Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2309.03507 · Frontiers in Quantum Science and Technology

Quantum retrodiction in Gaussian systems and applications in optomechanics

Jonas Lammers, Klemens Hammerer

Published Jan 25, 2024• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

What knowledge can be obtained from the record of a continuous measurement about the quantum state of the measured system at the beginning of the measurement? The task of quantum state retrodiction, the inverse of the more common state prediction, is rigorously addressed in quantum measurement theory through retrodictive positive operator-valued measures (POVMs). This introduction to this general framework presents its practical formulation for retrodicting Gaussian quantum states using continuous-time homodyne measurements and applies it to optomechanical systems. We identify and characterize achievable retrodictive POVMs in common optomechanical operating modes with resonant or off-resonant driving fields and specific choices of local oscillator frequencies in homodyne detection. In particular, we demonstrate the possibility of a near-ideal measurement of the quadrature of the mechanical oscillator, giving direct access to the position or momentum distribution of the oscillator at a given time. This forms the basis for complete quantum state tomography, albeit in a destructive manner.

DOI
10.3389/frqst.2023.1294905

Related papers

Prediction and retrodiction with continuously monitored Gaussian states

Jinglei Zhang, Klaus Mølmer

Gaussian states of quantum oscillators are fully characterized by the mean values and the covariance matrix of their quadrature observables. We consider the dynamics of a system of oscillators subject to interactions, damping, and continuous probing which maintain their Gaussian state property. Such dynamics is found in many physical systems that can therefore be efficiently described by the ensuing effective representation of the density matrix $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$. Our probabilistic knowledge about the outcome of measurements on a quantum system at time $t$ is not only governed by $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$ conditioned on the evolution and measurement outcomes obtained until time $t$ but is also modified by any information acquired after $t$. It was shown [S. Gammelmark, B. Julsgaard, and K. M\o{}lmer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 160401 (2013)] that this information is represented by a supplementary matrix, $E(t)$. We show here that the restriction of the dynamics of $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$ to Gaussian states implies that the matrix $E(t)$ is also fully characterized by a vector of mean values and a covariance matrix. We derive the dynamical equations for these quantities and we illustrate their use in the retrodiction of measurements on Gaussian systems.

arXiv:1710.04950•Physical Review A•Dec 26, 2017•47 citations

Quantum-state steering in optomechanical devices

Mueller-Ebhardt, Helge, Haixing Miao, S. L. Danilishin +1 more

We show that optomechanical systems in the quantum regime can be used to demonstrate EPR-type quantum entanglement between the optical field and the mechanical oscillator, via quantum-state steering. Namely, the conditional quantum state of the mechanical oscillator can be steered into different quantum states depending the choice made on which quadrature of the out-going field is to be measured via homodyne detection. More specifically, if quantum radiation pressure force dominates over thermal force, the oscillator's quantum state is steerable with a photodetection efficiency as low as 50%, approaching the ideal limit shown by Wiseman and Gambetta [Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 108}, 220402 (2012)]. We also show that requirement for steerability is the same as those for achieving sub-Heisenberg state tomography using the same experimental setup.

arXiv:1211.4315•Nov 19, 2012•5 citations

Operational formulation of homodyne detection

Tomá Tyc, Barry C. Sanders

We obtain the standard quadrature-phase positive operator-valued measure (POVM) for homodyne detection directly and rigorously from the POVM for photon counting without directly employing the mean field approximation for the local oscillator. In addition, we obtain correction terms for the quadrature-phase POVM that are applicable for relatively weak local oscillator field strengths and typical signal states.

arXiv:quant-ph/0404090•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jul 8, 2004•53 citations

Simultaneous retrodiction of multimode optomechanical systems using matched filters

Jonathan Kohler, Justin A. Gerber, Emma Deist +1 more

Generation and manipulation of many-body entangled states is of considerable interest, for applications in quantum simulation or sensing, for example. Measurement and verification of the resulting many-body state presents a formidable challenge, however, which can be simplified by multiplexed readout using shared measurement resources. In this work, we analyze and demonstrate state retrodiction for a system of optomechanical oscillators coupled to a single-mode optical cavity. Coupling to the shared cavity field facilitates simultaneous optical measurement of the oscillators' transient dynamics at distinct frequencies. Optimal estimators for the oscillators' initial state can be defined as a set of linear matched filters, derived from a detailed model for the detected homodyne signal. We find that the optimal state estimate for optomechanical retrodiction is obtained from high-cooperativity measurements, reaching estimate sensitivity at the standard quantum limit (SQL). Simultaneous estimation of the state of multiple oscillators places additional limits on the estimate precision, due to the diffusive noise each oscillator adds to the optomechanical signal. However, we show that the sensitivity of simultaneous multimode state retrodiction reaches the SQL for sufficiently well-resolved oscillators. Finally, an experimental demonstration of two-mode retrodiction is presented, which requires further accounting for technical fluctuations of the oscillator frequency.

arXiv:1906.03540•Physical Review A•Feb 5, 2020•6 citations

Nonlinear cavity quantum optomechanics: from quantum measurement to quantum state engineering

Jack Clarke

In a nutshell, a cavity optomechanical system consists of a mechanical oscillator inside an optical cavity. Cavity optomechanics studies the interplay between the light-matter radiation-pressure interaction and the change in the cavity frequency induced by mechanical motion. By leveraging the tools of quantum optics and quantum measurement, cavity quantum optomechanics enables the engineering of nonclassical quantum states of bulk matter. In this thesis, I present protocols for engineering such nonclassical quantum states in Part II. First, I introduce a scheme to ‘grow’ a quantum kitten state of a mechanical oscillator into a macroscopic Schrödinger cat state using a series of nonlinear pulsed optomechanical interactions. Next, I detail our proposed schemes to generate and verify entanglement between two mechanical oscillators. Moving on from pulsed optomechanics, I describe the theory behind an experiment that achieved multi-phonon subtraction from a mechanical oscillator in a continuously driven Brillouin optomechanical system. In the final chapter of Part II, I provide a theoretical preview of an experiment that investigates the behaviour of the mechanical oscillator when no light is detected at the output. In Part III, I introduce a new framework for nonlinear cavity quantum optomechanics that incorporates the intrinsic nonlinearity of the radiation-pressure interaction, the nonlinearity from the cavity enhancement, and higher-order mechanical position terms in the expansion of the cavity frequency. I then propose a scheme for measuring mechanical position using general-dyne detection, applicable to pulsed and continuous measurements. This predicts a new regime of operation, the “stochastic Gaussian” regime. Finally, I discuss a protocol for deterministic mechanical squeezing that utilizes the cavity response.

•Jun 16, 2022•0 citations

Unbiased Estimation of Conditional Covariance for Quantum Optomechanics

Katsuta Sakai, Nobuyuki Matsumoto

Continuous measurements can prepare macroscopic mechanical oscillators in conditional quantum states, but their covariance is difficult to verify. The conventional retrodictive estimator assumes a forward--backward covariance symmetry and can be biased, because physical dynamics such as feedback damping reduces the observability of the state from future records. Here, we derive an exact linear-Gaussian estimator from causal, retrodictive, and smoothed trajectories. For a milligram-scale mirror, it agrees with a Riccati prediction based on parameters fixed independently, while the conventional estimate exhibits a covariance-space bias of $d_M\simeq3.5$. Our method paves the way toward unbiased testing of macroscopic entanglement within a calibrated linear-Gaussian model, applicable to both tabletop mirrors and kg-scale gravitational-wave test masses.

quant-pharXiv:2607.06431•Jul 8, 2026•2 citations
What knowledge can be obtained from the record of a continuous measurement about the quantum state of the measured system at the beginning of the measurement? The task of quantum state retrodiction, the inverse of the more common state prediction, is rigorously addressed in quantum measurement theory through retrodictive positive operator-valued measures (POVMs). This introduction to this general framework presents its practical formulation for retrodicting Gaussian quantum states using continuous-time homodyne measurements and applies it to optomechanical systems. We identify and characterize achievable retrodictive POVMs in common optomechanical operating modes with resonant or off-resonant driving fields and specific choices of local oscillator frequencies in homodyne detection. In particular, we demonstrate the possibility of a near-ideal measurement of the quadrature of the mechanical oscillator, giving direct access to the position or momentum distribution of the oscillator at a given time. This forms the basis for complete quantum state tomography, albeit in a destructive manner.
Gaussian states of quantum oscillators are fully characterized by the mean values and the covariance matrix of their quadrature observables. We consider the dynamics of a system of oscillators subject to interactions, damping, and continuous probing which maintain their Gaussian state property. Such dynamics is found in many physical systems that can therefore be efficiently described by the ensuing effective representation of the density matrix $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$. Our probabilistic knowledge about the outcome of measurements on a quantum system at time ttt is not only governed by $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$ conditioned on the evolution and measurement outcomes obtained until time ttt but is also modified by any information acquired after ttt. It was shown [S. Gammelmark, B. Julsgaard, and K. M\o{}lmer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 160401 (2013)] that this information is represented by a supplementary matrix, E(t)E(t)E(t). We show here that the restriction of the dynamics of $\ensuremath{\rho}(t)$ to Gaussian states implies that the matrix E(t)E(t)E(t) is also fully characterized by a vector of mean values and a covariance matrix. We derive the dynamical equations for these quantities and we illustrate their use in the retrodiction of measurements on Gaussian systems.
We show that optomechanical systems in the quantum regime can be used to demonstrate EPR-type quantum entanglement between the optical field and the mechanical oscillator, via quantum-state steering. Namely, the conditional quantum state of the mechanical oscillator can be steered into different quantum states depending the choice made on which quadrature of the out-going field is to be measured via homodyne detection. More specifically, if quantum radiation pressure force dominates over thermal force, the oscillator's quantum state is steerable with a photodetection efficiency as low as 50%, approaching the ideal limit shown by Wiseman and Gambetta [Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 108}, 220402 (2012)]. We also show that requirement for steerability is the same as those for achieving sub-Heisenberg state tomography using the same experimental setup.
Generation and manipulation of many-body entangled states is of considerable interest, for applications in quantum simulation or sensing, for example. Measurement and verification of the resulting many-body state presents a formidable challenge, however, which can be simplified by multiplexed readout using shared measurement resources. In this work, we analyze and demonstrate state retrodiction for a system of optomechanical oscillators coupled to a single-mode optical cavity. Coupling to the shared cavity field facilitates simultaneous optical measurement of the oscillators' transient dynamics at distinct frequencies. Optimal estimators for the oscillators' initial state can be defined as a set of linear matched filters, derived from a detailed model for the detected homodyne signal. We find that the optimal state estimate for optomechanical retrodiction is obtained from high-cooperativity measurements, reaching estimate sensitivity at the standard quantum limit (SQL). Simultaneous estimation of the state of multiple oscillators places additional limits on the estimate precision, due to the diffusive noise each oscillator adds to the optomechanical signal. However, we show that the sensitivity of simultaneous multimode state retrodiction reaches the SQL for sufficiently well-resolved oscillators. Finally, an experimental demonstration of two-mode retrodiction is presented, which requires further accounting for technical fluctuations of the oscillator frequency.
In a nutshell, a cavity optomechanical system consists of a mechanical oscillator inside an optical cavity. Cavity optomechanics studies the interplay between the light-matter radiation-pressure interaction and the change in the cavity frequency induced by mechanical motion. By leveraging the tools of quantum optics and quantum measurement, cavity quantum optomechanics enables the engineering of nonclassical quantum states of bulk matter. In this thesis, I present protocols for engineering such nonclassical quantum states in Part II. First, I introduce a scheme to ‘grow’ a quantum kitten state of a mechanical oscillator into a macroscopic Schrödinger cat state using a series of nonlinear pulsed optomechanical interactions. Next, I detail our proposed schemes to generate and verify entanglement between two mechanical oscillators. Moving on from pulsed optomechanics, I describe the theory behind an experiment that achieved multi-phonon subtraction from a mechanical oscillator in a continuously driven Brillouin optomechanical system. In the final chapter of Part II, I provide a theoretical preview of an experiment that investigates the behaviour of the mechanical oscillator when no light is detected at the output. In Part III, I introduce a new framework for nonlinear cavity quantum optomechanics that incorporates the intrinsic nonlinearity of the radiation-pressure interaction, the nonlinearity from the cavity enhancement, and higher-order mechanical position terms in the expansion of the cavity frequency. I then propose a scheme for measuring mechanical position using general-dyne detection, applicable to pulsed and continuous measurements. This predicts a new regime of operation, the “stochastic Gaussian” regime. Finally, I discuss a protocol for deterministic mechanical squeezing that utilizes the cavity response.
Continuous measurements can prepare macroscopic mechanical oscillators in conditional quantum states, but their covariance is difficult to verify. The conventional retrodictive estimator assumes a forward--backward covariance symmetry and can be biased, because physical dynamics such as feedback damping reduces the observability of the state from future records. Here, we derive an exact linear-Gaussian estimator from causal, retrodictive, and smoothed trajectories. For a milligram-scale mirror, it agrees with a Riccati prediction based on parameters fixed independently, while the conventional estimate exhibits a covariance-space bias of dM≃3.5d_M\simeq3.5dM​≃3.5. Our method paves the way toward unbiased testing of macroscopic entanglement within a calibrated linear-Gaussian model, applicable to both tabletop mirrors and kg-scale gravitational-wave test masses.