Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9909048

On the Possibility of Unconditionally Secure Quantum Bit Commitment

Chi-Yee Cheung

Published Sep 15, 1999• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We propose a new quantum bit commitment scheme which is unconditionally secure.The key observation we make is that, by random permutation of particles, two appropriately prepared quantum mixtures with distinguishable density matrices can be rendered indistinguishable to another observer.In the new scheme, the sender encodes the bit in a mixture with commitment dependent density matrix, and randomizes the order of the particles to conceal the information from the receiver.Our result contradicts the claims in the literature that unconditionally secure quantum bit commitment is impossible.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/9909048

Related papers

How unconditionally secure quantum bit commitment is possible

Horace P. Yuen

Bit commitment involves the submission of evidence from one party to another so that the evidence can be used to confirm a later revealed bit value by the first party, while the second party cannot determine the bit value from the evidence alone. It is widely believed that unconditionally secure quantum bit commitment is impossible due to quantum entanglement cheating, which is codified in a general impossibility theorem. In this paper, the scope of this general impossibility proof is analyzed, and gaps are found. Two variants of a bit commitment scheme utilizing anonymous quantum states and decoy states are presented. In the first variant, the exact verifying measurement is independent of the committed bit value, thus the second party can make it before the first party opens, making possible an unconditional security proof based on no-cloning. In the second variant, the impossibility proof fails because quantum entanglement purification of a mixed state does not render the protocol determinate. Whether impossibility holds in this or similar protocols is an open question, although preliminary results already show that the impossibility proof cannot work as it stands.

arXiv:quant-ph/0109055•Sep 13, 2001•12 citations

Unconditionally Secure Qubit Commitment Scheme Using Quantum Maskers

Seok Hyung Lie, Hyukjoon Kwon, Myung-Gun Kim +1 more

A commitment scheme allows one to commit to hidden information while keeping its value recoverable when needed. Despite considerable efforts, an unconditionally and perfectly secure bit commitment has been proven impossible both classically and quantum-mechanically. The situation is similar when committing to qubits instead of classical bits as implied in the no-masking theorem [K. Modi et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 120}, 230501 (2018)]. In this Letter, we find that circumvention of the no-masking theorem is possible with the aid of classical randomness. Based on this, we construct an unconditionally secure quit-commitment scheme that utilises any kind of universal quantum maskers with optimal randomness consumption, which is distributed by a trusted initializer. This shows that randomness, which is normally considered only to obscure the information, can benefit a quantum secure communication scheme. This result can be generalised to an arbitrary dimensional system.

•Mar 29, 2019•10 citations

Unconditionally Secure Quantum Bit Commitment is Simply Possible

Arindam Mitra

It has been claimed that unconditionally secure quantum bit commitment is impossible. This claim has been widely accepted and is commonly referred to as the no-go theorem. The no-go theorem implicitly raises the question of whether quantum mechanics can be collectively verified with unconditional security against cheating. We demonstrate that by following an alternative quantum encoding scheme, unconditionally secure quantum bit commitment can, in fact, be achieved.

arXiv:physics/0007089•Jul 28, 2000•5 citations

Unconditionally Secure Quantum Bit Commitment is Impossible

Dominic Mayers

The claim of quantum cryptography has always been that it can provide protocols that are unconditionally secure, that is, for which the security does not depend on any restriction on the time, space, or technology available to the cheaters. We show that this claim does not hold for any quantum bit commitment protocol. Since many cryptographic tasks use bit commitment as a basic primitive, this result implies a severe setback for quantum cryptography. The model used encompasses all reasonable implementations of quantum bit commitment protocols in which the participants have not met before, including those that make use of the theory of special relativity.

arXiv:quant-ph/9605044•Physical Review Letters•Apr 28, 1997•767 citations

Unconditionally Secure Quantum Bit Commitment

Horace P. Yuen

The ``impossibility proof'' on unconditionally secure quantum bit commitment is examined. It is shown that the possibility of juxtaposing quantum and classical randomness has not been properly taken into account. A specific protocol that beats entanglement cheating with entanglement is proven to be unconditionally secure.

arXiv:quant-ph/0505132•May 18, 2005•11 citations

Is entanglement necessary to have unconditional security in quantum bit commitment ?

Arindam Mitra

A simple un-entanglement based quantum bit commitment scheme is presented. Although commitment is unconditionally secure but concealment is not.

arXiv:cs/0503048•Mar 21, 2005•1 citation
We propose a new quantum bit commitment scheme which is unconditionally secure.The key observation we make is that, by random permutation of particles, two appropriately prepared quantum mixtures with distinguishable density matrices can be rendered indistinguishable to another observer.In the new scheme, the sender encodes the bit in a mixture with commitment dependent density matrix, and randomizes the order of the particles to conceal the information from the receiver.Our result contradicts the claims in the literature that unconditionally secure quantum bit commitment is impossible.
Bit commitment involves the submission of evidence from one party to another so that the evidence can be used to confirm a later revealed bit value by the first party, while the second party cannot determine the bit value from the evidence alone. It is widely believed that unconditionally secure quantum bit commitment is impossible due to quantum entanglement cheating, which is codified in a general impossibility theorem. In this paper, the scope of this general impossibility proof is analyzed, and gaps are found. Two variants of a bit commitment scheme utilizing anonymous quantum states and decoy states are presented. In the first variant, the exact verifying measurement is independent of the committed bit value, thus the second party can make it before the first party opens, making possible an unconditional security proof based on no-cloning. In the second variant, the impossibility proof fails because quantum entanglement purification of a mixed state does not render the protocol determinate. Whether impossibility holds in this or similar protocols is an open question, although preliminary results already show that the impossibility proof cannot work as it stands.
A commitment scheme allows one to commit to hidden information while keeping its value recoverable when needed. Despite considerable efforts, an unconditionally and perfectly secure bit commitment has been proven impossible both classically and quantum-mechanically. The situation is similar when committing to qubits instead of classical bits as implied in the no-masking theorem [K. Modi et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 120}, 230501 (2018)]. In this Letter, we find that circumvention of the no-masking theorem is possible with the aid of classical randomness. Based on this, we construct an unconditionally secure quit-commitment scheme that utilises any kind of universal quantum maskers with optimal randomness consumption, which is distributed by a trusted initializer. This shows that randomness, which is normally considered only to obscure the information, can benefit a quantum secure communication scheme. This result can be generalised to an arbitrary dimensional system.
The claim of quantum cryptography has always been that it can provide protocols that are unconditionally secure, that is, for which the security does not depend on any restriction on the time, space, or technology available to the cheaters. We show that this claim does not hold for any quantum bit commitment protocol. Since many cryptographic tasks use bit commitment as a basic primitive, this result implies a severe setback for quantum cryptography. The model used encompasses all reasonable implementations of quantum bit commitment protocols in which the participants have not met before, including those that make use of the theory of special relativity.