Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Acta Physica Polonica A

Representations, Not Revolutions: Czachor's Calculus and Bell's Theorem

Mikołaj Sienicki, Krzysztof Sienicki

Published Dec 16, 2025• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We examine recent claims that "non-Newtonian" arithmetic and calculus topple Bell's theorem. Our basic point regarding such a claim is straightforward: the expectation functional used in those papers is linear only with respect to the deformed sum ⊕, not the ordinary +. Consequently, the familiar Clauser–Horne and Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt derivations — which lean on linearity under ordinary addition — do not apply. Within a single arithmetic level, a Bell-type analogue can be formulated if the outcomes and expectation values are defined in that level and satisfy linearity with respect to the level's addition ⊕; however, the standard Clauser–Horne/Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt proof for "+" is inapplicable. The eye-catching "beyond-Tsirelson" effects show up only when levels are mixed — thus, one computes with standard rules on quantities defined in a deformed calculus, producing out-of-range aggregates (e.g., totals exceeding one) rather than single-event probabilities. The touted "relativity of observed probabilities" also splices together two different moves, conditioning on a restricted sample space versus pushing everything through a scalar remapping. A simple horizon toy model already shows that there is no single-valued remapping that accomplishes this globally. The analogy with Einstein velocity addition helps a little in one dimension; in three dimensions, it collapses. There, the composition is non-commutative and non-associative, and the right language is a gyrogroup structure, not a pullback of ordinary addition. Bringing in Lambare's measurement-independence critique, we further argue that Czachor's reply (built from a hand-tuned bijection and a non-additive integral) addresses neither that objection nor Bell's own premises. In short, the program amounts to a representational re-encoding, not a counterexample of local hidden-variable.

DOI
10.12693/aphyspola.148.273

Related papers

A Loophole of All ‘Loophole-Free’ Bell-Type Theorems

Marek Czachor

Abstract Bell’s theorem cannot be proved if complementary measurements have to be represented by random variables which cannot be added or multiplied. One such case occurs if their domains are not identical. The case more directly related to the Einstein–Rosen–Podolsky argument occurs if there exists an ‘element of reality’ but nevertheless addition of complementary results is impossible because they are represented by elements from different arithmetics. A naive mixing of arithmetics leads to contradictions at a much more elementary level than the Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt inequality.

arXiv:1710.06126•Foundations of Science•May 15, 2020•13 citations

Arithmetic Loophole in Bell's Theorem: Overlooked Threat to Entangled-State Quantum Cryptography

Marek Czachor

Bell's theorem is supposed to exclude all local hidden-variable models of quantum correlations.However, an explicit counterexample shows that a new class of local realistic models, based on generalized arithmetic and calculus, can exactly reconstruct rotationally symmetric quantum probabilities typical of two-electron singlet states.Observable probabilities are consistent with the usual arithmetic employed by macroscopic observers but counterfactual aspects of Bell's theorem are sensitive to the choice of hidden-variable arithmetic and calculus.The model is classical in the sense of Einstein, Podolsky, Rosen and Bell: elements of reality exist and probabilities are modeled by integrals of hidden-variable probability densities.Probability densities have a Clauser-Horne product form typical of local realistic theories.However, neither the product nor the integral nor the representation of rotations are the usual ones.The integral has all the standard properties but only with respect to the arithmetic that defines the product.Certain formal transformations of integral expressions found in the usual proofs à la Bell do not work, so standard Bell-type inequalities cannot be proved.The system we deal with is deterministic, local-realistic, rotationally invariant, observers have free will, detectors are perfect, hence the system is free of all the canonical loopholes discussed in the literature.

arXiv:2004.04097•Acta Physica Polonica A•Jan 1, 2021•15 citations

Bell's Theorem Begs the Question

Joy Christian

I demonstrate that Bell's theorem is based on circular reasoning and thus a fundamentally flawed argument. It unjustifiably assumes the additivity of expectation values for dispersion-free states of contextual hidden variable theories for non-commuting observables involved in Bell-test experiments, which is tautologous to assuming the bounds of ±2 on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values. Its premises thus assume in a different guise the bounds of ±2 it sets out to prove. Once this oversight is ameliorated from Bell's argument by identifying the impediment that leads to it and local realism is implemented correctly, the bounds on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values work out to be ±2√2 instead of ±2, thereby mitigating the conclusion of Bell's theorem. Consequently, what is ruled out by any of the Bell-test experiments is not local realism but the linear additivity of expectation values, which does not hold for non-commuting observables in any hidden variable theories to begin with.

•Jan 26, 2024•0 citations

Response to Comment on "A Loophole of All "Loophole-Free" Bell-Type Theorems", by J.P. Lambare

Marek Czachor

Contrary to what Lambare [arXiv:2008.00369] assumes, in non-Newtonian calculus (a calculus based on non-Diophantine arithmetic) an integral is typically given by a nonlinear map. This is the technical reason why all the standard proofs of Bell-type inequalities fail if non-Newtonian hidden variables are taken into account. From the non-Newtonian perspective, Bell's inequality is a property of a limited and unphysical class of hidden-variable models. An explicit counterexample to Bell's theorem can be easily constructed.

arXiv:2008.11910•Aug 27, 2020•3 citations

Bell's Theorem Begs the Question

Joy Christian

I demonstrate that Bell's theorem is based on circular reasoning and thus a fundamentally flawed argument. It unjustifiably assumes the additivity of expectation values for dispersion-free states of contextual hidden variable theories for non-commuting observables involved in Bell-test experiments, which is tautologous to assuming the bounds of ±2 on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values. Its premises thus assume in a different guise the bounds of ±2 it sets out to prove. Once this oversight is ameliorated from Bell's argument by identifying the impediment that leads to it and local realism is implemented correctly, the bounds on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values work out to be ±2√2 instead of ±2, thereby mitigating the conclusion of Bell's theorem. Consequently, what is ruled out by any of the Bell-test experiments is not local realism but the linear additivity of expectation values, which does not hold for non-commuting observables in any hidden variable theories to begin with.

•Sep 25, 2023•0 citations

Bell's Theorem Begs the Question

Joy Christian

I demonstrate that Bell's theorem is based on circular reasoning and thus a fundamentally flawed argument. It unjustifiably assumes the additivity of expectation values for dispersion-free states of contextual hidden variable theories for non-commuting observables involved in Bell-test experiments, which is tautologous to assuming the bounds of ±2 on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values. Its premises thus assume in a different guise the bounds of ±2 it sets out to prove. Once this oversight is ameliorated from Bell's argument by identifying the impediment that leads to it and local realism is implemented correctly, the bounds on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values work out to be ±2√2 instead of ±2, thereby mitigating the conclusion of Bell's theorem. Consequently, what is ruled out by any of the Bell-test experiments is not local realism but the linear additivity of expectation values, which does not hold for non-commuting observables in any hidden variable theories to begin with.

•Aug 3, 2023•0 citations
We examine recent claims that "non-Newtonian" arithmetic and calculus topple Bell's theorem. Our basic point regarding such a claim is straightforward: the expectation functional used in those papers is linear only with respect to the deformed sum ⊕, not the ordinary +. Consequently, the familiar Clauser–Horne and Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt derivations — which lean on linearity under ordinary addition — do not apply. Within a single arithmetic level, a Bell-type analogue can be formulated if the outcomes and expectation values are defined in that level and satisfy linearity with respect to the level's addition ⊕; however, the standard Clauser–Horne/Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt proof for "+" is inapplicable. The eye-catching "beyond-Tsirelson" effects show up only when levels are mixed — thus, one computes with standard rules on quantities defined in a deformed calculus, producing out-of-range aggregates (e.g., totals exceeding one) rather than single-event probabilities. The touted "relativity of observed probabilities" also splices together two different moves, conditioning on a restricted sample space versus pushing everything through a scalar remapping. A simple horizon toy model already shows that there is no single-valued remapping that accomplishes this globally. The analogy with Einstein velocity addition helps a little in one dimension; in three dimensions, it collapses. There, the composition is non-commutative and non-associative, and the right language is a gyrogroup structure, not a pullback of ordinary addition. Bringing in Lambare's measurement-independence critique, we further argue that Czachor's reply (built from a hand-tuned bijection and a non-additive integral) addresses neither that objection nor Bell's own premises. In short, the program amounts to a representational re-encoding, not a counterexample of local hidden-variable.
Abstract Bell’s theorem cannot be proved if complementary measurements have to be represented by random variables which cannot be added or multiplied. One such case occurs if their domains are not identical. The case more directly related to the Einstein–Rosen–Podolsky argument occurs if there exists an ‘element of reality’ but nevertheless addition of complementary results is impossible because they are represented by elements from different arithmetics. A naive mixing of arithmetics leads to contradictions at a much more elementary level than the Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt inequality.
Bell's theorem is supposed to exclude all local hidden-variable models of quantum correlations.However, an explicit counterexample shows that a new class of local realistic models, based on generalized arithmetic and calculus, can exactly reconstruct rotationally symmetric quantum probabilities typical of two-electron singlet states.Observable probabilities are consistent with the usual arithmetic employed by macroscopic observers but counterfactual aspects of Bell's theorem are sensitive to the choice of hidden-variable arithmetic and calculus.The model is classical in the sense of Einstein, Podolsky, Rosen and Bell: elements of reality exist and probabilities are modeled by integrals of hidden-variable probability densities.Probability densities have a Clauser-Horne product form typical of local realistic theories.However, neither the product nor the integral nor the representation of rotations are the usual ones.The integral has all the standard properties but only with respect to the arithmetic that defines the product.Certain formal transformations of integral expressions found in the usual proofs à la Bell do not work, so standard Bell-type inequalities cannot be proved.The system we deal with is deterministic, local-realistic, rotationally invariant, observers have free will, detectors are perfect, hence the system is free of all the canonical loopholes discussed in the literature.
I demonstrate that Bell's theorem is based on circular reasoning and thus a fundamentally flawed argument. It unjustifiably assumes the additivity of expectation values for dispersion-free states of contextual hidden variable theories for non-commuting observables involved in Bell-test experiments, which is tautologous to assuming the bounds of ±2 on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values. Its premises thus assume in a different guise the bounds of ±2 it sets out to prove. Once this oversight is ameliorated from Bell's argument by identifying the impediment that leads to it and local realism is implemented correctly, the bounds on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values work out to be ±2√2 instead of ±2, thereby mitigating the conclusion of Bell's theorem. Consequently, what is ruled out by any of the Bell-test experiments is not local realism but the linear additivity of expectation values, which does not hold for non-commuting observables in any hidden variable theories to begin with.
Contrary to what Lambare [arXiv:2008.00369] assumes, in non-Newtonian calculus (a calculus based on non-Diophantine arithmetic) an integral is typically given by a nonlinear map. This is the technical reason why all the standard proofs of Bell-type inequalities fail if non-Newtonian hidden variables are taken into account. From the non-Newtonian perspective, Bell's inequality is a property of a limited and unphysical class of hidden-variable models. An explicit counterexample to Bell's theorem can be easily constructed.
I demonstrate that Bell's theorem is based on circular reasoning and thus a fundamentally flawed argument. It unjustifiably assumes the additivity of expectation values for dispersion-free states of contextual hidden variable theories for non-commuting observables involved in Bell-test experiments, which is tautologous to assuming the bounds of ±2 on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values. Its premises thus assume in a different guise the bounds of ±2 it sets out to prove. Once this oversight is ameliorated from Bell's argument by identifying the impediment that leads to it and local realism is implemented correctly, the bounds on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values work out to be ±2√2 instead of ±2, thereby mitigating the conclusion of Bell's theorem. Consequently, what is ruled out by any of the Bell-test experiments is not local realism but the linear additivity of expectation values, which does not hold for non-commuting observables in any hidden variable theories to begin with.
I demonstrate that Bell's theorem is based on circular reasoning and thus a fundamentally flawed argument. It unjustifiably assumes the additivity of expectation values for dispersion-free states of contextual hidden variable theories for non-commuting observables involved in Bell-test experiments, which is tautologous to assuming the bounds of ±2 on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values. Its premises thus assume in a different guise the bounds of ±2 it sets out to prove. Once this oversight is ameliorated from Bell's argument by identifying the impediment that leads to it and local realism is implemented correctly, the bounds on the Bell-CHSH sum of expectation values work out to be ±2√2 instead of ±2, thereby mitigating the conclusion of Bell's theorem. Consequently, what is ruled out by any of the Bell-test experiments is not local realism but the linear additivity of expectation values, which does not hold for non-commuting observables in any hidden variable theories to begin with.