arXiv:2609.22976
Weak Values Beyond the Weak Limit: Measurement-Strength Invariance Under Post-Selection
Cosmin Andrei, Vlatko Vedral
Abstract
Weak values are conventionally extracted in the limit of vanishing measurement strength. At finite strength, the corresponding post-selected conditional averages generally acquire nonlinear corrections and need not retain their weak value interpretation. Here we identify a class of measurement protocols for which this expectation fails: the conditional value reconstructed from the measuring probe is exactly independent of the probe strength and therefore coincides with the real part of the weak value. We first analyze this phenomenon in the measurement--disturbance protocol introduced by Lund and Wiseman. We then establish conditions under which this invariance persists, showing that it is determined by the interplay between the probe interaction, a subsequent measurement interaction with an ancillary apparatus, and the final post-selection. These results demonstrate that weak coupling, although generally sufficient for accessing weak values, is not always necessary.
AI Summary
The paper asks when a post-selected probe average can equal the real part of a weak value at finite measurement strength, rather than only in the weak-coupling limit. It studies the Lund–Wiseman protocol for reconstructing Ozawa measurement precision and disturbance, then replaces its qubit meters with continuous-variable von Neumann pointers. Exact calculations show that the calibrated conditional probe averages in the ideal qubit protocol are independent of probe strength, both for precision ($Z$ probing followed by a $Z$ apparatus interaction) and disturbance ($X$ probing followed by a $Z$ apparatus interaction). Consequently, the corresponding weak-valued conditional probabilities are recovered without weak probing. For identical coupling observables, this invariance extends to arbitrary finite system dimension when conditioning on the apparatus pointer outcome. For distinct observables, the analysis gives a sufficient condition: apparatus states associated with different initial probe-observable eigenstates must become orthogonal after post-selection. This removes interference contributions from both the conditional-average numerator and denominator. Real initial pointer wavefunctions and mutually unbiased coupling eigenbases ensure this condition for a two-dimensional system post-selected onto a probe-observable eigenstate. The result also extends to direct sums of invariant two-dimensional sectors. An explicit Gaussian-pointer qutrit counterexample shows that mutual unbiasedness alone is insufficient in higher dimensions. The conditions are sufficient, not a general classification. The identified mechanism produces convex combinations of eigenvalues and therefore excludes anomalous weak values. Whether other strength-invariant mechanisms can support anomalous values remains open; the treatment concerns real weak values and restricts initial pointer wavefunctions to be real.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 12 pages (10 pages for main text, 2 pages for appendices), 4 figures