Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2002.01564

Quantifying The Uncertainty Principle and The Effects of Minimal Length From a Finite-Dimensional Perspective

Oleg Kabernik

Published Feb 4, 2020• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is well known that due to the uncertainty principle the Planck constant sets a resolution boundary in phase space, and the resulting trade-off in resolutions between incompatible measurements has been thoroughly investigated. It is also known that in the classical regime sufficiently coarse measurements of position and momentum can simultaneously be determined. However, when we independently vary the resolutions of incompatible measurements, the picture of how the uncertainty principle transitions between the quantum and classical regimes is not so vivid. In the present work we will clarify this picture by studying certain probabilities that quantify the effects of the uncertainty principle. Since it is also expected that the uncertainty principle will be modified by the existence of minimal length in space, we will conduct our investigation on a lattice. We will show how these probabilities are modified by the lattice, and demonstrate the close relationship between the uncertainty principle and minimal length from a finite-dimensional perspective.

Related papers

On Majorization Uncertainty Relations in the Presence of a Minimal Length

Alexey E. Rastegin

The emergence of a minimal length at the Planck scale is consistent with modern developments in quantum gravity. This is taken into account by transforming the Heisenberg uncertainty principle into the generalized uncertainty principle. Here, the position-momentum commutator is modified accordingly. In this paper, majorization uncertainty relations within the generalized uncertainty principle are considered. Dealing with observables with continuous spectra, each of the axes of interest is divided into a set of non-intersecting bins. Such formulation is consistent with real experiments with a necessarily limited precision. On the other hand, the majorization approach is mainly indicative for high-resolution measurements with sufficiently small bins. Indeed, the effects of the uncertainty principle are brightly manifested just in this case. The current study aims to reveal how the generalized uncertainty principle affects the leading terms of the majorization bound for position and momentum measurements. Interrelations with entropic formulations of this principle are briefly discussed.

Physics•Dec 14, 2022•1 citation

Position in Minimal Length Quantum Mechanics

Pasquale Bosso

Several approaches to quantum gravity imply the presence of a minimal measurable length at high energies. This is in tension with the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. Such a contrast is then considered in phenomenological approaches to quantum gravity by introducing a minimal length in quantum mechanics via the Generalized Uncertainty Principle. Several features of the standard theory are affected by such a modification. For example, position eigenstates are no longer included in models of quantum mechanics with a minimal length. Furthermore, while the momentum-space description can still be realized in a relatively straightforward way, the (quasi-)position representation acquires numerous issues. Here, we will review such issues, clarifying aspects regarding models with a minimal length. Finally, we will consider the effects of such models on simple quantum mechanical systems.

Universe•Dec 29, 2021•2 citations

Optimal uncertainty relations in a modified Heisenberg algebra

Kais Abdelkhalek, Wissam A Chemissany, Leander Fiedler +2 more

Various theories that aim at unifying gravity with quantum mechanics suggest modifications of the Heisenberg algebra for position and momentum. From the perspective of quantum mechanics, such modifications lead to new uncertainty relations that are thought (but not proven) to imply the existence of a minimal observable length. Here we prove this statement in a framework of sufficient physical and structural assumptions. Moreover, we present a general method that allows us to formulate optimal and state-independent variance-based uncertainty relations. In addition, instead of variances, we make use of entropies as a measure of uncertainty and provide uncertainty relations in terms of min and Shannon entropies. We compute the corresponding entropic minimal lengths and find that the minimal length in terms of min entropy is exactly 1 bit.

arXiv:1607.00081•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Dec 5, 2016•20 citations

Position in Models of Quantum Mechanics with a Minimal Length

Pasquale Bosso

Candidate theories of quantum gravity predict the presence of a minimal measurable length at high energies. Such feature is in contrast with the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. Therefore, phenomenological approaches to quantum gravity introduced models spelled as modifications of quantum mechanics including a minimal length. The effects of such modification are expected to be relevant at large energies/small lengths. One first consequence is that position eigenstates are not included in such models due to the presence of a minimal uncertainty in position. Furthermore, depending on the particular modification of the position–momentum commutator, when such models are considered from momentum space, the position operator is changed, and a measure factor appears to let the position operator be self-adjoint. As a consequence, the (quasi-)position representation acquires numerous issues. For example, the position operator is no longer a multiplicative operator, and the momentum of a free particle does not correspond directly to its wave number. Here, we will review such issues, clarifying aspects of minimal length models, with particular reference to the representation of the position operator. Furthermore, we will show how such a (quasi-)position description of quantum mechanical models with a minimal length affects results concerning simple systems.

Electronic Conference on Universe (ECU)•Feb 22, 2021•3 citations

Noise-resolution uncertainty principle in classical and quantum systems

Timur E. Gureyev, Alexander Kozlov, David M. Paganin +2 more

We show that the width of an arbitrary function and the width of the distribution of its values cannot be made arbitrarily small simultaneously. In the case of ergodic stochastic processes, an ensuing uncertainty relationship is then demonstrated for the product of correlation length and variance. A closely related uncertainty principle is also established for the average degree of fourth-order coherence and the spatial width of modes of bosonic quantum fields. However, it is shown that, in the case of stochastic and quantum observables, certain non-classical states with sub-Poissonian statistics, such as for example photon number squeezed states in quantum optics, can overcome the "classical" noise-resolution uncertainty limit. This uncertainty relationship, which is fundamentally different from the Heisenberg and related uncertainty principles, can define an upper limit for the information capacity of communication and imaging systems. It is expected to be useful in a variety of problems in classical and quantum optics and imaging.

arXiv:1811.12592•Scientific Reports•May 12, 2020•11 citations

The Uncertainty Principle as a Structural Admissibility Constraint

Lisa Michelle Doumbouya

The uncertainty principle is among the most widely cited results of quantum mechanics, yet it is also one of the most persistently misunderstood. It is frequently explained as a limitation of measurement, experimental disturbance, or technological precision, despite being fundamentally independent of observation. This paper reframes the uncertainty principle as a structural constraint arising from the geometry of admissible physical paths under finite temporal resolution. We argue that tradeoffs between localization and momentum coherence do not reflect epistemic ignorance or measurement back-action, but instead express an unavoidable incompatibility between competing structural requirements. Within a structure-first framework, uncertainty emerges naturally from the need to maintain global coherence while restricting admissible continuation. This interpretation preserves the standard formalism of quantum mechanics while clarifying the conceptual origin of uncertainty and preparing a foundation for later discussions of quantum fields as pre-nodal harmonic structure.

•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations
It is well known that due to the uncertainty principle the Planck constant sets a resolution boundary in phase space, and the resulting trade-off in resolutions between incompatible measurements has been thoroughly investigated. It is also known that in the classical regime sufficiently coarse measurements of position and momentum can simultaneously be determined. However, when we independently vary the resolutions of incompatible measurements, the picture of how the uncertainty principle transitions between the quantum and classical regimes is not so vivid. In the present work we will clarify this picture by studying certain probabilities that quantify the effects of the uncertainty principle. Since it is also expected that the uncertainty principle will be modified by the existence of minimal length in space, we will conduct our investigation on a lattice. We will show how these probabilities are modified by the lattice, and demonstrate the close relationship between the uncertainty principle and minimal length from a finite-dimensional perspective.
The emergence of a minimal length at the Planck scale is consistent with modern developments in quantum gravity. This is taken into account by transforming the Heisenberg uncertainty principle into the generalized uncertainty principle. Here, the position-momentum commutator is modified accordingly. In this paper, majorization uncertainty relations within the generalized uncertainty principle are considered. Dealing with observables with continuous spectra, each of the axes of interest is divided into a set of non-intersecting bins. Such formulation is consistent with real experiments with a necessarily limited precision. On the other hand, the majorization approach is mainly indicative for high-resolution measurements with sufficiently small bins. Indeed, the effects of the uncertainty principle are brightly manifested just in this case. The current study aims to reveal how the generalized uncertainty principle affects the leading terms of the majorization bound for position and momentum measurements. Interrelations with entropic formulations of this principle are briefly discussed.
Several approaches to quantum gravity imply the presence of a minimal measurable length at high energies. This is in tension with the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. Such a contrast is then considered in phenomenological approaches to quantum gravity by introducing a minimal length in quantum mechanics via the Generalized Uncertainty Principle. Several features of the standard theory are affected by such a modification. For example, position eigenstates are no longer included in models of quantum mechanics with a minimal length. Furthermore, while the momentum-space description can still be realized in a relatively straightforward way, the (quasi-)position representation acquires numerous issues. Here, we will review such issues, clarifying aspects regarding models with a minimal length. Finally, we will consider the effects of such models on simple quantum mechanical systems.
Various theories that aim at unifying gravity with quantum mechanics suggest modifications of the Heisenberg algebra for position and momentum. From the perspective of quantum mechanics, such modifications lead to new uncertainty relations that are thought (but not proven) to imply the existence of a minimal observable length. Here we prove this statement in a framework of sufficient physical and structural assumptions. Moreover, we present a general method that allows us to formulate optimal and state-independent variance-based uncertainty relations. In addition, instead of variances, we make use of entropies as a measure of uncertainty and provide uncertainty relations in terms of min and Shannon entropies. We compute the corresponding entropic minimal lengths and find that the minimal length in terms of min entropy is exactly 1 bit.
Candidate theories of quantum gravity predict the presence of a minimal measurable length at high energies. Such feature is in contrast with the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. Therefore, phenomenological approaches to quantum gravity introduced models spelled as modifications of quantum mechanics including a minimal length. The effects of such modification are expected to be relevant at large energies/small lengths. One first consequence is that position eigenstates are not included in such models due to the presence of a minimal uncertainty in position. Furthermore, depending on the particular modification of the position–momentum commutator, when such models are considered from momentum space, the position operator is changed, and a measure factor appears to let the position operator be self-adjoint. As a consequence, the (quasi-)position representation acquires numerous issues. For example, the position operator is no longer a multiplicative operator, and the momentum of a free particle does not correspond directly to its wave number. Here, we will review such issues, clarifying aspects of minimal length models, with particular reference to the representation of the position operator. Furthermore, we will show how such a (quasi-)position description of quantum mechanical models with a minimal length affects results concerning simple systems.
We show that the width of an arbitrary function and the width of the distribution of its values cannot be made arbitrarily small simultaneously. In the case of ergodic stochastic processes, an ensuing uncertainty relationship is then demonstrated for the product of correlation length and variance. A closely related uncertainty principle is also established for the average degree of fourth-order coherence and the spatial width of modes of bosonic quantum fields. However, it is shown that, in the case of stochastic and quantum observables, certain non-classical states with sub-Poissonian statistics, such as for example photon number squeezed states in quantum optics, can overcome the "classical" noise-resolution uncertainty limit. This uncertainty relationship, which is fundamentally different from the Heisenberg and related uncertainty principles, can define an upper limit for the information capacity of communication and imaging systems. It is expected to be useful in a variety of problems in classical and quantum optics and imaging.
The uncertainty principle is among the most widely cited results of quantum mechanics, yet it is also one of the most persistently misunderstood. It is frequently explained as a limitation of measurement, experimental disturbance, or technological precision, despite being fundamentally independent of observation. This paper reframes the uncertainty principle as a structural constraint arising from the geometry of admissible physical paths under finite temporal resolution. We argue that tradeoffs between localization and momentum coherence do not reflect epistemic ignorance or measurement back-action, but instead express an unavoidable incompatibility between competing structural requirements. Within a structure-first framework, uncertainty emerges naturally from the need to maintain global coherence while restricting admissible continuation. This interpretation preserves the standard formalism of quantum mechanics while clarifying the conceptual origin of uncertainty and preparing a foundation for later discussions of quantum fields as pre-nodal harmonic structure.