Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.26483

Majorization for superpositions of nonorthogonal states and the existence of golden states

Gökhan Torun

quant-phmath-phphysics.atom-phSubmitted Oct 19, 2026• Announced Oct 20, 2026• 1 citation• Revised Nov 2, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Oct 19, 2026v2 · Nov 2, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Golden states, from which every state can be prepared by free operations, are the units of a resource theory. In the resource theory of superposition relative to linearly independent, nonorthogonal reference states, they were known only for two reference states and for special overlap matrices, all of them maximally coherent in the Löwdin basis. We determine what decides their existence and when this Löwdin pattern holds. For every overlap matrix, the robustness and the geometric measure of superposition are maximized by the same states, which overlap equally with all reference states; the maximal values are set by the ground-state energy of a classical $XY$ model on the dual basis. These states, and only these, are golden under the maximal superposition-free operations, but they need not be maximally coherent in the Löwdin basis. For the Kraus-type free operations, we prove Gram majorization, a necessary and sufficient criterion for converting pure states into targets with nonzero coefficients, which reduces to majorization for orthonormal reference states. It shows that every golden state of these operations is maximally coherent in the Löwdin basis, yet golden states exist only for special overlap matrices: three reference states that are not orthonormal admit one if and only if their overlaps have a common modulus $s$ and their Bargmann phase $Φ$ obeys $s\geq2\cos[(π+|Φ|)/3]$, so that a geometric phase decides whether the theory has a unit. Finally, equal-overlap states yield a complete family of superposition witnesses in the Löwdin basis, which show that white noise is a resource unless the reference states are orthonormal.

AI Summary

The paper studies deterministic state conversion and the existence of universal resource states (“golden states”) for superposition relative to $d$ normalized, linearly independent, nonorthogonal reference states with Gram matrix $S$. It distinguishes Kraus-wise superposition-free operations (FO) from all free-state-preserving channels (MFO). For every $S$, maximal robustness is $\Gamma(S)-1$ and maximal geometric superposition is $1-1/\Gamma(S)$, where $\Gamma(S)=\max_{|u_j|=1}u^\dagger S^{-1}u$ and $d\leq\Gamma\leq d/\lambda_{\min}$. Their pure-state maximizers are equal-overlap superpositions of dual-basis vectors; these are exactly the golden states under MFO. The phase optimization corresponds to a classical $XY$ ground-state problem. These maximizers are maximally coherent in the Löwdin orthonormal basis precisely when $\Gamma=d/\lambda_{\min}$. For FO, a necessary-and-sufficient “Gram majorization” criterion characterizes pure-state conversion into targets with nonzero reference-basis coefficients: the source component Gram matrix must dominate a convex mixture of permutations of the target Gram matrix. The proof constructs Kraus operators from the positive-semidefinite slack. This establishes necessary golden-state conditions and a complete classification for $d=3$: apart from orthonormal references, golden states exist exactly when all overlap moduli equal $s$ and the Bargmann phase satisfies $s\geq2\cos[(\pi+|\Phi|)/3]$. Equal-overlap vectors also provide complete superposition witnesses; white noise has robustness at least $\Gamma/d-1>0$ for nonorthogonal references. Limitations include the nonzero-target-coefficient restriction, nonconvex phase optimization in higher dimensions, and unresolved FO existence for some higher-dimensional Gram matrices, including two-eigenvalue cases with both eigenvalues degenerate.

No sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosed
the author used Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic) to assist in refining the mathematical proofs, writing the code for the numerical checks and the figures, and preparing the manuscript.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
30 pages, 4 figures

Related papers

Golden states in resource theory of superposition

Hüseyin Talha Şenyaşa, Gökhan Torun

One central study that constitutes a major branch of quantum resource theory is the hierarchy of states. This provides a broad understanding of resourcefulness in certain tasks in terms of efficiency. Here we investigate the maximal superposition states, i.e., golden states, of the resource theory of superposition. Golden states in the resource theory of coherence are very well established; however, it is a very challenging task for superposition due to the nonorthogonality of the basis states. We show that there are sets of inner product settings that admit a golden state in high-dimensional systems. We bridge the gap between the resource theory of superposition and coherence in the context of golden states by establishing a continuous relation by means of a Gram matrix. In addition, immediate corollaries of our framework provide a representation of maximal states which reduces to the maximal state of the coherence in the orthonormal limit of pure basis states.

arXiv:2111.05690•Physical Review A•Apr 7, 2022•8 citations

Resource theory of superposition: State transformations

Gökhan Torun, Hüseyin Talha Şenyaşa, Ali Kerem Yildiz

A combination of a finite number of linear independent states forms superposition in a way that cannot be conceived classically. Here, using the tools of resource theory of superposition, we give the conditions for a class of superposition state transformations. These conditions strictly depend on the scalar products of the basis states and reduce to the well-known majorization condition for quantum coherence in the limit of orthonormal basis. To further superposition-free transformations of $d$-dimensional systems, we provide superposition-free operators for a deterministic transformation of superposition states. The linear independence of a finite number of basis states requires a relation between the scalar products of these states. With this information in hand, we determine the maximal superposition states which are valid over a certain range of scalar products. Notably, we show that, for $d\ensuremath{\ge}3$, scalar products of the pure superposition-free states have a greater place in seeking maximally resourceful states. Various explicit examples illustrate our findings.

arXiv:2008.07811•Physical Review A•Mar 16, 2021•17 citations

Coherence, superposition, and Löwdin symmetric orthogonalization

Gökhan Torun

Abstract The notions of coherence and superposition are conceptually the same; however, an important distinction exists between their resource-theoretic formulations. Namely, while basis states are orthogonal in the resource theory of coherence, they are not necessarily orthogonal in the resource theory of superposition. Owing to the nonorthogonality, the manipulation and characterization of superposition states require significant efforts. Here, we demonstrate that the Löwdin symmetric orthogonalization (LSO) method offers a useful means for characterizing pure superposition states. The principal property of LSO is that the structure and symmetry of the original nonorthogonal basis states are preserved to the greatest extent possible, which prompts us to study the role of LSO in identifying the hierarchical relations of resource states. Notably, we reveal that the maximally coherent states turn into the states with maximal superposition with the help of LSO: in other words, they are equivalent under the action of symmetric orthogonalization. Our results facilitate further connections between coherence and superposition, where LSO is the main tool.

arXiv:2209.03746•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jul 31, 2023•2 citations

Resource Theory of Superposition

Thomas Theurer, Nathan Killoran, Dario Egloff +1 more

The superposition principle lies at the heart of many nonclassical properties of quantum mechanics. Motivated by this, we introduce a rigorous resource theory framework for the quantification of superposition of a finite number of linear independent states. This theory is a generalization of resource theories of coherence. We determine the general structure of operations which do not create superposition, find a fundamental connection to unambiguous state discrimination, and propose several quantitative superposition measures. Using this theory, we show that trace decreasing operations can be completed for free which, when specialized to the theory of coherence, resolves an outstanding open question and is used to address the free probabilistic transformation between pure states. Finally, we prove that linearly independent superposition is a necessary and sufficient condition for the faithful creation of entanglement in discrete settings, establishing a strong structural connection between our theory of superposition and entanglement theory.

arXiv:1703.10943•Physical Review Letters•Dec 5, 2017•149 citations

Symmetric orthogonalization and probabilistic weights in resource quantification

Gökhan Torun

Transforming nonorthogonal bases into orthogonal ones often compromises essential properties or physical meaning in quantum systems. Here, we demonstrate that Löwdin symmetric orthogonalization (LSO) outperforms the widely used Gram–Schmidt orthogonalization (GSO) in characterizing and quantifying quantum resources, with particular emphasis on coherence and superposition. We employ LSO both to construct an orthogonal basis from a nonorthogonal one and to obtain a nonorthogonal basis from an orthogonal set, thereby mitigating ambiguity related to the basis choice in defining quantum coherence. Unlike GSO, which depends on the ordering of input states, LSO applies a symmetric transformation that treats all vectors equally and minimizes deviation from the original basis. This procedure yields basis sets with enhanced stability, preserving the closest possible correspondence to the original physical states while satisfying orthogonality. Building on LSO, we also introduce Löwdin weights — probabilistic weights for nonorthogonal representations that provide a consistent measure of resource content. We explicitly contrast these with Chirgwin-Coulson weights, demonstrating that Löwdin weights ensure nonnegativity, a prerequisite for information-theoretic measures. These weights further enable the quantification of coherence and the characterization of superposition, providing a degree of superposition as a distinct measure, as well as facilitating the assessment of state delocalization through entropy and participation ratios. Our theoretical and numerical analyses confirm LSO’s superior preservation of quantum state symmetry and resource characteristics, underscoring the critical role of orthogonalization methods and Löwdin weights in resource theory frameworks involving nonorthogonal bases.

arXiv:2508.12949•TURKISH JOURNAL OF PHYSICS•Feb 18, 2026•0 citations

Pairwise detection, chiral conversion: Resource theory of quantum multistates

Yuan-Hong Tao, Yu-Xin Wu, Bing Xie +1 more

Basis-independent coherence of a quantum multistate is fixed by whether its constituent states commute, and for qubits it is detected by pairwise state overlaps alone. What governs its deterministic transformation has been open. We give the exact resource-conversion theory of quantum multistates under common commutativity-preserving operations (CPOs). For qubits, pairwise Bargmann invariants determine the singular values of the unique candidate channel, while a single third-order Bargmann phase determines its orientation. Complete positivity then yields a necessary and sufficient criterion for exact conversion. The criterion identifies a chirality-sensitive shell $\mathcal C_{\rm chir}$, within which targets with identical pairwise geometry can differ in convertibility solely by the sign of their cubic invariant. This yields an order separation, $k_{\rm detect}=2<3=k_{\rm convert}$, for qubit multistates of every size $n\geqslant3$. The chirality-sensitive shell occupies exactly one third of the singular-value simplex, while mirror reflection obstructs two thirds of the admissible orientation-preserving transformations by volume. For $d\geqslant3$, by contrast, the structure is rigid: every resourceful conversion is realized by either an isotropic depolarizing or a transpose-depolarizing channel. Convertibility is then decided by centered Bargmann invariants of degree at most $d^2$.

quant-pharXiv:2610.04930•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations
Golden states, from which every state can be prepared by free operations, are the units of a resource theory. In the resource theory of superposition relative to linearly independent, nonorthogonal reference states, they were known only for two reference states and for special overlap matrices, all of them maximally coherent in the Löwdin basis. We determine what decides their existence and when this Löwdin pattern holds. For every overlap matrix, the robustness and the geometric measure of superposition are maximized by the same states, which overlap equally with all reference states; the maximal values are set by the ground-state energy of a classical XYXYXY model on the dual basis. These states, and only these, are golden under the maximal superposition-free operations, but they need not be maximally coherent in the Löwdin basis. For the Kraus-type free operations, we prove Gram majorization, a necessary and sufficient criterion for converting pure states into targets with nonzero coefficients, which reduces to majorization for orthonormal reference states. It shows that every golden state of these operations is maximally coherent in the Löwdin basis, yet golden states exist only for special overlap matrices: three reference states that are not orthonormal admit one if and only if their overlaps have a common modulus sss and their Bargmann phase ΦΦΦ obeys s≥2cos⁡[(π+∣Φ∣)/3]s\geq2\cos[(π+|Φ|)/3]s≥2cos[(π+∣Φ∣)/3], so that a geometric phase decides whether the theory has a unit. Finally, equal-overlap states yield a complete family of superposition witnesses in the Löwdin basis, which show that white noise is a resource unless the reference states are orthonormal.
The paper studies deterministic state conversion and the existence of universal resource states (“golden states”) for superposition relative to ddd normalized, linearly independent, nonorthogonal reference states with Gram matrix SSS. It distinguishes Kraus-wise superposition-free operations (FO) from all free-state-preserving channels (MFO).
For every SSS, maximal robustness is Γ(S)−1\Gamma(S)-1Γ(S)−1 and maximal geometric superposition is 1−1/Γ(S)1-1/\Gamma(S)1−1/Γ(S), where Γ(S)=max⁡∣uj∣=1u†S−1u\Gamma(S)=\max_{|u_j|=1}u^\dagger S^{-1}uΓ(S)=max∣uj​∣=1​u†S−1u and d≤Γ≤d/λmin⁡d\leq\Gamma\leq d/\lambda_{\min}d≤Γ≤d/λmin​. Their pure-state maximizers are equal-overlap superpositions of dual-basis vectors; these are exactly the golden states under MFO. The phase optimization corresponds to a classical XYXYXY ground-state problem. These maximizers are maximally coherent in the Löwdin orthonormal basis precisely when Γ=d/λmin⁡\Gamma=d/\lambda_{\min}Γ=d/λmin​.
For FO, a necessary-and-sufficient “Gram majorization” criterion characterizes pure-state conversion into targets with nonzero reference-basis coefficients: the source component Gram matrix must dominate a convex mixture of permutations of the target Gram matrix. The proof constructs Kraus operators from the positive-semidefinite slack. This establishes necessary golden-state conditions and a complete classification for d=3d=3d=3: apart from orthonormal references, golden states exist exactly when all overlap moduli equal sss and the Bargmann phase satisfies s≥2cos⁡[(π+∣Φ∣)/3]s\geq2\cos[(\pi+|\Phi|)/3]s≥2cos[(π+∣Φ∣)/3].
Equal-overlap vectors also provide complete superposition witnesses; white noise has robustness at least Γ/d−1>0\Gamma/d-1>0Γ/d−1>0 for nonorthogonal references. Limitations include the nonzero-target-coefficient restriction, nonconvex phase optimization in higher dimensions, and unresolved FO existence for some higher-dimensional Gram matrices, including two-eigenvalue cases with both eigenvalues degenerate.
One central study that constitutes a major branch of quantum resource theory is the hierarchy of states. This provides a broad understanding of resourcefulness in certain tasks in terms of efficiency. Here we investigate the maximal superposition states, i.e., golden states, of the resource theory of superposition. Golden states in the resource theory of coherence are very well established; however, it is a very challenging task for superposition due to the nonorthogonality of the basis states. We show that there are sets of inner product settings that admit a golden state in high-dimensional systems. We bridge the gap between the resource theory of superposition and coherence in the context of golden states by establishing a continuous relation by means of a Gram matrix. In addition, immediate corollaries of our framework provide a representation of maximal states which reduces to the maximal state of the coherence in the orthonormal limit of pure basis states.
A combination of a finite number of linear independent states forms superposition in a way that cannot be conceived classically. Here, using the tools of resource theory of superposition, we give the conditions for a class of superposition state transformations. These conditions strictly depend on the scalar products of the basis states and reduce to the well-known majorization condition for quantum coherence in the limit of orthonormal basis. To further superposition-free transformations of ddd-dimensional systems, we provide superposition-free operators for a deterministic transformation of superposition states. The linear independence of a finite number of basis states requires a relation between the scalar products of these states. With this information in hand, we determine the maximal superposition states which are valid over a certain range of scalar products. Notably, we show that, for $d\ensuremath{\ge}3$, scalar products of the pure superposition-free states have a greater place in seeking maximally resourceful states. Various explicit examples illustrate our findings.
Abstract The notions of coherence and superposition are conceptually the same; however, an important distinction exists between their resource-theoretic formulations. Namely, while basis states are orthogonal in the resource theory of coherence, they are not necessarily orthogonal in the resource theory of superposition. Owing to the nonorthogonality, the manipulation and characterization of superposition states require significant efforts. Here, we demonstrate that the Löwdin symmetric orthogonalization (LSO) method offers a useful means for characterizing pure superposition states. The principal property of LSO is that the structure and symmetry of the original nonorthogonal basis states are preserved to the greatest extent possible, which prompts us to study the role of LSO in identifying the hierarchical relations of resource states. Notably, we reveal that the maximally coherent states turn into the states with maximal superposition with the help of LSO: in other words, they are equivalent under the action of symmetric orthogonalization. Our results facilitate further connections between coherence and superposition, where LSO is the main tool.
The superposition principle lies at the heart of many nonclassical properties of quantum mechanics. Motivated by this, we introduce a rigorous resource theory framework for the quantification of superposition of a finite number of linear independent states. This theory is a generalization of resource theories of coherence. We determine the general structure of operations which do not create superposition, find a fundamental connection to unambiguous state discrimination, and propose several quantitative superposition measures. Using this theory, we show that trace decreasing operations can be completed for free which, when specialized to the theory of coherence, resolves an outstanding open question and is used to address the free probabilistic transformation between pure states. Finally, we prove that linearly independent superposition is a necessary and sufficient condition for the faithful creation of entanglement in discrete settings, establishing a strong structural connection between our theory of superposition and entanglement theory.
Transforming nonorthogonal bases into orthogonal ones often compromises essential properties or physical meaning in quantum systems. Here, we demonstrate that Löwdin symmetric orthogonalization (LSO) outperforms the widely used Gram–Schmidt orthogonalization (GSO) in characterizing and quantifying quantum resources, with particular emphasis on coherence and superposition. We employ LSO both to construct an orthogonal basis from a nonorthogonal one and to obtain a nonorthogonal basis from an orthogonal set, thereby mitigating ambiguity related to the basis choice in defining quantum coherence. Unlike GSO, which depends on the ordering of input states, LSO applies a symmetric transformation that treats all vectors equally and minimizes deviation from the original basis. This procedure yields basis sets with enhanced stability, preserving the closest possible correspondence to the original physical states while satisfying orthogonality. Building on LSO, we also introduce Löwdin weights — probabilistic weights for nonorthogonal representations that provide a consistent measure of resource content. We explicitly contrast these with Chirgwin-Coulson weights, demonstrating that Löwdin weights ensure nonnegativity, a prerequisite for information-theoretic measures. These weights further enable the quantification of coherence and the characterization of superposition, providing a degree of superposition as a distinct measure, as well as facilitating the assessment of state delocalization through entropy and participation ratios. Our theoretical and numerical analyses confirm LSO’s superior preservation of quantum state symmetry and resource characteristics, underscoring the critical role of orthogonalization methods and Löwdin weights in resource theory frameworks involving nonorthogonal bases.
Basis-independent coherence of a quantum multistate is fixed by whether its constituent states commute, and for qubits it is detected by pairwise state overlaps alone. What governs its deterministic transformation has been open. We give the exact resource-conversion theory of quantum multistates under common commutativity-preserving operations (CPOs). For qubits, pairwise Bargmann invariants determine the singular values of the unique candidate channel, while a single third-order Bargmann phase determines its orientation. Complete positivity then yields a necessary and sufficient criterion for exact conversion. The criterion identifies a chirality-sensitive shell Cchir\mathcal C_{\rm chir}Cchir​, within which targets with identical pairwise geometry can differ in convertibility solely by the sign of their cubic invariant. This yields an order separation, kdetect=2<3=kconvertk_{\rm detect}=2<3=k_{\rm convert}kdetect​=2<3=kconvert​, for qubit multistates of every size n⩾3n\geqslant3n⩾3. The chirality-sensitive shell occupies exactly one third of the singular-value simplex, while mirror reflection obstructs two thirds of the admissible orientation-preserving transformations by volume. For d⩾3d\geqslant3d⩾3, by contrast, the structure is rigid: every resourceful conversion is realized by either an isotropic depolarizing or a transpose-depolarizing channel. Convertibility is then decided by centered Bargmann invariants of degree at most d2d^2d2.