Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Princeton University Press eBooks

Quantum Mechanics without Probability Amplitudes

William K. Wootters

Published Jul 5, 2017• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

First steps are taken toward a formulation of quantum mechanics which avoids the use of probability amplitudes and is expressed entirely in terms of observable probabilities. Quantum states are represented not by state vectors or density matrices but by “probability tables,” which contain only the probabilities of the outcomes of certain special measurements. The rule for computing transition probabilities, normally given by the squared modulus of the inner product of two state vectors, is re-expressed in terms of probability tables. The new version of the rule is surprisingly simple, especially when one considers that the notion of complex phases, so crucial in the evaluation of inner products, is entirely absent from the representation of states used here.

DOI
10.1515/9781400886975-035

Related papers

States as Vectors

Tilak Sinha

From here, we take up the task of reformulating quantum mechanics in the language of inner product space. We start by introducing vector space through the familiar example of a set of finite dimensional, complex, column matrices under addition and multiplication by scalars. The inner product is then introduced as a dot product generalized to complex vectors leading to the idea of an inner product space . This is adequate to show how the concept of a quantum state can be described by a normalized vector in an inner product space so that the state space can be identified with the inner product space. Amplitudes are associated with inner products , and observables with orthonormal bases in this space. Hence the laws of quantum mechanics are reformulated. We then point out that the now reformulated laws are independent of the space of description and the reader is urged to contemplate an universality which would reflect the independence with respect to the representation space . This creates the stage for the introduction of the abstract inner product space and the formulation of quantum mechanics in this setting. The chapter concludes with this description. The transformed laws are now called postulatesof quantum mechanics .

Chapman & Hall/CRC eBooks•Jun 18, 2021•0 citations

Consistency, amplitudes, and probabilities in quantum theory

Ariel Caticha

Quantum theory is formulated as the only consistent way to manipulate probability amplitudes. The crucial ingredient is a very natural consistency constraint: if there are two different ways to compute the amplitude for a given process, the two answers must agree. This constraint is expressed in the form of functional equations the solution of which leads to the usual sum and product rules for amplitudes. An immediate consequence is that the Schr\"odinger equation must be linear; i.e., nonlinear variants of quantum mechanics are inconsistent. The physical interpretation of the theory is given in terms of a single natural rule. This rule, which does not itself involve any probabilities, is used to obtain a proof of Born's statistical postulate: we show that the probability of a certain outcome in an experiment is given by the square of the modulus of the corresponding amplitude. Thus, consistency leads to indeterminism.

arXiv:quant-ph/9804012•Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1998•63 citations

Probability Amplitudes

F. J. Duarte

Quantum mechanics runs on probability amplitudes. Probability amplitudes must accurately describe the physics prior to calculating the quantum probability. Symbolical probability amplitudes are mathematically represented by complex wave functions. Many physicists in the field don’t even mention the words probability amplitude and prefer to refer to wave function, or state, instead. When they do that they miss out on the subtleties of the physics at hand. In this brief chapter we emphasize probability amplitudes à la Dirac since that is the way Feynman and Ward preferred to describe quantum mechanics. The Dirac notation is also ideally suited to describe quantum interference and quantum entanglement.

CRC Press eBooks•Apr 10, 2026•0 citations

Why square roots of probabilities?

Kevin H. Knuth

Square roots of probabilities appear in several contexts, which suggests that they are somehow more fundamental than probabilities.Square roots of probabilities appear in expressions of the Fisher-Rao Metric and the Hellinger-Bhattacharyya distance.They also come into play in Quantum Mechanics via the Born rule where probabilities are found by taking the squared modulus of the quantum amplitude.Why should this be the case and why do these square roots not arise in the various formulations of probability theory?In this short, inconclusive exploration, I consider quantifying a logical statement with a vector defined by a set of components each quantifying one of the atomic statements defining the hypothesis space.I show that conditional probabilities (bi-valuations), such as P(x|y), can be written as the dot product of the two vectors quantifying the logical statements x and y each normalized with respect to the vector quantifying the conditional y.The components of the vectors are proportional to the square root of the probability.As a result, this formulation is shown to be consistent with a concept of orthogonality applied to the set of mutually exclusive atomic statements such that the sum rule is represented as the sum of the squares of the square roots of probability.

arXiv:1603.08427•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2016•4 citations

Probability: Basic concepts and theorems

The mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics is a probability calculus. The probability algorithms it places at our disposal—state vectors, wave functions, density matrices, statistical operators—all serve the same purpose, which is to assign probabilities to the possible outcomes of measurements, on the basis of the actual outcomes of other (not necessarily earlier) measurements. In other words, the general theoretical framework of contemporary physics is essentially a calculus of correlations between measurement outcomes. This is reason enough to begin by putting together what we already know, and what we need to know, about probabilities.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 8, 2018•0 citations

Quantum Probability

Heinz‐Peter Breuer, Francesco Petruccione

Abstract This chapter develops the fundamental notions and concepts of the probabilistic and statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics. It begins with a brief review of the mathematical structure given by a Hilbert space of state vectors and an algebra of observables represented by selfadjoint operators. Special emphasis is laid on the connection between the spectral representation of a selfadjoint operator and a corresponding random variable that describes the possible measurement outcomes. The chapter further introduces the concepts of a composite quantum system, of the reduced density matrix, and of entangled quantum states. A section on quantum entropies is included, as well as the mathematical formulation of the generalized theory of quantum measurements in terms of completely positive quantum operations and effects.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 25, 2007•0 citations
First steps are taken toward a formulation of quantum mechanics which avoids the use of probability amplitudes and is expressed entirely in terms of observable probabilities. Quantum states are represented not by state vectors or density matrices but by “probability tables,” which contain only the probabilities of the outcomes of certain special measurements. The rule for computing transition probabilities, normally given by the squared modulus of the inner product of two state vectors, is re-expressed in terms of probability tables. The new version of the rule is surprisingly simple, especially when one considers that the notion of complex phases, so crucial in the evaluation of inner products, is entirely absent from the representation of states used here.
From here, we take up the task of reformulating quantum mechanics in the language of inner product space. We start by introducing vector space through the familiar example of a set of finite dimensional, complex, column matrices under addition and multiplication by scalars. The inner product is then introduced as a dot product generalized to complex vectors leading to the idea of an inner product space . This is adequate to show how the concept of a quantum state can be described by a normalized vector in an inner product space so that the state space can be identified with the inner product space. Amplitudes are associated with inner products , and observables with orthonormal bases in this space. Hence the laws of quantum mechanics are reformulated. We then point out that the now reformulated laws are independent of the space of description and the reader is urged to contemplate an universality which would reflect the independence with respect to the representation space . This creates the stage for the introduction of the abstract inner product space and the formulation of quantum mechanics in this setting. The chapter concludes with this description. The transformed laws are now called postulatesof quantum mechanics .
Quantum theory is formulated as the only consistent way to manipulate probability amplitudes. The crucial ingredient is a very natural consistency constraint: if there are two different ways to compute the amplitude for a given process, the two answers must agree. This constraint is expressed in the form of functional equations the solution of which leads to the usual sum and product rules for amplitudes. An immediate consequence is that the Schr\"odinger equation must be linear; i.e., nonlinear variants of quantum mechanics are inconsistent. The physical interpretation of the theory is given in terms of a single natural rule. This rule, which does not itself involve any probabilities, is used to obtain a proof of Born's statistical postulate: we show that the probability of a certain outcome in an experiment is given by the square of the modulus of the corresponding amplitude. Thus, consistency leads to indeterminism.
Quantum mechanics runs on probability amplitudes. Probability amplitudes must accurately describe the physics prior to calculating the quantum probability. Symbolical probability amplitudes are mathematically represented by complex wave functions. Many physicists in the field don’t even mention the words probability amplitude and prefer to refer to wave function, or state, instead. When they do that they miss out on the subtleties of the physics at hand. In this brief chapter we emphasize probability amplitudes à la Dirac since that is the way Feynman and Ward preferred to describe quantum mechanics. The Dirac notation is also ideally suited to describe quantum interference and quantum entanglement.
Square roots of probabilities appear in several contexts, which suggests that they are somehow more fundamental than probabilities.Square roots of probabilities appear in expressions of the Fisher-Rao Metric and the Hellinger-Bhattacharyya distance.They also come into play in Quantum Mechanics via the Born rule where probabilities are found by taking the squared modulus of the quantum amplitude.Why should this be the case and why do these square roots not arise in the various formulations of probability theory?In this short, inconclusive exploration, I consider quantifying a logical statement with a vector defined by a set of components each quantifying one of the atomic statements defining the hypothesis space.I show that conditional probabilities (bi-valuations), such as P(x|y), can be written as the dot product of the two vectors quantifying the logical statements x and y each normalized with respect to the vector quantifying the conditional y.The components of the vectors are proportional to the square root of the probability.As a result, this formulation is shown to be consistent with a concept of orthogonality applied to the set of mutually exclusive atomic statements such that the sum rule is represented as the sum of the squares of the square roots of probability.
The mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics is a probability calculus. The probability algorithms it places at our disposal—state vectors, wave functions, density matrices, statistical operators—all serve the same purpose, which is to assign probabilities to the possible outcomes of measurements, on the basis of the actual outcomes of other (not necessarily earlier) measurements. In other words, the general theoretical framework of contemporary physics is essentially a calculus of correlations between measurement outcomes. This is reason enough to begin by putting together what we already know, and what we need to know, about probabilities.
Abstract This chapter develops the fundamental notions and concepts of the probabilistic and statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics. It begins with a brief review of the mathematical structure given by a Hilbert space of state vectors and an algebra of observables represented by selfadjoint operators. Special emphasis is laid on the connection between the spectral representation of a selfadjoint operator and a corresponding random variable that describes the possible measurement outcomes. The chapter further introduces the concepts of a composite quantum system, of the reduced density matrix, and of entangled quantum states. A section on quantum entropies is included, as well as the mathematical formulation of the generalized theory of quantum measurements in terms of completely positive quantum operations and effects.