arXiv:2610.04930
Pairwise detection, chiral conversion: Resource theory of quantum multistates
Yuan-Hong Tao, Yu-Xin Wu, Bing Xie, Lin Zhang
Abstract
Basis-independent coherence of a quantum multistate is fixed by whether its constituent states commute, and for qubits it is detected by pairwise state overlaps alone. What governs its deterministic transformation has been open. We give the exact resource-conversion theory of quantum multistates under common commutativity-preserving operations (CPOs). For qubits, pairwise Bargmann invariants determine the singular values of the unique candidate channel, while a single third-order Bargmann phase determines its orientation. Complete positivity then yields a necessary and sufficient criterion for exact conversion. The criterion identifies a chirality-sensitive shell $\mathcal C_{\rm chir}$, within which targets with identical pairwise geometry can differ in convertibility solely by the sign of their cubic invariant. This yields an order separation, $k_{\rm detect}=2<3=k_{\rm convert}$, for qubit multistates of every size $n\geqslant3$. The chirality-sensitive shell occupies exactly one third of the singular-value simplex, while mirror reflection obstructs two thirds of the admissible orientation-preserving transformations by volume. For $d\geqslant3$, by contrast, the structure is rigid: every resourceful conversion is realized by either an isotropic depolarizing or a transpose-depolarizing channel. Convertibility is then decided by centered Bargmann invariants of degree at most $d^2$.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether pairwise state overlaps, which detect noncommutativity of qubit ensembles, also determine their deterministic conversion under a common commutativity-preserving channel (CPO). It develops conversion criteria for ordered tuples of states, treating commuting targets through POVM feasibility and noncommuting targets through channel classifications. For a qubit source triple whose Bloch vectors span $\mathbb R^3$, the unique candidate unital channel has Bloch matrix $T=SR^{-1}$. Pairwise Bargmann invariants determine its singular values $s_1\ge s_2\ge s_3$, while a cubic invariant determines its orientation $\eta$. Complete positivity is equivalent to $1+\eta s_3\ge s_1+s_2$ and $1-\eta s_3\ge s_1-s_2$. These conditions distinguish mirror targets with identical pairwise geometry. The chirality-sensitive region occupies $1/3$ of the ordered singular-value simplex and $2/3$ of its orientation-preserving admissible region, under uniform Lebesgue measure. Using Bloch-geometry reconstruction and explicit mirror counterexamples, the paper establishes $k_{\rm detect}=2$ and $k_{\rm convert}=3$ for every ensemble size $n\ge3$; both equal two for pairs. It also gives consistency and extension criteria for larger or planar ensembles. For $d\ge3$, an existing CPO classification restricts resourceful conversions to depolarizing or transpose-depolarizing branches; trace-invariant generation yields a sufficient-and-necessary test using centered Bargmann invariants through degree $d^2$. The order separation assumes invariants are measured separately within source and target: allowing cross overlaps removes it. Results concern exact, deterministic, same-dimensional conversion under common CPOs; other operation classes and distributed multistates remain open directions.
Error found: The abstract's claim that pairwise invariants determine the singular values of a unique candidate channel requires a source spanning the full Bloch space; planar sources can admit multiple valid converting channels with different singular values.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 11 pages, 4 figures