Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2211.03205 · Entropy

On the Complete Description of Entangled Systems Part II: The (Meta)Physical Status and Semantic Aspects

Karl Svozil

Published Nov 25, 2022• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We review some semantical aspects of probability bounds from Boole's "conditions on possible experience" violated by quantum mechanics. We also speculate about emerging space-time categories as an epiphenomenon of quantization and the resulting breakdown of relativity theory by non-unitary and non-linear processes.
DOI
10.3390/e24121724

Related papers

Quantum Information and Locality

Dennis Dieks

The surprising aspects of quantum information are due to two distinctly non-classical features of the quantum world: first, different quantum states need not be orthogonal and, second, quantum states may be entangled. Non-orthogonality leads to the blurring of classical distinctions. On the other hand, entanglement leads via non-locality to teleportation and other ``entanglement-assisted'' forms of communication that go beyond what is classically possible. In this article we attempt to understand these new possibilities via an analysis of the significance of entanglement for the basic physical concepts of a ``particle'' and a ``localized physical system''. Classical particles can be individuated on the basis of qualitative differences in their sets of properties. But in entangled states the ``particle labels'' of the quantum formalism usually do not pick out such sets of individuating particle properties. It is sometimes nevertheless possible to think in terms of individual particles, which may be localized; but we argue that in general the structure of quantum mechanics is at odds with such a particle interpretation. This finally leads us to the conclusion that quantum mechanics is best seen as not belonging to the category of space-time theories, in which physical quantities are functions on space-time points. The resulting picture of the quantum world is relevant for our understanding of the way in which quantum theory is non-local, and it sheds light on the novel aspects of quantum information.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 24, 2017•5 citations

Logical Views of Bell Inequalities

Zeno Toffano

Bell's Inequalites structure can be considered in a logical-probabilistic framework, as outlined by Pitowsky [1], where the origin of the inequality was attributed to George Boole’s “conditions of possible experience”. The inequality has then been often renamed the Bell-Boole inequality. An interesting fact is that G. Boole’s method used to establish his probability inequalities stems directly from his mathematical treatment of logic using idempotent symbols (which he called “elective symbols”). The “Boolean Algebra” we consider today bears some major differences with Boole’s original method as thoroughly discussed by Hailperin [2].We proposed recently the “Eigenlogic” approach [3] where we translate Boole’s original logical method to linear algebra using idempotent and also unitary operators and outline the bridges to quantum theories in particular to quantum information [4]. Eigenlogic can thus be a framework for transposing logic in a quantum context, the probabilistic aspects are then simply derived by measurements on logical operators using the Born rule.Bell Inequalities (BI) can be expressed in an operator form where the measurement observables of an experiment are combined to form Bell operators, the outcomes are then derived by using the quantum mechanical mean value (again the Born rule). The popular form adapted for this method is the CHSH form of the BI for spin 1/2 particles or polarized photons with outcomes ±1. Using the isomorphism between idempotent and self-inverse unitary operators (Householder transform) the CHSH Bell operator transforms in Eigenlogic in a combination of idempotent operators from which by using the Born rule one gets the Fine inequality on probabilities.As stated by Khrennikov [5] the BI violation occurs only when incompatible (non-commuting) observables are used in the BI associated experiments. Particularly in the CHSH-BI experiments on an entangled state, mutually unbiased bases (MUB), representing maximally dissimilar contexts, lead to the maximum quantum violation represented by the number 2√2>2. This is the case for the couple of MUB (z,x) associated to Pauli spin operators σ_x and σ_z. In Eigenlogic these (z,x) contexts represent dual logical systems which are at interplay and have an original syntax-semantic interpretation [4]. It has to be outlined that in many quantum algorithms the MUB (z,x), linked by the Hadamard gate which represents the Fourier Transformation between the two bases, provides a quantum algorithmic advantage.The situations of the BI in the so called post-quantum regime are also analyzed by generalizing the concept of PR-Box which relates outputs (a,b) to inputs (x,y) in a two-party correlation by means of the logical equation: a⊕b=x∧y. Using Eigenlogic, families of boxes with all possible combinations of logical functions are analyzed through the equations: f(a,b)=g(x,y), where f and g correspond to the 16 different Boolean functions, giving 256 possible logical equations. The logical equations are transformed in logical operators and used to define the associated Bell operator. 16 cases of the PR-Box type (considering all the possible complementations of the variables a,b,x,y) violate the CHSH-BI maximally with the number 4>2√2 (Tsirelson’s bound). Another family of 32 logical cases gives a CHSH-BI violation of 3.33 also beyond the quantum limit; this is the case for the logical equation: a∨b=x∧y.[1] Pitowsky, I., George Boole’s ‘conditions of possible experience’ and the quantum puzzle. Brit. J. Phil. Sci., 45:95–125 (1994).[2] Hailperin, T. Boole’s Algebra isn’t Boolean algebra. A description using modern algebra, of what Boole really did create. Math. Mag. 54(4): 172–184 (1981).[3] Toffano, Z. Eigenlogic in the Spirit of George Boole. Log. Univers. 14, 175–207 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11787-020-00252-3[4] Toffano, Z.; Dubois, F. Adapting Logic to Physics: The Quantum-Like Eigenlogic Program. Entropy 2020, 22, 139. https://doi.org/10.3390/e22020139[5] Khrennikov, A. Contextuality, Complementarity, Signaling, and Bell Tests. Entropy 2022, 24, 1380. https://doi.org/10.3390/e24101380

•Jun 13, 2023•0 citations

Notes on a future quantum event-ontology

Sebastian Horvat

This essay is a two-step reflection on the question 'Which events (can be said to) occur in quantum phenomena?' The first step regiments the ontological category of "statistical phenomena" and studies the adequacy of "probabilistic event models" as descriptions thereof. Guided by the conviction that quantum phenomena are to be circumscribed within this same ontological category, the second step highlights the peculiarities of probabilistic event models of some non-relativistic quantum phenomena, and thereby of what appear to be some plausible answers to our initial question. The reflection ends in an aporetic state, as it is by now usual in encounters between ontology and the quantum.

arXiv:2502.08823•Feb 12, 2025•1 citation

On the Complete Description Of Entangled Systems Part I–Exploring Hidden Variables and Context Communication Cost in Simulating Quantum Correlations

Karl Svozil

Abstract In this article, we investigate classical simulations of quantum-type probabilities and correlations that defy Boole’s conditions of possible experience, specifically the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality, and even surpass the Tsirelson bound. We demonstrate that such violations can be achieved by encoding a single bit to communicate the measurement context. Our findings highlight the crucial role of context communication in reproducing quantum correlations that are stronger than classical limits, providing insights into the fundamental principles underlying entangled systems.

arXiv:2209.09590•International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Jan 15, 2024•4 citations

Quantum Physics and Reality

Rudolf Haag

Abstract Apparent paradoxes in Quantum Physics demand a sharp distinction between a "real part of the world" and the realm of possibilities. In the former we may distinguish individual elements (coarse events) relating to space-time, with causal connections between them respecting the relativistic locality principle. The latter, quantitatively described by probability assignments conditioned on existing facts and depending on the definition of equivalence classes of situations, cannot be subdivided in space-time categories. There are global correlations (Pauli principle...). The cut between the realms of facts and possibilities implies an evolutionary picture of the "real world" in which the (generalized) arrow of time assumes basic significance. Some deficiencies of existing theory are pointed out.

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A•Feb 1, 2001•3 citations

Stability, Boundary Observability, and Emergent Probability in Deterministic Systems

William Andrew Lawrence

This paper is Part II of The Pre-Emergence Origin of Probability trilogy. Part I develops the structural requirements for finite recurrent stability before spacetime. Part II asks when persistent boundary-readable structure can support numerical probability. Part III examines what probability-status remains after boundary loss, before numerical weighting, and under what narrower conditions Born-form weighting may follow. The paper analyzes how probability-measure status may arise within a closed deterministic description rather than being assumed as a primitive numerical rule. A closed description cannot appeal to an external observer, hidden weighting convention, retained label, post-outcome selection, or independently supplied probability measure to explain its own probability assignments. Numerical probability must instead be supported by structures and relations admitted within the described system. The analysis begins with the requirements for persistent structured identity. Persistent identity is treated as recoverable cross-state relational distinction rather than exact sameness, repeated naming, scalar aggregation, or externally preserved memory. Within the tested structural registry, persistent refinable identity requires ordered dependence, a sufficient stabilization architecture, distributed relational structure, recurrence, bounded recoverability, and noncollapse of the distinctions being preserved. Bounded recurrent relational correction is classified as weak oscillatory form in a deliberately structural sense. The classification does not establish a physical wave, sinusoidal motion, exact periodicity, frequency, propagation, dynamics, mechanism operation, or physical carrier. It identifies a recurrent recoverability architecture that a later realization would have to preserve. The paper then develops the transition from persistent structure to boundary observability. Representation-sensitive bulk descriptions may depend on phase origin, refinement history, decomposition, internal labels, subpart identity, or other distinctions that do not survive admissible boundary readout. Under admissible-observable indistinguishability, boundary-readable observables factor through an emergence-boundary quotient that preserves only the distinctions carried by the admitted observable family and surviving the declared transport relation. The boundary quotient does not itself provide probability. It supplies a local architecture of boundary-readable alternatives and permits the admission of candidate nonnegative contribution scalars. Neither the alternative carrier nor a candidate scalar establishes scalar uniqueness, scalar closure, additivity, measure realization, normalization, or probability interpretation. Numerical probability-measure status becomes available only under a narrower cumulative condition package. The package requires an exact finite carrier, a finite positive event measure, a normalized scalar component on the same carrier, exact scalar-measure compatibility, one-scalar factorization of every admitted weight-bearing map, exclusion of independent weight-bearing invariants, pre-outcome assignment, absence of an external weighting source, and a declared scalar-only predictive regime. Additivity, commensurability, regularity, positive scale, finite nonzero total, and normalization remain separately controlled conditions within that route. Under those conditions, normalized scalar weights may receive conditional probability-measure status inside the declared local regime. This is not an unconditional derivation of probability from determinism. The result does not establish unrestricted probability, universal scalar representation, a global probability law, objective chance, stochastic dynamics, collapse, measurement theory, physical realization, or a final physical theory. Within the trilogy, Part II therefore supplies the middle structural layer: persistent recurrent structuretoboundary-readable alternativestocandidate scalar contenttoconditional numerical probability-measure status. Part III begins from a different question. It examines what remains when a boundary-readable description loses the ability to guarantee which admissible alternative obtains, before any numerical scalarization is supplied. Part II provides the scalar, measure, normalization, compatibility, and realization-burden architecture inherited by that later analysis, but it does not pre-establish the boundary-loss results of Part III. ### Revision note This revision is a substantial reconstruction and trilogy integration rather than a minor editorial update. The derivational architecture, definitions, condition packages, failure boundaries, dependency order, and claim-scope controls have been revised throughout. The manuscript has also been rewritten in new prose to present the argument as Part II of The Pre-Emergence Origin of Probability trilogy. Major changes include a clearer separation of persistent identity, ordered dependence, stabilization, distributed relational recurrence, weak oscillatory form, boundary observability, candidate scalar status, scalar closure, measure realization, normalization, and conditional probability-measure status. The emergence-boundary quotient and transport-survival architecture have been clarified, and the numerical-probability result has been narrowed to an expressly declared scalar-only predictive regime satisfying the complete carrier, measure, compatibility, factorization, pre-outcome, and independent-invariant exclusion conditions. The revision also strengthens the distinction between candidate weights, normalized weights, conditional measures, and probability interpretation. It adds more precise failure localization, preserves the distinction between conditioned failure and universal impossibility, and expands the realization-burden architecture separating mechanism satisfaction, physical scalar selection, boundary enforcement, branch generation, refinement implementation, physical realization, theory-specific realization, empirical validation, and final physical-theory status. The paper is now explicitly positioned between Part I, which establishes the structural requirements for finite recurrent stability before spacetime, and Part III, which develops boundary-unresolved and pre-numerical probability-status after recoverability loss. The central research program remains mechanism-neutral. No physical mechanism, collapse process, specific realization theory, unrestricted probability law, or empirical validation is claimed.

•May 2, 2026•4 citations
The surprising aspects of quantum information are due to two distinctly non-classical features of the quantum world: first, different quantum states need not be orthogonal and, second, quantum states may be entangled. Non-orthogonality leads to the blurring of classical distinctions. On the other hand, entanglement leads via non-locality to teleportation and other ``entanglement-assisted'' forms of communication that go beyond what is classically possible. In this article we attempt to understand these new possibilities via an analysis of the significance of entanglement for the basic physical concepts of a ``particle'' and a ``localized physical system''. Classical particles can be individuated on the basis of qualitative differences in their sets of properties. But in entangled states the ``particle labels'' of the quantum formalism usually do not pick out such sets of individuating particle properties. It is sometimes nevertheless possible to think in terms of individual particles, which may be localized; but we argue that in general the structure of quantum mechanics is at odds with such a particle interpretation. This finally leads us to the conclusion that quantum mechanics is best seen as not belonging to the category of space-time theories, in which physical quantities are functions on space-time points. The resulting picture of the quantum world is relevant for our understanding of the way in which quantum theory is non-local, and it sheds light on the novel aspects of quantum information.
Bell's Inequalites structure can be considered in a logical-probabilistic framework, as outlined by Pitowsky [1], where the origin of the inequality was attributed to George Boole’s “conditions of possible experience”. The inequality has then been often renamed the Bell-Boole inequality. An interesting fact is that G. Boole’s method used to establish his probability inequalities stems directly from his mathematical treatment of logic using idempotent symbols (which he called “elective symbols”). The “Boolean Algebra” we consider today bears some major differences with Boole’s original method as thoroughly discussed by Hailperin [2].We proposed recently the “Eigenlogic” approach [3] where we translate Boole’s original logical method to linear algebra using idempotent and also unitary operators and outline the bridges to quantum theories in particular to quantum information [4]. Eigenlogic can thus be a framework for transposing logic in a quantum context, the probabilistic aspects are then simply derived by measurements on logical operators using the Born rule.Bell Inequalities (BI) can be expressed in an operator form where the measurement observables of an experiment are combined to form Bell operators, the outcomes are then derived by using the quantum mechanical mean value (again the Born rule). The popular form adapted for this method is the CHSH form of the BI for spin 1/2 particles or polarized photons with outcomes ±1. Using the isomorphism between idempotent and self-inverse unitary operators (Householder transform) the CHSH Bell operator transforms in Eigenlogic in a combination of idempotent operators from which by using the Born rule one gets the Fine inequality on probabilities.As stated by Khrennikov [5] the BI violation occurs only when incompatible (non-commuting) observables are used in the BI associated experiments. Particularly in the CHSH-BI experiments on an entangled state, mutually unbiased bases (MUB), representing maximally dissimilar contexts, lead to the maximum quantum violation represented by the number 2√2>2. This is the case for the couple of MUB (z,x) associated to Pauli spin operators σ_x and σ_z. In Eigenlogic these (z,x) contexts represent dual logical systems which are at interplay and have an original syntax-semantic interpretation [4]. It has to be outlined that in many quantum algorithms the MUB (z,x), linked by the Hadamard gate which represents the Fourier Transformation between the two bases, provides a quantum algorithmic advantage.The situations of the BI in the so called post-quantum regime are also analyzed by generalizing the concept of PR-Box which relates outputs (a,b) to inputs (x,y) in a two-party correlation by means of the logical equation: a⊕b=x∧y. Using Eigenlogic, families of boxes with all possible combinations of logical functions are analyzed through the equations: f(a,b)=g(x,y), where f and g correspond to the 16 different Boolean functions, giving 256 possible logical equations. The logical equations are transformed in logical operators and used to define the associated Bell operator. 16 cases of the PR-Box type (considering all the possible complementations of the variables a,b,x,y) violate the CHSH-BI maximally with the number 4>2√2 (Tsirelson’s bound). Another family of 32 logical cases gives a CHSH-BI violation of 3.33 also beyond the quantum limit; this is the case for the logical equation: a∨b=x∧y.[1] Pitowsky, I., George Boole’s ‘conditions of possible experience’ and the quantum puzzle. Brit. J. Phil. Sci., 45:95–125 (1994).[2] Hailperin, T. Boole’s Algebra isn’t Boolean algebra. A description using modern algebra, of what Boole really did create. Math. Mag. 54(4): 172–184 (1981).[3] Toffano, Z. Eigenlogic in the Spirit of George Boole. Log. Univers. 14, 175–207 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11787-020-00252-3[4] Toffano, Z.; Dubois, F. Adapting Logic to Physics: The Quantum-Like Eigenlogic Program. Entropy 2020, 22, 139. https://doi.org/10.3390/e22020139[5] Khrennikov, A. Contextuality, Complementarity, Signaling, and Bell Tests. Entropy 2022, 24, 1380. https://doi.org/10.3390/e24101380
This essay is a two-step reflection on the question 'Which events (can be said to) occur in quantum phenomena?' The first step regiments the ontological category of "statistical phenomena" and studies the adequacy of "probabilistic event models" as descriptions thereof. Guided by the conviction that quantum phenomena are to be circumscribed within this same ontological category, the second step highlights the peculiarities of probabilistic event models of some non-relativistic quantum phenomena, and thereby of what appear to be some plausible answers to our initial question. The reflection ends in an aporetic state, as it is by now usual in encounters between ontology and the quantum.
Abstract In this article, we investigate classical simulations of quantum-type probabilities and correlations that defy Boole’s conditions of possible experience, specifically the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality, and even surpass the Tsirelson bound. We demonstrate that such violations can be achieved by encoding a single bit to communicate the measurement context. Our findings highlight the crucial role of context communication in reproducing quantum correlations that are stronger than classical limits, providing insights into the fundamental principles underlying entangled systems.
Abstract Apparent paradoxes in Quantum Physics demand a sharp distinction between a "real part of the world" and the realm of possibilities. In the former we may distinguish individual elements (coarse events) relating to space-time, with causal connections between them respecting the relativistic locality principle. The latter, quantitatively described by probability assignments conditioned on existing facts and depending on the definition of equivalence classes of situations, cannot be subdivided in space-time categories. There are global correlations (Pauli principle...). The cut between the realms of facts and possibilities implies an evolutionary picture of the "real world" in which the (generalized) arrow of time assumes basic significance. Some deficiencies of existing theory are pointed out.
This paper is Part II of The Pre-Emergence Origin of Probability trilogy. Part I develops the structural requirements for finite recurrent stability before spacetime. Part II asks when persistent boundary-readable structure can support numerical probability. Part III examines what probability-status remains after boundary loss, before numerical weighting, and under what narrower conditions Born-form weighting may follow. The paper analyzes how probability-measure status may arise within a closed deterministic description rather than being assumed as a primitive numerical rule. A closed description cannot appeal to an external observer, hidden weighting convention, retained label, post-outcome selection, or independently supplied probability measure to explain its own probability assignments. Numerical probability must instead be supported by structures and relations admitted within the described system. The analysis begins with the requirements for persistent structured identity. Persistent identity is treated as recoverable cross-state relational distinction rather than exact sameness, repeated naming, scalar aggregation, or externally preserved memory. Within the tested structural registry, persistent refinable identity requires ordered dependence, a sufficient stabilization architecture, distributed relational structure, recurrence, bounded recoverability, and noncollapse of the distinctions being preserved. Bounded recurrent relational correction is classified as weak oscillatory form in a deliberately structural sense. The classification does not establish a physical wave, sinusoidal motion, exact periodicity, frequency, propagation, dynamics, mechanism operation, or physical carrier. It identifies a recurrent recoverability architecture that a later realization would have to preserve. The paper then develops the transition from persistent structure to boundary observability. Representation-sensitive bulk descriptions may depend on phase origin, refinement history, decomposition, internal labels, subpart identity, or other distinctions that do not survive admissible boundary readout. Under admissible-observable indistinguishability, boundary-readable observables factor through an emergence-boundary quotient that preserves only the distinctions carried by the admitted observable family and surviving the declared transport relation. The boundary quotient does not itself provide probability. It supplies a local architecture of boundary-readable alternatives and permits the admission of candidate nonnegative contribution scalars. Neither the alternative carrier nor a candidate scalar establishes scalar uniqueness, scalar closure, additivity, measure realization, normalization, or probability interpretation. Numerical probability-measure status becomes available only under a narrower cumulative condition package. The package requires an exact finite carrier, a finite positive event measure, a normalized scalar component on the same carrier, exact scalar-measure compatibility, one-scalar factorization of every admitted weight-bearing map, exclusion of independent weight-bearing invariants, pre-outcome assignment, absence of an external weighting source, and a declared scalar-only predictive regime. Additivity, commensurability, regularity, positive scale, finite nonzero total, and normalization remain separately controlled conditions within that route. Under those conditions, normalized scalar weights may receive conditional probability-measure status inside the declared local regime. This is not an unconditional derivation of probability from determinism. The result does not establish unrestricted probability, universal scalar representation, a global probability law, objective chance, stochastic dynamics, collapse, measurement theory, physical realization, or a final physical theory. Within the trilogy, Part II therefore supplies the middle structural layer: persistent recurrent structuretoboundary-readable alternativestocandidate scalar contenttoconditional numerical probability-measure status. Part III begins from a different question. It examines what remains when a boundary-readable description loses the ability to guarantee which admissible alternative obtains, before any numerical scalarization is supplied. Part II provides the scalar, measure, normalization, compatibility, and realization-burden architecture inherited by that later analysis, but it does not pre-establish the boundary-loss results of Part III. ### Revision note This revision is a substantial reconstruction and trilogy integration rather than a minor editorial update. The derivational architecture, definitions, condition packages, failure boundaries, dependency order, and claim-scope controls have been revised throughout. The manuscript has also been rewritten in new prose to present the argument as Part II of The Pre-Emergence Origin of Probability trilogy. Major changes include a clearer separation of persistent identity, ordered dependence, stabilization, distributed relational recurrence, weak oscillatory form, boundary observability, candidate scalar status, scalar closure, measure realization, normalization, and conditional probability-measure status. The emergence-boundary quotient and transport-survival architecture have been clarified, and the numerical-probability result has been narrowed to an expressly declared scalar-only predictive regime satisfying the complete carrier, measure, compatibility, factorization, pre-outcome, and independent-invariant exclusion conditions. The revision also strengthens the distinction between candidate weights, normalized weights, conditional measures, and probability interpretation. It adds more precise failure localization, preserves the distinction between conditioned failure and universal impossibility, and expands the realization-burden architecture separating mechanism satisfaction, physical scalar selection, boundary enforcement, branch generation, refinement implementation, physical realization, theory-specific realization, empirical validation, and final physical-theory status. The paper is now explicitly positioned between Part I, which establishes the structural requirements for finite recurrent stability before spacetime, and Part III, which develops boundary-unresolved and pre-numerical probability-status after recoverability loss. The central research program remains mechanism-neutral. No physical mechanism, collapse process, specific realization theory, unrestricted probability law, or empirical validation is claimed.