Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2510.00637 · Entropy

On the Relativity of Quantumness as Implied by Relativity of Arithmetic and Probability

Marek Czachor

Published Sep 2, 2025• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A hierarchical structure of isomorphic arithmetics is defined by a bijection gR:R→R. It entails a hierarchy of probabilistic models, with probabilities pk=gk(p), where g is the restriction of gR to the interval [0,1], gk is the kth iterate of g, and k is an arbitrary integer (positive, negative, or zero; g0(x)=x). The relation between p and gk(p), k>0, is analogous to the one between probability and neural activation function. For k≪−1, gk(p) is essentially white noise (all processes are equally probable). The choice of k=0 is physically as arbitrary as the choice of origin of a line in space, hence what we regard as experimental binary probabilities, pexp, can be given by any k, pexp=gk(p). Quantum binary probabilities are defined by g(p)=sin2π2p. With this concrete form of g, one finds that any two neighboring levels of the hierarchy are related to each other in a quantum–subquantum relation. In this sense, any model in the hierarchy is probabilistically quantum in appropriate arithmetic and calculus. And the other way around: any model is subquantum in appropriate arithmetic and calculus. Probabilities involving more than two events are constructed by means of trees of binary conditional probabilities. We discuss from this perspective singlet-state probabilities and Bell inequalities. We find that singlet state probabilities involve simultaneously three levels of the hierarchy: quantum, hidden, and macroscopic. As a by-product of the analysis, we discover a new (arithmetic) interpretation of the Fubini–Study geodesic distance.

DOI
10.3390/e27090922

Related papers

Comment on Marek Czachor article entitled "On Relativity of Quantumness as Implied by Relativity of Arithmetic and Probability"

Krzysztof Sienicki, Mikołaj Sienicki

Czachor's model of hierarchical arithmetics begins with a valid formal premise but fixes the key probability mapping g by importing the Born rule and Fubini-Study metric from standard quantum mechanics, where Born probabilities are Kolmogorov within a fixed measurement context. This g is then applied in a non-Newtonian hidden-variable setting, producing a hybrid framework whose agreement with quantum correlations is built in by design, not derived from new physics, and thus does not constitute a genuine counterexample to Bell's theorem

arXiv:2510.02412•Oct 2, 2025•1 citation

A Hierarchy of Compatibility and Comeasurability Levels in Quantum Logics with Unique Conditional Probabilities

Gerd Niestegge

In the quantum mechanical Hilbert space formalism, the probabilistic interpretation is a later ad-hoc add-on, more or less enforced by the experimental evidence, but not motivated by the mathematical model itself. A model involving a clear probabilistic interpretation from the very beginning is provided by the quantum logics with unique conditional probabilities. It includes the projection lattices in von Neumann algebras and here probability conditionalization becomes identical with the state transition of the Lüders-von Neumann measurement process. This motivates the definition of a hierarchy of five compatibility and comeasurability levels in the abstract setting of the quantum logics with unique conditional probabilities. Their meanings are: the absence of quantum interference or influence, the existence of a joint distribution, simultaneous measurability, and the independence of the final state after two successive measurements from the sequential order of these two measurements. A further level means that two elements of the quantum logic (events) belong to the same Boolean subalgebra. In the general case, the five compatibility and comeasurability levels appear to differ, but they all coincide in the common Hilbert space formalism of quantum mechanics, in von Neumann algebras, and in some other cases.

arXiv:1001.1542•Communications in Theoretical Physics•Dec 1, 2010•6 citations

The Arithmetic of Uncertainty unifies Quantum Formalism and Relativistic Spacetime

John Skilling, Kevin H. Knuth

The theories of quantum mechanics and relativity dramatically altered our understanding of the universe ushering in the era of modern physics. Quantum theory deals with objects probabilistically at small scales, whereas relativity deals classically with motion in space and time. We show here that the mathematical structures of quantum theory and of relativity follow together from pure thought, defined and uniquely constrained by the same elementary ``combining and sequencing'' symmetries that underlie standard arithmetic and probability. The key is uncertainty, which inevitably accompanies observation of quantity and imposes the use of pairs of numbers. The symmetries then lead directly to the use of complex \sqrt{-1} arithmetic, the standard calculus of quantum mechanics, and the Lorentz transformations of relativistic spacetime. One dimension of time and three dimensions of space are thus derived as the profound and inevitable framework of physics.

arXiv:2104.05395•Dec 23, 2020•3 citations

Contributions to quantum probability

T. A. Fritz

Chapter 1: On the existence of quantum representations for two dichotomic measurements. Under which conditions do outcome probabilities of measurements possess a quantum-mechanical model? This kind of problem is solved here for the case of two dichotomic von Neumann measurements which can be applied repeatedly to a quantum system with trivial dynamics. The solution uses methods from the theory of operator algebras and the theory of moment problems. The ensuing conditions reveal surprisingly simple relations between certain quantum-mechanical probabilities. It also shown that generally, none of these relations holds in general probabilistic models. This result might facilitate further experimental discrimination between quantum mechanics and other general probabilistic theories. Chapter 2: Possibilistic Physics. I try to outline a framework for fundamental physics where the concept of probability gets replaced by the concept of possibility. Whereas a probabilistic theory assigns a state-dependent probability value to each outcome of each measurement, a possibilistic theory merely assigns one of the state-dependent labels "possible to occur" or "impossible to occur" to each outcome of each measurement. It is argued that Spekkens' combinatorial toy theory of quantum mechanics is inconsistent in a probabilistic framework, but can be regarded as possibilistic. Then, I introduce the concept of possibilistic local hidden variable models and derive a class of possibilistic Bell inequalities which are violated for the possibilistic Popescu-Rohrlich boxes. The chapter ends with a philosophical discussion on possibilistic vs. probabilistic. It can be argued that, due to better falsifiability properties, a possibilistic theory has higher predictive power than a probabilistic one. Chapter 3: The quantum region for von Neumann measurements with postselection. It is determined under which conditions a probability distribution on a finite set can occur as the outcome distribution of a quantum-mechanical von Neumann measurement with hyphenation given that the scalar product between the initial and the final state is known as well as the success probability of the postselection. An intermediate von Neumann measurement can enhance transition probabilities between states such that the error probability shrinks by a factor of up to 2. Chapter 4: A presentation of the category of stochastic matrices. This chapter gives generators and relations for the strict monoidal category of probabilistic maps on finite cardinals (i.e., stochastic matrices). Chapter 5: Convex Spaces: Definition and Examples. We try to promote convex spaces as an abstract concept of convexity which was introduced by Stone as "barycentric calculus''. A convex space is a set where one can take convex combinations in a consistent way. By identifying the corresponding Lawvere theory as the category from chapter 4 and using the results obtained there, we give a different proof of a result of Swirszcz which shows that convex spaces can be identified with algebras of a finitary version of the Giry monad. After giving an extensive list of examples of convex sets as they appear throughout mathematics and theoretical physics, we note that there also exist convex spaces that cannot be embedded into a vector space: semilattices are a class of examples of purely combinatorial type. In an information-theoretic interpretation, convex subsets of vector spaces are probabilistic, while semilattices are possibilistic. Convex spaces unify these two concepts.

•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Arithmetic Loophole in Bell's Theorem: Overlooked Threat to Entangled-State Quantum Cryptography

Marek Czachor

Bell's theorem is supposed to exclude all local hidden-variable models of quantum correlations.However, an explicit counterexample shows that a new class of local realistic models, based on generalized arithmetic and calculus, can exactly reconstruct rotationally symmetric quantum probabilities typical of two-electron singlet states.Observable probabilities are consistent with the usual arithmetic employed by macroscopic observers but counterfactual aspects of Bell's theorem are sensitive to the choice of hidden-variable arithmetic and calculus.The model is classical in the sense of Einstein, Podolsky, Rosen and Bell: elements of reality exist and probabilities are modeled by integrals of hidden-variable probability densities.Probability densities have a Clauser-Horne product form typical of local realistic theories.However, neither the product nor the integral nor the representation of rotations are the usual ones.The integral has all the standard properties but only with respect to the arithmetic that defines the product.Certain formal transformations of integral expressions found in the usual proofs à la Bell do not work, so standard Bell-type inequalities cannot be proved.The system we deal with is deterministic, local-realistic, rotationally invariant, observers have free will, detectors are perfect, hence the system is free of all the canonical loopholes discussed in the literature.

arXiv:2004.04097•Acta Physica Polonica A•Jan 1, 2021•15 citations

Representations, Not Revolutions: Czachor's Calculus and Bell's Theorem

Mikołaj Sienicki, Krzysztof Sienicki

We examine recent claims that "non-Newtonian" arithmetic and calculus topple Bell's theorem. Our basic point regarding such a claim is straightforward: the expectation functional used in those papers is linear only with respect to the deformed sum ⊕, not the ordinary +. Consequently, the familiar Clauser–Horne and Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt derivations — which lean on linearity under ordinary addition — do not apply. Within a single arithmetic level, a Bell-type analogue can be formulated if the outcomes and expectation values are defined in that level and satisfy linearity with respect to the level's addition ⊕; however, the standard Clauser–Horne/Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt proof for "+" is inapplicable. The eye-catching "beyond-Tsirelson" effects show up only when levels are mixed — thus, one computes with standard rules on quantities defined in a deformed calculus, producing out-of-range aggregates (e.g., totals exceeding one) rather than single-event probabilities. The touted "relativity of observed probabilities" also splices together two different moves, conditioning on a restricted sample space versus pushing everything through a scalar remapping. A simple horizon toy model already shows that there is no single-valued remapping that accomplishes this globally. The analogy with Einstein velocity addition helps a little in one dimension; in three dimensions, it collapses. There, the composition is non-commutative and non-associative, and the right language is a gyrogroup structure, not a pullback of ordinary addition. Bringing in Lambare's measurement-independence critique, we further argue that Czachor's reply (built from a hand-tuned bijection and a non-additive integral) addresses neither that objection nor Bell's own premises. In short, the program amounts to a representational re-encoding, not a counterexample of local hidden-variable.

Acta Physica Polonica A•Dec 16, 2025•1 citation
A hierarchical structure of isomorphic arithmetics is defined by a bijection gR:R→R. It entails a hierarchy of probabilistic models, with probabilities pk=gk(p), where g is the restriction of gR to the interval [0,1], gk is the kth iterate of g, and k is an arbitrary integer (positive, negative, or zero; g0(x)=x). The relation between p and gk(p), k>0, is analogous to the one between probability and neural activation function. For k≪−1, gk(p) is essentially white noise (all processes are equally probable). The choice of k=0 is physically as arbitrary as the choice of origin of a line in space, hence what we regard as experimental binary probabilities, pexp, can be given by any k, pexp=gk(p). Quantum binary probabilities are defined by g(p)=sin2π2p. With this concrete form of g, one finds that any two neighboring levels of the hierarchy are related to each other in a quantum–subquantum relation. In this sense, any model in the hierarchy is probabilistically quantum in appropriate arithmetic and calculus. And the other way around: any model is subquantum in appropriate arithmetic and calculus. Probabilities involving more than two events are constructed by means of trees of binary conditional probabilities. We discuss from this perspective singlet-state probabilities and Bell inequalities. We find that singlet state probabilities involve simultaneously three levels of the hierarchy: quantum, hidden, and macroscopic. As a by-product of the analysis, we discover a new (arithmetic) interpretation of the Fubini–Study geodesic distance.
Czachor's model of hierarchical arithmetics begins with a valid formal premise but fixes the key probability mapping g by importing the Born rule and Fubini-Study metric from standard quantum mechanics, where Born probabilities are Kolmogorov within a fixed measurement context. This g is then applied in a non-Newtonian hidden-variable setting, producing a hybrid framework whose agreement with quantum correlations is built in by design, not derived from new physics, and thus does not constitute a genuine counterexample to Bell's theorem
In the quantum mechanical Hilbert space formalism, the probabilistic interpretation is a later ad-hoc add-on, more or less enforced by the experimental evidence, but not motivated by the mathematical model itself. A model involving a clear probabilistic interpretation from the very beginning is provided by the quantum logics with unique conditional probabilities. It includes the projection lattices in von Neumann algebras and here probability conditionalization becomes identical with the state transition of the Lüders-von Neumann measurement process. This motivates the definition of a hierarchy of five compatibility and comeasurability levels in the abstract setting of the quantum logics with unique conditional probabilities. Their meanings are: the absence of quantum interference or influence, the existence of a joint distribution, simultaneous measurability, and the independence of the final state after two successive measurements from the sequential order of these two measurements. A further level means that two elements of the quantum logic (events) belong to the same Boolean subalgebra. In the general case, the five compatibility and comeasurability levels appear to differ, but they all coincide in the common Hilbert space formalism of quantum mechanics, in von Neumann algebras, and in some other cases.
The theories of quantum mechanics and relativity dramatically altered our understanding of the universe ushering in the era of modern physics. Quantum theory deals with objects probabilistically at small scales, whereas relativity deals classically with motion in space and time. We show here that the mathematical structures of quantum theory and of relativity follow together from pure thought, defined and uniquely constrained by the same elementary ``combining and sequencing'' symmetries that underlie standard arithmetic and probability. The key is uncertainty, which inevitably accompanies observation of quantity and imposes the use of pairs of numbers. The symmetries then lead directly to the use of complex \sqrt{-1} arithmetic, the standard calculus of quantum mechanics, and the Lorentz transformations of relativistic spacetime. One dimension of time and three dimensions of space are thus derived as the profound and inevitable framework of physics.
Chapter 1: On the existence of quantum representations for two dichotomic measurements. Under which conditions do outcome probabilities of measurements possess a quantum-mechanical model? This kind of problem is solved here for the case of two dichotomic von Neumann measurements which can be applied repeatedly to a quantum system with trivial dynamics. The solution uses methods from the theory of operator algebras and the theory of moment problems. The ensuing conditions reveal surprisingly simple relations between certain quantum-mechanical probabilities. It also shown that generally, none of these relations holds in general probabilistic models. This result might facilitate further experimental discrimination between quantum mechanics and other general probabilistic theories. Chapter 2: Possibilistic Physics. I try to outline a framework for fundamental physics where the concept of probability gets replaced by the concept of possibility. Whereas a probabilistic theory assigns a state-dependent probability value to each outcome of each measurement, a possibilistic theory merely assigns one of the state-dependent labels "possible to occur" or "impossible to occur" to each outcome of each measurement. It is argued that Spekkens' combinatorial toy theory of quantum mechanics is inconsistent in a probabilistic framework, but can be regarded as possibilistic. Then, I introduce the concept of possibilistic local hidden variable models and derive a class of possibilistic Bell inequalities which are violated for the possibilistic Popescu-Rohrlich boxes. The chapter ends with a philosophical discussion on possibilistic vs. probabilistic. It can be argued that, due to better falsifiability properties, a possibilistic theory has higher predictive power than a probabilistic one. Chapter 3: The quantum region for von Neumann measurements with postselection. It is determined under which conditions a probability distribution on a finite set can occur as the outcome distribution of a quantum-mechanical von Neumann measurement with hyphenation given that the scalar product between the initial and the final state is known as well as the success probability of the postselection. An intermediate von Neumann measurement can enhance transition probabilities between states such that the error probability shrinks by a factor of up to 2. Chapter 4: A presentation of the category of stochastic matrices. This chapter gives generators and relations for the strict monoidal category of probabilistic maps on finite cardinals (i.e., stochastic matrices). Chapter 5: Convex Spaces: Definition and Examples. We try to promote convex spaces as an abstract concept of convexity which was introduced by Stone as "barycentric calculus''. A convex space is a set where one can take convex combinations in a consistent way. By identifying the corresponding Lawvere theory as the category from chapter 4 and using the results obtained there, we give a different proof of a result of Swirszcz which shows that convex spaces can be identified with algebras of a finitary version of the Giry monad. After giving an extensive list of examples of convex sets as they appear throughout mathematics and theoretical physics, we note that there also exist convex spaces that cannot be embedded into a vector space: semilattices are a class of examples of purely combinatorial type. In an information-theoretic interpretation, convex subsets of vector spaces are probabilistic, while semilattices are possibilistic. Convex spaces unify these two concepts.
Bell's theorem is supposed to exclude all local hidden-variable models of quantum correlations.However, an explicit counterexample shows that a new class of local realistic models, based on generalized arithmetic and calculus, can exactly reconstruct rotationally symmetric quantum probabilities typical of two-electron singlet states.Observable probabilities are consistent with the usual arithmetic employed by macroscopic observers but counterfactual aspects of Bell's theorem are sensitive to the choice of hidden-variable arithmetic and calculus.The model is classical in the sense of Einstein, Podolsky, Rosen and Bell: elements of reality exist and probabilities are modeled by integrals of hidden-variable probability densities.Probability densities have a Clauser-Horne product form typical of local realistic theories.However, neither the product nor the integral nor the representation of rotations are the usual ones.The integral has all the standard properties but only with respect to the arithmetic that defines the product.Certain formal transformations of integral expressions found in the usual proofs à la Bell do not work, so standard Bell-type inequalities cannot be proved.The system we deal with is deterministic, local-realistic, rotationally invariant, observers have free will, detectors are perfect, hence the system is free of all the canonical loopholes discussed in the literature.
We examine recent claims that "non-Newtonian" arithmetic and calculus topple Bell's theorem. Our basic point regarding such a claim is straightforward: the expectation functional used in those papers is linear only with respect to the deformed sum ⊕, not the ordinary +. Consequently, the familiar Clauser–Horne and Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt derivations — which lean on linearity under ordinary addition — do not apply. Within a single arithmetic level, a Bell-type analogue can be formulated if the outcomes and expectation values are defined in that level and satisfy linearity with respect to the level's addition ⊕; however, the standard Clauser–Horne/Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt proof for "+" is inapplicable. The eye-catching "beyond-Tsirelson" effects show up only when levels are mixed — thus, one computes with standard rules on quantities defined in a deformed calculus, producing out-of-range aggregates (e.g., totals exceeding one) rather than single-event probabilities. The touted "relativity of observed probabilities" also splices together two different moves, conditioning on a restricted sample space versus pushing everything through a scalar remapping. A simple horizon toy model already shows that there is no single-valued remapping that accomplishes this globally. The analogy with Einstein velocity addition helps a little in one dimension; in three dimensions, it collapses. There, the composition is non-commutative and non-associative, and the right language is a gyrogroup structure, not a pullback of ordinary addition. Bringing in Lambare's measurement-independence critique, we further argue that Czachor's reply (built from a hand-tuned bijection and a non-additive integral) addresses neither that objection nor Bell's own premises. In short, the program amounts to a representational re-encoding, not a counterexample of local hidden-variable.