Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

Classical dynamical origin of Feynman paths?

M. Roncadelli

Published Sep 21, 1993• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Even though only the classical action explicitly appears in the Feynman path integral, quantum fluctuations show up in the fluctuating nature of Feynman paths. This prevents a classical interpretation of the latter objects. Still, it makes sense to ask whether the Feynman paths have any relation to the classical dynamical trajectories in configuration space-a possibility naturally suggested by the semiclassical approximation. Unfortunately, no such relation exists (in general). Things are quite different for the generalized Feynman paths, which actually contribute in a novel path integral giving an alternative representation of the quantum mechanical propagator. It is shown that these paths fluctuate about a classical dynamical trajectory (in configuration space) because of a certain white noise. That is to say, the generalized Feynman paths are fluctuating curves that collapse on a classical dynamical trajectory as h to 0. This result throws new light on the interplay between classical and quantum mechanics and hints at a new approach to the quantum theory.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/26/18/012

Related papers

New path integral representation of the quantum mechanical propagator

M. Roncadelli

A new path integral representation of the quantum mechanical propagator is proposed, which is even more intimately connected with classical mechanics than the Feynman path integral. The emergence of the semiclassical propagator is discussed in detail. It is argued that those paths which actually contribute in the new path integral have a very simple relation with the classical dynamical trajectories in configuration space.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 21, 1992•6 citations

White noise approach to Feynman integrals

Takeyuki Hida

The trajectory of a classical dynamics is determined by the least action principle. As soon as we come to quantum dynamics, we have to consider all possible trajectories which are proposed to be a sum of the classical trajectory and Brownian fluctuation. Thus, the action involves the square of the derivative B(t) (white noise) of a Brownian motion B(t). The square is a typical example of a generalized white noise functional. The Feynman propagator should therefore be an average of a certain generalized white noise functional. This idea can be applied to a large class of dynamics with various kinds of Lagrangians.

Journal of the Korean Mathematical Society•Jan 1, 2001•5 citations

Dirac and the Path Integral

N. D. Hari Dass

Through a very careful analysis of Dirac's 1932 paper on the Lagrangian in Quantum Mechanics as well as the second and third editions of his classic book {\it The Principles of Quantum Mechanics}, I show that Dirac's contributions to the birth of the path-integral approach to quantum mechanics is not restricted to just his seminal demonstration of how Lagrangians appear naturally in quantum mechanics, but that Dirac should be credited for creating a path-integral which I call {\it Dirac path-integral} which is far more general than Feynman's while possessing all its desirable features. On top of it, the Dirac path-integral is fully compatible with the inevitable quantisation ambiguities, while the Feynman path-integral can never have that full consistency. In particular, I show that the claim by Feynman that for infinitesimal time intervals, what Dirac thought were analogues were actually proportional can not be correct always. I have also shown the conection between Dirac path-integrals and the Schrödinger equation. In particular, it is shown that each choice of Dirac path-integral yields a {\it quantum Hamiltonian} that is generically different from what the Feynman path-integral gives, and that all of them have the same {\it classical analogue}. Dirac's method of demonstrating the least action principle for classical mechanics generalizes in a most straightforward way to all the generalized path-integrals.

arXiv:2003.12683•Mar 28, 2020•3 citations

The Physical Origin of the Feynman Path Integral

Armin Nikkhah Shirazi

The Feynman path integral is an essential part of our mathematical description of fundamental nature at small scales. However, what it seems to say about the world is very much at odds with our classical intu-itions, and exactly why nature requires us to describe her in this way is currently unknown. We will describe here a possibility according to which the path integral may be the spacetime manifestation of objects existing in a lower-dimensional analog of spacetime until they give rise to the emergence of spacetime objects under a process that is currently labeled a ‘Quantum Measure-ment’. This idea is based on a mathematical distinction which at present does not appear to be widely appreci-ated.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 19, 2013•0 citations

The Physical Origin of the Feynman Path Integral (Poster)

Armin Nikkhah Shirazi

The Feynman path integral is an essential part of our mathematical description of fundamental nature at small scales. However, what it seems to say about the world is very much at odds with our classical intuitions, and exactly why nature requires us to describe her in this way is currently unknown. We will describe here a possibility according to which the path integral may be the spacetime manifestation of objects existing in a lower-dimensional analog of spacetime until they give rise to the emergence of spacetime objects under a process that is currently labeled a ‘Quantum Measurement’. This idea is based on a mathematical distinction which at present does not appear to be widely appreciated.

•Nov 1, 2012•0 citations

Why Feynman Path Integration

Jaime Nava, Juan Ferret, Владик Крейнович +3 more

To describe physics properly, we need to take into account quantum effects. Thus, for every non-quantum physical theory, we must come up with an appropriate quantum theory. A traditional approach is to replace all the scalars in the classical description of this theory by the corresponding operators. The problem with the above approach is that due to non-commutativity of the quantum operators, two mathematically equivalent formulations of the classical theory can lead to different (non-equivalent) quantum theories. An alternative quantization approach that directly transforms the non-quantum action functional into the appropriate quantum theory, was indeed proposed by the Nobelist Richard Feynman, under the name of path integration. Feynman path integration is not just a foundational idea, it is actually an efficient computing tool (Feynman diagrams).\nFrom the pragmatic viewpoint, Feynman path integral is a great success. However, from the foundational viewpoint, we still face an important question: why the Feynman's path integration formula? In this paper, we provide a natural explanation for Feynman's path integration formula.

Journal of Uncertain Systems•Jan 1, 2010•1 citation
Even though only the classical action explicitly appears in the Feynman path integral, quantum fluctuations show up in the fluctuating nature of Feynman paths. This prevents a classical interpretation of the latter objects. Still, it makes sense to ask whether the Feynman paths have any relation to the classical dynamical trajectories in configuration space-a possibility naturally suggested by the semiclassical approximation. Unfortunately, no such relation exists (in general). Things are quite different for the generalized Feynman paths, which actually contribute in a novel path integral giving an alternative representation of the quantum mechanical propagator. It is shown that these paths fluctuate about a classical dynamical trajectory (in configuration space) because of a certain white noise. That is to say, the generalized Feynman paths are fluctuating curves that collapse on a classical dynamical trajectory as h to 0. This result throws new light on the interplay between classical and quantum mechanics and hints at a new approach to the quantum theory.
The trajectory of a classical dynamics is determined by the least action principle. As soon as we come to quantum dynamics, we have to consider all possible trajectories which are proposed to be a sum of the classical trajectory and Brownian fluctuation. Thus, the action involves the square of the derivative B(t) (white noise) of a Brownian motion B(t). The square is a typical example of a generalized white noise functional. The Feynman propagator should therefore be an average of a certain generalized white noise functional. This idea can be applied to a large class of dynamics with various kinds of Lagrangians.
Through a very careful analysis of Dirac's 1932 paper on the Lagrangian in Quantum Mechanics as well as the second and third editions of his classic book {\it The Principles of Quantum Mechanics}, I show that Dirac's contributions to the birth of the path-integral approach to quantum mechanics is not restricted to just his seminal demonstration of how Lagrangians appear naturally in quantum mechanics, but that Dirac should be credited for creating a path-integral which I call {\it Dirac path-integral} which is far more general than Feynman's while possessing all its desirable features. On top of it, the Dirac path-integral is fully compatible with the inevitable quantisation ambiguities, while the Feynman path-integral can never have that full consistency. In particular, I show that the claim by Feynman that for infinitesimal time intervals, what Dirac thought were analogues were actually proportional can not be correct always. I have also shown the conection between Dirac path-integrals and the Schrödinger equation. In particular, it is shown that each choice of Dirac path-integral yields a {\it quantum Hamiltonian} that is generically different from what the Feynman path-integral gives, and that all of them have the same {\it classical analogue}. Dirac's method of demonstrating the least action principle for classical mechanics generalizes in a most straightforward way to all the generalized path-integrals.
The Feynman path integral is an essential part of our mathematical description of fundamental nature at small scales. However, what it seems to say about the world is very much at odds with our classical intu-itions, and exactly why nature requires us to describe her in this way is currently unknown. We will describe here a possibility according to which the path integral may be the spacetime manifestation of objects existing in a lower-dimensional analog of spacetime until they give rise to the emergence of spacetime objects under a process that is currently labeled a ‘Quantum Measure-ment’. This idea is based on a mathematical distinction which at present does not appear to be widely appreci-ated.
The Feynman path integral is an essential part of our mathematical description of fundamental nature at small scales. However, what it seems to say about the world is very much at odds with our classical intuitions, and exactly why nature requires us to describe her in this way is currently unknown. We will describe here a possibility according to which the path integral may be the spacetime manifestation of objects existing in a lower-dimensional analog of spacetime until they give rise to the emergence of spacetime objects under a process that is currently labeled a ‘Quantum Measurement’. This idea is based on a mathematical distinction which at present does not appear to be widely appreciated.
To describe physics properly, we need to take into account quantum effects. Thus, for every non-quantum physical theory, we must come up with an appropriate quantum theory. A traditional approach is to replace all the scalars in the classical description of this theory by the corresponding operators. The problem with the above approach is that due to non-commutativity of the quantum operators, two mathematically equivalent formulations of the classical theory can lead to different (non-equivalent) quantum theories. An alternative quantization approach that directly transforms the non-quantum action functional into the appropriate quantum theory, was indeed proposed by the Nobelist Richard Feynman, under the name of path integration. Feynman path integration is not just a foundational idea, it is actually an efficient computing tool (Feynman diagrams).\nFrom the pragmatic viewpoint, Feynman path integral is a great success. However, from the foundational viewpoint, we still face an important question: why the Feynman's path integration formula? In this paper, we provide a natural explanation for Feynman's path integration formula.