Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2609.23609

Casimir force in a water nanolayer confined by graphene sheets

Wijnand Broer, Jure Dobnikar

quant-phcond-mat.softSubmitted Sep 20, 2026• Announced Sep 22, 2026• Revised Sep 29, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Sep 20, 2026v2 · Sep 29, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Casimir forces, arising from quantum and thermal fluctuations, depend strongly on the electromagnetic susceptibilities of the interacting materials. Here, we theoretically investigate the Casimir force between two graphene sheets separated by a nanometer-thin layer of liquid water. We find that deviations from the bulk case can be as large as 24 \%, mostly due to the static susceptibility components. This effect does not decrease monotonically as a function of the layer thickness: it increases up to a maximum at 70 nm and it slowly declines to the bulk limit only at 1 micron. This is due to two competing effects: on one hand, the anisotropy decreases with the layer thickness; on the other hand, the relative contribution of the most anisotropic, static susceptibility components increases.

AI Summary

How does confinement-induced dielectric anisotropy of water modify the Casimir pressure between two graphene sheets? The paper calculates the pressure at $T=300\,\mathrm{K}$ for water-layer thicknesses from $0.7\,\mathrm{nm}$ to $2\,\mu\mathrm{m}$ using Lifshitz theory with an out-of-plane uniaxial dielectric tensor and a local Kubo conductivity for graphene. Material inputs combine measured static permittivities, molecular-dynamics frequency-dependent susceptibilities, and bulk-water optical data; thickness dependence is modeled phenomenologically where data are unavailable. Relative to treating the water as bulk and isotropic, the calculated attractive pressure is reduced, with bulk-model overestimates reaching about $20\%$ below $6\,\mathrm{nm}$ and $24\%$ overall. The discrepancy is nonmonotonic: it peaks near $70\,\mathrm{nm}$ and falls below $5\%$ only around $1\,\mu\mathrm{m}$. Above $6\,\mathrm{nm}$, modeled confinement effects enter only through the zero-frequency Matsubara term, for which $P_0=-k_BT\zeta(3)\varepsilon_\perp(0)/(8\pi a^3\varepsilon_\parallel(0))$. The maximum reflects competition between decreasing dielectric anisotropy and increasing relative importance of this thermal term. The magnitude and long-distance persistence depend strongly on the assumed series-capacitor model for the perpendicular static permittivity and lack direct experimental verification. Short-distance frequency-dependent inputs cover only three sampled thicknesses, and static values at $0.7\,\mathrm{nm}$ are extrapolated. The calculation assumes confinement leaves electronic polarization unchanged. The paper also identifies limitations of local graphene conductivity, notes that substrates or nonlocal response could change the results, and discusses ionic screening of the static contribution.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptions

Error found: The abstract omits the body's explicit qualification that the predicted 24% maximum and long-ranged thickness dependence depend mainly on an experimentally unverified series-capacitor model for the static perpendicular permittivity. At 0.7 nm, the stated permittivities, zero-mode pressure formula, and approximately 20% bulk overestimate require nonzero Matsubara terms to supply at least approximately 99.75% of the confined pressure, contradicting the claim that they supply only a few percent.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
8 pages, 6 figures

Related papers

Casimir forces on suspended thin dielectric membranes covered with graphene

Tze Ue Ngai, Zuocheng Zhang, Q. Zhang +5 more

We investigate the Casimir force on thin suspended dielectric layers covered with graphene, both theoretically and experimentally. Thermal effects of the Casimir force on graphene occur at separations significantly smaller compared to ordinary metals and dielectrics. At such small separations, the Casimir force is sufficiently strong to be measured experimentally. However, the presence of substrates to support the graphene significantly reduces the enhancement. We show theoretically that replacing the solid substrate beneath graphene with a thin dielectric membrane partially restores this strong thermal dependence. One of the interacting objects is a solid gold plate. The other object is a suspended dielectric membrane made of either 15 nm of silicon oxide or 13 nm silicon nitride, covered with graphene. At a separation of $\sim$500 nm, theoretical predictions yield changes in the Casimir pressure of up to 54 % and 40 % for silicon oxide and silicon nitride, respectively, when the temperature is increased from 10 K to 294 K. Measurements were performed for graphene on a suspended silicon nitride membrane at room temperature, using a gold-coated sphere attached to a cantilever as the force sensor. The measured force gradient is consistent with the theoretical prediction, although the thermal dependence could not be resolved, in part because of uncertainties in the optical properties of silicon nitride. Replacing a bulk substrate with a thin dielectric membrane covered with graphene provides a substantial reduction of the Casimir force, which may facilitate the stable operation of neutral nanomechanical elements at small separations.

quant-pharXiv:2610.21437•Oct 16, 2026

Casimir interactions between two parallel graphene sheets carrying steady-state drift currents

Modi Ke, Dai-Nam Le, Lilia M. Woods

We investigate the fluctuation-induced Casimir interactions between two parallel graphene sheets carrying steady-state drift currents. The graphene properties are modeled based on the shifted Fermi disk model to capture the non-equilibrium optical response of the system. We find that the drift current introduces a repulsive correction to the perpendicular to the layers Casimir interaction, thereby reducing the overall attractive force. Although the correction is repulsive, it does not overcome the underlying attraction between the layers. It also generates a lateral force that opposes the carrier flow direction. Both contributions are studied in terms of distance and drift velocity functionalities showing pathways for Casimir force control.

quant-pharXiv:2601.00489•Jan 5, 2026

Oscillating Casimir force between two slabs in a Fermi sea

Li-Wei Chen, Guozhen Su, Jincan Chen +1 more

The Casimir effect for two parallel slabs immersed in an ideal Fermi sea is investigated at both zero and nonzero temperatures. It is found that the Casimir effect in a Fermi gas is distinctly different from that in an electromagnetic field or a massive Bose gas. In contrast to the familiar result that the Casimir force decreases monotonically with the increase of the separation L between two slabs in an electromagnetic field and a massive Bose gas, the Casimir force in a Fermi gas oscillates as a function of L. The Casimir force can be either attractive or repulsive, depending sensitively on the magnitude of L. In addition, it is found that the amplitude of the Casimir force in a Fermi gas decreases with the increase of the temperature, which also is contrary to the case in a Bose gas, since the bosonic Casimir force increases linearly with the increase of the temperature in the region T < T c , where T c is the critical temperature of the Bose—Einstein condensation.

Chinese Physics B•Jan 1, 2012•2 citations

Controlled ripple texturing of suspended graphene membranes due to coupling with ultracold atoms

Sofia Ribeiro, Stefan Scheel

We explore the possibility to create hybrid quantum systems that combine ultracold atoms with graphene membranes. We investigate a setup in which a cold atom cloud is placed close to a free-standing sheet of graphene at distances of a few hundred nanometers. The atoms then couple strongly to the graphene membrane via Casimir-Polder forces. Temporal changes in the atomic state of the atomic cloud changes the Casimir-Polder interaction, thereby leading to the creation of a back-action force in the graphene sheet. This setup provides a controllable way to engineer ripples in a graphene sheet with cold atoms.

arXiv:1303.1711•Physical Review A•Nov 26, 2013•10 citations

FLUCTUATION-INDUCED PHENOMENA: FROM BIOPHYSICS TO CAVITY QED

Ramin Golestanian, Mehran Kardar A

The static Casimir effect describes an attractive force between two conducting plates, due to quantum fluctuations of the electromagnetic (EM) field in the intervening space. Thermal fluctuations of correlated fluids (such as critical mixtures, super-fluids, or liquid crystals) are also modified by the boundaries, resulting in finite-size corrections at criticality, and additional forces that effect wetting and layering phenomena. Modified fluctuations of the EM field can also account for the “van der Waals” interaction between conducting spheres, and have analogs in the fluctuation-induced interactions between inclusions on a membrane. We employ a path integral formalism to study these phenomena for boundaries of arbitrary shape. This allows us to examine the many unexpected phenomena of the dynamic Casimir effect due to moving boundaries. With the inclusion of quantum fluctuations, the EM vacuum behaves essentially as a complex fluid, and modifies the motion of objects through it. In particular, from the mechanical response function of the EM vacuum, we extract a plethora of interesting results, the most notable being: (i) The effective mass of a plate depends on its shape, and becomes anisotropic. (ii) There is dissipation and damping of the motion, again dependent upon shape, and direction of motion. (iii) There is a continuous spectrum of resonant cavity modes that can be excited by the motion.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Dec 1, 2000•0 citations

Temperature dependence of the Casimir pressure on two graphene sheets placed on a substrate

Michael V. Davidovich

The dispersion interaction between two infinite sheets of graphene located on a substrate is considered based on the Lifshitz formula, taking temperature into account. The result is obtained in the form of a series that is easy to calculate. The influence of the interband conductivity of graphene, which turned out to be small, is examined.

quant-pharXiv:2609.27864•Aug 21, 2026
Casimir forces, arising from quantum and thermal fluctuations, depend strongly on the electromagnetic susceptibilities of the interacting materials. Here, we theoretically investigate the Casimir force between two graphene sheets separated by a nanometer-thin layer of liquid water. We find that deviations from the bulk case can be as large as 24 %, mostly due to the static susceptibility components. This effect does not decrease monotonically as a function of the layer thickness: it increases up to a maximum at 70 nm and it slowly declines to the bulk limit only at 1 micron. This is due to two competing effects: on one hand, the anisotropy decreases with the layer thickness; on the other hand, the relative contribution of the most anisotropic, static susceptibility components increases.
How does confinement-induced dielectric anisotropy of water modify the Casimir pressure between two graphene sheets? The paper calculates the pressure at T=300 KT=300\,\mathrm{K}T=300K for water-layer thicknesses from 0.7 nm0.7\,\mathrm{nm}0.7nm to 2 μm2\,\mu\mathrm{m}2μm using Lifshitz theory with an out-of-plane uniaxial dielectric tensor and a local Kubo conductivity for graphene. Material inputs combine measured static permittivities, molecular-dynamics frequency-dependent susceptibilities, and bulk-water optical data; thickness dependence is modeled phenomenologically where data are unavailable.
Relative to treating the water as bulk and isotropic, the calculated attractive pressure is reduced, with bulk-model overestimates reaching about 20%20\%20% below 6 nm6\,\mathrm{nm}6nm and 24%24\%24% overall. The discrepancy is nonmonotonic: it peaks near 70 nm70\,\mathrm{nm}70nm and falls below 5%5\%5% only around 1 μm1\,\mu\mathrm{m}1μm. Above 6 nm6\,\mathrm{nm}6nm, modeled confinement effects enter only through the zero-frequency Matsubara term, for which P0=−kBTζ(3)ε⊥(0)/(8πa3ε∥(0))P_0=-k_BT\zeta(3)\varepsilon_\perp(0)/(8\pi a^3\varepsilon_\parallel(0))P0​=−kB​Tζ(3)ε⊥​(0)/(8πa3ε∥​(0)). The maximum reflects competition between decreasing dielectric anisotropy and increasing relative importance of this thermal term.
The magnitude and long-distance persistence depend strongly on the assumed series-capacitor model for the perpendicular static permittivity and lack direct experimental verification. Short-distance frequency-dependent inputs cover only three sampled thicknesses, and static values at 0.7 nm0.7\,\mathrm{nm}0.7nm are extrapolated. The calculation assumes confinement leaves electronic polarization unchanged. The paper also identifies limitations of local graphene conductivity, notes that substrates or nonlocal response could change the results, and discusses ionic screening of the static contribution.
We investigate the Casimir force on thin suspended dielectric layers covered with graphene, both theoretically and experimentally. Thermal effects of the Casimir force on graphene occur at separations significantly smaller compared to ordinary metals and dielectrics. At such small separations, the Casimir force is sufficiently strong to be measured experimentally. However, the presence of substrates to support the graphene significantly reduces the enhancement. We show theoretically that replacing the solid substrate beneath graphene with a thin dielectric membrane partially restores this strong thermal dependence. One of the interacting objects is a solid gold plate. The other object is a suspended dielectric membrane made of either 15 nm of silicon oxide or 13 nm silicon nitride, covered with graphene. At a separation of $\sim$500 nm, theoretical predictions yield changes in the Casimir pressure of up to 54 % and 40 % for silicon oxide and silicon nitride, respectively, when the temperature is increased from 10 K to 294 K. Measurements were performed for graphene on a suspended silicon nitride membrane at room temperature, using a gold-coated sphere attached to a cantilever as the force sensor. The measured force gradient is consistent with the theoretical prediction, although the thermal dependence could not be resolved, in part because of uncertainties in the optical properties of silicon nitride. Replacing a bulk substrate with a thin dielectric membrane covered with graphene provides a substantial reduction of the Casimir force, which may facilitate the stable operation of neutral nanomechanical elements at small separations.
We investigate the fluctuation-induced Casimir interactions between two parallel graphene sheets carrying steady-state drift currents. The graphene properties are modeled based on the shifted Fermi disk model to capture the non-equilibrium optical response of the system. We find that the drift current introduces a repulsive correction to the perpendicular to the layers Casimir interaction, thereby reducing the overall attractive force. Although the correction is repulsive, it does not overcome the underlying attraction between the layers. It also generates a lateral force that opposes the carrier flow direction. Both contributions are studied in terms of distance and drift velocity functionalities showing pathways for Casimir force control.
The Casimir effect for two parallel slabs immersed in an ideal Fermi sea is investigated at both zero and nonzero temperatures. It is found that the Casimir effect in a Fermi gas is distinctly different from that in an electromagnetic field or a massive Bose gas. In contrast to the familiar result that the Casimir force decreases monotonically with the increase of the separation L between two slabs in an electromagnetic field and a massive Bose gas, the Casimir force in a Fermi gas oscillates as a function of L. The Casimir force can be either attractive or repulsive, depending sensitively on the magnitude of L. In addition, it is found that the amplitude of the Casimir force in a Fermi gas decreases with the increase of the temperature, which also is contrary to the case in a Bose gas, since the bosonic Casimir force increases linearly with the increase of the temperature in the region T < T c , where T c is the critical temperature of the Bose—Einstein condensation.
We explore the possibility to create hybrid quantum systems that combine ultracold atoms with graphene membranes. We investigate a setup in which a cold atom cloud is placed close to a free-standing sheet of graphene at distances of a few hundred nanometers. The atoms then couple strongly to the graphene membrane via Casimir-Polder forces. Temporal changes in the atomic state of the atomic cloud changes the Casimir-Polder interaction, thereby leading to the creation of a back-action force in the graphene sheet. This setup provides a controllable way to engineer ripples in a graphene sheet with cold atoms.
The static Casimir effect describes an attractive force between two conducting plates, due to quantum fluctuations of the electromagnetic (EM) field in the intervening space. Thermal fluctuations of correlated fluids (such as critical mixtures, super-fluids, or liquid crystals) are also modified by the boundaries, resulting in finite-size corrections at criticality, and additional forces that effect wetting and layering phenomena. Modified fluctuations of the EM field can also account for the “van der Waals” interaction between conducting spheres, and have analogs in the fluctuation-induced interactions between inclusions on a membrane. We employ a path integral formalism to study these phenomena for boundaries of arbitrary shape. This allows us to examine the many unexpected phenomena of the dynamic Casimir effect due to moving boundaries. With the inclusion of quantum fluctuations, the EM vacuum behaves essentially as a complex fluid, and modifies the motion of objects through it. In particular, from the mechanical response function of the EM vacuum, we extract a plethora of interesting results, the most notable being: (i) The effective mass of a plate depends on its shape, and becomes anisotropic. (ii) There is dissipation and damping of the motion, again dependent upon shape, and direction of motion. (iii) There is a continuous spectrum of resonant cavity modes that can be excited by the motion.