arXiv:2610.06682
Interacting quantum criticality with U(1) symmetry breaking in 1+1 dimensions
Mutsumi Shimomura, Kohei Kawabata
Abstract
The Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner theorem motivates the expectation that continuous symmetry remains unbroken in one-dimensional quantum ground states. Here, contrary to this expectation, we demonstrate the spontaneous breaking of U(1) spin-rotation symmetry and the emergence of an interacting quantum critical point in lattice spin-$1/2$ and spin-$1$ chains. Using subsystem Binder scaling, we locate the critical point and determine the correlation-length critical exponent as $ν= 0.60 \pm 0.02$, distinct from the Gaussian value $1/2$ but consistent with the perturbative renormalization-group value. We further estimate the dynamical critical exponent to be $z = 1.986 \pm 0.005$ from the lowest neutral excitation gap and $z = 1.955 \pm 0.021$ from the longitudinal spin correlations. The results $z < 2$ are incompatible with microscopic realizations of this critical theory by frustration-free models, implying a mechanism for continuous symmetry breaking in one-dimensional quantum ground states distinct from frustration freeness.
AI Summary
The paper tests whether finite-range, one-dimensional spin chains realize a previously proposed interacting quantum critical point with spontaneous U(1) symmetry breaking. This is not a violation of the finite-temperature Hohenberg–Mermin–Wagner theorem: the proposed ground-state criticality is nonrelativistic, with Berry-phase coupling between the transverse phase and longitudinal magnetization. DMRG calculations study a ferromagnetic spin-$1$ chain with on-site and nearest-neighbor longitudinal anisotropies, and a spin-$1/2$ chain with a four-site longitudinal interaction. Half-chain magnetization Binder ratios locate transitions despite fixed total magnetization. Finite-size scaling gives $\nu=0.60\pm0.02$ and $0.61\pm0.02$, respectively, distinct from the Gaussian value $1/2$. Extrapolated squared transverse magnetizations are $0.947\pm0.003$ and $0.212\pm0.003$, supporting U(1) long-range order at criticality. Infinite-chain, symmetry-preserving VUMPS calculations provide a separate check for spin $1$; a variational argument connects such order in fixed-magnetization sectors to infinitesimal-field symmetry breaking. For spin $1$, neutral-gap scaling gives $z=1.986\pm0.005$, while longitudinal-correlation scaling gives $z=1.955\pm0.021$. Both favor $z<2$, which, under the stated locality, sector-uniqueness and algebraic-correlation assumptions, excludes frustration-free realizations of this critical theory. The uncertainties describe fitting sensitivities, not statistical confidence intervals. The gap estimate assumes a correction exponent $\omega=2$ and uses sizes up to $L=42$. Available infinite-chain correlation lengths are insufficient for a precise direct power-law fit; correlation-based scaling dimensions do not quantitatively agree with the gap-derived estimate within the quoted ranges. Continuum mappings alone do not establish the proposed behavior in additional candidate models.
Central claim may not hold: The claimed subquadratic exponent and resulting frustration-free exclusion rely on a fixed ω=2 finite-size extrapolation whose correction-form uncertainty is not included in the quoted error range. The gap and longitudinal-correlation determinations of z have nonoverlapping quoted systematic envelopes, so they provide qualitative agreement on z<2 but not quantitatively consistent independent estimates.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 22 pages, 7 figures, 4 tables