Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2202.13364

A reconstruction of quantum theory for spinning particles

U. Klein

Published Feb 27, 2022• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

As part of a probabilistic reconstruction of quantum theory (QT), we show that spin is not a purely quantum mechanical phenomenon, as has long been assumed. Rather, this phenomenon occurs before the transition to QT takes place, namely in the area of the quasi-classical (here better quasi-quantum) theory. This borderland between classical physics and QT can be reached within the framework of our reconstruction by the replacement $p \rightarrow M (q, t)$, where $p$ is the momentum variable of the particle and $M(q, t)$ is the momentum field in configuration space. The occurrence of spin, and its special value $1/2$ , is a consequence of the fact that $M(q,t)$ must have exactly three independent components $M_{k}(q,t)$ for a single particle because of the three-dimensionality of space. In the Schrödinger equation for a "particle with spin zero", the momentum field is usually represented as a gradient of a single function $S$. This implies dependencies between the components $M_{k}(q,t)$ for which no explanation exists. In reality, $M(q,t)$ needs to be represented by three functions, two of which are rotational degrees of freedom. The latter are responsible for the existence of spin. All massive structureless particles in nature must therefore be spin-one-half particles, simply because they have to be described by $4$ real fields, one of which has the physical meaning of a probability density, while the other three are required to represent the momentum field in three-dimensional space. We derive the Pauli-Schrödinger equation, the correct value $g=2$ of the gyromagnetic ratio, the classical limit of the Pauli-Schrödinger equation, and clarify some other open questions in the borderland between classical physics and QT.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2202.13364

Related papers

A reconstruction of quantum theory for nonspinning particles

U. Klein

Within the framework of the individuality interpretation of quantum theory (QT), the basic equations of QT cannot be derived from the basic equations of classical mechanics (CM). The unbridgeable gap between CM and QT is given by the fact that a certain system which is described in CM by a finite number of degrees of freedom requires an infinite number in QT. The standard quantization method, which is conceptually closely linked to the individuality interpretation, is limited to finding structural similarities between observables and operators. The fundamental question \emph{why} one must move from a finite number to an infinite number of degrees of freedom, remains unanswered. This gap can only be closed if probabilistic aspects are already taken into account in the classical area. This may be done by taking the uncertainty in initial conditions into account. In this probabilistic version of mechanics (PM), a system is mathematically described as an ensemble, with an infinite number of degrees of freedom, thus bridging the gap mentioned above. This step then enables the reconstruction of QT, in particular the derivation of the Schrödinger equation, from PM. This work is the third in a series of works in which this program is carried out. The method used here differs from the previous one and allows a better understanding of the structural differences between classical physics and QT. The derivation of the Schrödinger equation essentially takes place in two steps: a projection from phase space to configuration space and a linearization. Some contradictions of the individuality interpretation are analyzed and eliminated from the point of view of the ensemble interpretation.

arXiv:2202.13356•Feb 27, 2022•3 citations

From probabilistic mechanics to quantum theory

U. Klein

We show that quantum theory (QT) is a substructure of classical probabilistic physics. The central quantity of the classical theory is Hamilton’s function, which determines canonical equations, a corresponding flow, and a Liouville equation for a probability density. We extend this theory in two respects: (1) The same structure is defined for arbitrary observables. Thus, we have all of the above entities generated not only by Hamilton’s function but also by every observable. (2) We introduce for each observable a phase space function representing the classical action. This is a redundant quantity in a classical context but indispensable for the transition to QT. The basic equations of the resulting theory take a “quantum-like” form, which allows for a simple derivation of QT by means of a projection to configuration space reported previously [Quantum Stud Math Found 5:219–227, 2018]. We obtain the most important relations of QT, namely the form of operators, Schrödinger’s equation, eigenvalue equations, commutation relations, expectation values, and Born’s rule. Implications for the interpretation of QT are discussed, as well as an alternative projection method allowing for a derivation of spin.

arXiv:1907.08513•Quantum Studies Mathematics and Foundations•Aug 29, 2019•11 citations

The non-relativistic nature of spin in quantum mechanics: a historical and pedagogical perspective

Marco Giliberti, Luisa Lovisetti

Abstract Conventional methods for teaching spin at a university level generally follow four main approaches. The first introduces spin into the Schrödinger equation artificially, leaving its physical meaning unclear. The second connects spin to the representation of the rotation group, which clarifies its nature but requires knowledge of group theory. The third approach derives from field theory, separating angular momentum into orbital and intrinsic parts, the latter corresponding to spin; however, this cannot be done within quantum mechanics alone. The fourth derives electron spin from Dirac’s 1928 relativistic equation, which, though correct, has led to the misconception that spin is a purely relativistic effect. A detailed analysis of Dirac’s 1928 papers shows that the concept of spin arises from the need to construct an equation linear in both energy and momentum to preserve Born’s probabilistic interpretation. This linearization of the Klein–Gordon equation reveals that spin is conceptually independent of relativity. Historical and pedagogical perspectives can together clarify conceptual difficulties and promote a deeper understanding of fundamental ideas in physics. Drawing on selected passages from Dirac’s original work, the present discussion offers broader conceptual and cultural considerations that introduce the notion of spin with limited mathematical requirements and can be applied independently of the didactic approach adopted.

•Aug 27, 2026•0 citations

A Possible Explanation of Spin

Spin is one of the most elusive concepts in physics. It is a property of otherwise indistinguishable particles. Indistinguishability is a classical concept. It implies the existence of a "classical Pauli cell." However, the classical Pauli cell — unlike the quantum Pauli cell — contains not two but only one particle, for classical particles possess no spin, as Pauli stressed. Nevertheless spin arises endophysically — as a property of the "interface" which forms between an observing subsystem and the rest of its Hamiltonian universe, provided the latter is three-dimensional. In a spatially one-dimensional universe, the "micro-time-reversals" in the observer only generate a back-and-forth perturbation in the environment. If the observer is two-dimensional, the micro-time-reversals no longer produce straight perturbations alone. The observer rotates in successive time slices in opposite directions relative to an external particle. The particle therefore performs the opposite rotation, relative to the observer, in the next, time-inverted ("white"), time slice. Nevertheless, the particle seemingly performs the same rotation as in the preceding black (non-time-inverted) time slice, as far as the observer is concerned. For during a white time slice, all external motions are perceived to take place in the opposite direction, as mentioned. Thus all particles always have the same spin in a two-dimensional universe. Two spins arise in three dimensions. A spinning particle now in addition either approaches or recedes from the observer. This makes two otherwise equal particles distinguishable. Since, of particles in random motion, one half approaches and the other half recedes from the observer, they all fall into two different spin classes. More important, two equal particles in adjacent classical Pauli cells tend to have opposite spins. This makes them distinguishable — so that the two now share the combined cell. However, something strange happens during the next time slice: the partner which formerly had the one spin acquires the other and vice versa — the two swap their identities. This is because the direction of external path motions is inverted from one time slice to the next, as mentioned. The two particles become maximally correlated. "Endo" Pauli cells having two correlated occupants therefore exist classically. If the same fact held good in the real world, "most" properties of atoms and molecules (Kossel pairs) and superfluids (Cooper pairs) would be nonexistent exophysically. It would be correct to say: Endochemistry is different from exochemistry.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•May 1, 1998•0 citations

On the role of Spin in Quantum Mechanics

Salvatore Esposito

From the invariance properties of the Schrodinger equation and the isotropy of space we show that a generic (non-relativistic) quantum system is endowed with an ``external'' motion, which can be interpreted as the motion of the centre of mass, and an ``internal'' one, whose presence disappears in the classical limit. The latter is caused by the spin of the particle, whatever is its actual value (different from zero). The quantum potential in the Schrodinger equation, which is responsible of the quantum effects of the system, is then completely determined from the properties of the internal motion, and its ``unusual'' properties have a simple and physical explanation in the present context. From the impossibility to fix the initial conditions relevant for the internal motion follows, finally, the need of a probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:quant-ph/9902019•Feb 5, 1999•7 citations

Classical physics and electron spin

A. G. Chirkov, Igor V. Kazinets

In the framework of classical physics, the formation of the intrinsic angular momentum of an electron is described and the correct value of the gyromagnetic ratio is obtained. The Maslov-Leray quasi-classical quantization rules result in the exact values of Landau levels obtained from the Pauli equation.

Technical Physics•Sep 1, 2000•3 citations
As part of a probabilistic reconstruction of quantum theory (QT), we show that spin is not a purely quantum mechanical phenomenon, as has long been assumed. Rather, this phenomenon occurs before the transition to QT takes place, namely in the area of the quasi-classical (here better quasi-quantum) theory. This borderland between classical physics and QT can be reached within the framework of our reconstruction by the replacement p→M(q,t)p \rightarrow M (q, t)p→M(q,t), where ppp is the momentum variable of the particle and M(q,t)M(q, t)M(q,t) is the momentum field in configuration space. The occurrence of spin, and its special value 1/21/21/2 , is a consequence of the fact that M(q,t)M(q,t)M(q,t) must have exactly three independent components Mk(q,t)M_{k}(q,t)Mk​(q,t) for a single particle because of the three-dimensionality of space. In the Schrödinger equation for a "particle with spin zero", the momentum field is usually represented as a gradient of a single function SSS. This implies dependencies between the components Mk(q,t)M_{k}(q,t)Mk​(q,t) for which no explanation exists. In reality, M(q,t)M(q,t)M(q,t) needs to be represented by three functions, two of which are rotational degrees of freedom. The latter are responsible for the existence of spin. All massive structureless particles in nature must therefore be spin-one-half particles, simply because they have to be described by 444 real fields, one of which has the physical meaning of a probability density, while the other three are required to represent the momentum field in three-dimensional space. We derive the Pauli-Schrödinger equation, the correct value g=2g=2g=2 of the gyromagnetic ratio, the classical limit of the Pauli-Schrödinger equation, and clarify some other open questions in the borderland between classical physics and QT.
Within the framework of the individuality interpretation of quantum theory (QT), the basic equations of QT cannot be derived from the basic equations of classical mechanics (CM). The unbridgeable gap between CM and QT is given by the fact that a certain system which is described in CM by a finite number of degrees of freedom requires an infinite number in QT. The standard quantization method, which is conceptually closely linked to the individuality interpretation, is limited to finding structural similarities between observables and operators. The fundamental question \emph{why} one must move from a finite number to an infinite number of degrees of freedom, remains unanswered. This gap can only be closed if probabilistic aspects are already taken into account in the classical area. This may be done by taking the uncertainty in initial conditions into account. In this probabilistic version of mechanics (PM), a system is mathematically described as an ensemble, with an infinite number of degrees of freedom, thus bridging the gap mentioned above. This step then enables the reconstruction of QT, in particular the derivation of the Schrödinger equation, from PM. This work is the third in a series of works in which this program is carried out. The method used here differs from the previous one and allows a better understanding of the structural differences between classical physics and QT. The derivation of the Schrödinger equation essentially takes place in two steps: a projection from phase space to configuration space and a linearization. Some contradictions of the individuality interpretation are analyzed and eliminated from the point of view of the ensemble interpretation.
We show that quantum theory (QT) is a substructure of classical probabilistic physics. The central quantity of the classical theory is Hamilton’s function, which determines canonical equations, a corresponding flow, and a Liouville equation for a probability density. We extend this theory in two respects: (1) The same structure is defined for arbitrary observables. Thus, we have all of the above entities generated not only by Hamilton’s function but also by every observable. (2) We introduce for each observable a phase space function representing the classical action. This is a redundant quantity in a classical context but indispensable for the transition to QT. The basic equations of the resulting theory take a “quantum-like” form, which allows for a simple derivation of QT by means of a projection to configuration space reported previously [Quantum Stud Math Found 5:219–227, 2018]. We obtain the most important relations of QT, namely the form of operators, Schrödinger’s equation, eigenvalue equations, commutation relations, expectation values, and Born’s rule. Implications for the interpretation of QT are discussed, as well as an alternative projection method allowing for a derivation of spin.
Abstract Conventional methods for teaching spin at a university level generally follow four main approaches. The first introduces spin into the Schrödinger equation artificially, leaving its physical meaning unclear. The second connects spin to the representation of the rotation group, which clarifies its nature but requires knowledge of group theory. The third approach derives from field theory, separating angular momentum into orbital and intrinsic parts, the latter corresponding to spin; however, this cannot be done within quantum mechanics alone. The fourth derives electron spin from Dirac’s 1928 relativistic equation, which, though correct, has led to the misconception that spin is a purely relativistic effect. A detailed analysis of Dirac’s 1928 papers shows that the concept of spin arises from the need to construct an equation linear in both energy and momentum to preserve Born’s probabilistic interpretation. This linearization of the Klein–Gordon equation reveals that spin is conceptually independent of relativity. Historical and pedagogical perspectives can together clarify conceptual difficulties and promote a deeper understanding of fundamental ideas in physics. Drawing on selected passages from Dirac’s original work, the present discussion offers broader conceptual and cultural considerations that introduce the notion of spin with limited mathematical requirements and can be applied independently of the didactic approach adopted.
Spin is one of the most elusive concepts in physics. It is a property of otherwise indistinguishable particles. Indistinguishability is a classical concept. It implies the existence of a "classical Pauli cell." However, the classical Pauli cell — unlike the quantum Pauli cell — contains not two but only one particle, for classical particles possess no spin, as Pauli stressed. Nevertheless spin arises endophysically — as a property of the "interface" which forms between an observing subsystem and the rest of its Hamiltonian universe, provided the latter is three-dimensional. In a spatially one-dimensional universe, the "micro-time-reversals" in the observer only generate a back-and-forth perturbation in the environment. If the observer is two-dimensional, the micro-time-reversals no longer produce straight perturbations alone. The observer rotates in successive time slices in opposite directions relative to an external particle. The particle therefore performs the opposite rotation, relative to the observer, in the next, time-inverted ("white"), time slice. Nevertheless, the particle seemingly performs the same rotation as in the preceding black (non-time-inverted) time slice, as far as the observer is concerned. For during a white time slice, all external motions are perceived to take place in the opposite direction, as mentioned. Thus all particles always have the same spin in a two-dimensional universe. Two spins arise in three dimensions. A spinning particle now in addition either approaches or recedes from the observer. This makes two otherwise equal particles distinguishable. Since, of particles in random motion, one half approaches and the other half recedes from the observer, they all fall into two different spin classes. More important, two equal particles in adjacent classical Pauli cells tend to have opposite spins. This makes them distinguishable — so that the two now share the combined cell. However, something strange happens during the next time slice: the partner which formerly had the one spin acquires the other and vice versa — the two swap their identities. This is because the direction of external path motions is inverted from one time slice to the next, as mentioned. The two particles become maximally correlated. "Endo" Pauli cells having two correlated occupants therefore exist classically. If the same fact held good in the real world, "most" properties of atoms and molecules (Kossel pairs) and superfluids (Cooper pairs) would be nonexistent exophysically. It would be correct to say: Endochemistry is different from exochemistry.
From the invariance properties of the Schrodinger equation and the isotropy of space we show that a generic (non-relativistic) quantum system is endowed with an ``external'' motion, which can be interpreted as the motion of the centre of mass, and an ``internal'' one, whose presence disappears in the classical limit. The latter is caused by the spin of the particle, whatever is its actual value (different from zero). The quantum potential in the Schrodinger equation, which is responsible of the quantum effects of the system, is then completely determined from the properties of the internal motion, and its ``unusual'' properties have a simple and physical explanation in the present context. From the impossibility to fix the initial conditions relevant for the internal motion follows, finally, the need of a probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics.