monte Carlo computation. The critical exponents are computed from high-temperature expansions specialized to these improved models. By the same technique we determine the coefficients of the small-magnetization expansion of the equation of state. This expansion is extended analytically by means of approximate parametric representations, obtaining the equation of state in the whole critical region. We also determine the specific-heat amplitude ratio.
We perform large-scale Monte Carlo simulations of the classical XY model on a three-dimensional L×L×LL\times L \times LL×L×L cubic lattice using the graphics processing unit (GPU). By the combination of Metropolis single-spin flip, over-relaxation and parallel-tempering methods, we simulate systems up to L=160. Performing the finite-size scaling analysis, we obtain estimates of the critical exponents for the three-dimensional XY universality class: α=−0.01293(48)α=-0.01293(48)α=−0.01293(48) and ν=0.67098(16)ν=0.67098(16)ν=0.67098(16). Our estimate for the correlation-length exponent ννν, in contrast to previous theoretical estimates, agrees with the most recent experimental estimate νexp=0.6709(1)ν_{\rm exp}=0.6709(1)νexp​=0.6709(1) at the superfluid transition of 4^44He in a microgravity environment.
Simulation results are reported for the critical point of the two-component ${\ensuremath{\phi}}^{4}$ field theory. The correlation-length exponent is measured to high precision with the result $\ensuremath{\nu}=0.6717(3)$. This value is in agreement with recent simulation results [Campostrini et al., Phys. Rev. B 63, 214503 (2001)] and marginally agrees with the most recent space-based measurements of the superfluid transition in 4He^{4}\mathrm{He}4He [Lipa et al., Phys. Rev. B 68, 174518 (2003)].
We present a Monte Carlo study of the two-component 4 model on the simple cubic lattice in three dimensions. By suitable tuning of the coupling constant, , we eliminate leading-order corrections to scaling. High-statistics simulations using finite-size scaling techniques yield = 0.6723(3)[8] and = 0.0381(2)[2], where the statistical and systematical errors are given in the first and second bracket, respectively. These results are more precise than any previous theoretical estimate of the critical exponents for the 3D XY universality class.
We simulate the improved three-dimensional two-component ϕ 4 model on the simple cubic lattice in the low and the high temperature phase for reduced temperatures down to | T − T c |/ T c ≈ 0.0017 on lattices of size up to 350 3 . Our new results for the internal energy and the specific heat are combined with the accurate estimates of β c and data for the internal energy and the specific heat at β c recently obtained in Campostrini et al (2006 Preprint cond-mat/0605083 ). We find R α = (1 − A + / A − )/α = 4.01(5), where α is the critical exponent of the specific heat and A ± is the amplitude of the specific heat in the high and the low temperature phase, respectively.