Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2604.23346

Bayesian phase transition for the critical Ising model: Enlarged replica symmetry in the epsilon expansion and in 2D

Kay Joerg Wiese, Alapan Das, Adam Nahum

cond-mat.stat-mechcond-mat.dis-nncond-mat.str-elphysics.data-anquant-phSubmitted Apr 25, 2026• Announced Apr 28, 2026• 8 citations• Revised Oct 30, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Apr 25, 2026v2 · Oct 30, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A process that images or measures bond energies in the critical Ising model can be in distinct measurement 'phases', depending on the precision of measurement. We study the transition into the strong-measurement phase using replica field theory (an epsilon expansion around six dimensions), a symmetry analysis, and numerical simulations in two dimensions. The results show that certain inference problems possess unexpected structure associated with an enlarged symmetry of the replica description. The symmetry imposes constraints on correlation functions, and is an analog of the Nishimori phenomenon in the Ising spin glass, but in a distinct replica limit. It determines the exact critical exponent for an Edwards-Anderson-like correlator in the measured Ising model, both in 2D and near the upper critical dimension. The symmetry is present microscopically for certain measurement protocols, and it emerges in the infrared for generic protocols at the critical measurement strength. We also examine the epsilon expansion for models with power-law interactions and/or long-range measurement. Finally, we describe an analogous replica symmetry enlargement for measurement in Wegner's lattice gauge theory.

Comments
38 pages, 14 figures

Related papers

Higher Nishimori Criticality and Exact Results at the Learning Transition of Deformed Toric Codes

Rushikesh A. Patil, Malte Pütz, Simon Trebst +2 more

We revisit a learning-induced tricritical point, at which three phases with strong, weak, and broken $Z_2$ symmetry meet, in the phase diagram of a deformed toric code wavefunction subjected to weak measurements. This setting is exactly dual to a classical Bayesian inference phase diagram of the $2D$ classical Ising model. Here we demonstrate that this tricritical point lies on a distinct $\textit{higher Nishimori line}$, which has an emergent gauge-invariant formulation, just like the ordinary Nishimori line but with a higher replica symmetry as a replica stat-mech model in the replica number $R\rightarrow2$ limit, where disorder is averaged according to the Born rule. As such, the learning tricritical point is in fact a $\textit{higher Nishimori critical point}$. Using this identification, we obtain a number of $\textit{exact results}$ at this $\textit{higher}$ Nishimori critical point; e.g., we show that the power-law exponent of the Edwards-Anderson correlation function is exactly equal to that of the spin correlation function at the unmeasured Ising critical point and verify this in numerical simulations. Using the tools of the proof of a $c$-effective theorem [arXiv:2507.07959], we show that the Casimir effective central charge $c_{\text{eff}}$ $\textit{decreases}$ under renormalization group (RG) flow from the $\textit{higher}$ Nishimori critical point to the unmeasured $2D$ Ising critical point, and is thus greater than $1/2$. This is corroborated by extensive numerical simulations finding $c_{\text{eff}} = 0.522(1)$. The analytical result also explains, with a physically motivated assumption, the numerically observed increase of the Casimir effective central charge under the RG flow from the ordinary Nishimori critical point to the clean Ising critical point in the random-bond Ising model. We also discuss $\textit{higher}$ Nishimori criticality in general dimensions $D>1$.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2604.06324•Apr 9, 2026•10 citations

Emergent Topological Universality and Marginal Replica Symmetry Breaking in Gauge-Correlated Spin Glasses

Alok Yadav

Recent tensor-network samplings of modified Nishimori spin glasses have revealed robust finite-temperature critical transitions in two dimensions, defying the standard Edwards-Anderson lower critical dimension boundary ($d_{l}\approx2.5$). We present a theoretical framework demonstrating that the discrete $Z_{2}$ gauge constraints utilized to bypass Monte Carlo kinetic traps fundamentally alter the system's universality class. By mapping the algorithmic disorder distribution to the 2D Ising Conformal Field Theory (CFT), we prove the emergent spatial variance generates a fractional momentum operator that drives the dynamic upper critical dimension to zero ($d_{u}\rightarrow0$). This marginal topology dynamically suppresses the replica-coupling vertices, yielding an infinite-order Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) transition and a non-integrable replicon divergence that predicts a massive instability toward 1-step Replica Symmetry Breaking (1-RSB). Leveraging a spectral Corner Transfer Matrix Renormalization Group (CTMRG) architecture up to macroscopic scales ($L=1024$), we quantitatively validate the topological scaling argument $\mathcal{G}((T-T_{c})\ln(L/L_{0}))$. By isolating the continuum field theory from microscopic lattice artifacts, we recover the fundamental lattice metric $L_{0}\approx 0.94$, unequivocally confirming the existence of a distinct, topologically driven spin-glass phase.

arXiv:2604.10309•Apr 11, 2026•0 citations

Replica cluster variational method: the replica symmetric solution for the 2D random bond Ising model

Alejandro Lage-Castellanos, Roberto Mulet, Federico Ricci‐Tersenghi +1 more

We present and solve the replica symmetric equations in the context of the replica cluster variational method for the 2D random bond Ising model (including the 2D Edwards–Anderson spin-glass model). First, we solve a linearized version of these equations to obtain the phase diagrams of the model on the square and triangular lattices. In both cases, the spin-glass transition temperatures and the multicritical point estimations improve largely over the Bethe predictions. Moreover, we show that this phase diagram is consistent with the behavior of inference algorithms on single instances of the problem. Finally, we present a method to consistently find approximate solutions to the equations in the glassy phase. The method is applied to the triangular lattice down to T = 0, also in the presence of an external field.

arXiv:1204.0439•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Mar 13, 2013•19 citations

Evidence of a second-order phase transition in the six-dimensional Ising spin glass in a field

Miguel Aguilar-Janita, Víctor Martín-Mayor, J. Moreno-Gordo +1 more

The very existence of a phase transition for spin glasses in an external magnetic field is controversial, even in high dimensions. We carry out massive simulations of the Ising spin-glass in a field, in six dimensions (which, according to classical-but not generally accepted-field-theoretical studies, is the upper critical dimension). We obtain results compatible with a second-order phase transition and estimate its critical exponents for the simulated lattice sizes. The detailed analysis performed by other authors of the replica symmetric Hamiltonian, under the hypothesis of critical behavior, predicts that the ratio of the renormalized coupling constants remain bounded as the correlation length grows. Our numerical results are in agreement with this expectation.

arXiv:2306.00569•Physical review. E•May 10, 2024•9 citations

Bayesian critical points in classical lattice models

Adam Nahum, Jesper Lykke Jacobsen

The Boltzmann distribution encodes our subjective knowledge of the configuration in a classical lattice model, given only its Hamiltonian. If we acquire further information about the configuration from measurement, our knowledge is updated according to Bayes' theorem. We examine the resulting “conditioned ensembles,” finding that they show many new phase transitions and new renormalization-group fixed points. (Similar conditioned ensembles also describe “partial quenches” in which some of the system's degrees of freedom are instantaneously frozen, while the others continue to evolve.) After describing general features of the replica field theories for these problems, we analyze the effect of measurement on illustrative critical systems, including: critical Ising and Potts models, which show surprisingly rich phase diagrams, with RG fixed points at weak, intermediate, and infinite measurement strength; various models involving free fields, XY spins, or flux lines in 2D or 3D; and geometrical models such as polymers or clusters. We also give a formalism for measurement of classical stochastic processes. We use this to make connections with quantum dynamics, in particular with “charge sharpening” in 1D, for which we give a purely hydrodynamic derivation of the known effective field theory. We discuss qualitative differences between RG flows for the above measured systems, described by N → 1 replica limits, and those for disordered systems, described by N → 0 limits. In addition to discussing measurement of critical states, we give a unifying treatment of a family of inference problems for noncritical states. These are related to the Nishimori line in the phase diagram of the random-bond Ising model, and are relevant to various quantum error correction problems. We describe distinct physical interpretations of conditioned ensembles and note interesting open questions.

arXiv:2504.01264•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 3, 2025•23 citations

Phase Transitions in Mismatched Bayesian Inference for the Ising Model

Xinyu Sun, Zhou‐Quan Wan, Shao-Kai Jian +1 more

Bayesian inference with a mismatched model can develop an overconfident phase, characterized by posterior agreement without faithful reconstruction of the true state. We study Bayesian inference from noisy bond measurements of an Ising model in its paramagnetic phase, with true inverse temperature $β$ and measurement-noise strength $Δ$, while inference assumes corresponding parameters $β_Q$ and $Δ_Q$. Using replica field theory, we analytically show that the overconfidence phase can occur when inference underestimates the measurement noise ($Δ_Q < Δ$) or assumes a lower prior temperature than the true one ($β_Q > β$). An exact change of variables maps the problem to a correlated random-bond Ising model, where the informative, uninformative, and overconfident phases correspond to ferromagnetic, paramagnetic, and spin-glass phases, respectively. We further perform Monte Carlo simulations of the mapped model in three dimensions and establish a finite overconfident region between the informative and uninformative phases, consistent with our analytical prediction. Finally, we show that the true model parameters can be inferred directly from the measurement records, providing a natural route to calibrating the inference model.

arXiv:2610.36041•Oct 26, 2026•0 citations
A process that images or measures bond energies in the critical Ising model can be in distinct measurement 'phases', depending on the precision of measurement. We study the transition into the strong-measurement phase using replica field theory (an epsilon expansion around six dimensions), a symmetry analysis, and numerical simulations in two dimensions. The results show that certain inference problems possess unexpected structure associated with an enlarged symmetry of the replica description. The symmetry imposes constraints on correlation functions, and is an analog of the Nishimori phenomenon in the Ising spin glass, but in a distinct replica limit. It determines the exact critical exponent for an Edwards-Anderson-like correlator in the measured Ising model, both in 2D and near the upper critical dimension. The symmetry is present microscopically for certain measurement protocols, and it emerges in the infrared for generic protocols at the critical measurement strength. We also examine the epsilon expansion for models with power-law interactions and/or long-range measurement. Finally, we describe an analogous replica symmetry enlargement for measurement in Wegner's lattice gauge theory.
We revisit a learning-induced tricritical point, at which three phases with strong, weak, and broken Z2Z_2Z2​ symmetry meet, in the phase diagram of a deformed toric code wavefunction subjected to weak measurements. This setting is exactly dual to a classical Bayesian inference phase diagram of the 2D2D2D classical Ising model. Here we demonstrate that this tricritical point lies on a distinct higher Nishimori line\textit{higher Nishimori line}higher Nishimori line, which has an emergent gauge-invariant formulation, just like the ordinary Nishimori line but with a higher replica symmetry as a replica stat-mech model in the replica number R→2R\rightarrow2R→2 limit, where disorder is averaged according to the Born rule. As such, the learning tricritical point is in fact a higher Nishimori critical point\textit{higher Nishimori critical point}higher Nishimori critical point. Using this identification, we obtain a number of exact results\textit{exact results}exact results at this higher\textit{higher}higher Nishimori critical point; e.g., we show that the power-law exponent of the Edwards-Anderson correlation function is exactly equal to that of the spin correlation function at the unmeasured Ising critical point and verify this in numerical simulations. Using the tools of the proof of a ccc-effective theorem [arXiv:2507.07959], we show that the Casimir effective central charge ceffc_{\text{eff}}ceff​ decreases\textit{decreases}decreases under renormalization group (RG) flow from the higher\textit{higher}higher Nishimori critical point to the unmeasured 2D2D2D Ising critical point, and is thus greater than 1/21/21/2. This is corroborated by extensive numerical simulations finding ceff=0.522(1)c_{\text{eff}} = 0.522(1)ceff​=0.522(1). The analytical result also explains, with a physically motivated assumption, the numerically observed increase of the Casimir effective central charge under the RG flow from the ordinary Nishimori critical point to the clean Ising critical point in the random-bond Ising model. We also discuss higher\textit{higher}higher Nishimori criticality in general dimensions D>1D>1D>1.
Recent tensor-network samplings of modified Nishimori spin glasses have revealed robust finite-temperature critical transitions in two dimensions, defying the standard Edwards-Anderson lower critical dimension boundary (dl≈2.5d_{l}\approx2.5dl​≈2.5). We present a theoretical framework demonstrating that the discrete Z2Z_{2}Z2​ gauge constraints utilized to bypass Monte Carlo kinetic traps fundamentally alter the system's universality class. By mapping the algorithmic disorder distribution to the 2D Ising Conformal Field Theory (CFT), we prove the emergent spatial variance generates a fractional momentum operator that drives the dynamic upper critical dimension to zero (du→0d_{u}\rightarrow0du​→0). This marginal topology dynamically suppresses the replica-coupling vertices, yielding an infinite-order Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) transition and a non-integrable replicon divergence that predicts a massive instability toward 1-step Replica Symmetry Breaking (1-RSB). Leveraging a spectral Corner Transfer Matrix Renormalization Group (CTMRG) architecture up to macroscopic scales (L=1024L=1024L=1024), we quantitatively validate the topological scaling argument G((T−Tc)ln⁡(L/L0))\mathcal{G}((T-T_{c})\ln(L/L_{0}))G((T−Tc​)ln(L/L0​)). By isolating the continuum field theory from microscopic lattice artifacts, we recover the fundamental lattice metric L0≈0.94L_{0}\approx 0.94L0​≈0.94, unequivocally confirming the existence of a distinct, topologically driven spin-glass phase.
We present and solve the replica symmetric equations in the context of the replica cluster variational method for the 2D random bond Ising model (including the 2D Edwards–Anderson spin-glass model). First, we solve a linearized version of these equations to obtain the phase diagrams of the model on the square and triangular lattices. In both cases, the spin-glass transition temperatures and the multicritical point estimations improve largely over the Bethe predictions. Moreover, we show that this phase diagram is consistent with the behavior of inference algorithms on single instances of the problem. Finally, we present a method to consistently find approximate solutions to the equations in the glassy phase. The method is applied to the triangular lattice down to T = 0, also in the presence of an external field.
The very existence of a phase transition for spin glasses in an external magnetic field is controversial, even in high dimensions. We carry out massive simulations of the Ising spin-glass in a field, in six dimensions (which, according to classical-but not generally accepted-field-theoretical studies, is the upper critical dimension). We obtain results compatible with a second-order phase transition and estimate its critical exponents for the simulated lattice sizes. The detailed analysis performed by other authors of the replica symmetric Hamiltonian, under the hypothesis of critical behavior, predicts that the ratio of the renormalized coupling constants remain bounded as the correlation length grows. Our numerical results are in agreement with this expectation.
The Boltzmann distribution encodes our subjective knowledge of the configuration in a classical lattice model, given only its Hamiltonian. If we acquire further information about the configuration from measurement, our knowledge is updated according to Bayes' theorem. We examine the resulting “conditioned ensembles,” finding that they show many new phase transitions and new renormalization-group fixed points. (Similar conditioned ensembles also describe “partial quenches” in which some of the system's degrees of freedom are instantaneously frozen, while the others continue to evolve.) After describing general features of the replica field theories for these problems, we analyze the effect of measurement on illustrative critical systems, including: critical Ising and Potts models, which show surprisingly rich phase diagrams, with RG fixed points at weak, intermediate, and infinite measurement strength; various models involving free fields, XY spins, or flux lines in 2D or 3D; and geometrical models such as polymers or clusters. We also give a formalism for measurement of classical stochastic processes. We use this to make connections with quantum dynamics, in particular with “charge sharpening” in 1D, for which we give a purely hydrodynamic derivation of the known effective field theory. We discuss qualitative differences between RG flows for the above measured systems, described by N → 1 replica limits, and those for disordered systems, described by N → 0 limits. In addition to discussing measurement of critical states, we give a unifying treatment of a family of inference problems for noncritical states. These are related to the Nishimori line in the phase diagram of the random-bond Ising model, and are relevant to various quantum error correction problems. We describe distinct physical interpretations of conditioned ensembles and note interesting open questions.
Bayesian inference with a mismatched model can develop an overconfident phase, characterized by posterior agreement without faithful reconstruction of the true state. We study Bayesian inference from noisy bond measurements of an Ising model in its paramagnetic phase, with true inverse temperature βββ and measurement-noise strength ΔΔΔ, while inference assumes corresponding parameters βQβ_QβQ​ and ΔQΔ_QΔQ​. Using replica field theory, we analytically show that the overconfidence phase can occur when inference underestimates the measurement noise (ΔQ<ΔΔ_Q < ΔΔQ​<Δ) or assumes a lower prior temperature than the true one (βQ>ββ_Q > ββQ​>β). An exact change of variables maps the problem to a correlated random-bond Ising model, where the informative, uninformative, and overconfident phases correspond to ferromagnetic, paramagnetic, and spin-glass phases, respectively. We further perform Monte Carlo simulations of the mapped model in three dimensions and establish a finite overconfident region between the informative and uninformative phases, consistent with our analytical prediction. Finally, we show that the true model parameters can be inferred directly from the measurement records, providing a natural route to calibrating the inference model.