Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1505.05907 · Journal of Applied Physics

Precise determination of micromotion for trapped-ion optical clocks

J. Keller, H. L. Partner, T. Burgermeister, T. E. Mehlstäubler

Published Sep 8, 2015• 129 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

As relative systematic frequency uncertainties in trapped-ion spectroscopy are approaching the low 10−18 range, motional frequency shifts account for a considerable fraction of the uncertainty budget. Micromotion, a driven motion fundamentally connected to the principle of the Paul trap, is a particular concern in these systems. In this article, we experimentally investigate at this level three common methods for minimizing and determining the micromotion amplitude. We develop a generalized model for a quantitative application of the photon-correlation technique, which is applicable in the commonly encountered regime where the transition linewidth is comparable to the rf drive frequency. We show that a fractional frequency uncertainty due to the 2nd-order Doppler shift below |Δν/ν|=1×10−20 can be achieved. The quantitative evaluation is verified in an interleaved measurement with the conceptually simpler resolved sideband method. If not performed deep within the Lamb-Dicke regime, a temperature-dependent offset at the level of 10−19 is observed in resolved sideband measurements due to sampling of intrinsic micromotion. By direct comparison with photon-correlation measurements, we show that the simple to implement parametric heating method is sensitive to micromotion at the level of |Δν/ν|=1×10−20 as well.

DOI
10.1063/1.4930037

Related papers

Spectroscopic characterization of ion motion for an optical clock based on Coulomb crystals

Keller, Jonas

Laser-cooled, trapped ions are among the most successful candidates for an optical frequency standard, with fractional frequency uncertainties approaching the low 10 -18 range.However, current implementations of optical ion clocks are based on a single reference ion, which results in an intrinsically low signal-to-noise ratio.Averaging times of several days are necessary for resolving the transition frequency well enough to benefit from these low systematic uncertainties.In order to overcome this impediment to applications, the averaging can be performed more quickly by interrogating an ensemble of ions simultaneously.Due to their mutual repulsion, these ions can be confined by a common trapping potential, in which they arrange in crystalline structures (Coulomb crystals).The technical challenge of this approach is to preserve the excellent systematic uncertainties obtainable with a single ion.This work contributes to the approach of using 115 In + / 172 Yb + Coulomb crystals as the reference for an optical clock.Two ultra-stable cavities for the stabilization of spectroscopy lasers have been set up.With a simple setup, a diode laser has been stabilized to σ y (1 s) = 6 × 10 -16 .The vibration sensitivity of a simple 30 cm long spacer has been measured, showing that a cavity using this spacer can provide a fractional frequency instability of σ y = 1 × 10 -16 for times > 30 ms, sufficient to operate a clock based on 100 115 In + ions at its quantum projection noise limit of 7.2 × 10 -17 / τ /s.Frequency shifts resulting from time dilation due to ion motion are among the limiting contributions in current ion frequency standards.A spectroscopy laser has been set up in order to characterize the motion of Coulomb crystals by interrogating a narrow transition in 172 Yb + .Spatially resolved state detection with an EMCCD camera allows multiple ions to be interrogated simultaneously.Groundstate cooling of two modes in a single ion allowed the determination of heating rates below 2 s -1 at secular frequencies around 500 kHz.Three micromotion compensation techniques have been characterized in terms of their resolution and applicability during clock operation.A new model was developed for the photon-correlation technique to allow quantitative evaluation in the common regime of comparable drive frequency and linewidth.It was experimentally verified in a comparison with resolved sideband measurements.Both the photon-correlation and the parametric excitation method were shown capable of micromotion compensation with a resulting fractional frequency uncertainty well below 10 -19 .Overall, it has been shown that the motional frequency shift contributions due to external heating, secular motion and micromotion in a single 115 In + ion can each be controlled at a level of 10 -19 in the present setup and the foundation has been laid to extend these measurements to multiple ions.

•Jan 1, 2015•5 citations

Evaluation of trap-induced systematic frequency shifts for a multi-ion optical clock at the 10−19level

Jonas Keller, T. Burgermeister, Dimitri Kalincev +2 more

In order to improve the short-term stability of trapped-ion optical clocks, we are developing a frequency standard based on 115 In + / 172 Yb + Coulomb crystals. For this purpose, we have developed scalable segmented Paul traps which allow a high level of control for multiple ion ensembles. In this article, we detail on our recent results regarding the reduction of the leading sources of frequency uncertainty introduced by the ion trap: 2nd-order Doppler shifts due to micromotion and the heating of secular motion, as well as the black-body radiation shift due to warming of the trap. We show that the fractional frequency uncertainty due to each of these effects can be reduced to well below 10 -19 .

arXiv:1512.05677•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2016•29 citations

Sub-kelvin temperature management in ion traps for optical clocks

T. Nordmann, Alexandre Didier, M. Doležal +3 more

The uncertainty of the ac Stark shift due to thermal radiation represents a major contribution to the systematic uncertainty budget of state-of-the-art optical atomic clocks. In the case of optical clocks based on trapped ions, the thermal behavior of the rf-driven ion trap must be precisely known. This determination is even more difficult when scalable linear ion traps are used. Such traps enable a more advanced control of multiple ions and have become a platform for new applications in quantum metrology, simulation, and computation. Nevertheless, their complex structure makes it more difficult to precisely determine its temperature in operation and thus the related systematic uncertainty. We present here scalable linear ion traps for optical clocks, which exhibit very low temperature rise under operation. We use a finite-element model refined with experimental measurements to determine the thermal distribution in the ion trap and the temperature at the position of the ions. The trap temperature is investigated at different rf-drive frequencies and amplitudes with an infrared camera and integrated temperature sensors. We show that for typical trapping parameters for In+, Al+, Lu+, Ca+, Sr+, or Yb+ ions, the temperature rise at the position of the ions resulting from rf heating of the trap stays below 700 mK and can be controlled with an uncertainty on the order of a few 100 mK maximum. The corresponding uncertainty of the trap-related blackbody radiation shift is in the low 10−19 and even 10−20 regime for 171Yb+(E3) and 115In+, respectively.

arXiv:2008.04231•Review of Scientific Instruments•Nov 1, 2020•15 citations

Evaluation of Systematic Uncertainty Induced by Excess Micromotion in NIMT Optical Atomic Clock

R. Kaewuam, P. Phoonthong

Excess micromotion is a systematic effect that can cause a significant frequency shift to an optical atomic clock based on trapped ions. It is a rapid driven motion that is typically caused by a stray electric field in the trap. This fast motion results in motion-induced shifts of the clock frequency. Here we present the measurement of excess micromotion in a linear Paul trap at National Institute of Metrology Thailand (NIMT). After the stray field compensation, the estimated second-order Doppler shift and scalar Stark shift of the 435-nm clock transition in171Yb+are –1.5(8) × 10–18and 1.3(7) × 10–17, respectively.

Conference on Precision Electromagnetic Measurements•Sep 1, 2026•0 citations

Progress towards a 40Ca+ optical clock with a fractional uncertainty at the 10−18 level

Yao Huang, Hua Guan, Kelin Gao

We recently reported a 5×10-17level frequency comparison of two40Ca+optical clocks, one of which has fractional frequency uncertainty of 3.4×10-17, limited by the BBR effect. Here we present progress towards a40Ca+optical clock with uncertainty at the 10-18level. The differential static scalar polarizability Δα0 of the40Ca+ion clock transition is obtained by precisely measuring the “magic” rf drive frequency. Δα0 is measured as -7.2653(44)x10-40J m2/V2, the blackbody radiation shift is then calculated to be 0.3790(2) Hz at 300 K. The contribution of the blackbody shift coefficient to the uncertainty of the optical clock at room temperature is reduced to 5.6×10-19, the excess micromotion induced clock uncertainty is also reduced to the 10-19level by choosing the appropriate trap drive frequency. With a suppression of the BBR field temperature uncertainty to the sub-Kelvin level and improved clock stability, a robust, relatively low-cost40Ca+ion clock with uncertainty at 10-18level can be made.

Joint Conference of the European Frequency and Time Forum and IEEE International Frequency Control Symposium (EFTF/IFCS)•Jul 1, 2017•0 citations

Ion-trajectory analysis for micromotion minimization and the measurement of small forces

Timm F. Gloger, Peter Kaufmann, Delia Kaufmann +4 more

For experiments with ions confined in a Paul trap, minimization of micromotion is often essential. In order to diagnose and compensate micromotion we have implemented a method that allows for finding the position of the radio-frequency (rf) null reliably and efficiently, in principle, without any variation of direct current (dc) voltages. We apply a trap modulation technique and focus-scanning imaging to extract three-dimensional ion positions for various rf drive powers and analyze the power dependence of the equilibrium position of the trapped ion. In contrast to commonly used methods, the search algorithm directly makes use of a physical effect as opposed to efficient numerical minimization in a high-dimensional parameter space. Using this method we achieve a compensation of the residual electric field that causes excess micromotion in the radial plane of a linear Paul trap down to $0.09\phantom{\rule{4pt}{0ex}}\text{V}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\text{m}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. Additionally, the precise position determination of a single harmonically trapped ion employed here can also be utilized for the detection of small forces. This is demonstrated by determining light pressure forces with a precision of 135 yN. As the method is based on imaging only, it can be applied to several ions simultaneously and is independent of laser direction and thus well suited to be used with, for example, surface-electrode traps.

arXiv:1503.07031•Physical Review A•Oct 27, 2015•45 citations
As relative systematic frequency uncertainties in trapped-ion spectroscopy are approaching the low 10−18 range, motional frequency shifts account for a considerable fraction of the uncertainty budget. Micromotion, a driven motion fundamentally connected to the principle of the Paul trap, is a particular concern in these systems. In this article, we experimentally investigate at this level three common methods for minimizing and determining the micromotion amplitude. We develop a generalized model for a quantitative application of the photon-correlation technique, which is applicable in the commonly encountered regime where the transition linewidth is comparable to the rf drive frequency. We show that a fractional frequency uncertainty due to the 2nd-order Doppler shift below |Δν/ν|=1×10−20 can be achieved. The quantitative evaluation is verified in an interleaved measurement with the conceptually simpler resolved sideband method. If not performed deep within the Lamb-Dicke regime, a temperature-dependent offset at the level of 10−19 is observed in resolved sideband measurements due to sampling of intrinsic micromotion. By direct comparison with photon-correlation measurements, we show that the simple to implement parametric heating method is sensitive to micromotion at the level of |Δν/ν|=1×10−20 as well.
Laser-cooled, trapped ions are among the most successful candidates for an optical frequency standard, with fractional frequency uncertainties approaching the low 10 -18 range.However, current implementations of optical ion clocks are based on a single reference ion, which results in an intrinsically low signal-to-noise ratio.Averaging times of several days are necessary for resolving the transition frequency well enough to benefit from these low systematic uncertainties.In order to overcome this impediment to applications, the averaging can be performed more quickly by interrogating an ensemble of ions simultaneously.Due to their mutual repulsion, these ions can be confined by a common trapping potential, in which they arrange in crystalline structures (Coulomb crystals).The technical challenge of this approach is to preserve the excellent systematic uncertainties obtainable with a single ion.This work contributes to the approach of using 115 In + / 172 Yb + Coulomb crystals as the reference for an optical clock.Two ultra-stable cavities for the stabilization of spectroscopy lasers have been set up.With a simple setup, a diode laser has been stabilized to σ y (1 s) = 6 × 10 -16 .The vibration sensitivity of a simple 30 cm long spacer has been measured, showing that a cavity using this spacer can provide a fractional frequency instability of σ y = 1 × 10 -16 for times > 30 ms, sufficient to operate a clock based on 100 115 In + ions at its quantum projection noise limit of 7.2 × 10 -17 / τ /s.Frequency shifts resulting from time dilation due to ion motion are among the limiting contributions in current ion frequency standards.A spectroscopy laser has been set up in order to characterize the motion of Coulomb crystals by interrogating a narrow transition in 172 Yb + .Spatially resolved state detection with an EMCCD camera allows multiple ions to be interrogated simultaneously.Groundstate cooling of two modes in a single ion allowed the determination of heating rates below 2 s -1 at secular frequencies around 500 kHz.Three micromotion compensation techniques have been characterized in terms of their resolution and applicability during clock operation.A new model was developed for the photon-correlation technique to allow quantitative evaluation in the common regime of comparable drive frequency and linewidth.It was experimentally verified in a comparison with resolved sideband measurements.Both the photon-correlation and the parametric excitation method were shown capable of micromotion compensation with a resulting fractional frequency uncertainty well below 10 -19 .Overall, it has been shown that the motional frequency shift contributions due to external heating, secular motion and micromotion in a single 115 In + ion can each be controlled at a level of 10 -19 in the present setup and the foundation has been laid to extend these measurements to multiple ions.
In order to improve the short-term stability of trapped-ion optical clocks, we are developing a frequency standard based on 115 In + / 172 Yb + Coulomb crystals. For this purpose, we have developed scalable segmented Paul traps which allow a high level of control for multiple ion ensembles. In this article, we detail on our recent results regarding the reduction of the leading sources of frequency uncertainty introduced by the ion trap: 2nd-order Doppler shifts due to micromotion and the heating of secular motion, as well as the black-body radiation shift due to warming of the trap. We show that the fractional frequency uncertainty due to each of these effects can be reduced to well below 10 -19 .
The uncertainty of the ac Stark shift due to thermal radiation represents a major contribution to the systematic uncertainty budget of state-of-the-art optical atomic clocks. In the case of optical clocks based on trapped ions, the thermal behavior of the rf-driven ion trap must be precisely known. This determination is even more difficult when scalable linear ion traps are used. Such traps enable a more advanced control of multiple ions and have become a platform for new applications in quantum metrology, simulation, and computation. Nevertheless, their complex structure makes it more difficult to precisely determine its temperature in operation and thus the related systematic uncertainty. We present here scalable linear ion traps for optical clocks, which exhibit very low temperature rise under operation. We use a finite-element model refined with experimental measurements to determine the thermal distribution in the ion trap and the temperature at the position of the ions. The trap temperature is investigated at different rf-drive frequencies and amplitudes with an infrared camera and integrated temperature sensors. We show that for typical trapping parameters for In+, Al+, Lu+, Ca+, Sr+, or Yb+ ions, the temperature rise at the position of the ions resulting from rf heating of the trap stays below 700 mK and can be controlled with an uncertainty on the order of a few 100 mK maximum. The corresponding uncertainty of the trap-related blackbody radiation shift is in the low 10−19 and even 10−20 regime for 171Yb+(E3) and 115In+, respectively.
Excess micromotion is a systematic effect that can cause a significant frequency shift to an optical atomic clock based on trapped ions. It is a rapid driven motion that is typically caused by a stray electric field in the trap. This fast motion results in motion-induced shifts of the clock frequency. Here we present the measurement of excess micromotion in a linear Paul trap at National Institute of Metrology Thailand (NIMT). After the stray field compensation, the estimated second-order Doppler shift and scalar Stark shift of the 435-nm clock transition in171Yb+are –1.5(8) × 10–18and 1.3(7) × 10–17, respectively.
We recently reported a 5×10-17level frequency comparison of two40Ca+optical clocks, one of which has fractional frequency uncertainty of 3.4×10-17, limited by the BBR effect. Here we present progress towards a40Ca+optical clock with uncertainty at the 10-18level. The differential static scalar polarizability Δα0 of the40Ca+ion clock transition is obtained by precisely measuring the “magic” rf drive frequency. Δα0 is measured as -7.2653(44)x10-40J m2/V2, the blackbody radiation shift is then calculated to be 0.3790(2) Hz at 300 K. The contribution of the blackbody shift coefficient to the uncertainty of the optical clock at room temperature is reduced to 5.6×10-19, the excess micromotion induced clock uncertainty is also reduced to the 10-19level by choosing the appropriate trap drive frequency. With a suppression of the BBR field temperature uncertainty to the sub-Kelvin level and improved clock stability, a robust, relatively low-cost40Ca+ion clock with uncertainty at 10-18level can be made.
For experiments with ions confined in a Paul trap, minimization of micromotion is often essential. In order to diagnose and compensate micromotion we have implemented a method that allows for finding the position of the radio-frequency (rf) null reliably and efficiently, in principle, without any variation of direct current (dc) voltages. We apply a trap modulation technique and focus-scanning imaging to extract three-dimensional ion positions for various rf drive powers and analyze the power dependence of the equilibrium position of the trapped ion. In contrast to commonly used methods, the search algorithm directly makes use of a physical effect as opposed to efficient numerical minimization in a high-dimensional parameter space. Using this method we achieve a compensation of the residual electric field that causes excess micromotion in the radial plane of a linear Paul trap down to $0.09\phantom{\rule{4pt}{0ex}}\text{V}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\text{m}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. Additionally, the precise position determination of a single harmonically trapped ion employed here can also be utilized for the detection of small forces. This is demonstrated by determining light pressure forces with a precision of 135 yN. As the method is based on imaging only, it can be applied to several ions simultaneously and is independent of laser direction and thus well suited to be used with, for example, surface-electrode traps.