Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.21281 · Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences

Hamilton-Jacobi as model reduction, extension to Newtonian particle mechanics, and a wave mechanical curiosity

Amit Acharya

math-phphysics.class-phquant-phSubmitted Dec 24, 2025• Announced Dec 25, 2025• 0 citations• Revised Apr 1, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Dec 24, 2025v2 · Apr 1, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Hamilton-Jacobi equation of classical mechanics is approached as a model reduction of conservative particle mechanics where the velocity degrees-of-freedom are eliminated. This viewpoint allows an extension of the association of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation from conservative systems to general Newtonian particle systems involving non-conservative forces, including dissipative ones. A geometric optics approximation leads to a dissipative Schrödinger equation, with the expected limiting form when the associated classical force system involves conservative forces.

Comments
Paper to appear in Proc. of the Royal Society, A

Related papers

Quantum Theory In The Classical Limit

Jack Cohn

The problem of the reduction of quantum mechanics to classical mechanics is considered. It is demonstrated that the customary derivation of classical mechanics from the Schrödinger equation via the Hamilton-Jacobi action equation is incomplete. An improved derivation, involving the expectation value of the action, rather than the action itself, is given. Under this formulation the Hamilton-Jacobi description of classical mechanics is obtained from quantum mechanics, for suitable wave packets as h goes to zero.

American Journal of Physics•Mar 1, 1972•11 citations

From the Hamilton-Jacobi equation to the Schrödinger equation and vice versa, without additional terms and approximations

J.D. Bulnes, M.A.I. Travassos, Davron Aslonqulovich Juraev +1 more

In this article, we will answer a question posed in the book Classical Mechanics by H. Goldstein: ``"Is the Hamilton-Jacobi equation the short wavelength limit of the Schrödinger equation?" But, before that, we will identify an essential element that will take us from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation to the dynamic equation of non-relativistic quantum mechanics for a function ψ through an exact procedure. This element is the linear independence of the functions ψ and ψ* (their complex conjugate). Their independence is demonstrated for physical systems where the acting physical potential does not explicitly depend on time. Proceeding in reverse, from the Schrödinger equation, we obtain the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, exactly, without additional terms.

Himalayan Physics•May 24, 2024•0 citations

Nonlinear Generalized Schrödinger’s Equations by Lifting Hamilton-Jacobi’s Formulation of Classical Mechanics

G. Gouesbet

It is well known that, by taking a limit of Schrödinger’s equation, we may recover Hamilton-Jacobi’s equation which governs one of the possible formulations of classical mechanics. Conversely, we may start from the Hamilton-Jacobi’s equation and, by using a lifting principle, we may reach a set of nonlinear generalized Schrödinger’s equations. The classical Schrödinger’s equation then occurs as the simplest equation among the set.

IntechOpen eBooks•Oct 6, 2021•0 citations

Simple derivations of the Hamilton–Jacobi equation and the eikonal equation without the use of canonical transformations

Alex Small, Kai S. Lam

The Hamilton–Jacobi equation in classical mechanics and the related eikonal equation in geometrical optics are often described as the “point of closest approach” between classical and quantum mechanics. Most textbook treatments of Hamilton–Jacobi theory are aimed at graduate students and derive the equation only after a long introduction to canonical transformations. Most treatments of the eikonal equation only emphasize its use in geometrical optics. We show that both the Hamilton–Jacobi equation and the eikonal equation can be derived by a common procedure using only elementary aspects of the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formalisms introduced in undergraduate classical mechanics courses. Through this common approach, we hope to highlight to undergraduates the deep connections between classical mechanics, classical wave theory, and Schrödinger’s wave mechanics.

American Journal of Physics•May 13, 2011•8 citations

Generalized Hamilton-Jacobi equation for simple dissipative processes

Ferenc Márkus, Katalin Gambár

Following the method of classical mechanics, we calculate the action for Fourier heat conduction from the classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation. We can write a Schrödinger-type equation and we obtain its solution, the kernel by which we may introduce a kind of wave function. Mathematically, we follow Bohm's method introduced to quantum mechanics. The generalized Hamilton-Jacobi equation-which may be handled as a quantum-thermodynamical form-can be calculated. Irreversibility and dissipation are included in a natural way in the field theory of nonequilibrium thermodynamics, so in this way we obtain a quantum-thermodynamical approach of simple dissipative processes.

Physical Review E•Jul 30, 2004•7 citations

The Quantum Hamilton–Jacobi Equation and the Link Between Classical and Quantum Mechanics

M. Fusco Girard

We study how the classical Hamilton's principal and characteristic functions are generated from the solutions of the quantum Hamilton–Jacobi equation. While in the classically forbidden regions these quantum quantities directly tend to the classical ones, this is not the case in the allowed regions. There, the limit is reached only if the quantum fluctuations are eliminated by means of coarse-graining averages. Analogously, the classical Hamilton–Jacobi scheme bringing to the motion's equations arises from a similar formal quantum procedure. Quanta 2022; 11: 42–52.

arXiv:2203.07005•Quanta•Nov 3, 2022•4 citations
The Hamilton-Jacobi equation of classical mechanics is approached as a model reduction of conservative particle mechanics where the velocity degrees-of-freedom are eliminated. This viewpoint allows an extension of the association of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation from conservative systems to general Newtonian particle systems involving non-conservative forces, including dissipative ones. A geometric optics approximation leads to a dissipative Schrödinger equation, with the expected limiting form when the associated classical force system involves conservative forces.
The problem of the reduction of quantum mechanics to classical mechanics is considered. It is demonstrated that the customary derivation of classical mechanics from the Schrödinger equation via the Hamilton-Jacobi action equation is incomplete. An improved derivation, involving the expectation value of the action, rather than the action itself, is given. Under this formulation the Hamilton-Jacobi description of classical mechanics is obtained from quantum mechanics, for suitable wave packets as h goes to zero.
In this article, we will answer a question posed in the book Classical Mechanics by H. Goldstein: ``"Is the Hamilton-Jacobi equation the short wavelength limit of the Schrödinger equation?" But, before that, we will identify an essential element that will take us from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation to the dynamic equation of non-relativistic quantum mechanics for a function ψ through an exact procedure. This element is the linear independence of the functions ψ and ψ* (their complex conjugate). Their independence is demonstrated for physical systems where the acting physical potential does not explicitly depend on time. Proceeding in reverse, from the Schrödinger equation, we obtain the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, exactly, without additional terms.
The Hamilton–Jacobi equation in classical mechanics and the related eikonal equation in geometrical optics are often described as the “point of closest approach” between classical and quantum mechanics. Most textbook treatments of Hamilton–Jacobi theory are aimed at graduate students and derive the equation only after a long introduction to canonical transformations. Most treatments of the eikonal equation only emphasize its use in geometrical optics. We show that both the Hamilton–Jacobi equation and the eikonal equation can be derived by a common procedure using only elementary aspects of the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formalisms introduced in undergraduate classical mechanics courses. Through this common approach, we hope to highlight to undergraduates the deep connections between classical mechanics, classical wave theory, and Schrödinger’s wave mechanics.
Following the method of classical mechanics, we calculate the action for Fourier heat conduction from the classical Hamilton-Jacobi equation. We can write a Schrödinger-type equation and we obtain its solution, the kernel by which we may introduce a kind of wave function. Mathematically, we follow Bohm's method introduced to quantum mechanics. The generalized Hamilton-Jacobi equation-which may be handled as a quantum-thermodynamical form-can be calculated. Irreversibility and dissipation are included in a natural way in the field theory of nonequilibrium thermodynamics, so in this way we obtain a quantum-thermodynamical approach of simple dissipative processes.
We study how the classical Hamilton's principal and characteristic functions are generated from the solutions of the quantum Hamilton–Jacobi equation. While in the classically forbidden regions these quantum quantities directly tend to the classical ones, this is not the case in the allowed regions. There, the limit is reached only if the quantum fluctuations are eliminated by means of coarse-graining averages. Analogously, the classical Hamilton–Jacobi scheme bringing to the motion's equations arises from a similar formal quantum procedure. Quanta 2022; 11: 42–52.