Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Comment on ‘On the inconsistency of the Bohm–Gadella theory with quantum mechanics’

Manuel Gadella, S. Wickramasekara

Published Apr 11, 2007• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Rigged Hilbert spaces of Hardy functions lead to a consistent theory of resonance scattering and decay. Contrary to the claims of a recent article [8], the theory holds for a wide range of potentials and rigorously describes the asymmetric time evolution of resonances.
DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/40/17/n01

Related papers

Reply to ‘Comment on ‘On the inconsistency of the Bohm–Gadella theory with quantum mechanics’’

Rafael de la Madrid

In this reply, we show that when we apply standard distribution theory to the Lippmann–Schwinger equation, the resulting spaces of test functions would comply with the Hardy axiom only if classic results of Paley and Wiener, of Gelfand and Shilov, and of the theory of ultradistributions were wrong. Also, we point out several differences between the ‘standard method’ of constructing rigged Hilbert spaces in quantum mechanics and the method used in time asymmetric quantum theory.

arXiv:0704.1613•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 11, 2007•3 citations

On the inconsistency of the Bohm–Gadella theory with quantum mechanics

Rafael de la Madrid

The Bohm–Gadella theory, sometimes referred to as the time asymmetric quantum theory of scattering and decay, is based on the Hardy axiom. The Hardy axiom asserts that the solutions of the Lippmann–Schwinger equation are functionals over spaces of Hardy functions. The preparation–registration arrow of time provides the physical justification for the Hardy axiom. In this paper, it is shown that the Hardy axiom is incorrect, because the solutions of the Lippmann–Schwinger equation do not act on spaces of Hardy functions. It is also shown that the derivation of the preparation–registration arrow of time is flawed. Thus, Hardy functions neither appear when we solve the Lippmann–Schwinger equation nor should they appear. It is also shown that the Bohm–Gadella theory does not rest on the same physical principles as quantum mechanics, and that it does not solve any problem that quantum mechanics cannot solve. The Bohm–Gadella theory must therefore be abandoned.

arXiv:quant-ph/0606186•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jul 5, 2006•8 citations

RIGGED HILBERT SPACE RESONANCES AND TIME ASYMMETRIC QUANTUM MECHANICS

Arno Böhm, Hani Kaldass

The Rigged Hilbert Space (RHS) theory of resonance scattering and decay is reviewed and contrasted with the standard Hilbert space (HS) theory of quantum mechanics. The main difference is in the choice of boundary conditions. Whereas the conventional theory allows for the in-states $ϕ^+$ and the out-states (observables) $ψ^-$ of the S-matrix elements $(ψ^-,ϕ^+)=(ψ^{out},S ϕ^{in})$ any elements of the HS $\H$, $\{ψ^-\}=\{ϕ^+\}(=\H)$, the RHS theory chooses the boundary conditions~: $ϕ^+\inΦ_-\subset\H\subsetΦ_-^\times$, $ψ^-\inΦ_+\subset \H\subset Φ_+^\times$, where $Φ_-$ ($Φ_+$) are Hardy class spaces associated to the lower (upper) half-plane of the second sheet of the analytically continued S-matrix. This can be phenomenologically justified by causality. The two RHS's for states $ϕ^+$ and observables $ψ^-$ provide new vectors which are not in $\H$, e.g. the Dirac-Lippmann-Schwinger kets $|E^{\pm}\inΦ_{\mp}^{\times}$ (solutions of the Lippmann-Schwinger equation with $\pm iε$ respectively) and the Gamow vectors $|E_R-iΓ/2^\pm\inΦ_{\mp}^\times$. The Gamow vectors $|E_R-iΓ/2^-$ have all the properties that one heuristically needs for quasistable states. In addition, they give rise to asymmetric time evolution expressing irreversibility on the microphysical level.

arXiv:quant-ph/9909081•WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 1, 2000•5 citations

Resonances, Gamow Vectors and Time Asymmetric Quantum Theory

Arno Böhm, Raymond Scurek, Sujeewa Wikramasekara

Decaying states can be represented by Gamow vectors with an exponential, asymmetric time evolution. This asymmetric evolution is a manifestation of irreversibility on the microphysical level. The Rigged Hilbert Space provides a mathematical theory.

arXiv:nucl-th/9902076•Revista Mexicana de Física•Feb 26, 1999•10 citations

Mathematical Foundations of Time Asymmetric Quantum Mechanics

Manuel Gadella

We review the mathematical tools that are suitable for a formulation of time asymmetry in quantum mechanics. In particular, Hardy functions on a half plane and rigged Hilbert spaces constructed with a subclass of Hardy functions. This time asymmetry often appears in quantum scattering and, in particular, in resonance scattering. We review the construction of Gamow vectors, often considered Gamow states for resonances. A brief summary of the fundamental ideas of time asymmetric quantum mechanics is presented in a last section.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 26, 2017•2 citations

Remarks related to the paper of Rafael de la Madrid: "On the inconsistency of the Bohm-Gadella theory with quantum mechanics", JPhysA 39, No. 29, 9255-9268 (2006)

Hellmut Baumgaertel

The paper contains critical comments to the paper mentioned in the title from the mathematical point of view

arXiv:0704.3529•Apr 26, 2007•2 citations
The Bohm–Gadella theory, sometimes referred to as the time asymmetric quantum theory of scattering and decay, is based on the Hardy axiom. The Hardy axiom asserts that the solutions of the Lippmann–Schwinger equation are functionals over spaces of Hardy functions. The preparation–registration arrow of time provides the physical justification for the Hardy axiom. In this paper, it is shown that the Hardy axiom is incorrect, because the solutions of the Lippmann–Schwinger equation do not act on spaces of Hardy functions. It is also shown that the derivation of the preparation–registration arrow of time is flawed. Thus, Hardy functions neither appear when we solve the Lippmann–Schwinger equation nor should they appear. It is also shown that the Bohm–Gadella theory does not rest on the same physical principles as quantum mechanics, and that it does not solve any problem that quantum mechanics cannot solve. The Bohm–Gadella theory must therefore be abandoned.
The Rigged Hilbert Space (RHS) theory of resonance scattering and decay is reviewed and contrasted with the standard Hilbert space (HS) theory of quantum mechanics. The main difference is in the choice of boundary conditions. Whereas the conventional theory allows for the in-states ϕ+ϕ^+ϕ+ and the out-states (observables) ψ−ψ^-ψ− of the S-matrix elements (ψ−,ϕ+)=(ψout,Sϕin)(ψ^-,ϕ^+)=(ψ^{out},S ϕ^{in})(ψ−,ϕ+)=(ψout,Sϕin) any elements of the HS $\H$, {ψ−}={ϕ+}(=)˝\{ψ^-\}=\{ϕ^+\}(=\H){ψ−}={ϕ+}(=)˝​, the RHS theory chooses the boundary conditions~: ϕ+∈Φ−⊂⊂˝Φ−×ϕ^+\inΦ_-\subset\H\subsetΦ_-^\timesϕ+∈Φ−​⊂⊂˝​Φ−×​, ψ−∈Φ+⊂⊂˝Φ+×ψ^-\inΦ_+\subset \H\subset Φ_+^\timesψ−∈Φ+​⊂⊂˝​Φ+×​, where Φ−Φ_-Φ−​ (Φ+Φ_+Φ+​) are Hardy class spaces associated to the lower (upper) half-plane of the second sheet of the analytically continued S-matrix. This can be phenomenologically justified by causality. The two RHS's for states ϕ+ϕ^+ϕ+ and observables ψ−ψ^-ψ− provide new vectors which are not in $\H$, e.g. the Dirac-Lippmann-Schwinger kets ∣E±∈Φ∓×|E^{\pm}\inΦ_{\mp}^{\times}∣E±∈Φ∓×​ (solutions of the Lippmann-Schwinger equation with ±iε\pm iε±iε respectively) and the Gamow vectors ∣ER−iΓ/2±∈Φ∓×|E_R-iΓ/2^\pm\inΦ_{\mp}^\times∣ER​−iΓ/2±∈Φ∓×​. The Gamow vectors ∣ER−iΓ/2−|E_R-iΓ/2^-∣ER​−iΓ/2− have all the properties that one heuristically needs for quasistable states. In addition, they give rise to asymmetric time evolution expressing irreversibility on the microphysical level.
We review the mathematical tools that are suitable for a formulation of time asymmetry in quantum mechanics. In particular, Hardy functions on a half plane and rigged Hilbert spaces constructed with a subclass of Hardy functions. This time asymmetry often appears in quantum scattering and, in particular, in resonance scattering. We review the construction of Gamow vectors, often considered Gamow states for resonances. A brief summary of the fundamental ideas of time asymmetric quantum mechanics is presented in a last section.