Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1004.2640

Holographic position uncertainty and the quantum-classical transition

C. L. Herzenberg

Published Apr 15, 2010• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Arguments based on general principles of quantum mechanics have suggested that a minimum length associated with Planck-scale unification may in the context of the holographic principle entail a new kind of observable uncertainty in the transverse position of macroscopically separated objects. Here, we address potential implications of such a position uncertainty for establishing an additional threshold between quantum and classical behavior.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1004.2640

Related papers

Quantum Geometry and Interferometry

Craig J. Hogan

All existing experimental results are currently interpreted using classical geometry. However, there are theoretical reasons to suspect that at a deeper level, geometry emerges as an approximate macroscopic behavior of a quantum system at the Planck scale. If directions in emergent quantum geometry do not commute, new quantum-geometrical degrees of freedom can produce detectable macroscopic deviations from classicality: spatially coherent, transverse position indeterminacy between any pair of world lines, with a displacement amplitude much larger than the Planck length. Positions of separate bodies are entangled with each other, and undergo quantum-geometrical fluctuations that are not describable as metric fluctuations or gravitational waves. These fluctuations can either be cleanly identified or ruled out using interferometers. A Planck-precision test of the classical coherence of space-time on a laboratory scale is now underway at Fermilab.

arXiv:1208.3703•Aug 17, 2012•13 citations

The Holographic Nature of Quantum Mechanics

Vitaly Kuyukov Petrovich

This article applies the holographic principle to obtain the basic provisions holographic quantum mechanics and is an entirely new interpretation of the principle of the Heisenberg uncertainty over the measurement information about the state of the quantum object.

•Sep 1, 2014•0 citations

Hilbert space representation of the minimal length uncertainty relation

Achim Kempf, G. Mangano, Robert B. Mann

The existence of a minimal observable length has long been suggested in quantum gravity as well as in string theory. In this context a generalized uncertainty relation has been derived which quantum theoretically describes the minimal length as a minimal uncertainty in position measurements. Here we study in full detail the quantum-mechanical structure which underlies this uncertainty relation.

arXiv:hep-th/9412167•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jul 15, 1995•1,997 citations

Becoming Classical: A Possible Cosmological Influence on the Quantum-Classical Transition.

C. L. Herzenberg

Although cosmic expansion at very small distances is usually dismissed as entirely inconsequential, these extraordinarily small effects may in fact have a real and significant influence on our world. A calculation suggests that the minute recessional velocities associated with regions encompassed by extended bodies may have a role in creating the distinction between quantum and classical behavior. Using the criterion that the uncertainty in position should be smaller than the size of an object together with estimates based on the range of Hubble velocities extending through the object lead to a threshold size that could provide a fundamental limit distinguishing the realm of objects governed by classical laws from those governed by quantum mechanics.

arXiv:physics/0602161•Physics Essays•Dec 1, 2006•10 citations

Quantifying The Uncertainty Principle and The Effects of Minimal Length From a Finite-Dimensional Perspective

Oleg Kabernik

It is well known that due to the uncertainty principle the Planck constant sets a resolution boundary in phase space, and the resulting trade-off in resolutions between incompatible measurements has been thoroughly investigated. It is also known that in the classical regime sufficiently coarse measurements of position and momentum can simultaneously be determined. However, when we independently vary the resolutions of incompatible measurements, the picture of how the uncertainty principle transitions between the quantum and classical regimes is not so vivid. In the present work we will clarify this picture by studying certain probabilities that quantify the effects of the uncertainty principle. Since it is also expected that the uncertainty principle will be modified by the existence of minimal length in space, we will conduct our investigation on a lattice. We will show how these probabilities are modified by the lattice, and demonstrate the close relationship between the uncertainty principle and minimal length from a finite-dimensional perspective.

arXiv:2002.01564•Feb 4, 2020•1 citation

Minimal-length kinematics of coherent light and a proposed two-color vacuum chronoscopy

Zhi-Wei Wang, Saurya Das, Samuel L. Braunstein

The unification of quantum theory and general relativity suggests the existence of a minimal measurable length, leading to a generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) and an energy-dependent vacuum group velocity. Testing these effects with macroscopic objects typically encounters the ``soccer-ball problem,'' where applying Planck-scale deformations to the total momentum predicts observationally ruled-out velocity deviations. We adopt the QFT-natural prescription in which the GUP modifies single-mode commutators, and verify by explicit calculation that the macroscopic group velocity of a multimode coherent pulse reduces to the single-photon GUP velocity evaluated at the central wavelength, multiplied by the classical Gaussian-beam factor, with no dependence on the total pulse energy. The energy--momentum relation $E=pc$ itself is unmodified; the deformation enters through the velocity--momentum relation and is equivalent to a modified dispersion relation in the wave vector, with a quadratic coefficient that depends on which of the two variables is used. The soccer-ball problem $\,$---$\,$ which arises only when the GUP is applied to the center-of-mass momentum of a composite system $\,$---$\,$ is therefore absent for coherent light, and macroscopic petawatt pulses probe the same parameter space as single high-energy photons. Building on this framework, we propose a two-color vacuum chronoscopy experiment using a short-pulse petawatt laser and its high-harmonic generation. By systematically varying the macroscopic beam waist, our setup separates Planck-scale kinematic shifts from classical diffraction delays, establishing a controlled, source-independent terrestrial methodology whose sensitivity we assess against current astrophysical bounds and against the dominant waist-independent systematics that limit it, residual-gas dispersion and the harmonic birth-time offset.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2610.26892•Oct 16, 2026
Arguments based on general principles of quantum mechanics have suggested that a minimum length associated with Planck-scale unification may in the context of the holographic principle entail a new kind of observable uncertainty in the transverse position of macroscopically separated objects. Here, we address potential implications of such a position uncertainty for establishing an additional threshold between quantum and classical behavior.
All existing experimental results are currently interpreted using classical geometry. However, there are theoretical reasons to suspect that at a deeper level, geometry emerges as an approximate macroscopic behavior of a quantum system at the Planck scale. If directions in emergent quantum geometry do not commute, new quantum-geometrical degrees of freedom can produce detectable macroscopic deviations from classicality: spatially coherent, transverse position indeterminacy between any pair of world lines, with a displacement amplitude much larger than the Planck length. Positions of separate bodies are entangled with each other, and undergo quantum-geometrical fluctuations that are not describable as metric fluctuations or gravitational waves. These fluctuations can either be cleanly identified or ruled out using interferometers. A Planck-precision test of the classical coherence of space-time on a laboratory scale is now underway at Fermilab.
Although cosmic expansion at very small distances is usually dismissed as entirely inconsequential, these extraordinarily small effects may in fact have a real and significant influence on our world. A calculation suggests that the minute recessional velocities associated with regions encompassed by extended bodies may have a role in creating the distinction between quantum and classical behavior. Using the criterion that the uncertainty in position should be smaller than the size of an object together with estimates based on the range of Hubble velocities extending through the object lead to a threshold size that could provide a fundamental limit distinguishing the realm of objects governed by classical laws from those governed by quantum mechanics.
It is well known that due to the uncertainty principle the Planck constant sets a resolution boundary in phase space, and the resulting trade-off in resolutions between incompatible measurements has been thoroughly investigated. It is also known that in the classical regime sufficiently coarse measurements of position and momentum can simultaneously be determined. However, when we independently vary the resolutions of incompatible measurements, the picture of how the uncertainty principle transitions between the quantum and classical regimes is not so vivid. In the present work we will clarify this picture by studying certain probabilities that quantify the effects of the uncertainty principle. Since it is also expected that the uncertainty principle will be modified by the existence of minimal length in space, we will conduct our investigation on a lattice. We will show how these probabilities are modified by the lattice, and demonstrate the close relationship between the uncertainty principle and minimal length from a finite-dimensional perspective.
The unification of quantum theory and general relativity suggests the existence of a minimal measurable length, leading to a generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) and an energy-dependent vacuum group velocity. Testing these effects with macroscopic objects typically encounters the ``soccer-ball problem,'' where applying Planck-scale deformations to the total momentum predicts observationally ruled-out velocity deviations. We adopt the QFT-natural prescription in which the GUP modifies single-mode commutators, and verify by explicit calculation that the macroscopic group velocity of a multimode coherent pulse reduces to the single-photon GUP velocity evaluated at the central wavelength, multiplied by the classical Gaussian-beam factor, with no dependence on the total pulse energy. The energy--momentum relation E=pcE=pcE=pc itself is unmodified; the deformation enters through the velocity--momentum relation and is equivalent to a modified dispersion relation in the wave vector, with a quadratic coefficient that depends on which of the two variables is used. The soccer-ball problem  \,--- \, which arises only when the GUP is applied to the center-of-mass momentum of a composite system  \,--- \, is therefore absent for coherent light, and macroscopic petawatt pulses probe the same parameter space as single high-energy photons. Building on this framework, we propose a two-color vacuum chronoscopy experiment using a short-pulse petawatt laser and its high-harmonic generation. By systematically varying the macroscopic beam waist, our setup separates Planck-scale kinematic shifts from classical diffraction delays, establishing a controlled, source-independent terrestrial methodology whose sensitivity we assess against current astrophysical bounds and against the dominant waist-independent systematics that limit it, residual-gas dispersion and the harmonic birth-time offset.