Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2510.02412

Comment on Marek Czachor article entitled "On Relativity of Quantumness as Implied by Relativity of Arithmetic and Probability"

Krzysztof Sienicki, Mikołaj Sienicki

Published Oct 2, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Czachor's model of hierarchical arithmetics begins with a valid formal premise but fixes the key probability mapping g by importing the Born rule and Fubini-Study metric from standard quantum mechanics, where Born probabilities are Kolmogorov within a fixed measurement context. This g is then applied in a non-Newtonian hidden-variable setting, producing a hybrid framework whose agreement with quantum correlations is built in by design, not derived from new physics, and thus does not constitute a genuine counterexample to Bell's theorem

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2510.02412

Related papers

On the Relativity of Quantumness as Implied by Relativity of Arithmetic and Probability

Marek Czachor

A hierarchical structure of isomorphic arithmetics is defined by a bijection gR:R→R. It entails a hierarchy of probabilistic models, with probabilities pk=gk(p), where g is the restriction of gR to the interval [0,1], gk is the kth iterate of g, and k is an arbitrary integer (positive, negative, or zero; g0(x)=x). The relation between p and gk(p), k>0, is analogous to the one between probability and neural activation function. For k≪−1, gk(p) is essentially white noise (all processes are equally probable). The choice of k=0 is physically as arbitrary as the choice of origin of a line in space, hence what we regard as experimental binary probabilities, pexp, can be given by any k, pexp=gk(p). Quantum binary probabilities are defined by g(p)=sin2π2p. With this concrete form of g, one finds that any two neighboring levels of the hierarchy are related to each other in a quantum–subquantum relation. In this sense, any model in the hierarchy is probabilistically quantum in appropriate arithmetic and calculus. And the other way around: any model is subquantum in appropriate arithmetic and calculus. Probabilities involving more than two events are constructed by means of trees of binary conditional probabilities. We discuss from this perspective singlet-state probabilities and Bell inequalities. We find that singlet state probabilities involve simultaneously three levels of the hierarchy: quantum, hidden, and macroscopic. As a by-product of the analysis, we discover a new (arithmetic) interpretation of the Fubini–Study geodesic distance.

arXiv:2510.00637•Entropy•Sep 2, 2025•3 citations

The Born Rule for Projective Measurements from Metric Non-Expansion and Calibration

Aaron Lax

Why should a calibrated quantum measurement report Born probabilities? Fix a finite dimension $d\geq 2$ and a projective measurement $M$ on $\mathbb{C}^d$, and let $P_M$ be a map assigning outcome probabilities to pure states. I prove that three per-apparatus hypotheses force $P_M$ to be the Born readout: the square-root readout $R_M=\sqrt{P_M}$ is absolutely continuous along Fubini--Study geodesics; the classical Fisher speed of the output never exceeds the quantum Fisher speed of the input almost everywhere on smooth pure-state curves; and the readout reports certainty on every state in each labeled eigenspace. Taking square roots turns probabilities into coordinates on a spherical orthant, and calibration pins the vertices. The metric hypotheses make $R_M$ globally $1$-Lipschitz from Fubini--Study to round distance, so the readout cannot move farther from any calibrated vertex: every coordinate is at least its Born value, both vectors have unit norm, and they are equal. The hypotheses are per measurement; imposing them in every projective context yields the Born assignment on all projective measurements, at every $d\geq 2$, with noncontextuality arriving as an output rather than an axiom. The metric argument stops at projective measurements: for every non-projective POVM, an explicit family of non-Born readouts satisfies the same metric hypotheses even with the stated certainty-of-occurrence calibration.

quant-pharXiv:2604.27339•May 1, 2026•0 citations

Mathematics and physics of consistency of the Born rule with normal probability distribution

Alexey A. Kryukov

Abstract Newtonian and Scrödinger dynamics can be formulated in a physically meaningful way within the same Hilbert space framework. The resulting unexpected relation between classical and quantum motions goes beyond the results provided by the Ehrenfest theorem. The normal probability distribution and the Born rule turn out to be related. A dynamical mechanism responsible for the latter formula is proposed and applied to measurements of macroscopic and microscopic systems.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Sep 1, 2019•2 citations

Linking Probability Theory and Quantum Mechanics, and a Novel Formulation of Quantization

Fritiof Wallentin

This doctoral thesis in mathematics consists of three articles that explore the probabilistic structure of quantum mechanics and quantization from a novel perspective. The thesis adopts a probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics, which views the archetypical quantum experiments of Bell- and double-slit- type as violating the principle of non-contextuality, i.e., the assertion that all events and observables are always representable on one single Kolmogorovian probability space, rather than the principles of realism or locality. This probabilistic interpretation posits that quantum mechanics constitutes a probability theory that adheres to the principle of contextuality, and that quantum events explicitly occur at the level of measurement, rather than the level of that which is measured, as these are traditionally interpreted. The thesis establishes a natural connection between the probabilistic structure of quantum mechanics, specifically Born’s rule, and the frequentist interpretation of probability. The major conceptual step in establishing this connection is to re-identify quantum observables instead as unitary representations of groups, whose irreducible sub-representations correspond to the observable’s different possible outcomes, rather than primarily as self- adjoint operators. Furthermore, the thesis reformulates classical statistical mechanics in the formalism of quantum mechanics, known as the Koopman-von Neumann formulation, to demonstrate that classical statistical mechanics also adheres to the principle of contextuality. This finding is significant because it raises questions about the existence of a hidden-variable model of classical statistical mechanics of the kind as examined in Bell’s theorem, where this presumed hidden-variable model traditionally has been seen as that which distinguishes "classical" from "quantum" probability.A novel reformulation of quantization is proposed considering it rather in terms of the representation theory of Hamiltonian flows and their associated inherent symmetry group of symplectomorphisms. Contrary to the traditional view of quantization, this formulation can be regarded as compatible with the probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics and offers a new perspective on the quantization of gravity.

•May 22, 2023•0 citations

Bell’s Theorem and Einstein’s Worry about Quantum Mechanics

Han J.F. Geurdes

With the use of a local dependency on instrument setting parameters of the probability density of local hidden variables, it is demonstrated that a Kolmogorov formulation reproduces the quantum correlation. This is the novelty of the work. In a Bell experiment, one cannot distinguish between Bell’s formula and the here presented local Kolmogorov formula. With the presented formula, no CHSH can be obtained. Therefore, the famous CHSH inequality has no excluding power concerning local extra Einstein parameter models. This result concurs with other previous research concerning difficulties with Bell’s formula.

Journal of Quantum Information Science•Jan 1, 2023•2 citations

Born Readout as Observable-Slice Projection

Craig Edwin Holdway

T99 provides a geometric interpretation of the Born rule within a real symplectic-metric framework. Rather than treating quantum probabilities as fundamental postulates, the theorem derives them as normalized projection weights onto an observable subspace of a larger real state space. The construction begins with a real vector space \[R\] equipped with a compatible metric-symplectic-complex structure \[(R,g,\omega,J),\] where \[J^2=-I,\qquadg(Ju,Jv)=g(u,v).\] The state space is assumed to be split into complementary components \[R=O\oplusO',\] where \(O\) is the observable subspace and \[O'=JO\] is its conjugate counterpart. The theorem introduces the observable projection operator \[\Pi_O:R\rightarrow O\] and an orthogonal decomposition of the observable sector into measurement directions \[O=\bigoplus_i O_i,\] with associated projectors \(\Pi_i\). Every state \[v\in R\] admits a unique decomposition \[v=o+h,\qquado\in O,\qquadh\in O'.\] The observable component is \[o=\Pi_O v,\] while the conjugate component lies outside the directly observed sector. A central result is that the conjugate sector is metrically equivalent to the observable sector. Because \[g(Jv,Jv)=g(v,v),\] The conjugate component possesses the same norm structure as the observable component. It is therefore not a lower-order correction or negligible remainder, but a geometrically equivalent part of the larger real state space. The theorem then derives the Born readout formula as a projection law. For each measurement direction \(O_i\), \[P_i(v)=\frac{\|\Pi_i v\|^2}{\|v\|^2}.\] The probabilities satisfy \[0\le P_i(v)\le1,\] and \[\sum_i P_i(v)=P_O(v)=\frac{\|\Pi_O v\|^2}{\|v\|^2}.\] Whenever the state is normalized entirely within the observable sector, \[\|\Pi_O v\|=\|v\|,\] The probabilities satisfy \[\sum_i P_i(v)=1.\] The Born rule, therefore, emerges as the normalized squared projection of the full state onto observable measurement directions. Choosing the complex structure \(J\) recovers the familiar complex formulation. The real metric and symplectic structures combine into the Hermitian inner product \[g(\cdot,\cdot)+i\,\omega(\cdot,\cdot),\] and the projection formula becomes \[P_i=|\langle i|\psi\rangle|^2.\] The standard Born rule is thus recovered as the complex representation of the underlying projection geometry. Several consequences follow. Components lying entirely in the conjugate sector contribute no direct observable readout when measurements are restricted to the observable slice. The observable sector nevertheless remains a complete probability space, since normalized states within \(O\) satisfy the usual probability-sum rule. Standard quantum mechanics, therefore, appears as the special case in which measurements access only the observable sector and no probability weight leaks from the conjugate component into observable readout. T99 provides a geometric foundation for the Born rule within the reduced Q5 framework. The theorem interprets quantum probabilities as observable-slice projections of a larger real symplectic structure and identifies the standard complex Born rule as the closed-observable-sector limit of that broader geometric description.

•Jun 3, 2026•0 citations
Czachor's model of hierarchical arithmetics begins with a valid formal premise but fixes the key probability mapping g by importing the Born rule and Fubini-Study metric from standard quantum mechanics, where Born probabilities are Kolmogorov within a fixed measurement context. This g is then applied in a non-Newtonian hidden-variable setting, producing a hybrid framework whose agreement with quantum correlations is built in by design, not derived from new physics, and thus does not constitute a genuine counterexample to Bell's theorem
A hierarchical structure of isomorphic arithmetics is defined by a bijection gR:R→R. It entails a hierarchy of probabilistic models, with probabilities pk=gk(p), where g is the restriction of gR to the interval [0,1], gk is the kth iterate of g, and k is an arbitrary integer (positive, negative, or zero; g0(x)=x). The relation between p and gk(p), k>0, is analogous to the one between probability and neural activation function. For k≪−1, gk(p) is essentially white noise (all processes are equally probable). The choice of k=0 is physically as arbitrary as the choice of origin of a line in space, hence what we regard as experimental binary probabilities, pexp, can be given by any k, pexp=gk(p). Quantum binary probabilities are defined by g(p)=sin2π2p. With this concrete form of g, one finds that any two neighboring levels of the hierarchy are related to each other in a quantum–subquantum relation. In this sense, any model in the hierarchy is probabilistically quantum in appropriate arithmetic and calculus. And the other way around: any model is subquantum in appropriate arithmetic and calculus. Probabilities involving more than two events are constructed by means of trees of binary conditional probabilities. We discuss from this perspective singlet-state probabilities and Bell inequalities. We find that singlet state probabilities involve simultaneously three levels of the hierarchy: quantum, hidden, and macroscopic. As a by-product of the analysis, we discover a new (arithmetic) interpretation of the Fubini–Study geodesic distance.
Why should a calibrated quantum measurement report Born probabilities? Fix a finite dimension d≥2d\geq 2d≥2 and a projective measurement MMM on Cd\mathbb{C}^dCd, and let PMP_MPM​ be a map assigning outcome probabilities to pure states. I prove that three per-apparatus hypotheses force PMP_MPM​ to be the Born readout: the square-root readout RM=PMR_M=\sqrt{P_M}RM​=PM​​ is absolutely continuous along Fubini--Study geodesics; the classical Fisher speed of the output never exceeds the quantum Fisher speed of the input almost everywhere on smooth pure-state curves; and the readout reports certainty on every state in each labeled eigenspace. Taking square roots turns probabilities into coordinates on a spherical orthant, and calibration pins the vertices. The metric hypotheses make RMR_MRM​ globally 111-Lipschitz from Fubini--Study to round distance, so the readout cannot move farther from any calibrated vertex: every coordinate is at least its Born value, both vectors have unit norm, and they are equal. The hypotheses are per measurement; imposing them in every projective context yields the Born assignment on all projective measurements, at every d≥2d\geq 2d≥2, with noncontextuality arriving as an output rather than an axiom. The metric argument stops at projective measurements: for every non-projective POVM, an explicit family of non-Born readouts satisfies the same metric hypotheses even with the stated certainty-of-occurrence calibration.
This doctoral thesis in mathematics consists of three articles that explore the probabilistic structure of quantum mechanics and quantization from a novel perspective. The thesis adopts a probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics, which views the archetypical quantum experiments of Bell- and double-slit- type as violating the principle of non-contextuality, i.e., the assertion that all events and observables are always representable on one single Kolmogorovian probability space, rather than the principles of realism or locality. This probabilistic interpretation posits that quantum mechanics constitutes a probability theory that adheres to the principle of contextuality, and that quantum events explicitly occur at the level of measurement, rather than the level of that which is measured, as these are traditionally interpreted. The thesis establishes a natural connection between the probabilistic structure of quantum mechanics, specifically Born’s rule, and the frequentist interpretation of probability. The major conceptual step in establishing this connection is to re-identify quantum observables instead as unitary representations of groups, whose irreducible sub-representations correspond to the observable’s different possible outcomes, rather than primarily as self- adjoint operators. Furthermore, the thesis reformulates classical statistical mechanics in the formalism of quantum mechanics, known as the Koopman-von Neumann formulation, to demonstrate that classical statistical mechanics also adheres to the principle of contextuality. This finding is significant because it raises questions about the existence of a hidden-variable model of classical statistical mechanics of the kind as examined in Bell’s theorem, where this presumed hidden-variable model traditionally has been seen as that which distinguishes "classical" from "quantum" probability.A novel reformulation of quantization is proposed considering it rather in terms of the representation theory of Hamiltonian flows and their associated inherent symmetry group of symplectomorphisms. Contrary to the traditional view of quantization, this formulation can be regarded as compatible with the probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics and offers a new perspective on the quantization of gravity.
With the use of a local dependency on instrument setting parameters of the probability density of local hidden variables, it is demonstrated that a Kolmogorov formulation reproduces the quantum correlation. This is the novelty of the work. In a Bell experiment, one cannot distinguish between Bell’s formula and the here presented local Kolmogorov formula. With the presented formula, no CHSH can be obtained. Therefore, the famous CHSH inequality has no excluding power concerning local extra Einstein parameter models. This result concurs with other previous research concerning difficulties with Bell’s formula.
T99 provides a geometric interpretation of the Born rule within a real symplectic-metric framework. Rather than treating quantum probabilities as fundamental postulates, the theorem derives them as normalized projection weights onto an observable subspace of a larger real state space. The construction begins with a real vector space RRR equipped with a compatible metric-symplectic-complex structure (R,g,ω,J),(R,g,\omega,J),(R,g,ω,J), where \[J^2=-I,\qquadg(Ju,Jv)=g(u,v).\] The state space is assumed to be split into complementary components \[R=O\oplusO',\] where OOO is the observable subspace and O′=JOO'=JOO′=JO is its conjugate counterpart. The theorem introduces the observable projection operator ΠO:R→O\Pi_O:R\rightarrow OΠO​:R→O and an orthogonal decomposition of the observable sector into measurement directions O=⨁iOi,O=\bigoplus_i O_i,O=⨁i​Oi​, with associated projectors Πi\Pi_iΠi​. Every state v∈Rv\in Rv∈R admits a unique decomposition \[v=o+h,\qquado\in O,\qquadh\in O'.\] The observable component is o=ΠOv,o=\Pi_O v,o=ΠO​v, while the conjugate component lies outside the directly observed sector. A central result is that the conjugate sector is metrically equivalent to the observable sector. Because g(Jv,Jv)=g(v,v),g(Jv,Jv)=g(v,v),g(Jv,Jv)=g(v,v), The conjugate component possesses the same norm structure as the observable component. It is therefore not a lower-order correction or negligible remainder, but a geometrically equivalent part of the larger real state space. The theorem then derives the Born readout formula as a projection law. For each measurement direction OiO_iOi​, Pi(v)=∥Πiv∥2∥v∥2.P_i(v)=\frac{\|\Pi_i v\|^2}{\|v\|^2}.Pi​(v)=∥v∥2∥Πi​v∥2​. The probabilities satisfy 0≤Pi(v)≤1,0\le P_i(v)\le1,0≤Pi​(v)≤1, and ∑iPi(v)=PO(v)=∥ΠOv∥2∥v∥2.\sum_i P_i(v)=P_O(v)=\frac{\|\Pi_O v\|^2}{\|v\|^2}.∑i​Pi​(v)=PO​(v)=∥v∥2∥ΠO​v∥2​. Whenever the state is normalized entirely within the observable sector, ∥ΠOv∥=∥v∥,\|\Pi_O v\|=\|v\|,∥ΠO​v∥=∥v∥, The probabilities satisfy ∑iPi(v)=1.\sum_i P_i(v)=1.∑i​Pi​(v)=1. The Born rule, therefore, emerges as the normalized squared projection of the full state onto observable measurement directions. Choosing the complex structure JJJ recovers the familiar complex formulation. The real metric and symplectic structures combine into the Hermitian inner product g(⋅,⋅)+i ω(⋅,⋅),g(\cdot,\cdot)+i\,\omega(\cdot,\cdot),g(⋅,⋅)+iω(⋅,⋅), and the projection formula becomes Pi=∣⟨i∣ψ⟩∣2.P_i=|\langle i|\psi\rangle|^2.Pi​=∣⟨i∣ψ⟩∣2. The standard Born rule is thus recovered as the complex representation of the underlying projection geometry. Several consequences follow. Components lying entirely in the conjugate sector contribute no direct observable readout when measurements are restricted to the observable slice. The observable sector nevertheless remains a complete probability space, since normalized states within OOO satisfy the usual probability-sum rule. Standard quantum mechanics, therefore, appears as the special case in which measurements access only the observable sector and no probability weight leaks from the conjugate component into observable readout. T99 provides a geometric foundation for the Born rule within the reduced Q5 framework. The theorem interprets quantum probabilities as observable-slice projections of a larger real symplectic structure and identifies the standard complex Born rule as the closed-observable-sector limit of that broader geometric description.