arXiv:2609.31319
Criticality enabled long-range order in a U(1)-symmetric spin-1 Heisenberg chain with biquadratic interactions
Natalia Chepiga, Fabian H. L. Essler
Abstract
In a recent paper Nahum argued on the basis of a renormalization-group analysis that, contrary to standard lore, ground states of 1D spin chains with short-range interactions can spontaneously break U(1) ``easy-plane'' spin rotation symmetry. True long-range order of $(S^x,S^y)$ arises at the phase transition between two quasi-long-range-ordered phases. Here we present detailed numerical results for an anisotropic spin-1 chain model. We find a magnetization exponent $β\approx0.29$, consistent with the $ε$-expansion prediction $β\approx0.28$, a divergence of the Luttinger parameter on approaching the transition from both sides with an exponent that we relate to Nahum's transition, and finite-size spectra consistent with a dynamical critical exponent $z\approx2$. Our results support the critical behavior predicted by Nahum's field theory.
AI Summary
Can a short-range, one-dimensional quantum spin chain spontaneously break an easy-plane $U(1)$ symmetry at a transition between two Luttinger liquids? This paper numerically tests the criticality-enabled long-range order predicted by Nahum’s renormalization-group theory, using a ferromagnetic spin-1 Heisenberg chain with single-ion anisotropy $g_1(S_j^z)^2$ and nearest-neighbor interaction $g_2(S_j^z)^2(S_{j+1}^z)^2$. DMRG calculations map unmagnetized and partially magnetized Luttinger liquids and a saturated ferromagnet. Simulations reach 1,500 sites with open boundaries and typically 240 with periodic boundaries. Entanglement entropy and spin correlations support the Luttinger-liquid descriptions. Near the transition between the liquids, the longitudinal magnetization vanishes with exponent $\beta\approx0.31$ at $g_2=0.4$ and $\beta\approx0.29$ at $g_2=1$, compared with the field-theory prediction $\beta\approx0.28$. The Luttinger parameter, extracted from entanglement spectra, diverges on both sides consistently with the proposed relation $K\propto|g_1-g_c|^{\nu(1-z)}$, whose predicted exponent is approximately $-0.554$. This implies a vanishing transverse correlation exponent and supports transverse long-range order at criticality. Low-energy finite-size spectra give $z\approx2$, incompatible with a previously reported estimate $1.51\pm0.03$. Phase-separated excitations in the magnetized liquid have a finite domain-wall energy above the ground state. The stated limitations include strong finite-size and boundary effects, corrections near the SU(2)-symmetric point, and slower convergence restricting access to criticality at $g_2=1$. The spectral results cannot distinguish $z=2$ from the field-theory value $z\approx1.992$; long-range order is supported indirectly through the divergence of $K$.
Error found: Critical transverse long-range order is supported indirectly through the neighboring-phase divergence of K, rather than established by a thermodynamic extrapolation of correlations at criticality. The proposed divergence exponent of K depends on an explicitly assumed finite, nonzero stiffness vK that is not independently verified in the paper. The crossover derivation prints incorrect signs in both the correlation-length scaling and the frequency prefactor, although correcting them recovers the stated final exponent. The appendix incorrectly makes the chemical potential proportional to the square root of tuning distance, contradicting its own subsequent scaling and the body's square-root law; expanding the potential instead gives a linear chemical potential.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 21 pages, 16 figures