Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1011.4971 · International Journal of Modern Physics D

THE LOGIC BEHIND FEYNMAN'S PATHS

EDGARDO T. GARCÍA ÁLVAREZ

Published May 19, 2011• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The classical notions of continuity and mechanical causality are left in order to reformulate the Quantum Theory starting from two principles: (I) the intrinsic randomness of quantum process at microphysical level, (II) the projective representations of symmetries of the system. The second principle determines the geometry and then a new logic for describing the history of events (Feynman's paths) that modifies the rules of classical probabilistic calculus. The notion of classical trajectory is replaced by a history of spontaneous, random and discontinuous events. So the theory is reduced to determining the probability distribution for such histories accordingly with the symmetries of the system. The representation of the logic in terms of amplitudes leads to Feynman rules and, alternatively, its representation in terms of projectors results in the Schwinger trace formula.

DOI
10.1142/s0218271811018998

Related papers

Quantum causality, stochastics, trajectories and information

V. P. Belavkin

A history of the discovery of `new' quantum mechanics and the paradoxes of its probabilistic interpretation are briefly reviewed from the modern point of view of quantum probability and information. Modern quantum theory, which has been developed during the last 20 years for the treatment of quantum open systems including quantum noise, decoherence, quantum diffusions and spontaneous jumps occurring under continuous in time observation, is not yet a part of the standard curriculum of quantum physics. It is argued that the conventional formalism of quantum mechanics is insufficient for the description of quantum events, such as spontaneous decays say, and the new experimental phenomena related to individual quantum measurements, but they have all received an adequate mathematical treatment in quantum stochastics of open systems. Moreover, the only reasonable probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics put forward by Max Born was, in fact, in irreconcilable contradiction with traditional mechanical reality and causality. This led to numerous quantum paradoxes, some of them due to the great inventors of quantum theory such as Einstein and Schrödinger. They are reconsidered in this paper from the modern point of view of quantum stochastics and information. The development of quantum measurement theory, initiated by von Neumann, indicated a possibility for resolution of this interpretational crisis by divorcing the algebra of the dynamical generators and the algebra of the actual observables, or Bell's be ables. It is shown that within this approach quantum causality can be rehabilitated in the form of a superselection rule for compatibility of the actual histories with the potential future. This rule, together with the self-compatibility of the measurements ensuring the consistency of the histories, is called the nondemolition, or causality principle in modern quantum theory. The application of this rule in the form of dynamical commutation relations leads to the derivation of the von Neumann projection postulate, and also to the more general reductions, instantaneous, spontaneous, and even continuous in time. This gives a dynamical solution, in the form of the quantum stochastic filtering equations, of the notorious measurement problem which was tackled unsuccessfully by many famous physicists starting with Schrödinger and Bohr. It has been recently proved that the quantum stochastic model for the continuous in time measurements is equivalent to a Dirac type boundary-value problem for the secondary quantized input `offer waves from future' in one extra dimension, and to a reduction of the algebra of the consistent histories of past events to an Abelian subalgebra for the `trajectories of the output particles'. This supports the corpuscular-wave duality in the form of the thesis that everything in the future are quantized waves, while everything in the past are trajectories of the recorded particles.

arXiv:quant-ph/0208087•Reports on Progress in Physics•Feb 20, 2002•25 citations

Continuity, A Key to Quantum Mechanics

Alfred Landé

The present article is written by a theoretical physicist who, for some time, has endeavored to trace the origin of the concepts and principles of quantum theory to an empirical background broader than that afforded by delicate optical and mechanical experiments on a microphysical scale involving the microconstant h. In particular he tried to reduce the dominant role of probability in modern physics to irrefutable evidence of a quite general nature. As long as quantum probability is deduced from experience with seemingly uncontrollable micro-mechanisms—think of radioactive disintegration as the most typical example—there will always be the objection that one day we still may find a hidden causality behind those small scale gambling devices called atoms, although one example of an exactly predictable atomic event would make present-day quantum theory untenable. In order to dislodge the remaining classicists from their fortress of doubt one may try to show that quantum probability is not an alibi for a temporary impotence of predicting microphysical events, but is a positive conclusion drawn from experience of a most general type, namely, from the principle of continuity, the basic tenet of the philosophy of Leibniz.

Philosophy of Science•Apr 1, 1953•7 citations

Classical dynamical origin of Feynman paths?

M. Roncadelli

Even though only the classical action explicitly appears in the Feynman path integral, quantum fluctuations show up in the fluctuating nature of Feynman paths. This prevents a classical interpretation of the latter objects. Still, it makes sense to ask whether the Feynman paths have any relation to the classical dynamical trajectories in configuration space-a possibility naturally suggested by the semiclassical approximation. Unfortunately, no such relation exists (in general). Things are quite different for the generalized Feynman paths, which actually contribute in a novel path integral giving an alternative representation of the quantum mechanical propagator. It is shown that these paths fluctuate about a classical dynamical trajectory (in configuration space) because of a certain white noise. That is to say, the generalized Feynman paths are fluctuating curves that collapse on a classical dynamical trajectory as h to 0. This result throws new light on the interplay between classical and quantum mechanics and hints at a new approach to the quantum theory.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Sep 21, 1993•3 citations

Schwinger's Quantum Action Principle. I. From Dirac's Formulation through Feynman's Path Integrals to the Schwinger-Keldysh Method

Kimball A. Milton

Starting from the earlier notions of stationary action principles, we show how Schwinger's Quantum Action Principle descended from Dirac's formulation, which independently led Feynman to his path-integral formulation of quantum mechanics. The connection between the two is brought out, and applications are discussed. The Keldysh-Schwinger time-cycle method of extracting matrix elements is described. Part II will discuss the variational formulation of quantum electrodynamics and the development of source theory.

arXiv:1402.3762•Feb 16, 2014•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics from the Quantization of the Action Variable

V. Hushwater

Starting from the quantization of the action variable as a basic principle, and regarding the momentum and the energy of a particle as random functions of coordinates I arrive at the quantum mechanical formalism and the rule for probabilities in quantum mechanics. The discussion involves the correspondence principle and the assumption that the space-time symmetries known in classical physics are valid in the quantum domain.

Fortschritte der Physik•Nov 1, 1998•1 citation

A Proposal for the Groupoidal Description of Classical and Quantum Fields

Alberto Ibort, Giuseppe Marmo

The recent groupoidal description of Schwinger’s picture of quantum mechanics is used to provide a new approach to the notion of quantum field. Starting with Feynman’s quantum mechanics, where classical paths play a key role, a groupoidal interpretation of them is provided by reckoning the basic notions involved on them, most singularly the notion of clocks. It is found that natural requisites about the use of clocks in describing quantum systems lead naturally to the notion of histories as a class of homomorphisms of groupoids, and such notion leads directly to Feynman’s notion of classical paths. Similar arguments can be used when replacing clocks by reference frames. There the notion of universal histories of quantum systems and an associated notion of field emerge naturally. Moreover, the analysis of the properties of clocks in quantum systems leads to a characterization of semidirect products of groupoids.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Apr 1, 2023•1 citation
The classical notions of continuity and mechanical causality are left in order to reformulate the Quantum Theory starting from two principles: (I) the intrinsic randomness of quantum process at microphysical level, (II) the projective representations of symmetries of the system. The second principle determines the geometry and then a new logic for describing the history of events (Feynman's paths) that modifies the rules of classical probabilistic calculus. The notion of classical trajectory is replaced by a history of spontaneous, random and discontinuous events. So the theory is reduced to determining the probability distribution for such histories accordingly with the symmetries of the system. The representation of the logic in terms of amplitudes leads to Feynman rules and, alternatively, its representation in terms of projectors results in the Schwinger trace formula.
A history of the discovery of `new' quantum mechanics and the paradoxes of its probabilistic interpretation are briefly reviewed from the modern point of view of quantum probability and information. Modern quantum theory, which has been developed during the last 20 years for the treatment of quantum open systems including quantum noise, decoherence, quantum diffusions and spontaneous jumps occurring under continuous in time observation, is not yet a part of the standard curriculum of quantum physics. It is argued that the conventional formalism of quantum mechanics is insufficient for the description of quantum events, such as spontaneous decays say, and the new experimental phenomena related to individual quantum measurements, but they have all received an adequate mathematical treatment in quantum stochastics of open systems. Moreover, the only reasonable probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics put forward by Max Born was, in fact, in irreconcilable contradiction with traditional mechanical reality and causality. This led to numerous quantum paradoxes, some of them due to the great inventors of quantum theory such as Einstein and Schrödinger. They are reconsidered in this paper from the modern point of view of quantum stochastics and information. The development of quantum measurement theory, initiated by von Neumann, indicated a possibility for resolution of this interpretational crisis by divorcing the algebra of the dynamical generators and the algebra of the actual observables, or Bell's be ables. It is shown that within this approach quantum causality can be rehabilitated in the form of a superselection rule for compatibility of the actual histories with the potential future. This rule, together with the self-compatibility of the measurements ensuring the consistency of the histories, is called the nondemolition, or causality principle in modern quantum theory. The application of this rule in the form of dynamical commutation relations leads to the derivation of the von Neumann projection postulate, and also to the more general reductions, instantaneous, spontaneous, and even continuous in time. This gives a dynamical solution, in the form of the quantum stochastic filtering equations, of the notorious measurement problem which was tackled unsuccessfully by many famous physicists starting with Schrödinger and Bohr. It has been recently proved that the quantum stochastic model for the continuous in time measurements is equivalent to a Dirac type boundary-value problem for the secondary quantized input `offer waves from future' in one extra dimension, and to a reduction of the algebra of the consistent histories of past events to an Abelian subalgebra for the `trajectories of the output particles'. This supports the corpuscular-wave duality in the form of the thesis that everything in the future are quantized waves, while everything in the past are trajectories of the recorded particles.
The present article is written by a theoretical physicist who, for some time, has endeavored to trace the origin of the concepts and principles of quantum theory to an empirical background broader than that afforded by delicate optical and mechanical experiments on a microphysical scale involving the microconstant h. In particular he tried to reduce the dominant role of probability in modern physics to irrefutable evidence of a quite general nature. As long as quantum probability is deduced from experience with seemingly uncontrollable micro-mechanisms—think of radioactive disintegration as the most typical example—there will always be the objection that one day we still may find a hidden causality behind those small scale gambling devices called atoms, although one example of an exactly predictable atomic event would make present-day quantum theory untenable. In order to dislodge the remaining classicists from their fortress of doubt one may try to show that quantum probability is not an alibi for a temporary impotence of predicting microphysical events, but is a positive conclusion drawn from experience of a most general type, namely, from the principle of continuity, the basic tenet of the philosophy of Leibniz.
Even though only the classical action explicitly appears in the Feynman path integral, quantum fluctuations show up in the fluctuating nature of Feynman paths. This prevents a classical interpretation of the latter objects. Still, it makes sense to ask whether the Feynman paths have any relation to the classical dynamical trajectories in configuration space-a possibility naturally suggested by the semiclassical approximation. Unfortunately, no such relation exists (in general). Things are quite different for the generalized Feynman paths, which actually contribute in a novel path integral giving an alternative representation of the quantum mechanical propagator. It is shown that these paths fluctuate about a classical dynamical trajectory (in configuration space) because of a certain white noise. That is to say, the generalized Feynman paths are fluctuating curves that collapse on a classical dynamical trajectory as h to 0. This result throws new light on the interplay between classical and quantum mechanics and hints at a new approach to the quantum theory.
Starting from the earlier notions of stationary action principles, we show how Schwinger's Quantum Action Principle descended from Dirac's formulation, which independently led Feynman to his path-integral formulation of quantum mechanics. The connection between the two is brought out, and applications are discussed. The Keldysh-Schwinger time-cycle method of extracting matrix elements is described. Part II will discuss the variational formulation of quantum electrodynamics and the development of source theory.
The recent groupoidal description of Schwinger’s picture of quantum mechanics is used to provide a new approach to the notion of quantum field. Starting with Feynman’s quantum mechanics, where classical paths play a key role, a groupoidal interpretation of them is provided by reckoning the basic notions involved on them, most singularly the notion of clocks. It is found that natural requisites about the use of clocks in describing quantum systems lead naturally to the notion of histories as a class of homomorphisms of groupoids, and such notion leads directly to Feynman’s notion of classical paths. Similar arguments can be used when replacing clocks by reference frames. There the notion of universal histories of quantum systems and an associated notion of field emerge naturally. Moreover, the analysis of the properties of clocks in quantum systems leads to a characterization of semidirect products of groupoids.