Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The non-relativistic nature of spin in quantum mechanics: a historical and pedagogical perspective

Marco Giliberti, Luisa Lovisetti

Published Aug 27, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Conventional methods for teaching spin at a university level generally follow four main approaches. The first introduces spin into the Schrödinger equation artificially, leaving its physical meaning unclear. The second connects spin to the representation of the rotation group, which clarifies its nature but requires knowledge of group theory. The third approach derives from field theory, separating angular momentum into orbital and intrinsic parts, the latter corresponding to spin; however, this cannot be done within quantum mechanics alone. The fourth derives electron spin from Dirac’s 1928 relativistic equation, which, though correct, has led to the misconception that spin is a purely relativistic effect. A detailed analysis of Dirac’s 1928 papers shows that the concept of spin arises from the need to construct an equation linear in both energy and momentum to preserve Born’s probabilistic interpretation. This linearization of the Klein–Gordon equation reveals that spin is conceptually independent of relativity. Historical and pedagogical perspectives can together clarify conceptual difficulties and promote a deeper understanding of fundamental ideas in physics. Drawing on selected passages from Dirac’s original work, the present discussion offers broader conceptual and cultural considerations that introduce the notion of spin with limited mathematical requirements and can be applied independently of the didactic approach adopted.

DOI
10.21203/rs.3.rs-10579281/v1

Related papers

Whence spin?

Nicholas Zumbulyadis

Abstract The concept of angular momentum in quantum mechanics has many counterintuitive aspects, such as assuming only certain discrete values and only certain orientations in space in the presence of external fields. Spin is more esoteric yet; it is hard to imagine how point‐particles with no spatial extent can have an intrinsic angular momentum. Nevertheless, spin is the most fundamental concept in magnetic resonance. Appreciation of the spin concept requires some understanding of the relativistic quantum mechanics developed by P. A. M. Dirac. The history of the evolution of the spin concept is traced—from the turn‐of‐the‐century observation of the Zeeman effect, through the old and new quantum mechanics, and on to Dirac's theory of the electron, which was published in the late 1920s. The special relativity theory is discussed, and there is a brief explanation of how spin emerges naturally in a relativistically correct formulation of quantum mechanics.

Concepts in Magnetic Resonance•Apr 1, 1991•3 citations

Elementary relativistic quantum mechanics

Efstratios Manousakis

Abstract This chapter is seeking relativistic wave equations, which are invariant under Lorentz transformations, in an attempt to obtain a quantum mechanical description of relativistic particles. First, the chapter starts with the Klein–Gordon equation and then it discusses the Dirac equation. It also takes the non-relativistic limit of the Dirac equation to derive the Schrödinger equation with two additional terms, the Zeeman term and the spin–orbit coupling term. These two terms emerge naturally from the Dirac equation, and thus the spin, as an internal quantum number which behaves like angular momentum, is clearly identified. Finally, the existence of antimatter is clearly supported by the nature of the solutions to the Dirac equation.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Nov 1, 2015•0 citations

The Dirac equation: historical context, comparisons with the Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon equations, and elementary consequences

Thiago Takaji Tsutsui, Edilberto Oliveira Silva, Antonio S. M. de Castro +1 more

Abstract This paper offers educational insight into the Dirac equation, examining its historical context and contrasting it with the earlier Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon equations. The comparison highlights their Lorentz transformation symmetry and potential probabilistic interpretations. We explicitly solve the free particle dynamics in Dirac’s model, revealing the emergence of solutions with negative energy. In this discussion, we examine the Dirac Sea Hypothesis and explore the inherent helicity of the solutions. Additionally, we demonstrate how the Dirac equation accounts for spin and derive the Pauli equation in the non-relativistic limit. Through the Foldy–Wouthuysen transformation, we reveal how the equation incorporates spin–orbit interaction and other relativistic effects, ultimately leading to the hydrogen fine structure. A section on relativistic covariant notation is included to emphasize the invariance of the Dirac equation, along with more refined formulations of both the Klein–Gordon and Dirac equations. Designed for undergraduate students with an interest in the Dirac equation, this resource provides a historical perspective without being purely theoretical. Our approach underscores the significance of a pedagogical method that combines historical and comparative elements to profoundly understand the role of the Dirac equation in modern physics.

arXiv:2504.17797•European Journal of Physics•Aug 8, 2025•0 citations

On the relativistic concept of the Dirac's electron spin

Nizar Hamdan, A. Chamaa, José Luis López-Bonilla

Despite the success of the Dirac equation, the incorporation of the special theory of relativity into quantum mechanics predicts some paradoxes, like that the spin prediction from Dirac equation can be only identified with non- relativistic approximations (Pauli and Foldy-Wouthysen), as well as the spin predication is a relativistic quantum phenomena because the spin prediction is a necessary requirement of the relativistic quantum mechanics only. In this paper we show that the derivation of the spin and its magnetic moment can be done with a pure classical treatment. Since we start from the classical physical laws and the classical relativity principle to get the linear Schrödinger equation as a result the derivation of the spin and its magnetic moment can be done with a pure classical treatment. This approach result a Schrödinger equation, in which we show that the spin of the electron is a non relativistic quantum phenomenon too.

Latin American journal of physics education•Jan 1, 2008•1 citation

- Relativity and Quantum Mechanics

Alastair I. M. Rae, Jim Napolitano

The early twentieth century saw two major revolutions in the way physicists understand the world. One was quantum mechanics itself and the other was the theory of relativity. Important results also emerged when these two ideas were brought together: some of these have been referred to in earlier chapters-in particular the fact that fundamental particles such as electrons have intrinsic angular momentum (spin) was stated to be a relativistic effect. This chapter explores the relationship between relativity and quantum mechanics more deeply A full understanding of relativistic quantum mechanics is well outside the scope of this book, but many of the important results can be understood at this level and these will be discussed in this chapter. After a short summary of the main results of special relativity, we show how combining this with the time-dependent Schro¨dinger equation leads to a new wave equation known as the Dirac equation. We show how the Dirac equation requires particles such as electrons to have intrinsic angular momentum (spin) and we explore some of its other consequences. The chapter concludes with an outline of some more advanced ideas known as quantum field theory.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 16, 2015•0 citations

Relativistic Schrödinger Equation

Z. Ficek

This chapter introduces the concepts of the relativistic theory to basic problems of quantum physics, in particular, the extension of the Schrodinger equation to a relativistic form. Starting from the fundamental laws of relativity, the chapter evaluates the Klein–Gordon equation and investigates if the equation can be considered a generalization of the non-relativistic Schrodinger equation to the case of the relativistic energy. The chapter shows that the wave function, which is a solution to the Klein–Gordon equation, cannot be connected with the probability wave function. For this reason, the Dirac equation is used to solve the problems faced by the Klein–Gordon equation. The Dirac equation also includes the spin. The advantage of the Dirac equation over the Schrodinger and Klein–Gordon equations is that it naturally includes the spin. In the Schrodinger and Klein–Gordon equations, the spin is not present and has to be added to the wave function manually whenever the wave function determines a system with the spin.

•Mar 3, 2017•0 citations
Abstract Conventional methods for teaching spin at a university level generally follow four main approaches. The first introduces spin into the Schrödinger equation artificially, leaving its physical meaning unclear. The second connects spin to the representation of the rotation group, which clarifies its nature but requires knowledge of group theory. The third approach derives from field theory, separating angular momentum into orbital and intrinsic parts, the latter corresponding to spin; however, this cannot be done within quantum mechanics alone. The fourth derives electron spin from Dirac’s 1928 relativistic equation, which, though correct, has led to the misconception that spin is a purely relativistic effect. A detailed analysis of Dirac’s 1928 papers shows that the concept of spin arises from the need to construct an equation linear in both energy and momentum to preserve Born’s probabilistic interpretation. This linearization of the Klein–Gordon equation reveals that spin is conceptually independent of relativity. Historical and pedagogical perspectives can together clarify conceptual difficulties and promote a deeper understanding of fundamental ideas in physics. Drawing on selected passages from Dirac’s original work, the present discussion offers broader conceptual and cultural considerations that introduce the notion of spin with limited mathematical requirements and can be applied independently of the didactic approach adopted.
Abstract The concept of angular momentum in quantum mechanics has many counterintuitive aspects, such as assuming only certain discrete values and only certain orientations in space in the presence of external fields. Spin is more esoteric yet; it is hard to imagine how point‐particles with no spatial extent can have an intrinsic angular momentum. Nevertheless, spin is the most fundamental concept in magnetic resonance. Appreciation of the spin concept requires some understanding of the relativistic quantum mechanics developed by P. A. M. Dirac. The history of the evolution of the spin concept is traced—from the turn‐of‐the‐century observation of the Zeeman effect, through the old and new quantum mechanics, and on to Dirac's theory of the electron, which was published in the late 1920s. The special relativity theory is discussed, and there is a brief explanation of how spin emerges naturally in a relativistically correct formulation of quantum mechanics.
Abstract This chapter is seeking relativistic wave equations, which are invariant under Lorentz transformations, in an attempt to obtain a quantum mechanical description of relativistic particles. First, the chapter starts with the Klein–Gordon equation and then it discusses the Dirac equation. It also takes the non-relativistic limit of the Dirac equation to derive the Schrödinger equation with two additional terms, the Zeeman term and the spin–orbit coupling term. These two terms emerge naturally from the Dirac equation, and thus the spin, as an internal quantum number which behaves like angular momentum, is clearly identified. Finally, the existence of antimatter is clearly supported by the nature of the solutions to the Dirac equation.
Abstract This paper offers educational insight into the Dirac equation, examining its historical context and contrasting it with the earlier Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon equations. The comparison highlights their Lorentz transformation symmetry and potential probabilistic interpretations. We explicitly solve the free particle dynamics in Dirac’s model, revealing the emergence of solutions with negative energy. In this discussion, we examine the Dirac Sea Hypothesis and explore the inherent helicity of the solutions. Additionally, we demonstrate how the Dirac equation accounts for spin and derive the Pauli equation in the non-relativistic limit. Through the Foldy–Wouthuysen transformation, we reveal how the equation incorporates spin–orbit interaction and other relativistic effects, ultimately leading to the hydrogen fine structure. A section on relativistic covariant notation is included to emphasize the invariance of the Dirac equation, along with more refined formulations of both the Klein–Gordon and Dirac equations. Designed for undergraduate students with an interest in the Dirac equation, this resource provides a historical perspective without being purely theoretical. Our approach underscores the significance of a pedagogical method that combines historical and comparative elements to profoundly understand the role of the Dirac equation in modern physics.
Despite the success of the Dirac equation, the incorporation of the special theory of relativity into quantum mechanics predicts some paradoxes, like that the spin prediction from Dirac equation can be only identified with non- relativistic approximations (Pauli and Foldy-Wouthysen), as well as the spin predication is a relativistic quantum phenomena because the spin prediction is a necessary requirement of the relativistic quantum mechanics only. In this paper we show that the derivation of the spin and its magnetic moment can be done with a pure classical treatment. Since we start from the classical physical laws and the classical relativity principle to get the linear Schrödinger equation as a result the derivation of the spin and its magnetic moment can be done with a pure classical treatment. This approach result a Schrödinger equation, in which we show that the spin of the electron is a non relativistic quantum phenomenon too.
The early twentieth century saw two major revolutions in the way physicists understand the world. One was quantum mechanics itself and the other was the theory of relativity. Important results also emerged when these two ideas were brought together: some of these have been referred to in earlier chapters-in particular the fact that fundamental particles such as electrons have intrinsic angular momentum (spin) was stated to be a relativistic effect. This chapter explores the relationship between relativity and quantum mechanics more deeply A full understanding of relativistic quantum mechanics is well outside the scope of this book, but many of the important results can be understood at this level and these will be discussed in this chapter. After a short summary of the main results of special relativity, we show how combining this with the time-dependent Schro¨dinger equation leads to a new wave equation known as the Dirac equation. We show how the Dirac equation requires particles such as electrons to have intrinsic angular momentum (spin) and we explore some of its other consequences. The chapter concludes with an outline of some more advanced ideas known as quantum field theory.
This chapter introduces the concepts of the relativistic theory to basic problems of quantum physics, in particular, the extension of the Schrodinger equation to a relativistic form. Starting from the fundamental laws of relativity, the chapter evaluates the Klein–Gordon equation and investigates if the equation can be considered a generalization of the non-relativistic Schrodinger equation to the case of the relativistic energy. The chapter shows that the wave function, which is a solution to the Klein–Gordon equation, cannot be connected with the probability wave function. For this reason, the Dirac equation is used to solve the problems faced by the Klein–Gordon equation. The Dirac equation also includes the spin. The advantage of the Dirac equation over the Schrodinger and Klein–Gordon equations is that it naturally includes the spin. In the Schrodinger and Klein–Gordon equations, the spin is not present and has to be added to the wave function manually whenever the wave function determines a system with the spin.