Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2306.12000 · Physical Review A

Space-time-symmetric extension of quantum mechanics: Interpretation and arrival-time predictions

Rodrigo Gomes de Araujo, Ricardo Ximenes, Eduardo O. Dias

Published Jan 24, 2024• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

An alternative quantization rule, in which time becomes a self-adjoint operator and position is a parameter, was proposed by Dias and Parisio [Phys. Rev. A 95, 032133 (2017)]. In this approach, the authors derived a space-time-symmetric (STS) extension of quantum mechanics (QM) where a new quantum state (intrinsic to the particle) $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ is defined at each point in space. The quantum state $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ obeys a space-conditional (SC) Schr\"odinger equation and its projection on $|t\ensuremath{\rangle}, \ensuremath{\langle}t|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$, represents the probability amplitude of the particle's arrival time at $x$. In this work we provide an interpretation of the SC Schr\"odinger equation and the eigenstates of observables in the STS extension. Analogous to the usual QM, we propose that by knowing the initial state $|\ensuremath{\phi}({x}_{0})\ensuremath{\rangle}$, which predicts any measurement on the particle performed by a detector localized at ${x}_{0}$, the SC Schr\"odinger equation provides $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}=\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{\mathbb{U}}(x,{x}_{0})|\ensuremath{\phi}({x}_{0})\ensuremath{\rangle}$, enabling us to predict measurements when the detector is at $x\ensuremath{\lessgtr}{x}_{0}$. We also verify that for space-dependent potentials, momentum eigenstates in the STS extension $|{P}_{b}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ depend on position just as energy eigenstates in the usual QM depend on time for time-dependent potentials. In this context, whereas a particle in the momentum eigenstate in the standard QM, $|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)\ensuremath{\rangle}={|P\ensuremath{\rangle}|}_{t}$, at time $t$, has momentum $P$ (and indefinite position), the same particle in the state $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}=|{P}_{b}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ arrives at position $x$ with momentum ${P}_{b}(x)$ (and indefinite arrival time). By investigating the fact that $|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ and $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ describe experimental data of the same observables collected at $t$ and $x$, respectively, we conclude that they provide complementary information about the same particle. Finally, we solve the SC Schr\"odinger equation for an arbitrary space-dependent potential. We apply this solution to a potential barrier and compare it with a generalized Kijowski distribution, showing that they can predict distinct traversal times.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.109.012221

Related papers

Space-time-symmetric non-relativistic quantum mechanics: Time and position of arrival and an extension of a Wheeler-DeWitt-type equation

Eduardo O. Dias

We generalize a space-time-symmetric (STS) extension of non-relativistic quantum mechanics (QM) to describe a particle moving in three spatial dimensions. In addition to the conventional time-conditional (Schrödinger) wave function $ψ(x, y, z | t)$, we introduce space-conditional wave functions such as $ϕ(t, y, z | x)$, where $x$ plays the role of the evolution parameter. The function $ϕ(t, y, z | x)$ represents the probability amplitude for the particle to arrive on the plane $x = \text{constant}$ at time $t$ and transverse position $(y, z)$. Within this framework, the coordinate $x^μ\in \{t, x, y, z\}$ can be conveniently chosen as the evolution parameter, depending on the experimental context under consideration. This leads to a unified formalism governed by a generalized Schrödinger-type equation, $\hat{P}^μ |ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangle = -i\hbar \, η^{μν} \frac{d}{dx^ν} |ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangle$. It reproduces standard QM when $x^μ= t$, with $|ϕ^0(x^0)\rangle = |ψ(t)\rangle$, and recovers the STS extension when $x^μ= x^i \in \{x, y, z\}$. For a free particle, we show that $ϕ(t, y, z | x) = \langle t, y, z | ϕ(x) \rangle$ naturally reproduces the same dependence on the momentum wave function as the axiomatic Kijowski distribution. Possible experimental tests of these predictions are discussed. Finally, we demonstrate that the different states $|ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangle$ can emerge by conditioning (i.e., projecting) a timeless and spaceless physical state onto the eigenstate $|x^μ\rangle$, leading to constraint equations of the form $\hat{\mathbb{P}}^μ|Φ^μ\rangle = 0$. This formulation generalizes the spirit of the Wheeler-DeWitt-type equation: instead of privileging time as the sole evolution parameter, it treats all coordinates on equal footing.

arXiv:2308.04376•Aug 8, 2023•2 citations

Space-time-symmetric extension of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics

Eduardo O. Dias, Fernando Parisio

In quantum theory we refer to the probability of finding a particle between positions $x$ and $x+dx$ at the instant $t$, although we have no capacity of predicting exactly when the detection occurs. In this work, we first present an extended nonrelativistic quantum formalism where space and time play equivalent roles. It leads to the probability of finding a particle between $x$ and $x+dx$ during [$t,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}t+dt$]. Then, we find a Schr\"odinger-like equation for a ``mirror'' wave function $\ensuremath{\phi}(t,x)$ associated with the probability of measuring the system between $t$ and $t+dt$, given that detection occurs at $x$. In this framework, it is shown that energy measurements of a stationary state display a nonzero dispersion, and that energy-time uncertainty arises from first principles. We show that a central result on arrival time, obtained through approaches that resort to ad hoc assumptions, is a natural, built-in part of the formalism presented here.

arXiv:1605.03121•Physical Review A•Mar 29, 2017•23 citations

Probability distribution of arrival times in quantum mechanics

V. Delgado

In a previous paper [V. Delgado and J. G. Muga, Phys. Rev. A 56, 3425 (1997)] we introduced a self-adjoint operator $\mathcal{T}^(X)$ whose eigenstates can be used to define consistently a probability distribution of the time of arrival at a given spatial point. In the present work we show that the probability distribution previously proposed can be well understood on classical grounds in the sense that it is given by the expectation value of a certain positive-definite operator ${J}^{(+)}(X)$, which is nothing but a straightforward quantum version of the modulus of the classical current. For quantum states highly localized in momentum space about a certain momentum ${p}_{0}\ensuremath{\ne}0$, the expectation value of ${J}^{(+)}(X)$ becomes indistinguishable from the quantum probability current. This fact may provide a justification for the common practice of using the latter quantity as a probability distribution of arrival times.

arXiv:quant-ph/9709037•Physical Review A•Feb 1, 1998•40 citations

A simple means for deriving quantum mechanics

Eric Tesse

A type of mechanics will be presented that possesses some distinctive properties. On the one hand, its physical description & rules of operation are readily comprehensible & intuitively clear. On the other, it fully satisfies all observable predictions of non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Within it, particles exist at points in space, follow continuous, piecewise differentiable paths, and their linear momentum is equal to their mass times their velocity along their path. Yet the probabilities for position and momentum, conditioned on the state of the particle's environment, follow the rules of quantum theory. Indeed, all observable consequences of quantum theory are satisfied; particles can be entangled, have intrinsic spin, this spin is not local to the particle, particle identity can effect probabilities, and so forth. All the rules of quantum mechanics are obeyed, and all arise in a straightforward fashion. After this is established, connections will be drawn out between this type of mechanics and other types of quantum worlds; those that obey Bohmian mechanics, stochastic mechanics, the many worlds interpretation, and physical collapse. In the final section, a relativistic version of the mechanics will be presented.

quant-pharXiv:2602.04524•Feb 5, 2026•0 citations

Traveling time in a spacetime-symmetric extension of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics

Arlans J. S. de Lara, Marcus W. Beims

Time continues to be an intriguing physical property in the modern era. On the one hand, we have the classical and relativistic notion of time, where space and time have the same hierarchy, essential in describing events in spacetime. On the other hand, in quantum mechanics, time appears as a classical parameter, meaning that it does not have an uncertain relation with its canonical conjugate. In this work we use a recent spacetime-symmetric proposal [Phys. Rev. A 95, 032133 (2017)] that tries to solve the unbalance in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics by extending the usual Hilbert space: the time parameter $t$ and the position operator $\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{X}$ in one subspace, and the position parameter $x$ and time operator $\mathbb{T}$ in the other subspace. Time as an operator is better suited for describing tunneling processes. We then solve the $1/2$-fractional integrodifferential equation for a particle subjected to strong and weak potential limits and obtain an analytical expression for the tunneling time through a rectangular barrier. Using a Gaussian energy distribution, we demonstrate that for wave packets well resolved in time, the expectation value of the operator $\mathbb{T}$ is the energy average of the classical time ${T}_{\text{class}}=\ensuremath{\partial}S/\ensuremath{\partial}E$, where $S$ is the classical action, which can be real or imaginary. The imaginary classical time does not contribute to the traveling time. Furthermore, we apply our results to a Gaussian energy distribution and compare them to previous works. This work is a correction of a previous paper [Phys. Rev. A 107, 052220 (2023)].

Physical Review A•Jul 12, 2024•6 citations

Physical and mathematical properties of the space-time-symmetric formalism

Ximenes, Ricardo, Eduardo O. Dias

It is well known that nonrelativistic quantum mechanics presents a clear asymmetry between space and time. Much of this asymmetry is attributed to the lack of Lorentz invariance of the theory. Nonetheless, a recent work [Phys. Rev. A \textbf{95}, 032133 (2017)] showed that even though this is partially true, there is a broader physical scenario in which space and time can be handled in nonrelativistic quantum theory in a more symmetric way. In this space-time-symmetric formalism, an additional Hilbert space is defined so that time is raised to the status of operator and position becomes a parameter. As a consequence, the Hilbert space now requires a space-conditional quantum state governed by a new quantum dynamics. In this manuscript, we reveal some physical and mathematical properties of the space-time-symmetric formalism such as: symmetries between the Hamilton-Jacobi and the space-conditional equation; the general solution for a time-independent potential; and a new Lagrangian for a spinless particle in one dimensional. Finally, we present the space-conditional equation for a particle under the effect of an electromagnetic field, and the gauge invariance of this equation is proved.

arXiv:1712.03446•Dec 9, 2017•1 citation
An alternative quantization rule, in which time becomes a self-adjoint operator and position is a parameter, was proposed by Dias and Parisio [Phys. Rev. A 95, 032133 (2017)]. In this approach, the authors derived a space-time-symmetric (STS) extension of quantum mechanics (QM) where a new quantum state (intrinsic to the particle) ∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩ is defined at each point in space. The quantum state ∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩ obeys a space-conditional (SC) Schr"odinger equation and its projection on ∣t\ensuremath⟩,\ensuremath⟨t∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩|t\ensuremath{\rangle}, \ensuremath{\langle}t|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}∣t\ensuremath⟩,\ensuremath⟨t∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩, represents the probability amplitude of the particle's arrival time at xxx. In this work we provide an interpretation of the SC Schr"odinger equation and the eigenstates of observables in the STS extension. Analogous to the usual QM, we propose that by knowing the initial state ∣\ensuremathϕ(x0)\ensuremath⟩|\ensuremath{\phi}({x}_{0})\ensuremath{\rangle}∣\ensuremathϕ(x0​)\ensuremath⟩, which predicts any measurement on the particle performed by a detector localized at x0{x}_{0}x0​, the SC Schr"odinger equation provides ∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩=U\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi(x,x0)∣\ensuremathϕ(x0)\ensuremath⟩|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}=\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{\mathbb{U}}(x,{x}_{0})|\ensuremath{\phi}({x}_{0})\ensuremath{\rangle}∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩=U\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi​(x,x0​)∣\ensuremathϕ(x0​)\ensuremath⟩, enabling us to predict measurements when the detector is at x\ensuremath≶x0x\ensuremath{\lessgtr}{x}_{0}x\ensuremath≶x0​. We also verify that for space-dependent potentials, momentum eigenstates in the STS extension ∣Pb(x)\ensuremath⟩|{P}_{b}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}∣Pb​(x)\ensuremath⟩ depend on position just as energy eigenstates in the usual QM depend on time for time-dependent potentials. In this context, whereas a particle in the momentum eigenstate in the standard QM, ∣\ensuremathψ(t)\ensuremath⟩=∣P\ensuremath⟩∣t|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)\ensuremath{\rangle}={|P\ensuremath{\rangle}|}_{t}∣\ensuremathψ(t)\ensuremath⟩=∣P\ensuremath⟩∣t​, at time ttt, has momentum PPP (and indefinite position), the same particle in the state ∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩=∣Pb(x)\ensuremath⟩|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}=|{P}_{b}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩=∣Pb​(x)\ensuremath⟩ arrives at position xxx with momentum Pb(x){P}_{b}(x)Pb​(x) (and indefinite arrival time). By investigating the fact that ∣\ensuremathψ(t)\ensuremath⟩|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)\ensuremath{\rangle}∣\ensuremathψ(t)\ensuremath⟩ and ∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}∣\ensuremathϕ(x)\ensuremath⟩ describe experimental data of the same observables collected at ttt and xxx, respectively, we conclude that they provide complementary information about the same particle. Finally, we solve the SC Schr"odinger equation for an arbitrary space-dependent potential. We apply this solution to a potential barrier and compare it with a generalized Kijowski distribution, showing that they can predict distinct traversal times.
We generalize a space-time-symmetric (STS) extension of non-relativistic quantum mechanics (QM) to describe a particle moving in three spatial dimensions. In addition to the conventional time-conditional (Schrödinger) wave function ψ(x,y,z∣t)ψ(x, y, z | t)ψ(x,y,z∣t), we introduce space-conditional wave functions such as ϕ(t,y,z∣x)ϕ(t, y, z | x)ϕ(t,y,z∣x), where xxx plays the role of the evolution parameter. The function ϕ(t,y,z∣x)ϕ(t, y, z | x)ϕ(t,y,z∣x) represents the probability amplitude for the particle to arrive on the plane x=constantx = \text{constant}x=constant at time ttt and transverse position (y,z)(y, z)(y,z). Within this framework, the coordinate xμ∈{t,x,y,z}x^μ\in \{t, x, y, z\}xμ∈{t,x,y,z} can be conveniently chosen as the evolution parameter, depending on the experimental context under consideration. This leads to a unified formalism governed by a generalized Schrödinger-type equation, P^μ∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩=−iℏ ημνddxν∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩\hat{P}^μ |ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangle = -i\hbar \, η^{μν} \frac{d}{dx^ν} |ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangleP^μ∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩=−iℏημνdxνd​∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩. It reproduces standard QM when xμ=tx^μ= txμ=t, with ∣ϕ0(x0)⟩=∣ψ(t)⟩|ϕ^0(x^0)\rangle = |ψ(t)\rangle∣ϕ0(x0)⟩=∣ψ(t)⟩, and recovers the STS extension when xμ=xi∈{x,y,z}x^μ= x^i \in \{x, y, z\}xμ=xi∈{x,y,z}. For a free particle, we show that ϕ(t,y,z∣x)=⟨t,y,z∣ϕ(x)⟩ϕ(t, y, z | x) = \langle t, y, z | ϕ(x) \rangleϕ(t,y,z∣x)=⟨t,y,z∣ϕ(x)⟩ naturally reproduces the same dependence on the momentum wave function as the axiomatic Kijowski distribution. Possible experimental tests of these predictions are discussed. Finally, we demonstrate that the different states ∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩|ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangle∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩ can emerge by conditioning (i.e., projecting) a timeless and spaceless physical state onto the eigenstate ∣xμ⟩|x^μ\rangle∣xμ⟩, leading to constraint equations of the form P^μ∣Φμ⟩=0\hat{\mathbb{P}}^μ|Φ^μ\rangle = 0P^μ∣Φμ⟩=0. This formulation generalizes the spirit of the Wheeler-DeWitt-type equation: instead of privileging time as the sole evolution parameter, it treats all coordinates on equal footing.
In quantum theory we refer to the probability of finding a particle between positions xxx and x+dxx+dxx+dx at the instant ttt, although we have no capacity of predicting exactly when the detection occurs. In this work, we first present an extended nonrelativistic quantum formalism where space and time play equivalent roles. It leads to the probability of finding a particle between xxx and x+dxx+dxx+dx during [t,t+dtt,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}t+dtt,t+dt]. Then, we find a Schr\"odinger-like equation for a ``mirror'' wave function $\ensuremath{\phi}(t,x)$ associated with the probability of measuring the system between ttt and t+dtt+dtt+dt, given that detection occurs at xxx. In this framework, it is shown that energy measurements of a stationary state display a nonzero dispersion, and that energy-time uncertainty arises from first principles. We show that a central result on arrival time, obtained through approaches that resort to ad hoc assumptions, is a natural, built-in part of the formalism presented here.
In a previous paper [V. Delgado and J. G. Muga, Phys. Rev. A 56, 3425 (1997)] we introduced a self-adjoint operator T(X)\mathcal{T}^(X)T(X) whose eigenstates can be used to define consistently a probability distribution of the time of arrival at a given spatial point. In the present work we show that the probability distribution previously proposed can be well understood on classical grounds in the sense that it is given by the expectation value of a certain positive-definite operator J(+)(X){J}^{(+)}(X)J(+)(X), which is nothing but a straightforward quantum version of the modulus of the classical current. For quantum states highly localized in momentum space about a certain momentum ${p}_{0}\ensuremath{\ne}0$, the expectation value of J(+)(X){J}^{(+)}(X)J(+)(X) becomes indistinguishable from the quantum probability current. This fact may provide a justification for the common practice of using the latter quantity as a probability distribution of arrival times.
A type of mechanics will be presented that possesses some distinctive properties. On the one hand, its physical description & rules of operation are readily comprehensible & intuitively clear. On the other, it fully satisfies all observable predictions of non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Within it, particles exist at points in space, follow continuous, piecewise differentiable paths, and their linear momentum is equal to their mass times their velocity along their path. Yet the probabilities for position and momentum, conditioned on the state of the particle's environment, follow the rules of quantum theory. Indeed, all observable consequences of quantum theory are satisfied; particles can be entangled, have intrinsic spin, this spin is not local to the particle, particle identity can effect probabilities, and so forth. All the rules of quantum mechanics are obeyed, and all arise in a straightforward fashion. After this is established, connections will be drawn out between this type of mechanics and other types of quantum worlds; those that obey Bohmian mechanics, stochastic mechanics, the many worlds interpretation, and physical collapse. In the final section, a relativistic version of the mechanics will be presented.
Time continues to be an intriguing physical property in the modern era. On the one hand, we have the classical and relativistic notion of time, where space and time have the same hierarchy, essential in describing events in spacetime. On the other hand, in quantum mechanics, time appears as a classical parameter, meaning that it does not have an uncertain relation with its canonical conjugate. In this work we use a recent spacetime-symmetric proposal [Phys. Rev. A 95, 032133 (2017)] that tries to solve the unbalance in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics by extending the usual Hilbert space: the time parameter ttt and the position operator $\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{X}$ in one subspace, and the position parameter xxx and time operator T\mathbb{T}T in the other subspace. Time as an operator is better suited for describing tunneling processes. We then solve the 1/21/21/2-fractional integrodifferential equation for a particle subjected to strong and weak potential limits and obtain an analytical expression for the tunneling time through a rectangular barrier. Using a Gaussian energy distribution, we demonstrate that for wave packets well resolved in time, the expectation value of the operator T\mathbb{T}T is the energy average of the classical time ${T}_{\text{class}}=\ensuremath{\partial}S/\ensuremath{\partial}E$, where SSS is the classical action, which can be real or imaginary. The imaginary classical time does not contribute to the traveling time. Furthermore, we apply our results to a Gaussian energy distribution and compare them to previous works. This work is a correction of a previous paper [Phys. Rev. A 107, 052220 (2023)].
It is well known that nonrelativistic quantum mechanics presents a clear asymmetry between space and time. Much of this asymmetry is attributed to the lack of Lorentz invariance of the theory. Nonetheless, a recent work [Phys. Rev. A \textbf{95}, 032133 (2017)] showed that even though this is partially true, there is a broader physical scenario in which space and time can be handled in nonrelativistic quantum theory in a more symmetric way. In this space-time-symmetric formalism, an additional Hilbert space is defined so that time is raised to the status of operator and position becomes a parameter. As a consequence, the Hilbert space now requires a space-conditional quantum state governed by a new quantum dynamics. In this manuscript, we reveal some physical and mathematical properties of the space-time-symmetric formalism such as: symmetries between the Hamilton-Jacobi and the space-conditional equation; the general solution for a time-independent potential; and a new Lagrangian for a spinless particle in one dimensional. Finally, we present the space-conditional equation for a particle under the effect of an electromagnetic field, and the gauge invariance of this equation is proved.