Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9809017 · Physical Review A

Comment on “Consistency, amplitudes, and probabilities in quantum theory”

J. Finkelstein

Published Aug 1, 1999• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a recent article [Phys. Rev. A 57, 1572 (1998)] Caticha has concluded that ``nonlinear variants of quantum mechanics are inconsistent.'' In this paper we identify which assumptions made in that article lead to this conclusion.
DOI
10.1103/physreva.60.1723

Related papers

Consistency, amplitudes and probabilities in quantum theory

Yoel Tikochinsky, Stephen F Gull

Caticha (1998 Phys. Rev. A 57 1572) applies consistency arguments to derive the quantum mechanical rules for compounding probability amplitudes in much the same way as in earlier work by Tikochinsky (1988 J. Math. Phys. 29 398, 1988 Int. J. Theor. Phys. 27 543). These works are examined together to find the assumptions needed to obtain the most general results.

arXiv:quant-ph/9903031•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jul 28, 2000•5 citations

The assumptions underlying the consistent-amplitude approach to quantum theory

Ariel Caticha

In this note I expand further on the main assumptions leading to the consistent-amplitude approach to quantum theory and I offer a reply to Jerry Finkelstein's recent comment (quant-ph/9809017) concerning my argument for the linearity of quantum mechanics (Phys. Rev. A57, 1572 (1998)).

arXiv:quant-ph/9809066•Sep 22, 1998•1 citation

Reply to “Comment on ‘Consistency, amplitudes, and probabilities in quantum theory’ ”

Ariel Caticha

I reply to Finkelstein’s comment [preceding paper, Phys. Rev. A 60, 1723 (1999)] and remark on the meanings conveyed by the word “amplitude.”Received 23 December 1998DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.60.1725©1999 American Physical Society

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1999•1 citation

Reply to “Comment on ‘Nonlocality counterfactuals, and quantum mechanics’ ”

William George Unruh

Stapp [preceding Comment, Phys. Rev. A 60, 2595 (1999)] has argued that my criticism of his nonlocality proof is wrong. I point out that counterfactual arguments are fraught with dangers, and that any such claim should use them in a conservative manner. A reanalysis of his claims continues to lead me to the conclusion that the nonlocality of quantum mechanics remains unproven.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1999•2 citations

Comment on "Association between quantum paradoxes based on weak values and a realistic interpretation of quantum measurements"

Juan José Seoane, Xabier Oianguren-Asua, Albert Solé +1 more

In their paper (arXiv:2402.09879), Aredes and Saldanha analyze several paradoxes related to weak values and present a "general argument" that aims to show that "realistic interpretations ...of weak values lead to inconsistencies". Although we agree with the identified inconsistencies for the specific weak values analyzed there, in this Comment we demonstrate that the origin of these inconsistencies is not their general argument, which is formally incorrect. We use Bohmian mechanics as a counterexample to confirm that their conclusions are not valid for all weak values and quantum theories. In particular, we show that weak values postselected in position can in fact be interpreted within Bohmian mechanics as properties of quantum systems, detached from any measuring devices, in a consistent and meaningful way.

quant-pharXiv:2603.18713•Physical Review A•Mar 20, 2026•3 citations

Comment on ‘On the inconsistency of the Bohm–Gadella theory with quantum mechanics’

Manuel Gadella, S. Wickramasekara

Rigged Hilbert spaces of Hardy functions lead to a consistent theory of resonance scattering and decay. Contrary to the claims of a recent article [8], the theory holds for a wide range of potentials and rigorously describes the asymmetric time evolution of resonances.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 11, 2007•3 citations
In their paper (arXiv:2402.09879), Aredes and Saldanha analyze several paradoxes related to weak values and present a "general argument" that aims to show that "realistic interpretations ...of weak values lead to inconsistencies". Although we agree with the identified inconsistencies for the specific weak values analyzed there, in this Comment we demonstrate that the origin of these inconsistencies is not their general argument, which is formally incorrect. We use Bohmian mechanics as a counterexample to confirm that their conclusions are not valid for all weak values and quantum theories. In particular, we show that weak values postselected in position can in fact be interpreted within Bohmian mechanics as properties of quantum systems, detached from any measuring devices, in a consistent and meaningful way.