Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1704.08725 · Physical Review A

What quantum measurements measure

Robert B. Griffiths

Published Sep 13, 2017• 46 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A solution to the second measurement problem, determining what prior microscopic properties can be inferred from measurement outcomes (``pointer positions''), is worked out for projective and generalized (POVM) measurements, using consistent histories. The result supports the idea that equipment properly designed and calibrated reveals the properties it was designed to measure. Applications include Einstein's hemisphere and Wheeler's delayed choice paradoxes, and a method for analyzing weak measurements without recourse to weak values. Quantum measurements are noncontextual in the original sense employed by Bell and Mermin: if $[A,B]=[A,C]=0,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}[B,C]\ensuremath{\ne}0$, the outcome of an $A$ measurement does not depend on whether it is measured with $B$ or with $C$. An application to Bohm's model of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen situation suggests that a faulty understanding of quantum measurements is at the root of this paradox.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.96.032110

Related papers

Alternative Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen argument based on premises not falsified by Bell's theorem: weak macroscopic realism and weak local realism

Jesse Fulton, Run Yan Teh, M. D. Reid

The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox gives an argument for the incompleteness of quantum mechanics based on a plausible criterion for reality, as well as the assumption of locality. A general view is that the argument is compromised, because EPR's premises are falsified by Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) and Bell experiments. In this paper, we present an EPR argument based on premises not falsified by these experiments. First, we consider macroscopic EPR-Bohm, Bell, and GHZ experiments using spins ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{S}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ defined by two macroscopically distinct states. The analyzers that realize the unitary operations ${U}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ determining the measurement settings $\ensuremath{\theta}$ are nonlinear devices creating macroscopic superposition states. We note two definitions of macroscopic realism (MR). For a system with two macroscopically distinct states available to it, MR posits a predetermined outcome for the measurement ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{S}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ distinguishing between the states. Deterministic macroscopic realism assumes MR for the system defined prior to the interaction ${U}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ being carried out but is falsifiable by the macroscopic Bell and GHZ proposals. Motivated by arguments to uphold MR (without resorting to decoherence), as well as no-signaling and the properties of a meter, we define a set of premises referred to as weak macroscopic realism (wMR). Weak macroscopic realism (wMR) posits MR for the system after ${U}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$, at the time ${t}_{f}$---when the system is prepared with respect to the measurement basis, ready for a ``pointer'' measurement and readout. For this system, wMR posits that the outcome of ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{S}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ is determined and not changed by interactions that might subsequently occur at a remote system $B$. The premise wMR also posits a weaker version of EPR's criterion for reality. Importantly, we show that the GHZ and Bell predictions are consistent with wMR. Yet, an EPR paradox arises for a macroscopic EPR-Bohm state, based on wMR. As considered by Schr\"odinger, it is possible to measure two complementary spins of system $A$ simultaneously, ``one by direct, the other by indirect measurement'': If we assume wMR, then once both settings are fixed, the outcomes of the two spins are both determined. We revisit the original EPR paradox and find a similar result: An EPR argument can be based on a set of premises, weak local realism, which we show are not falsifiable by GHZ or Bell experiments.

arXiv:2208.01225•Physical Review A•Aug 13, 2024•6 citations

Measurements according to "Consistent Quantum Theory"

Elias Okon, Daniel Sudarsky

We critically evaluate the treatment of the notion of measurement in the Consistent Histories approach to quantum mechanics. We find such treatment unsatisfactory because it relies, often implicitly, on elements external to the provided formalism. In particular, when dealing with measurement scenarios, the formalism, in order to be informative, needs to assume that after measurements measuring apparatuses are always in states of well defined pointer positions. The problem is that there is nothing in the formalism to justify this assumption. We conclude that the Consistent Histories approach, contrary to what is claimed by its proponents, fails to provide a truly satisfactory resolution to the measurement problem of quantum mechanics.

•Sep 3, 2013•3 citations

Generalized measurements

Stephen Mark Barnett

Extracting information from a quantum system inevitably requires the performance of a measurement, and it is no surprise that the theory of measurement plays a central role in our subject. The physical nature of the measurement process remains one of the great philosophical problems in the formulation of quantum theory. Fortunately, however, it is sufficient for us to take a pragmatic view by asking what measurements are possible and how the theory describes them, without addressing the physical mechanism of the measurement process. This is the approach we shall adopt. We shall find that it leads us to a powerful and general description of both the probabilities associated with measurement outcomes and the manner in which the observation transforms the quantum state of the measured system. The simplest form of measurement was given a mathematical formulation by von Neumann, and we shall refer to measurements of this type as von Neumann measurements or projective measurements. It is this description of measurements that is usually introduced in elementary quantum theory courses. We start with an observable quantity A represented by a Hermitian operator Â, the eigenvalues of which are the possible results of the measurement of A. The relationship between the operator, its eigenstates {|λnñ}, and its (real) eigenvalues {λn} is expressed by the eigenvalue equation . . . Â |λn_ = λn|λn_. (4.1) . . .

Oxford University Press eBooks•May 28, 2009•0 citations

The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Paradox and Entanglement 1: Signatures of EPR correlations for continuous variables

M. D. Reid

A generalization of the 1935 Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) argument for measurements with continuous variable outcomes is presented to establish criteria for the demonstration of the EPR paradox, for situations where the correlation between spatially separated subsystems is not perfect. Two types of criteria for EPR correlations are determined. The first type are based on measurements of the variances of conditional probability distributions and are necessary to reflect directly the situation of the original EPR paradox. The second weaker set of EPR criteria are based on the proven failure of (Bell-type) local realistic theories which could be consistent with a local quantum description for each subsystem. The relationship with criteria sufficient to prove entanglement is established, to show that any demonstration of EPR correlations will also signify entanglement. It is also shown how a demonstration of entanglement between two spatially separated subsystems, if not able to interpreted as a violation of a Bell-type inequality, may be interpreted as a demonstration of the EPR correlations. In particular it is explained how the experimental observation of two-mode squeezing using spatially separated detectors will signify not only entanglement but EPR correlations defined in a general sense.

arXiv:quant-ph/0112038•Dec 7, 2001•17 citations

Quantum Measurements Are Noncontextual

Robert B. Griffiths

Quantum measurements are noncontextual, with outcomes independent of which other commuting observables are measured at the same time, when consistently analyzed using principles of Hilbert space quantum mechanics rather than classical hidden variables.

arXiv:1302.5052•Feb 20, 2013•3 citations

Macroscopic delayed choice and retrocausality: Quantum eraser, Leggett-Garg, and dimension witness tests with cat states

Manushan Thenabadu, M. D. Reid

We propose delayed-choice experiments carried out with macroscopic qubits, realized as macroscopically distinct coherent states $|\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rangle}$ and $|\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rangle}$. Quantum superpositions of $|\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rangle}$ and $|\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rangle}$ are created via a unitary interaction $U(\ensuremath{\theta})$ based on a nonlinear Hamiltonian, in analogy with polarizing beam splitters used in photonic experiments. Macroscopic delayed-choice experiments give a compelling reason to develop interpretations not allowing macroscopic retrocausality: This would otherwise suggest changes to the macroscopic qubit value based on a future measurement setting $\ensuremath{\phi}$. We therefore consider weak macroscopic realism (wMR), which for the system at time $t$ specifies a hidden variable ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ to determine the macroscopic qubit value, independently of $\ensuremath{\phi}$. Using entangled cat states, we demonstrate a quantum eraser where the choice to measure a which-way or wave-type property is delayed. Consistency with wMR is possible, if we interpret the macroscopic qubit value to be determined by ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ without specification of the state at the level of $\ensuremath{\hbar}$. We then demonstrate violations of a delayed-choice Leggett-Garg inequality, and of the Wheeler-Chaves-Lemos-Pienaar dimension witness inequality, for the macroscopic qubits. This negates all two-dimensional nonretrocausal wMR models. However, one can interpret consistently with wMR, thus avoiding conclusions of macroscopic retrocausality, by noting extra dimensions, and that violations require further unitary dynamics $U$ after $t$. The violations are then explained as failure of deterministic macroscopic realism, which specifies the validity of ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ prior to the dynamics $U(\ensuremath{\theta})$ determining the measurement setting $\ensuremath{\theta}$. Finally, although there is consistency with wMR for macroscopic observations, Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen--type paradoxes pointing to the incompleteness of quantum mechanics exist at a microscopic level, based on fringe distributions.

arXiv:2109.12465•Physical Review A•Jun 8, 2022•10 citations
A solution to the second measurement problem, determining what prior microscopic properties can be inferred from measurement outcomes (``pointer positions''), is worked out for projective and generalized (POVM) measurements, using consistent histories. The result supports the idea that equipment properly designed and calibrated reveals the properties it was designed to measure. Applications include Einstein's hemisphere and Wheeler's delayed choice paradoxes, and a method for analyzing weak measurements without recourse to weak values. Quantum measurements are noncontextual in the original sense employed by Bell and Mermin: if [A,B]=[A,C]=0,[B,C]\ensuremath≠0[A,B]=[A,C]=0,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}[B,C]\ensuremath{\ne}0[A,B]=[A,C]=0,[B,C]\ensuremath=0, the outcome of an AAA measurement does not depend on whether it is measured with BBB or with CCC. An application to Bohm's model of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen situation suggests that a faulty understanding of quantum measurements is at the root of this paradox.
The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox gives an argument for the incompleteness of quantum mechanics based on a plausible criterion for reality, as well as the assumption of locality. A general view is that the argument is compromised, because EPR's premises are falsified by Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) and Bell experiments. In this paper, we present an EPR argument based on premises not falsified by these experiments. First, we consider macroscopic EPR-Bohm, Bell, and GHZ experiments using spins ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{S}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ defined by two macroscopically distinct states. The analyzers that realize the unitary operations ${U}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ determining the measurement settings $\ensuremath{\theta}$ are nonlinear devices creating macroscopic superposition states. We note two definitions of macroscopic realism (MR). For a system with two macroscopically distinct states available to it, MR posits a predetermined outcome for the measurement ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{S}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ distinguishing between the states. Deterministic macroscopic realism assumes MR for the system defined prior to the interaction ${U}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ being carried out but is falsifiable by the macroscopic Bell and GHZ proposals. Motivated by arguments to uphold MR (without resorting to decoherence), as well as no-signaling and the properties of a meter, we define a set of premises referred to as weak macroscopic realism (wMR). Weak macroscopic realism (wMR) posits MR for the system after ${U}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$, at the time tf{t}_{f}tf​---when the system is prepared with respect to the measurement basis, ready for a ``pointer'' measurement and readout. For this system, wMR posits that the outcome of ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{S}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ is determined and not changed by interactions that might subsequently occur at a remote system BBB. The premise wMR also posits a weaker version of EPR's criterion for reality. Importantly, we show that the GHZ and Bell predictions are consistent with wMR. Yet, an EPR paradox arises for a macroscopic EPR-Bohm state, based on wMR. As considered by Schr\"odinger, it is possible to measure two complementary spins of system AAA simultaneously, ``one by direct, the other by indirect measurement'': If we assume wMR, then once both settings are fixed, the outcomes of the two spins are both determined. We revisit the original EPR paradox and find a similar result: An EPR argument can be based on a set of premises, weak local realism, which we show are not falsifiable by GHZ or Bell experiments.
We critically evaluate the treatment of the notion of measurement in the Consistent Histories approach to quantum mechanics. We find such treatment unsatisfactory because it relies, often implicitly, on elements external to the provided formalism. In particular, when dealing with measurement scenarios, the formalism, in order to be informative, needs to assume that after measurements measuring apparatuses are always in states of well defined pointer positions. The problem is that there is nothing in the formalism to justify this assumption. We conclude that the Consistent Histories approach, contrary to what is claimed by its proponents, fails to provide a truly satisfactory resolution to the measurement problem of quantum mechanics.
Extracting information from a quantum system inevitably requires the performance of a measurement, and it is no surprise that the theory of measurement plays a central role in our subject. The physical nature of the measurement process remains one of the great philosophical problems in the formulation of quantum theory. Fortunately, however, it is sufficient for us to take a pragmatic view by asking what measurements are possible and how the theory describes them, without addressing the physical mechanism of the measurement process. This is the approach we shall adopt. We shall find that it leads us to a powerful and general description of both the probabilities associated with measurement outcomes and the manner in which the observation transforms the quantum state of the measured system. The simplest form of measurement was given a mathematical formulation by von Neumann, and we shall refer to measurements of this type as von Neumann measurements or projective measurements. It is this description of measurements that is usually introduced in elementary quantum theory courses. We start with an observable quantity A represented by a Hermitian operator Â, the eigenvalues of which are the possible results of the measurement of A. The relationship between the operator, its eigenstates {|λnñ}, and its (real) eigenvalues {λn} is expressed by the eigenvalue equation . . . Â |λn_ = λn|λn_. (4.1) . . .
A generalization of the 1935 Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) argument for measurements with continuous variable outcomes is presented to establish criteria for the demonstration of the EPR paradox, for situations where the correlation between spatially separated subsystems is not perfect. Two types of criteria for EPR correlations are determined. The first type are based on measurements of the variances of conditional probability distributions and are necessary to reflect directly the situation of the original EPR paradox. The second weaker set of EPR criteria are based on the proven failure of (Bell-type) local realistic theories which could be consistent with a local quantum description for each subsystem. The relationship with criteria sufficient to prove entanglement is established, to show that any demonstration of EPR correlations will also signify entanglement. It is also shown how a demonstration of entanglement between two spatially separated subsystems, if not able to interpreted as a violation of a Bell-type inequality, may be interpreted as a demonstration of the EPR correlations. In particular it is explained how the experimental observation of two-mode squeezing using spatially separated detectors will signify not only entanglement but EPR correlations defined in a general sense.
We propose delayed-choice experiments carried out with macroscopic qubits, realized as macroscopically distinct coherent states $|\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rangle}$ and $|\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rangle}$. Quantum superpositions of $|\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rangle}$ and $|\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rangle}$ are created via a unitary interaction $U(\ensuremath{\theta})$ based on a nonlinear Hamiltonian, in analogy with polarizing beam splitters used in photonic experiments. Macroscopic delayed-choice experiments give a compelling reason to develop interpretations not allowing macroscopic retrocausality: This would otherwise suggest changes to the macroscopic qubit value based on a future measurement setting $\ensuremath{\phi}$. We therefore consider weak macroscopic realism (wMR), which for the system at time ttt specifies a hidden variable ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ to determine the macroscopic qubit value, independently of $\ensuremath{\phi}$. Using entangled cat states, we demonstrate a quantum eraser where the choice to measure a which-way or wave-type property is delayed. Consistency with wMR is possible, if we interpret the macroscopic qubit value to be determined by ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ without specification of the state at the level of $\ensuremath{\hbar}$. We then demonstrate violations of a delayed-choice Leggett-Garg inequality, and of the Wheeler-Chaves-Lemos-Pienaar dimension witness inequality, for the macroscopic qubits. This negates all two-dimensional nonretrocausal wMR models. However, one can interpret consistently with wMR, thus avoiding conclusions of macroscopic retrocausality, by noting extra dimensions, and that violations require further unitary dynamics UUU after ttt. The violations are then explained as failure of deterministic macroscopic realism, which specifies the validity of ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{\ensuremath{\theta}}$ prior to the dynamics $U(\ensuremath{\theta})$ determining the measurement setting $\ensuremath{\theta}$. Finally, although there is consistency with wMR for macroscopic observations, Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen--type paradoxes pointing to the incompleteness of quantum mechanics exist at a microscopic level, based on fringe distributions.