Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2607.06431

Unbiased Estimation of Conditional Covariance for Quantum Optomechanics

Katsuta Sakai, Nobuyuki Matsumoto

quant-phSubmitted Jul 7, 2026• Announced Jul 8, 2026• 2 citations• Revised Jul 21, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Jul 7, 2026v2 · Jul 21, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Continuous measurements can prepare macroscopic mechanical oscillators in conditional quantum states, but their covariance is difficult to verify. The conventional retrodictive estimator assumes a forward--backward covariance symmetry and can be biased, because physical dynamics such as feedback damping reduces the observability of the state from future records. Here, we derive an exact linear-Gaussian estimator from causal, retrodictive, and smoothed trajectories. For a milligram-scale mirror, it agrees with a Riccati prediction based on parameters fixed independently, while the conventional estimate exhibits a covariance-space bias of $d_M\simeq3.5$. Our method paves the way toward unbiased testing of macroscopic entanglement within a calibrated linear-Gaussian model, applicable to both tabletop mirrors and kg-scale gravitational-wave test masses.

Related papers

Measurement-Based Estimation of Causal Conditional Variances and Its Application to Macroscopic quantum phenomenon

Kosei Hatakeyama, Ryotaro Fukuzumi, Akira Matsumura +2 more

We analytically investigate a quantum estimation method for a mechanical oscillator in a detuned cavity system based solely on homodyne measurement records, building on the framework developed by C.Meng et al. (Science Advances 8, 7585 (2022)). Estimation based only on measurement records is important because it enables state verification without assuming knowledge of the true system state. We construct a relative estimate operator from causal and anti-causal quantum Wiener filters and calculate its variance. The deviation from the causal conditional variance is defined as a reconstruction bias, whose magnitude is evaluated analytically. We show that, within experimentally relevant parameter regimes for typical quantum-state preparation, the reconstruction bias is sufficiently small to be neglected. As applications to state verification, we apply the method to proposals for macroscopic quantum entanglement mediated by electromagnetic interactions and for conditional momentum-squeezed states generated by homodyne detection, and clarify the conditions under which the bias remains negligible and when the reconstruction bias becomes significant.

quant-pharXiv:2603.16821•Physical Review A•Mar 18, 2026•1 citation

Probing macroscopic quantum states with a sub-Heisenberg accuracy

Haixing Miao, S. L. Danilishin, H. Müller‐Ebhardt +3 more

Significant achievements in high-sensitivity measurements will soon allow us to probe quantum behaviors of macroscopic mechanical oscillators. In a recent work [Phys. Rev. A 80, 043802 (2009)], we formulated a general framework for treating preparation of Gaussian quantum states of macroscopic oscillators through linear position measurements. To outline a complete procedure for testing macroscopic quantum mechanics, here we consider a subsequent verification stage which probes the prepared macroscopic quantum state and verifies the quantum dynamics. By adopting an optimal time-dependent homodyne detection in which the phase of the local oscillator varies in time, the conditional quantum state can be characterized below the Heisenberg limit, thereby achieving a quantum tomography. In the limiting case of no readout loss, such a scheme evades measurement-induced back action, which is identical to the variational-type measurement scheme invented by Vyatchanin et al. [JETP 77, 218 (1993)] but in the context for detecting gravitational waves. To motivate macroscopic quantum mechanics experiments with future gravitational-wave detectors, we mostly focus on the parameter regime where the characteristic measurement frequency is much higher than the oscillator frequency and the classical noises are Markovian, which captures the main feature of a broadband gravitational-wave detector. In addition, we discuss verifications of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-type entanglement between macroscopic test masses in future gravitational-wave detectors, which enables us to test one particular version of gravity decoherence conjectured by Di\'osi [Phys. Lett. A120, 377 (1987)] and Penrose [Gen. Rel. Grav. 28, 581 (1996)].

arXiv:0905.3729•Physical Review A•Jan 25, 2010•52 citations

Generating quantum entanglement between macroscopic objects with continuous measurement and feedback control

Daisuke Miki, Nobuyuki Matsumoto, Akira Matsumura +4 more

This paper is aimed at investigating the feasibility of generating quantum conditional entanglement between macroscopic mechanical mirrors in optomechanical systems while under continuous measurement and feedback control. We consider the squeezing of the states of the mechanical common and the differential motions of the mirrors by the action of measuring the common and the differential output light beams in the Fabry-P\'erot-Michelson interferometer. We carefully derive a covariance matrix for the mechanical mirrors in a steady state, employing the Kalman filtering problem with dissipative cavities. We demonstrate that Gaussian entanglement between the mechanical mirrors is generated when the states of the mechanical common and differential modes of the mirrors are squeezed with high purity in an asymmetric manner. Our results also show that quantum entanglement between 7-mg mirrors is achievable in the short term.

arXiv:2210.13169•Physical Review A•Mar 13, 2023•33 citations

Prediction and retrodiction with continuously monitored Gaussian states

Jinglei Zhang, Klaus Mølmer

Gaussian states of quantum oscillators are fully characterized by the mean values and the covariance matrix of their quadrature observables. We consider the dynamics of a system of oscillators subject to interactions, damping, and continuous probing which maintain their Gaussian state property. Such dynamics is found in many physical systems that can therefore be efficiently described by the ensuing effective representation of the density matrix $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$. Our probabilistic knowledge about the outcome of measurements on a quantum system at time $t$ is not only governed by $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$ conditioned on the evolution and measurement outcomes obtained until time $t$ but is also modified by any information acquired after $t$. It was shown [S. Gammelmark, B. Julsgaard, and K. M\o{}lmer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 160401 (2013)] that this information is represented by a supplementary matrix, $E(t)$. We show here that the restriction of the dynamics of $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$ to Gaussian states implies that the matrix $E(t)$ is also fully characterized by a vector of mean values and a covariance matrix. We derive the dynamical equations for these quantities and we illustrate their use in the retrodiction of measurements on Gaussian systems.

arXiv:1710.04950•Physical Review A•Dec 26, 2017•47 citations

Quantum retrodiction in Gaussian systems and applications in optomechanics

Jonas Lammers, Klemens Hammerer

What knowledge can be obtained from the record of a continuous measurement about the quantum state of the measured system at the beginning of the measurement? The task of quantum state retrodiction, the inverse of the more common state prediction, is rigorously addressed in quantum measurement theory through retrodictive positive operator-valued measures (POVMs). This introduction to this general framework presents its practical formulation for retrodicting Gaussian quantum states using continuous-time homodyne measurements and applies it to optomechanical systems. We identify and characterize achievable retrodictive POVMs in common optomechanical operating modes with resonant or off-resonant driving fields and specific choices of local oscillator frequencies in homodyne detection. In particular, we demonstrate the possibility of a near-ideal measurement of the quadrature of the mechanical oscillator, giving direct access to the position or momentum distribution of the oscillator at a given time. This forms the basis for complete quantum state tomography, albeit in a destructive manner.

arXiv:2309.03507•Frontiers in Quantum Science and Technology•Jan 25, 2024•6 citations

Testing Alternative Theories of Quantum Mechanics with Optomechanics, and Effective Modes for Gaussian Linear Optomechanics

Bassam Helou

Optomechanics has made great strides in theory and experiments over the past decade, which culminated in the first direct detection of gravitational waves in 2015 by LIGO. This thesis explores how optomechanics can be used to test fundamental physics other than the theory of general relativity. Our emphasis will be on falsifiable theories (ultimately, only experiments can decide whether a theory is correct) that address two outstanding issues in quantum mechanics: the measurement problem, and reconciling quantum mechanics with the theory of general relativity. In particular, we show that the space experiment LISA pathfinder places aggressive bounds on two objective collapse models, which are non-linear stochastic modifications of the Schroedinger equation that can resolve the measurement problem. Moreover, we show that state-of-the-art torsion pendulum experiments can test the Schroedinger-Newton theory, which is the non-relativistic limit of a non-linear theory combining quantum mechanics with a fundamentally classical spacetime. Along the way, we propose how to resolve two major difficulties with determining the predictions of non-linear quantum mechanics in an actual experiment. First, we cannot use the density matrix formalism in non-linear quantum mechanics and so we have to suggest and justify a particular ensemble for the thermal bath. Separating out quantum and classical fluctuations helped us propose a reasonable ensemble. Second, most researchers believe that deterministic non-linear quantum mechanics must violate the no-signaling condition. We show this isn't necessarily the case because different interpretations of quantum mechanics make different predictions in non-linear quantum mechanics. We propose an interpretation, the causal-conditional prescription, that doesn't violate causality by noticing that once we fix an initial state, the evolution of a system under many non-linear theories is equivalent to evolution under a linear Hamiltonian with feedback. The mapping allows us to leverage the tools of quantum control, and it tells us that if the non-linear parameters of a non-linear Hamiltonian respond causally (i.e. with an appropriate delay) to measurement results, then the theory can be made causal. We also contribute to the theory of quantum optomechanics. We introduce two new bases that one can view environment modes with. In linear optomechanics a system interacts with an infinite number of bath modes. We show that the interaction can be reduced to one with finite degrees of freedom. Moreover, at any particular time, the system is correlated with only a finite number of bath modes. We show that if we make the assumption that we can measure any commuting environment modes, then this basis allows us to understand the one-shot quantum Cramer-Rao bound in a simple way, and allows us to sweep large parameter regimes and so find promising optomechanics topologies for quantum state preparation tasks that we can then analyze without the assumption of being able to measure any observable of the environment. We also use this basis to show that when we are interested in the conditional dynamics of a test mass, we can only adiabatically eliminate a lossy cavity when we measure the optomechanical system at a slow enough rate. Finally, we develop an analytic filter for obtaining the state of a generic optomechanical system that interacts linearly with its environment and is driven by Gaussian states, and where the outgoing light is measured with a non-linear photon-counting measurement. We hope that our work will help researchers explore optomechanics topologies that make use of photon counters.

•Mar 27, 2019•2 citations
Continuous measurements can prepare macroscopic mechanical oscillators in conditional quantum states, but their covariance is difficult to verify. The conventional retrodictive estimator assumes a forward--backward covariance symmetry and can be biased, because physical dynamics such as feedback damping reduces the observability of the state from future records. Here, we derive an exact linear-Gaussian estimator from causal, retrodictive, and smoothed trajectories. For a milligram-scale mirror, it agrees with a Riccati prediction based on parameters fixed independently, while the conventional estimate exhibits a covariance-space bias of dM≃3.5d_M\simeq3.5dM​≃3.5. Our method paves the way toward unbiased testing of macroscopic entanglement within a calibrated linear-Gaussian model, applicable to both tabletop mirrors and kg-scale gravitational-wave test masses.
We analytically investigate a quantum estimation method for a mechanical oscillator in a detuned cavity system based solely on homodyne measurement records, building on the framework developed by C.Meng et al. (Science Advances 8, 7585 (2022)). Estimation based only on measurement records is important because it enables state verification without assuming knowledge of the true system state. We construct a relative estimate operator from causal and anti-causal quantum Wiener filters and calculate its variance. The deviation from the causal conditional variance is defined as a reconstruction bias, whose magnitude is evaluated analytically. We show that, within experimentally relevant parameter regimes for typical quantum-state preparation, the reconstruction bias is sufficiently small to be neglected. As applications to state verification, we apply the method to proposals for macroscopic quantum entanglement mediated by electromagnetic interactions and for conditional momentum-squeezed states generated by homodyne detection, and clarify the conditions under which the bias remains negligible and when the reconstruction bias becomes significant.
Significant achievements in high-sensitivity measurements will soon allow us to probe quantum behaviors of macroscopic mechanical oscillators. In a recent work [Phys. Rev. A 80, 043802 (2009)], we formulated a general framework for treating preparation of Gaussian quantum states of macroscopic oscillators through linear position measurements. To outline a complete procedure for testing macroscopic quantum mechanics, here we consider a subsequent verification stage which probes the prepared macroscopic quantum state and verifies the quantum dynamics. By adopting an optimal time-dependent homodyne detection in which the phase of the local oscillator varies in time, the conditional quantum state can be characterized below the Heisenberg limit, thereby achieving a quantum tomography. In the limiting case of no readout loss, such a scheme evades measurement-induced back action, which is identical to the variational-type measurement scheme invented by Vyatchanin et al. [JETP 77, 218 (1993)] but in the context for detecting gravitational waves. To motivate macroscopic quantum mechanics experiments with future gravitational-wave detectors, we mostly focus on the parameter regime where the characteristic measurement frequency is much higher than the oscillator frequency and the classical noises are Markovian, which captures the main feature of a broadband gravitational-wave detector. In addition, we discuss verifications of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-type entanglement between macroscopic test masses in future gravitational-wave detectors, which enables us to test one particular version of gravity decoherence conjectured by Di\'osi [Phys. Lett. A120, 377 (1987)] and Penrose [Gen. Rel. Grav. 28, 581 (1996)].
This paper is aimed at investigating the feasibility of generating quantum conditional entanglement between macroscopic mechanical mirrors in optomechanical systems while under continuous measurement and feedback control. We consider the squeezing of the states of the mechanical common and the differential motions of the mirrors by the action of measuring the common and the differential output light beams in the Fabry-P\'erot-Michelson interferometer. We carefully derive a covariance matrix for the mechanical mirrors in a steady state, employing the Kalman filtering problem with dissipative cavities. We demonstrate that Gaussian entanglement between the mechanical mirrors is generated when the states of the mechanical common and differential modes of the mirrors are squeezed with high purity in an asymmetric manner. Our results also show that quantum entanglement between 7-mg mirrors is achievable in the short term.
Gaussian states of quantum oscillators are fully characterized by the mean values and the covariance matrix of their quadrature observables. We consider the dynamics of a system of oscillators subject to interactions, damping, and continuous probing which maintain their Gaussian state property. Such dynamics is found in many physical systems that can therefore be efficiently described by the ensuing effective representation of the density matrix $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$. Our probabilistic knowledge about the outcome of measurements on a quantum system at time ttt is not only governed by $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$ conditioned on the evolution and measurement outcomes obtained until time ttt but is also modified by any information acquired after ttt. It was shown [S. Gammelmark, B. Julsgaard, and K. M\o{}lmer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 160401 (2013)] that this information is represented by a supplementary matrix, E(t)E(t)E(t). We show here that the restriction of the dynamics of $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$ to Gaussian states implies that the matrix E(t)E(t)E(t) is also fully characterized by a vector of mean values and a covariance matrix. We derive the dynamical equations for these quantities and we illustrate their use in the retrodiction of measurements on Gaussian systems.
What knowledge can be obtained from the record of a continuous measurement about the quantum state of the measured system at the beginning of the measurement? The task of quantum state retrodiction, the inverse of the more common state prediction, is rigorously addressed in quantum measurement theory through retrodictive positive operator-valued measures (POVMs). This introduction to this general framework presents its practical formulation for retrodicting Gaussian quantum states using continuous-time homodyne measurements and applies it to optomechanical systems. We identify and characterize achievable retrodictive POVMs in common optomechanical operating modes with resonant or off-resonant driving fields and specific choices of local oscillator frequencies in homodyne detection. In particular, we demonstrate the possibility of a near-ideal measurement of the quadrature of the mechanical oscillator, giving direct access to the position or momentum distribution of the oscillator at a given time. This forms the basis for complete quantum state tomography, albeit in a destructive manner.
Optomechanics has made great strides in theory and experiments over the past decade, which culminated in the first direct detection of gravitational waves in 2015 by LIGO. This thesis explores how optomechanics can be used to test fundamental physics other than the theory of general relativity. Our emphasis will be on falsifiable theories (ultimately, only experiments can decide whether a theory is correct) that address two outstanding issues in quantum mechanics: the measurement problem, and reconciling quantum mechanics with the theory of general relativity. In particular, we show that the space experiment LISA pathfinder places aggressive bounds on two objective collapse models, which are non-linear stochastic modifications of the Schroedinger equation that can resolve the measurement problem. Moreover, we show that state-of-the-art torsion pendulum experiments can test the Schroedinger-Newton theory, which is the non-relativistic limit of a non-linear theory combining quantum mechanics with a fundamentally classical spacetime. Along the way, we propose how to resolve two major difficulties with determining the predictions of non-linear quantum mechanics in an actual experiment. First, we cannot use the density matrix formalism in non-linear quantum mechanics and so we have to suggest and justify a particular ensemble for the thermal bath. Separating out quantum and classical fluctuations helped us propose a reasonable ensemble. Second, most researchers believe that deterministic non-linear quantum mechanics must violate the no-signaling condition. We show this isn't necessarily the case because different interpretations of quantum mechanics make different predictions in non-linear quantum mechanics. We propose an interpretation, the causal-conditional prescription, that doesn't violate causality by noticing that once we fix an initial state, the evolution of a system under many non-linear theories is equivalent to evolution under a linear Hamiltonian with feedback. The mapping allows us to leverage the tools of quantum control, and it tells us that if the non-linear parameters of a non-linear Hamiltonian respond causally (i.e. with an appropriate delay) to measurement results, then the theory can be made causal. We also contribute to the theory of quantum optomechanics. We introduce two new bases that one can view environment modes with. In linear optomechanics a system interacts with an infinite number of bath modes. We show that the interaction can be reduced to one with finite degrees of freedom. Moreover, at any particular time, the system is correlated with only a finite number of bath modes. We show that if we make the assumption that we can measure any commuting environment modes, then this basis allows us to understand the one-shot quantum Cramer-Rao bound in a simple way, and allows us to sweep large parameter regimes and so find promising optomechanics topologies for quantum state preparation tasks that we can then analyze without the assumption of being able to measure any observable of the environment. We also use this basis to show that when we are interested in the conditional dynamics of a test mass, we can only adiabatically eliminate a lossy cavity when we measure the optomechanical system at a slow enough rate. Finally, we develop an analytic filter for obtaining the state of a generic optomechanical system that interacts linearly with its environment and is driven by Gaussian states, and where the outgoing light is measured with a non-linear photon-counting measurement. We hope that our work will help researchers explore optomechanics topologies that make use of photon counters.