arXiv:2610.26892
Minimal-length kinematics of coherent light and a proposed two-color vacuum chronoscopy
Zhi-Wei Wang, Saurya Das, Samuel L. Braunstein
Abstract
The unification of quantum theory and general relativity suggests the existence of a minimal measurable length, leading to a generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) and an energy-dependent vacuum group velocity. Testing these effects with macroscopic objects typically encounters the ``soccer-ball problem,'' where applying Planck-scale deformations to the total momentum predicts observationally ruled-out velocity deviations. We adopt the QFT-natural prescription in which the GUP modifies single-mode commutators, and verify by explicit calculation that the macroscopic group velocity of a multimode coherent pulse reduces to the single-photon GUP velocity evaluated at the central wavelength, multiplied by the classical Gaussian-beam factor, with no dependence on the total pulse energy. The energy--momentum relation $E=pc$ itself is unmodified; the deformation enters through the velocity--momentum relation and is equivalent to a modified dispersion relation in the wave vector, with a quadratic coefficient that depends on which of the two variables is used. The soccer-ball problem $\,$---$\,$ which arises only when the GUP is applied to the center-of-mass momentum of a composite system $\,$---$\,$ is therefore absent for coherent light, and macroscopic petawatt pulses probe the same parameter space as single high-energy photons. Building on this framework, we propose a two-color vacuum chronoscopy experiment using a short-pulse petawatt laser and its high-harmonic generation. By systematically varying the macroscopic beam waist, our setup separates Planck-scale kinematic shifts from classical diffraction delays, establishing a controlled, source-independent terrestrial methodology whose sensitivity we assess against current astrophysical bounds and against the dominant waist-independent systematics that limit it, residual-gas dispersion and the harmonic birth-time offset.
AI Summary
The paper asks how a phenomenological generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) affects coherent-light propagation without producing pulse-energy-dependent velocities—the “soccer-ball problem”—and whether two-color terrestrial timing can test the resulting dispersion. It assumes a deformation acting independently on individual photon modes, retains $E=cp$, and expresses the modification through a nonlinear relation between physical momentum and wave vector. Using photon-number-weighted momentum sums for a multimode coherent state with a Gaussian envelope, it calculates an energy-weighted transport velocity. In the paraxial, narrow-band limit, total pulse energy cancels, giving $V\simeq c[1-\lambda^2/(8\pi^2w^2)][1-2\pi\alpha_0l_{\rm Pl}/\lambda+4\pi^2\beta_0^{(k)}l_{\rm Pl}^2/\lambda^2]$, where $\beta_0^{(k)}=\beta_0+\alpha_0^2/2$. Avoidance of macroscopic amplification follows from the assumed per-mode prescription; the calculation is presented as a consistency check. At this order, photon statistics beyond spectral occupations do not enter. The proposed experiment compares an $800$ nm infrared pulse with its $1$ nm high harmonic over $4$ km. Scanning beam waist separates the $1/w^2$ diffraction delay from a waist-independent intercept. Assuming $10^{-21}$ s timing and controlled systematics, a null result would give $\alpha_0\lesssim7.4\times10^8$ or, with $\alpha_0=0$, $\beta_0\lesssim7\times10^{33}$, versus quoted astrophysical bounds near $0.083$ and $4.3\times10^{14}$. Order-unity linear sensitivity would require approximately $10^{-30}$ s timing. Stated limitations include photon flux, unestablished timing performance for this setup, residual-gas delays requiring pressure characterization or scans, and a $10^{-16}$–$10^{-15}$ s harmonic birth-time offset requiring multiple baselines. Optical path changes and source drift also require control.
Error found: The central-wavelength formula is a narrowband, paraxial approximation with neglected mixed corrections, rather than an unrestricted identity for multimode coherent pulses. The pulse-velocity derivation incorrectly uses undeformed photon energies as exact weights despite stipulating a modified dispersion, omitting a finite-bandwidth correction at quadratic order. The experimental prose reverses the relative signs: positive beta reinforces the differential diffraction delay, while positive alpha opposes it. The general quadratic-order time-of-flight formula omits the alpha_0^2 term required when inverting the stated velocity.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 18 pages, 5 figures, accepted by Physical Review D