Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9804012 · Physical Review A

Consistency, amplitudes, and probabilities in quantum theory

Ariel Caticha

Published Mar 1, 1998• 63 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum theory is formulated as the only consistent way to manipulate probability amplitudes. The crucial ingredient is a very natural consistency constraint: if there are two different ways to compute the amplitude for a given process, the two answers must agree. This constraint is expressed in the form of functional equations the solution of which leads to the usual sum and product rules for amplitudes. An immediate consequence is that the Schr\"odinger equation must be linear; i.e., nonlinear variants of quantum mechanics are inconsistent. The physical interpretation of the theory is given in terms of a single natural rule. This rule, which does not itself involve any probabilities, is used to obtain a proof of Born's statistical postulate: we show that the probability of a certain outcome in an experiment is given by the square of the modulus of the corresponding amplitude. Thus, consistency leads to indeterminism.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.57.1572

Related papers

Quantum Mechanics without Probability Amplitudes

William K. Wootters

First steps are taken toward a formulation of quantum mechanics which avoids the use of probability amplitudes and is expressed entirely in terms of observable probabilities. Quantum states are represented not by state vectors or density matrices but by “probability tables,” which contain only the probabilities of the outcomes of certain special measurements. The rule for computing transition probabilities, normally given by the squared modulus of the inner product of two state vectors, is re-expressed in terms of probability tables. The new version of the rule is surprisingly simple, especially when one considers that the notion of complex phases, so crucial in the evaluation of inner products, is entirely absent from the representation of states used here.

Princeton University Press eBooks•Jul 5, 2017•0 citations

Derivation of quantum probabilities from deterministic evolution

T. G. Philbin

The predictions of quantum mechanics are probabilistic. Quantum probabilities are extracted using a postulate of the theory called the Born rule, the status of which is central to the "measurement problem" of quantum mechanics. Efforts to justify the Born rule from other physical principles, and thus elucidate the measurement process, have involved lengthy statistical or information-theoretic arguments. Here we show that Bohm's deterministic formulation of quantum mechanics allows the Born rule for measurements on a single system to be derived, without any statistical assumptions. We solve a simple example where the creation of an ensemble of identical quantum states, together with position measurements on those states, are described by Bohm's quantum dynamics. The calculated measurement outcomes agree with the Born-rule probabilities, which are thus a consequence of deterministic evolution. Our results demonstrate that quantum probabilities can emerge from simple dynamical laws alone, and they support the view that there is no underlying indeterminism in quantum phenomena.

arXiv:1409.7891•Sep 28, 2014•5 citations

Why Does Probability Emerge from Wave Amplitude? Reconstructing the Physical Connection Between Born's Scattering Interpretation and Schrödinger's Wave Function

Kaisheng Li, Longji Li

The Born rule, \[P(\mathbf{x})=|\psi(\mathbf{x})|^2\] is one of the most successful relations in modern physics. Yet its physical meaning remains conceptually distinctive. Schrödinger's equation describes the continuous evolution of a complex wave amplitude, whereas an actual detector records discrete and localized events. The Born rule connects these two descriptions with remarkable precision, but the physical mechanism responsible for the quadratic relation between wave amplitude and event frequency is not contained explicitly in the Schrödinger equation itself. This paper revisits the historical and physical relationship between Schrödinger's wave mechanics and Born's statistical interpretation of scattering. The purpose is not to deny the empirical validity of the Born rule, but to identify the physical gap between continuous wave evolution and discrete detection statistics. We distinguish three levels of description: the preparation of localized quantum excitations, their continuous propagation and scattering, and the final microscopic detector event. This leads to a central question: \boxedtext{Why should the rate of discrete detection events be proportional to $|\psi|^2$?} The paper argues that the answer cannot be obtained merely by defining $|\psi|^2$ to be a probability density. Instead, a physical theory must explain how a continuously distributed complex amplitude produces a localized event rate. We investigate the possibility that the quadratic dependence emerges from a local interaction functional, energy-transfer mechanism, or bilinear response of the detector to the incident quantum amplitude. A particularly important distinction is made between the wave amplitude itself and the experimentally recorded event frequency. A single detection event is localized, whereas the Born distribution emerges only through repeated preparations and statistical accumulation. The paper therefore proposes that the Born rule may be viewed as the macroscopic statistical image of a microscopic event-generation process. No completed derivation of Born's rule is claimed here. Rather, the paper formulates the precise dynamical problem that such a derivation must solve and identifies several mathematical and experimental constraints that any successful mechanism must satisfy.

•Sep 19, 2026•0 citations

The Born rule in Bohmian mechanics

T. G. Philbin

The predictions of quantum mechanics are probabilistic. Quantum probabilities are extracted using a postulate of the theory called the Born rule, the status of which is central to the problem of quantum mechanics. Efforts to justify the Born rule from other physical principles, and thus elucidate the measurement process, have involved lengthy statistical or information-theoretic arguments. Here we show that Bohm's deterministic formulation of quantum mechanics allows the Born rule for measurements on a single system to be derived, without any statistical assumptions. We solve a simple example where the creation of an ensemble of identical quantum states, together with position measurements on those states, are described by Bohm's quantum dynamics. The calculated measurement outcomes agree with the Born-rule probabilities, which are thus a consequence of deterministic evolution. Our results demonstrate that quantum probabilities can emerge from simple dynamical laws alone, and they support the view that there is no underlying indeterminism in quantum phenomena.

•Sep 28, 2014•0 citations

A theory of amplitudes

Stanley Gudder

A stochastic framework for quantum mechanics is presented in which the elements are measurements and amplitudes. The resulting structure provides three stochastic levels. At the bottom level are the sample points. These may be unobservable, in general. At the next level are the outcomes of measurements. The amplitude of an outcome is computed by summing the amplitudes of the sample points resulting in that outcome upon a measurement. At the highest level are the events of a measurement. The probability of an event is computed by summing the moduli squared of the amplitudes for the outcomes comprising that event. Using these guidelines, various probabilities, conditional probabilities, and expectations are defined. Superpositions of amplitude functions are investigated and superselection sectors are shown to occur in a natural way. The framework is illustrated in various mathematical models such as spin- (1)/(2) models, the two-slit experiment, and phase space quantum mechanics. Finally, a theory of discrete Feynman amplitudes is presented

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Sep 1, 1988•22 citations

Derivation of quantum theory from Feynman's rules

Philip Goyal

Feynman's formulation of quantum theory is remarkable in its combination of formal simplicity and computational power. However, as a formulation of the abstract structure of quantum theory, it is incomplete as it does not account for most of the fundamental mathematical structure of the standard von Neumann--Dirac formalism such as the unitary evolution of quantum states. In this paper, we show how to reconstruct the entirety of the finite-dimensional quantum formalism starting from Feynman's rules with the aid of a single physical postulate, the no-disturbance postulate. This postulate states that a particular class of measurements have no effect on the outcome probabilities of subsequent measurements performed. We also show how it is possible to derive both the amplitude rule for composite systems of distinguishable subsystems and Dirac's amplitude-action rule, each from a single elementary and natural assumption, by making use of the fact that these assumptions must be consistent with Feynman's rules.

arXiv:1403.3527•Physical Review A•Mar 20, 2014•17 citations
Quantum theory is formulated as the only consistent way to manipulate probability amplitudes. The crucial ingredient is a very natural consistency constraint: if there are two different ways to compute the amplitude for a given process, the two answers must agree. This constraint is expressed in the form of functional equations the solution of which leads to the usual sum and product rules for amplitudes. An immediate consequence is that the Schr"odinger equation must be linear; i.e., nonlinear variants of quantum mechanics are inconsistent. The physical interpretation of the theory is given in terms of a single natural rule. This rule, which does not itself involve any probabilities, is used to obtain a proof of Born's statistical postulate: we show that the probability of a certain outcome in an experiment is given by the square of the modulus of the corresponding amplitude. Thus, consistency leads to indeterminism.
First steps are taken toward a formulation of quantum mechanics which avoids the use of probability amplitudes and is expressed entirely in terms of observable probabilities. Quantum states are represented not by state vectors or density matrices but by “probability tables,” which contain only the probabilities of the outcomes of certain special measurements. The rule for computing transition probabilities, normally given by the squared modulus of the inner product of two state vectors, is re-expressed in terms of probability tables. The new version of the rule is surprisingly simple, especially when one considers that the notion of complex phases, so crucial in the evaluation of inner products, is entirely absent from the representation of states used here.
The predictions of quantum mechanics are probabilistic. Quantum probabilities are extracted using a postulate of the theory called the Born rule, the status of which is central to the "measurement problem" of quantum mechanics. Efforts to justify the Born rule from other physical principles, and thus elucidate the measurement process, have involved lengthy statistical or information-theoretic arguments. Here we show that Bohm's deterministic formulation of quantum mechanics allows the Born rule for measurements on a single system to be derived, without any statistical assumptions. We solve a simple example where the creation of an ensemble of identical quantum states, together with position measurements on those states, are described by Bohm's quantum dynamics. The calculated measurement outcomes agree with the Born-rule probabilities, which are thus a consequence of deterministic evolution. Our results demonstrate that quantum probabilities can emerge from simple dynamical laws alone, and they support the view that there is no underlying indeterminism in quantum phenomena.
The Born rule, P(x)=∣ψ(x)∣2P(\mathbf{x})=|\psi(\mathbf{x})|^2P(x)=∣ψ(x)∣2 is one of the most successful relations in modern physics. Yet its physical meaning remains conceptually distinctive. Schrödinger's equation describes the continuous evolution of a complex wave amplitude, whereas an actual detector records discrete and localized events. The Born rule connects these two descriptions with remarkable precision, but the physical mechanism responsible for the quadratic relation between wave amplitude and event frequency is not contained explicitly in the Schrödinger equation itself. This paper revisits the historical and physical relationship between Schrödinger's wave mechanics and Born's statistical interpretation of scattering. The purpose is not to deny the empirical validity of the Born rule, but to identify the physical gap between continuous wave evolution and discrete detection statistics. We distinguish three levels of description: the preparation of localized quantum excitations, their continuous propagation and scattering, and the final microscopic detector event. This leads to a central question: \boxedtext{Why should the rate of discrete detection events be proportional to ∣ψ∣2|\psi|^2∣ψ∣2?} The paper argues that the answer cannot be obtained merely by defining ∣ψ∣2|\psi|^2∣ψ∣2 to be a probability density. Instead, a physical theory must explain how a continuously distributed complex amplitude produces a localized event rate. We investigate the possibility that the quadratic dependence emerges from a local interaction functional, energy-transfer mechanism, or bilinear response of the detector to the incident quantum amplitude. A particularly important distinction is made between the wave amplitude itself and the experimentally recorded event frequency. A single detection event is localized, whereas the Born distribution emerges only through repeated preparations and statistical accumulation. The paper therefore proposes that the Born rule may be viewed as the macroscopic statistical image of a microscopic event-generation process. No completed derivation of Born's rule is claimed here. Rather, the paper formulates the precise dynamical problem that such a derivation must solve and identifies several mathematical and experimental constraints that any successful mechanism must satisfy.
The predictions of quantum mechanics are probabilistic. Quantum probabilities are extracted using a postulate of the theory called the Born rule, the status of which is central to the problem of quantum mechanics. Efforts to justify the Born rule from other physical principles, and thus elucidate the measurement process, have involved lengthy statistical or information-theoretic arguments. Here we show that Bohm's deterministic formulation of quantum mechanics allows the Born rule for measurements on a single system to be derived, without any statistical assumptions. We solve a simple example where the creation of an ensemble of identical quantum states, together with position measurements on those states, are described by Bohm's quantum dynamics. The calculated measurement outcomes agree with the Born-rule probabilities, which are thus a consequence of deterministic evolution. Our results demonstrate that quantum probabilities can emerge from simple dynamical laws alone, and they support the view that there is no underlying indeterminism in quantum phenomena.
A stochastic framework for quantum mechanics is presented in which the elements are measurements and amplitudes. The resulting structure provides three stochastic levels. At the bottom level are the sample points. These may be unobservable, in general. At the next level are the outcomes of measurements. The amplitude of an outcome is computed by summing the amplitudes of the sample points resulting in that outcome upon a measurement. At the highest level are the events of a measurement. The probability of an event is computed by summing the moduli squared of the amplitudes for the outcomes comprising that event. Using these guidelines, various probabilities, conditional probabilities, and expectations are defined. Superpositions of amplitude functions are investigated and superselection sectors are shown to occur in a natural way. The framework is illustrated in various mathematical models such as spin- (1)/(2) models, the two-slit experiment, and phase space quantum mechanics. Finally, a theory of discrete Feynman amplitudes is presented
Feynman's formulation of quantum theory is remarkable in its combination of formal simplicity and computational power. However, as a formulation of the abstract structure of quantum theory, it is incomplete as it does not account for most of the fundamental mathematical structure of the standard von Neumann--Dirac formalism such as the unitary evolution of quantum states. In this paper, we show how to reconstruct the entirety of the finite-dimensional quantum formalism starting from Feynman's rules with the aid of a single physical postulate, the no-disturbance postulate. This postulate states that a particular class of measurements have no effect on the outcome probabilities of subsequent measurements performed. We also show how it is possible to derive both the amplitude rule for composite systems of distinguishable subsystems and Dirac's amplitude-action rule, each from a single elementary and natural assumption, by making use of the fact that these assumptions must be consistent with Feynman's rules.