Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1605.03121 · Physical Review A

Space-time-symmetric extension of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics

Eduardo O. Dias, Fernando Parisio

Published Mar 29, 2017• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In quantum theory we refer to the probability of finding a particle between positions $x$ and $x+dx$ at the instant $t$, although we have no capacity of predicting exactly when the detection occurs. In this work, we first present an extended nonrelativistic quantum formalism where space and time play equivalent roles. It leads to the probability of finding a particle between $x$ and $x+dx$ during [$t,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}t+dt$]. Then, we find a Schr\"odinger-like equation for a ``mirror'' wave function $\ensuremath{\phi}(t,x)$ associated with the probability of measuring the system between $t$ and $t+dt$, given that detection occurs at $x$. In this framework, it is shown that energy measurements of a stationary state display a nonzero dispersion, and that energy-time uncertainty arises from first principles. We show that a central result on arrival time, obtained through approaches that resort to ad hoc assumptions, is a natural, built-in part of the formalism presented here.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.95.032133

Related papers

Space-time-symmetric extension of quantum mechanics: Interpretation and arrival-time predictions

Rodrigo Gomes de Araujo, Ricardo Ximenes, Eduardo O. Dias

An alternative quantization rule, in which time becomes a self-adjoint operator and position is a parameter, was proposed by Dias and Parisio [Phys. Rev. A 95, 032133 (2017)]. In this approach, the authors derived a space-time-symmetric (STS) extension of quantum mechanics (QM) where a new quantum state (intrinsic to the particle) $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ is defined at each point in space. The quantum state $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ obeys a space-conditional (SC) Schr\"odinger equation and its projection on $|t\ensuremath{\rangle}, \ensuremath{\langle}t|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$, represents the probability amplitude of the particle's arrival time at $x$. In this work we provide an interpretation of the SC Schr\"odinger equation and the eigenstates of observables in the STS extension. Analogous to the usual QM, we propose that by knowing the initial state $|\ensuremath{\phi}({x}_{0})\ensuremath{\rangle}$, which predicts any measurement on the particle performed by a detector localized at ${x}_{0}$, the SC Schr\"odinger equation provides $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}=\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{\mathbb{U}}(x,{x}_{0})|\ensuremath{\phi}({x}_{0})\ensuremath{\rangle}$, enabling us to predict measurements when the detector is at $x\ensuremath{\lessgtr}{x}_{0}$. We also verify that for space-dependent potentials, momentum eigenstates in the STS extension $|{P}_{b}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ depend on position just as energy eigenstates in the usual QM depend on time for time-dependent potentials. In this context, whereas a particle in the momentum eigenstate in the standard QM, $|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)\ensuremath{\rangle}={|P\ensuremath{\rangle}|}_{t}$, at time $t$, has momentum $P$ (and indefinite position), the same particle in the state $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}=|{P}_{b}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ arrives at position $x$ with momentum ${P}_{b}(x)$ (and indefinite arrival time). By investigating the fact that $|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ and $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ describe experimental data of the same observables collected at $t$ and $x$, respectively, we conclude that they provide complementary information about the same particle. Finally, we solve the SC Schr\"odinger equation for an arbitrary space-dependent potential. We apply this solution to a potential barrier and compare it with a generalized Kijowski distribution, showing that they can predict distinct traversal times.

arXiv:2306.12000•Physical Review A•Jan 24, 2024•7 citations

Space-time-symmetric non-relativistic quantum mechanics: Time and position of arrival and an extension of a Wheeler-DeWitt-type equation

Eduardo O. Dias

We generalize a space-time-symmetric (STS) extension of non-relativistic quantum mechanics (QM) to describe a particle moving in three spatial dimensions. In addition to the conventional time-conditional (Schrödinger) wave function $ψ(x, y, z | t)$, we introduce space-conditional wave functions such as $ϕ(t, y, z | x)$, where $x$ plays the role of the evolution parameter. The function $ϕ(t, y, z | x)$ represents the probability amplitude for the particle to arrive on the plane $x = \text{constant}$ at time $t$ and transverse position $(y, z)$. Within this framework, the coordinate $x^μ\in \{t, x, y, z\}$ can be conveniently chosen as the evolution parameter, depending on the experimental context under consideration. This leads to a unified formalism governed by a generalized Schrödinger-type equation, $\hat{P}^μ |ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangle = -i\hbar \, η^{μν} \frac{d}{dx^ν} |ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangle$. It reproduces standard QM when $x^μ= t$, with $|ϕ^0(x^0)\rangle = |ψ(t)\rangle$, and recovers the STS extension when $x^μ= x^i \in \{x, y, z\}$. For a free particle, we show that $ϕ(t, y, z | x) = \langle t, y, z | ϕ(x) \rangle$ naturally reproduces the same dependence on the momentum wave function as the axiomatic Kijowski distribution. Possible experimental tests of these predictions are discussed. Finally, we demonstrate that the different states $|ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangle$ can emerge by conditioning (i.e., projecting) a timeless and spaceless physical state onto the eigenstate $|x^μ\rangle$, leading to constraint equations of the form $\hat{\mathbb{P}}^μ|Φ^μ\rangle = 0$. This formulation generalizes the spirit of the Wheeler-DeWitt-type equation: instead of privileging time as the sole evolution parameter, it treats all coordinates on equal footing.

arXiv:2308.04376•Aug 8, 2023•2 citations

Time of arrival in quantum mechanics

Norbert Grot, Carlo Rovelli C, Ranjeet S. Tate

We study the problem of computing the probability for the time of arrival of a quantum particle at a given spatial position. We consider a solution to this problem based on the spectral decomposition of the particle's (Heisenberg) state into the eigenstates of a suitable operator, which we denote as the ``time-of-arrival'' operator. We discuss the general properties of this operator. We construct the operator explicitly in the simple case of a free nonrelativistic particle and compare the probabilities it yields with the ones estimated indirectly in terms of the flux of the Schr\"odinger current. We derive a well-defined uncertainty relation between time of arrival and energy; this result shows that the well-known arguments against the existence of such a relation can be circumvented. Finally, we define a ``time representation'' of the quantum mechanics of a free particle, in which the time of arrival is diagonal. Our results suggest that, contrary to what is commonly assumed, quantum mechanics exhibits a hidden equivalence between independent (time) and dependent (position) variables, analogous to the one revealed by the parametrized formalism in classical mechanics. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

arXiv:quant-ph/9603021•Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1996•207 citations

Evolução sem evolução: assimetria e a emergência do tempo na teoria quântica

Tiago Martinelli

In quantum theory it is usual one refers to the probability of finding a particle between the positions x and x + dx at time t, although the theory does not provide when detection occurs.In the primordies of the theory, Pauli presented an argument refuting the idea of introducing an operator describing the probability of the instant in which the detection occurs.Later, Page and Wootters, motivated by the fact that one is not able to observe energy eigenstates superposition, presented a non-relativistic quantum formalism in an extended space in which space and time play equivalent roles, being consistent with Pauli's inquiries.This leads to a description given by the conditional probability of finding a particle between x and x + dx in respect to the time [t, t + dt] given by another particle, called the clock particle.This dissertation consists in a review of the Page and Wootters proposal to address the time problem in quantum mechanics as well as a detailed analysis of this using recent tools introduced in the area of quantum information for the treatment of symmetries in physics.

•May 18, 2017•0 citations

Quantum time and spatial localization

Francis S. G. Von Zuben

The concept of position and its measurement are fundamental to modern navigation technology as well as to theoretical physics. Nevertheless, a consistent notion of position has not been found in modern physics because of apparent inconsistencies between quantum mechanics and relativity. In quantum mechanics the probability distribution for a particle's position is determined by its wave function. A wave function strictly localized in space describes a particle within that locality, and nowhere else. But the quantum equations of motion predict the function will disperse, after any length of time at all, to occupy all space. Therefore the theoretical prediction is that, shortly after detection in a laboratory, a particle may be found anywhere in the universe, including regions requiring faster-than-light travel to reach. This contradicts the theory of relativity, which precludes a body traveling faster than the speed of light. The conflict arises from unexamined assumptions regarding the time of the measurement event and the time of the system under measurement. The prevailing view in physics is that time is only a parameter, having a definite value, describing dynamic changes in physical systems. This view endures even though quantum mechanics recognizes position as a quantum variable with inherent uncertainty, and relativity indicates that time should be placed on the same footing as position. But if time is recognized as a quantum variable with inherent uncertainty, the conceptual problems with position are resolved. The particle has finite probability of being in the past (or future) of the observer, while the quantum mechanical operator describing the position measurement contains a term which extrapolates from the intrinsic time of the particle to the time of the observer. Being potentially well in the past of the measurement event, the particle has time to travel to remote regions without exceeding the speed of light, and the conflict with relativity is resolved. A relativistic quantum theory can therefore be constructed incorporating a well-defined concept of position.

IEEE/ION Position Location and Navigation Symposium•Nov 7, 2002•0 citations

Time as an observable in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics

G. E. Hahne

The nonrelativistic Schrödinger equation for motion of a structureless particle in four-dimensional spacetime entails a well-known expression for the conserved four-vector field of local probability density and current that are associated with a quantum state solution to the equation. Under the physical assumption that each spatial, as well as the temporal, component of this current is observable, the position in time becomes an operator and an observable in that the weighted average value of the time of the particle's crossing of a complete hyperplane can be simply defined: the theory predicts, and experiment is presumed to be able to observe, the integral over the hyperplane of the normal component of probability current, weighted by the time coordinate. In conventional formulations the hyperplane is always spacelike, i.e. is a time = constant hyperplane in the Galilean relativity, and the result is then trivial. A nontrivial result is obtained if the plane is not of this type. When the spacetime coordinates are ( t , x , y , z ), the paper analyses in detail the case that the hyperplane is of the type z = constant. Particles can cross such a hyperplane in either direction, so it proves convenient to introduce an indefinite metric, and correspondingly a sesquilinear inner product with non-Hilbert space structure, for the space of quantum states on such a surface. Since the metric is indefinite, an uncertainty principle involving the dispersion of the crossing time and the dispersion of its conjugate momentum does not appear to be derivable from the theory. A detailed formalism for computing average crossing times on a z = constant hyperplane, and average dwell times and delay times between a pair of z = constant hyperplanes, is presented.

arXiv:quant-ph/0404012•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jun 11, 2003•6 citations
In quantum theory we refer to the probability of finding a particle between positions xxx and x+dxx+dxx+dx at the instant ttt, although we have no capacity of predicting exactly when the detection occurs. In this work, we first present an extended nonrelativistic quantum formalism where space and time play equivalent roles. It leads to the probability of finding a particle between xxx and x+dxx+dxx+dx during [t,t+dtt,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}t+dtt,t+dt]. Then, we find a Schr"odinger-like equation for a ``mirror'' wave function \ensuremathϕ(t,x)\ensuremath{\phi}(t,x)\ensuremathϕ(t,x) associated with the probability of measuring the system between ttt and t+dtt+dtt+dt, given that detection occurs at xxx. In this framework, it is shown that energy measurements of a stationary state display a nonzero dispersion, and that energy-time uncertainty arises from first principles. We show that a central result on arrival time, obtained through approaches that resort to ad hoc assumptions, is a natural, built-in part of the formalism presented here.
An alternative quantization rule, in which time becomes a self-adjoint operator and position is a parameter, was proposed by Dias and Parisio [Phys. Rev. A 95, 032133 (2017)]. In this approach, the authors derived a space-time-symmetric (STS) extension of quantum mechanics (QM) where a new quantum state (intrinsic to the particle) $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ is defined at each point in space. The quantum state $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ obeys a space-conditional (SC) Schr\"odinger equation and its projection on $|t\ensuremath{\rangle}, \ensuremath{\langle}t|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$, represents the probability amplitude of the particle's arrival time at xxx. In this work we provide an interpretation of the SC Schr\"odinger equation and the eigenstates of observables in the STS extension. Analogous to the usual QM, we propose that by knowing the initial state $|\ensuremath{\phi}({x}_{0})\ensuremath{\rangle}$, which predicts any measurement on the particle performed by a detector localized at x0{x}_{0}x0​, the SC Schr\"odinger equation provides $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}=\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{\mathbb{U}}(x,{x}_{0})|\ensuremath{\phi}({x}_{0})\ensuremath{\rangle}$, enabling us to predict measurements when the detector is at $x\ensuremath{\lessgtr}{x}_{0}$. We also verify that for space-dependent potentials, momentum eigenstates in the STS extension $|{P}_{b}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ depend on position just as energy eigenstates in the usual QM depend on time for time-dependent potentials. In this context, whereas a particle in the momentum eigenstate in the standard QM, $|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)\ensuremath{\rangle}={|P\ensuremath{\rangle}|}_{t}$, at time ttt, has momentum PPP (and indefinite position), the same particle in the state $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}=|{P}_{b}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ arrives at position xxx with momentum Pb(x){P}_{b}(x)Pb​(x) (and indefinite arrival time). By investigating the fact that $|\ensuremath{\psi}(t)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ and $|\ensuremath{\phi}(x)\ensuremath{\rangle}$ describe experimental data of the same observables collected at ttt and xxx, respectively, we conclude that they provide complementary information about the same particle. Finally, we solve the SC Schr\"odinger equation for an arbitrary space-dependent potential. We apply this solution to a potential barrier and compare it with a generalized Kijowski distribution, showing that they can predict distinct traversal times.
We generalize a space-time-symmetric (STS) extension of non-relativistic quantum mechanics (QM) to describe a particle moving in three spatial dimensions. In addition to the conventional time-conditional (Schrödinger) wave function ψ(x,y,z∣t)ψ(x, y, z | t)ψ(x,y,z∣t), we introduce space-conditional wave functions such as ϕ(t,y,z∣x)ϕ(t, y, z | x)ϕ(t,y,z∣x), where xxx plays the role of the evolution parameter. The function ϕ(t,y,z∣x)ϕ(t, y, z | x)ϕ(t,y,z∣x) represents the probability amplitude for the particle to arrive on the plane x=constantx = \text{constant}x=constant at time ttt and transverse position (y,z)(y, z)(y,z). Within this framework, the coordinate xμ∈{t,x,y,z}x^μ\in \{t, x, y, z\}xμ∈{t,x,y,z} can be conveniently chosen as the evolution parameter, depending on the experimental context under consideration. This leads to a unified formalism governed by a generalized Schrödinger-type equation, P^μ∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩=−iℏ ημνddxν∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩\hat{P}^μ |ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangle = -i\hbar \, η^{μν} \frac{d}{dx^ν} |ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangleP^μ∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩=−iℏημνdxνd​∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩. It reproduces standard QM when xμ=tx^μ= txμ=t, with ∣ϕ0(x0)⟩=∣ψ(t)⟩|ϕ^0(x^0)\rangle = |ψ(t)\rangle∣ϕ0(x0)⟩=∣ψ(t)⟩, and recovers the STS extension when xμ=xi∈{x,y,z}x^μ= x^i \in \{x, y, z\}xμ=xi∈{x,y,z}. For a free particle, we show that ϕ(t,y,z∣x)=⟨t,y,z∣ϕ(x)⟩ϕ(t, y, z | x) = \langle t, y, z | ϕ(x) \rangleϕ(t,y,z∣x)=⟨t,y,z∣ϕ(x)⟩ naturally reproduces the same dependence on the momentum wave function as the axiomatic Kijowski distribution. Possible experimental tests of these predictions are discussed. Finally, we demonstrate that the different states ∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩|ϕ^μ(x^μ)\rangle∣ϕμ(xμ)⟩ can emerge by conditioning (i.e., projecting) a timeless and spaceless physical state onto the eigenstate ∣xμ⟩|x^μ\rangle∣xμ⟩, leading to constraint equations of the form P^μ∣Φμ⟩=0\hat{\mathbb{P}}^μ|Φ^μ\rangle = 0P^μ∣Φμ⟩=0. This formulation generalizes the spirit of the Wheeler-DeWitt-type equation: instead of privileging time as the sole evolution parameter, it treats all coordinates on equal footing.
We study the problem of computing the probability for the time of arrival of a quantum particle at a given spatial position. We consider a solution to this problem based on the spectral decomposition of the particle's (Heisenberg) state into the eigenstates of a suitable operator, which we denote as the ``time-of-arrival'' operator. We discuss the general properties of this operator. We construct the operator explicitly in the simple case of a free nonrelativistic particle and compare the probabilities it yields with the ones estimated indirectly in terms of the flux of the Schr\"odinger current. We derive a well-defined uncertainty relation between time of arrival and energy; this result shows that the well-known arguments against the existence of such a relation can be circumvented. Finally, we define a ``time representation'' of the quantum mechanics of a free particle, in which the time of arrival is diagonal. Our results suggest that, contrary to what is commonly assumed, quantum mechanics exhibits a hidden equivalence between independent (time) and dependent (position) variables, analogous to the one revealed by the parametrized formalism in classical mechanics. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
In quantum theory it is usual one refers to the probability of finding a particle between the positions x and x + dx at time t, although the theory does not provide when detection occurs.In the primordies of the theory, Pauli presented an argument refuting the idea of introducing an operator describing the probability of the instant in which the detection occurs.Later, Page and Wootters, motivated by the fact that one is not able to observe energy eigenstates superposition, presented a non-relativistic quantum formalism in an extended space in which space and time play equivalent roles, being consistent with Pauli's inquiries.This leads to a description given by the conditional probability of finding a particle between x and x + dx in respect to the time [t, t + dt] given by another particle, called the clock particle.This dissertation consists in a review of the Page and Wootters proposal to address the time problem in quantum mechanics as well as a detailed analysis of this using recent tools introduced in the area of quantum information for the treatment of symmetries in physics.
The concept of position and its measurement are fundamental to modern navigation technology as well as to theoretical physics. Nevertheless, a consistent notion of position has not been found in modern physics because of apparent inconsistencies between quantum mechanics and relativity. In quantum mechanics the probability distribution for a particle's position is determined by its wave function. A wave function strictly localized in space describes a particle within that locality, and nowhere else. But the quantum equations of motion predict the function will disperse, after any length of time at all, to occupy all space. Therefore the theoretical prediction is that, shortly after detection in a laboratory, a particle may be found anywhere in the universe, including regions requiring faster-than-light travel to reach. This contradicts the theory of relativity, which precludes a body traveling faster than the speed of light. The conflict arises from unexamined assumptions regarding the time of the measurement event and the time of the system under measurement. The prevailing view in physics is that time is only a parameter, having a definite value, describing dynamic changes in physical systems. This view endures even though quantum mechanics recognizes position as a quantum variable with inherent uncertainty, and relativity indicates that time should be placed on the same footing as position. But if time is recognized as a quantum variable with inherent uncertainty, the conceptual problems with position are resolved. The particle has finite probability of being in the past (or future) of the observer, while the quantum mechanical operator describing the position measurement contains a term which extrapolates from the intrinsic time of the particle to the time of the observer. Being potentially well in the past of the measurement event, the particle has time to travel to remote regions without exceeding the speed of light, and the conflict with relativity is resolved. A relativistic quantum theory can therefore be constructed incorporating a well-defined concept of position.
The nonrelativistic Schrödinger equation for motion of a structureless particle in four-dimensional spacetime entails a well-known expression for the conserved four-vector field of local probability density and current that are associated with a quantum state solution to the equation. Under the physical assumption that each spatial, as well as the temporal, component of this current is observable, the position in time becomes an operator and an observable in that the weighted average value of the time of the particle's crossing of a complete hyperplane can be simply defined: the theory predicts, and experiment is presumed to be able to observe, the integral over the hyperplane of the normal component of probability current, weighted by the time coordinate. In conventional formulations the hyperplane is always spacelike, i.e. is a time = constant hyperplane in the Galilean relativity, and the result is then trivial. A nontrivial result is obtained if the plane is not of this type. When the spacetime coordinates are ( t , x , y , z ), the paper analyses in detail the case that the hyperplane is of the type z = constant. Particles can cross such a hyperplane in either direction, so it proves convenient to introduce an indefinite metric, and correspondingly a sesquilinear inner product with non-Hilbert space structure, for the space of quantum states on such a surface. Since the metric is indefinite, an uncertainty principle involving the dispersion of the crossing time and the dispersion of its conjugate momentum does not appear to be derivable from the theory. A detailed formalism for computing average crossing times on a z = constant hyperplane, and average dwell times and delay times between a pair of z = constant hyperplanes, is presented.