Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Simple derivations of the Hamilton–Jacobi equation and the eikonal equation without the use of canonical transformations

Alex Small, Kai S. Lam

Published May 13, 2011• 8 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Hamilton–Jacobi equation in classical mechanics and the related eikonal equation in geometrical optics are often described as the “point of closest approach” between classical and quantum mechanics. Most textbook treatments of Hamilton–Jacobi theory are aimed at graduate students and derive the equation only after a long introduction to canonical transformations. Most treatments of the eikonal equation only emphasize its use in geometrical optics. We show that both the Hamilton–Jacobi equation and the eikonal equation can be derived by a common procedure using only elementary aspects of the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formalisms introduced in undergraduate classical mechanics courses. Through this common approach, we hope to highlight to undergraduates the deep connections between classical mechanics, classical wave theory, and Schrödinger’s wave mechanics.

DOI
10.1119/1.3553462

Related papers

Derivation of Schrodinger's equation from the Hamilton-Jacobi and the Eikonal equations

Lachezar S. Simeonov

Most authors of textbooks on quantum mechanics either postulate or sketch a short `ad hoc` derivation of Schrodinger's equation. In this work we give a detailed derivation of Schrodinger's equation from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation and the Eikonal equation in geometrical optics. We start from the historical debates on the nature of light -- whether it is a beam of particles, or waves in the aether. We derive the Eikonal equation and show the conditions when a wave can behave as a beam of particles. Then we discuss several experiments with an electron gun, that show clearly diffraction and interference of a single electron. Next, in order to explain these experiments, we derive Schrodinger's equation by comparing Hamilton-Jacobi equation in classical mechanics with the Eikonal equation in geometrical optics. To do that, we first show how to derive the wave equation from the Eikonal equation (not the other way around!). Second, we use this method to derive Schrodinger's equation from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation. Next, we derive Born's statistical rule using the early understanding of de Broglie that both particles and waves exist. Afterwards, we show that historically people preferred to remove the particles (as well as their trajectories) altogether from de Broglie's ideas but retained Born's rule (the so called Copenhagen interpretation). These derivations of the foundations of quantum mechanics do not follow precisely the history of the subject. Rather we select some early ideas and experiments in a judicious manner to present Schrodinger's equation in a logical and ordered way. We use the electron gun experiments instead of black body radiation and photoelectric effect. Our derivation may bring more light and satisfaction for the undergraduate students about the confusing and rather mysterious subject of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2410.03689•Sep 21, 2024•5 citations

The Eikonal Principle: A Hamilton-Jacobi Unification of Classical Mechanics

Revista, Zen, PHYSICS, 10

This paper explores the profound connection between the Eikonal principle, primarily known in optics for describing wavefront propagation, and the Hamilton-Jacobi formulation of classical mechanics. We explicitly demonstrate how the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, a powerful partial differential equation that unifies various aspects of classical dynamics, naturally gives rise to an Eikonal-like behavior when considering the surfaces of constant action. By drawing an explicit analogy between the optical path length and Hamilton's principal function, we show that the trajectories of particles in classical mechanics can be interpreted as "rays" that are orthogonal to these propagating "wavefronts" of constant action in configuration space. This framework provides an elegant geometric interpretation of classical mechanics, where the evolution of a system is described by the propagation of a scalar field. The paper elucidates how the principle of least action, a cornerstone of classical mechanics, finds its optical counterpart in Fermat's principle of least time, thereby achieving a deeper, unified understanding of these seemingly disparate physical phenomena. This unification not only offers a powerful method for solving complex mechanical problems but also provides conceptual insights bridging classical wave theory and particle dynamics, laying foundational groundwork for quantum mechanics.

•Nov 28, 2025•0 citations

From Classical to Quantum Mechanics: An Introduction to the Formalism, Foundations and Applications

Giampiero V. M. Esposito, Giuseppe Marmo, George Sudarshan

This 2004 textbook provides a pedagogical introduction to the formalism, foundations and applications of quantum mechanics. Part I covers the basic material which is necessary to understand the transition from classical to wave mechanics. Topics include classical dynamics, with emphasis on canonical transformations and the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, the Cauchy problem for the wave equation, Helmholtz equation and eikonal approximation, introduction to spin, perturbation theory and scattering theory. The Weyl quantization is presented in Part II, along with the postulates of quantum mechanics. Part III is devoted to topics such as statistical mechanics and black-body radiation, Lagrangian and phase-space formulations of quantum mechanics, and the Dirac equation. This book is intended for use as a textbook for beginning graduate and advanced undergraduate courses. It is self-contained and includes problems to aid the reader's understanding.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 11, 2004•116 citations

Derivation of classical relativity and Schrödinger equation using Hamilton and Hamilton-Jacobi formalisms

M. Hage Hassan

\nUsing Hamilton formalism of classical mechanic we derive \nin a simple waythe equations of motions of classical relativity. Applying \nthe canonical transformation and the Lagrange-Euler equation we find the \nSchrödinger equation. Our objective is a pedagogical point of view.\n

Journal de Physique IV (Proceedings)•May 1, 2005•0 citations

Linear Canonical Transformations and the Hamilton-Jacobi Theory in Quantum Mechanics

Akihiro Ogura, Motoo Sekiguchi

We investigate two methods of constructing a solution of the Schrödinger equation from the canonical transformation in classical mechanics. One method shows that we can formulate the solution of the Schrödinger equation from linear canonical transformations, the other focuses on the generating function which satisfies the Hamilton-Jacobi equation in classical mechanics. We also show that these two methods lead to the same solution of the Schrödinger equation.

arXiv:quant-ph/0410173•Oct 22, 2004•1 citation

Hamilton-Jacobi as model reduction, extension to Newtonian particle mechanics, and a wave mechanical curiosity

Amit Acharya

The Hamilton-Jacobi equation of classical mechanics is approached as a model reduction of conservative particle mechanics where the velocity degrees-of-freedom are eliminated. This viewpoint allows an extension of the association of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation from conservative systems to general Newtonian particle systems involving non-conservative forces, including dissipative ones. A geometric optics approximation leads to a dissipative Schrödinger equation, with the expected limiting form when the associated classical force system involves conservative forces.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2512.21281•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Dec 25, 2025•0 citations
The Hamilton–Jacobi equation in classical mechanics and the related eikonal equation in geometrical optics are often described as the “point of closest approach” between classical and quantum mechanics. Most textbook treatments of Hamilton–Jacobi theory are aimed at graduate students and derive the equation only after a long introduction to canonical transformations. Most treatments of the eikonal equation only emphasize its use in geometrical optics. We show that both the Hamilton–Jacobi equation and the eikonal equation can be derived by a common procedure using only elementary aspects of the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formalisms introduced in undergraduate classical mechanics courses. Through this common approach, we hope to highlight to undergraduates the deep connections between classical mechanics, classical wave theory, and Schrödinger’s wave mechanics.
Most authors of textbooks on quantum mechanics either postulate or sketch a short `ad hoc` derivation of Schrodinger's equation. In this work we give a detailed derivation of Schrodinger's equation from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation and the Eikonal equation in geometrical optics. We start from the historical debates on the nature of light -- whether it is a beam of particles, or waves in the aether. We derive the Eikonal equation and show the conditions when a wave can behave as a beam of particles. Then we discuss several experiments with an electron gun, that show clearly diffraction and interference of a single electron. Next, in order to explain these experiments, we derive Schrodinger's equation by comparing Hamilton-Jacobi equation in classical mechanics with the Eikonal equation in geometrical optics. To do that, we first show how to derive the wave equation from the Eikonal equation (not the other way around!). Second, we use this method to derive Schrodinger's equation from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation. Next, we derive Born's statistical rule using the early understanding of de Broglie that both particles and waves exist. Afterwards, we show that historically people preferred to remove the particles (as well as their trajectories) altogether from de Broglie's ideas but retained Born's rule (the so called Copenhagen interpretation). These derivations of the foundations of quantum mechanics do not follow precisely the history of the subject. Rather we select some early ideas and experiments in a judicious manner to present Schrodinger's equation in a logical and ordered way. We use the electron gun experiments instead of black body radiation and photoelectric effect. Our derivation may bring more light and satisfaction for the undergraduate students about the confusing and rather mysterious subject of quantum mechanics.
This paper explores the profound connection between the Eikonal principle, primarily known in optics for describing wavefront propagation, and the Hamilton-Jacobi formulation of classical mechanics. We explicitly demonstrate how the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, a powerful partial differential equation that unifies various aspects of classical dynamics, naturally gives rise to an Eikonal-like behavior when considering the surfaces of constant action. By drawing an explicit analogy between the optical path length and Hamilton's principal function, we show that the trajectories of particles in classical mechanics can be interpreted as "rays" that are orthogonal to these propagating "wavefronts" of constant action in configuration space. This framework provides an elegant geometric interpretation of classical mechanics, where the evolution of a system is described by the propagation of a scalar field. The paper elucidates how the principle of least action, a cornerstone of classical mechanics, finds its optical counterpart in Fermat's principle of least time, thereby achieving a deeper, unified understanding of these seemingly disparate physical phenomena. This unification not only offers a powerful method for solving complex mechanical problems but also provides conceptual insights bridging classical wave theory and particle dynamics, laying foundational groundwork for quantum mechanics.
This 2004 textbook provides a pedagogical introduction to the formalism, foundations and applications of quantum mechanics. Part I covers the basic material which is necessary to understand the transition from classical to wave mechanics. Topics include classical dynamics, with emphasis on canonical transformations and the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, the Cauchy problem for the wave equation, Helmholtz equation and eikonal approximation, introduction to spin, perturbation theory and scattering theory. The Weyl quantization is presented in Part II, along with the postulates of quantum mechanics. Part III is devoted to topics such as statistical mechanics and black-body radiation, Lagrangian and phase-space formulations of quantum mechanics, and the Dirac equation. This book is intended for use as a textbook for beginning graduate and advanced undergraduate courses. It is self-contained and includes problems to aid the reader's understanding.
The Hamilton-Jacobi equation of classical mechanics is approached as a model reduction of conservative particle mechanics where the velocity degrees-of-freedom are eliminated. This viewpoint allows an extension of the association of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation from conservative systems to general Newtonian particle systems involving non-conservative forces, including dissipative ones. A geometric optics approximation leads to a dissipative Schrödinger equation, with the expected limiting form when the associated classical force system involves conservative forces.