The Boltzmann distribution encodes our subjective knowledge of the configuration in a classical lattice model, given only its Hamiltonian. If we acquire further information about the configuration from measurement, our knowledge is updated according to Bayes' theorem. We examine the resulting “conditioned ensembles,” finding that they show many new phase transitions and new renormalization-group fixed points. (Similar conditioned ensembles also describe “partial quenches” in which some of the system's degrees of freedom are instantaneously frozen, while the others continue to evolve.) After describing general features of the replica field theories for these problems, we analyze the effect of measurement on illustrative critical systems, including: critical Ising and Potts models, which show surprisingly rich phase diagrams, with RG fixed points at weak, intermediate, and infinite measurement strength; various models involving free fields, XY spins, or flux lines in 2D or 3D; and geometrical models such as polymers or clusters. We also give a formalism for measurement of classical stochastic processes. We use this to make connections with quantum dynamics, in particular with “charge sharpening” in 1D, for which we give a purely hydrodynamic derivation of the known effective field theory. We discuss qualitative differences between RG flows for the above measured systems, described by N → 1 replica limits, and those for disordered systems, described by N → 0 limits. In addition to discussing measurement of critical states, we give a unifying treatment of a family of inference problems for noncritical states. These are related to the Nishimori line in the phase diagram of the random-bond Ising model, and are relevant to various quantum error correction problems. We describe distinct physical interpretations of conditioned ensembles and note interesting open questions.
PART I: DISORDER The effect of quenched impurities on systems which undergo first-order phase transitions is studied within the framework of the q-state Potts model. For large q a mapping to the random field Ising model is introduced which provides a simple physical explanation of the absence of any latent heat in two dimensions, and suggests that in higher dimensions such systems should exhibit a tricritical point with a correlation length exponent related to the exponents of the random field model by \nu = \nu_RF/(2-\alpha_RF-\beta_RF). A phase diagram unifying pure, percolative and non-trivial random behaviour is proposed. In two dimensions we analyze the model using finite-size scaling and conformal invariance, and find a continuous transition with a magnetic exponent \beta/\nu which varies continuously with q, and a weakly varying correlation length exponent \nu ~ 1. For q>4 the first-order transitions of the pure model are softened due to the impurities, and the resulting universality class is different from that of the pure Ising model. We find strong evidence for multiscaling of the correlation functions, as expected for such random systems. PART II: FRUSTRATION Exact results for conformational statistics of compact polymers are derived from the two-flavour fully packed loop model on the square lattice. This loop model exhibits a two-dimensional manifold of critical fixed points each one characterised by an infinite set of geometrical scaling dimensions. We calculate these dimensions exactly by mapping the loop model to an interface model whose scaling limit is described by a Liouville field theory. The formulae for the central charge and the first few scaling dimensions are compared to numerical transfer matrix results and excellent agreement is found. Compact polymers are identified with a particular point in the phase diagram of the loop model, and the non-mean field value of the conformational exponent \gamma = 117/112 is calculated for the first time. We also present the very precise numerical estimate \kappa = 1.472801(10) for the connective constant. Interacting compact polymers are described by a line of fixed points along which \gamma and \kappa vary continuously. Our identification of compact polymers with a critical model has bearings on the cooperativity of protein folding thermodynamics. Namely, in the large chain limit, the absence of an energy gap separating the denatured states from the native (compact) ones implies that homopolymer collapse is a one-state process. We comment on the prospects of modeling specific sequence (amino acid) information through the imposition of quenched disorder.
Motivated by a previous Ising study, we identify a
higher Nishimori line in the learning phase diagram of the
2D q-state Potts model
(2<q≤4) under bond-energy measurements. This
higher Nishimori line meets the critical temperature line of the Potts model, in a
higher Nishimori critical point -- a tricritical point at finite inference strength that separates a paramagnetic, a ferromagnetic and a 'spin-glass' phase. With analytical tools, we discuss the general structure of the rich phase diagram, which contains two unstable and three stable fixed points, and obtain a number of exact results for universal quantities, including the decay exponent of the Edwards-Anderson correlator, using a Gaussian measurement protocol which allows for exact calculations. Using extensive numerical tools, we confirm these statements for a generic, discrete
q-state measurement protocol and determine precise numerical estimates for the location of higher and ordinary Nishimori critical points as well as RG flows between the various fixed points. We also discuss the Casimir effective central charges of the critical points in the learning phase diagram, and their monotonic
decrease along measurement-induced RG flows, as established non-perturbatively by the c-effective theorem and its extensions, and contrast it to the monotonic increase along the corresponding RG flows in the random-bond Potts model. Finally, we discuss a general argument based on
Elitzur′stheorem that establishes stability of the ordinary Nishimori critical points in their respective learning phase diagrams. Equivalently, our results describe a monitored deformed
Zq toric code where the tricritical
higher Nishimori point is an 'information' critical point that separates stable quantum, classical, and no memory phases.
Conditional probability distributions describe the effect of learning an initially unknown classical state through Bayesian inference. Here we demonstrate the existence of a learning transition, having signatures in the long distance behavior of conditional correlation functions, in the two-dimensional classical Ising model. This transition, which arises when learning local energy densities, extends all the way from the infinite-temperature paramagnetic state down to the thermal critical state. The intersection of the line of learning transitions and the thermal Ising transition is a new tricritical point. Our model for learning also exactly describes the effects of weak measurements on ground states of frustration-free quantum Hamiltonians, which interpolate between the toric code and a paramagnet. Notably, the location of the above tricritical point implies that the quantum memory defined by the degenerate ground states in the topological phase is robust to weak measurement, even when the initial state is arbitrarily close to the quantum phase transition separating topological and trivial phases. Our analysis uses a replica field theory combined with the renormalization group, and we chart out the phase diagram using a combination of tensor network and Monte Carlo techniques. Our methods can be extended to study the more general effects of learning on both classical and quantum states. The learning induced critical states can be realized in classical or quantum devices.
A process that images or measures bond energies in the critical Ising model can be in distinct measurement 'phases', depending on the precision of measurement. We study the transition into the strong-measurement phase using replica field theory (an epsilon expansion around six dimensions), a symmetry analysis, and numerical simulations in two dimensions. The results show that certain inference problems possess unexpected structure associated with an enlarged symmetry of the replica description. The symmetry imposes constraints on correlation functions, and is an analog of the Nishimori phenomenon in the Ising spin glass, but in a distinct replica limit. It determines the exact critical exponent for an Edwards-Anderson-like correlator in the measured Ising model, both in 2D and near the upper critical dimension. The symmetry is present microscopically for certain measurement protocols, and it emerges in the infrared for generic protocols at the critical measurement strength. We also examine the epsilon expansion for models with power-law interactions and/or long-range measurement. Finally, we describe an analogous replica symmetry enlargement for measurement in Wegner's lattice gauge theory.
The critical behavior of spin systems with quenched disorder is studied by renormalization-group methods. For the randomly dilute
m-vector model, the
n=0 limit is used to construct a translationally invariant effective Hamiltonian which describes the original disordered system. This Hamiltonian is analyzed in the $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ expansion to order ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}$. Sharp second-order phase transitions with exponents which do not depend continuously on impurity concentration are predicted. For $m>{m}_{c}\ensuremath{\equiv}4\ensuremath{-}4\ensuremath{\epsilon}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2})$ the isotropic
m-component fixed point, which characterizes the critical behavior of the pure system, is stable. For
m<mc, a new random fixed point becomes stable. The exponents corresponding to this fixed point are $\ensuremath{\eta}=[\frac{(5{m}^{2}\ensuremath{-}8m)}{256{(m\ensuremath{-}1)}^{2}}]{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{3})$, $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{2}+[\frac{3m}{32(m\ensuremath{-}1)}]\ensuremath{\epsilon}+[\frac{m(127{m}^{2}\ensuremath{-}572m\ensuremath{-}32)}{4096{(m\ensuremath{-}1)}^{3}}]{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{3})$ for $m\ensuremath{\ne}1$, and $\ensuremath{\eta}=\ensuremath{-}\frac{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}{106}+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{\frac{3}{2}})$, $\ensuremath{\nu}=\frac{1}{2}+\frac{{(\frac{6\ensuremath{\epsilon}}{53})}^{\frac{1}{2}}}{4}+O(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ for
m=1. More general random systems are qualitatively discussed from the effective-Hamiltonian viewpoint.
We revisit a learning-induced tricritical point, at which three phases with strong, weak, and broken
Z2 symmetry meet, in the phase diagram of a deformed toric code wavefunction subjected to weak measurements. This setting is exactly dual to a classical Bayesian inference phase diagram of the
2D classical Ising model. Here we demonstrate that this tricritical point lies on a distinct
higher Nishimori line, which has an emergent gauge-invariant formulation, just like the ordinary Nishimori line but with a higher replica symmetry as a replica stat-mech model in the replica number
R→2 limit, where disorder is averaged according to the Born rule. As such, the learning tricritical point is in fact a
higher Nishimori critical point. Using this identification, we obtain a number of
exact results at this
higher Nishimori critical point; e.g., we show that the power-law exponent of the Edwards-Anderson correlation function is exactly equal to that of the spin correlation function at the unmeasured Ising critical point and verify this in numerical simulations. Using the tools of the proof of a
c-effective theorem [arXiv:2507.07959], we show that the Casimir effective central charge
ceff decreases under renormalization group (RG) flow from the
higher Nishimori critical point to the unmeasured
2D Ising critical point, and is thus greater than
1/2. This is corroborated by extensive numerical simulations finding
ceff=0.522(1). The analytical result also explains, with a physically motivated assumption, the numerically observed increase of the Casimir effective central charge under the RG flow from the ordinary Nishimori critical point to the clean Ising critical point in the random-bond Ising model. We also discuss
higher Nishimori criticality in general dimensions
D>1.