Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0606186 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

On the inconsistency of the Bohm–Gadella theory with quantum mechanics

Rafael de la Madrid

Published Jul 5, 2006• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Bohm–Gadella theory, sometimes referred to as the time asymmetric quantum theory of scattering and decay, is based on the Hardy axiom. The Hardy axiom asserts that the solutions of the Lippmann–Schwinger equation are functionals over spaces of Hardy functions. The preparation–registration arrow of time provides the physical justification for the Hardy axiom. In this paper, it is shown that the Hardy axiom is incorrect, because the solutions of the Lippmann–Schwinger equation do not act on spaces of Hardy functions. It is also shown that the derivation of the preparation–registration arrow of time is flawed. Thus, Hardy functions neither appear when we solve the Lippmann–Schwinger equation nor should they appear. It is also shown that the Bohm–Gadella theory does not rest on the same physical principles as quantum mechanics, and that it does not solve any problem that quantum mechanics cannot solve. The Bohm–Gadella theory must therefore be abandoned.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/39/29/017

Related papers

Reply to ‘Comment on ‘On the inconsistency of the Bohm–Gadella theory with quantum mechanics’’

Rafael de la Madrid

In this reply, we show that when we apply standard distribution theory to the Lippmann–Schwinger equation, the resulting spaces of test functions would comply with the Hardy axiom only if classic results of Paley and Wiener, of Gelfand and Shilov, and of the theory of ultradistributions were wrong. Also, we point out several differences between the ‘standard method’ of constructing rigged Hilbert spaces in quantum mechanics and the method used in time asymmetric quantum theory.

arXiv:0704.1613•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 11, 2007•3 citations

Comment on ‘On the inconsistency of the Bohm–Gadella theory with quantum mechanics’

Manuel Gadella, S. Wickramasekara

Rigged Hilbert spaces of Hardy functions lead to a consistent theory of resonance scattering and decay. Contrary to the claims of a recent article [8], the theory holds for a wide range of potentials and rigorously describes the asymmetric time evolution of resonances.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 11, 2007•3 citations

Complex Energies and Beginnings of Time Suggest a Theory of Scattering and Decay

Arno Böhm, Piotr Kielanowski, Sujeewa Wickramasekara

Many useful concepts for a quantum theory of scattering and decay (like Lippmann-Schwinger kets, purely outgoing boundary conditions, exponentially decaying Gamow vectors, causality) are not well defined in the mathematical frame set by the conventional (Hilbert space) axioms of quantum mechanics. Using the Lippmann-Schwinger equations as the takeoff point and aiming for a theory that unites resonances and decay, we conjecture a new axiom for quantum mechanics that distinguishes mathematically between prepared states and detected observables. Suggested by the two signs $\\pm i\\epsilon$ of the Lippmann-Schwinger equations, this axiom replaces the one Hilbert space of conventional quantum mechanics by two Hardy spaces. The new Hardy space theory automatically provides Gamow kets with exponential time evolution derived from the complex poles of the $S$-matrix. It solves the causality problem since it results in a semigroup evolution. But this semigroup brings into quantum physics a new concept of the semigroup time $t=0$, a beginning of time. Its interpretation and observations are discussed in the last section.

•Oct 8, 2005•13 citations

Resonance and decay phenomena lead to quantum mechanical time asymmetry

Arno Böhm, Hai Viet Bui

The states (Schrödinger picture) and observables (Heisenberg picture) in the standard quantum theory evolve symmetrically in time, given by the unitary group with time extending over − ∞ < t < + ∞ . This time evolution is a mathematical consequence of the Hilbert space boundary condition for the dynamical differential equations. However, this unitary group evolution violates causality. Moreover, it does not solve an old puzzle of Wigner: How does one describe excited states of atoms which decay exponentially, and how is their lifetime τ related to the Lorentzian width Γ? These question can be answered if one replaces the Hilbert space boundary condition by new, Hardy space boundary conditions. These Hardy space boundary conditions allow for a distinction between states (prepared by a preparation apparatus) and observables (detected by a registration apparatus). The new Hardy space quantum theory is time asymmetric, i.e, the time evolution is given by the semigroup with t 0 ≤ t < + ∞ , which predicts a finite "beginning of time" t 0 , where t 0 is the ensemble of time at which each individual system has been prepared. The Hardy space axiom also leads to the new prediction: the width Γ and the lifetime τ are exactly related by τ = ℏ/Γ .

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Apr 5, 2013•1 citation

Time asymmetric quantum theory – I. Modifying an axiom of quantum physics

A.R. Bohm, M. Loewe, B. Van de Ven

Abstract A slight modification of one axiom of quantum theory changes a reversible theory into a time asymmetric theory. Whereas the standard Hilbert space axiom does not distinguish mathematically between the space of states (in‐states of scattering theory) and the space of observables (out‐“states” of scattering theory) the new axiom associates states and observables to two different Hardy subspaces which are dense in the same Hilbert space and analytic in the lower and upper complex energy plane, respectively. As a consequence of this new axiom the dynamical equations (Schrödinger or Heisenberg) integrate to a semigroup evolution. Extending this new Hardy space axiom to a relativistic theory provides a relativistic theory of resonance scattering and decay with Born probablilities that fulfill Einstein causality and the exponential decay law.

arXiv:quant-ph/0212130•Fortschritte der Physik•May 13, 2003•29 citations

On using physical properties to make mathematical choices in quantum mechanical scattering

Joshua Russell Hebert

Traditional Quantum Scattering theory is built upon a Hilbert space formalism. The nature of the Hilbert space has led to a number of ideas about the nature of scattering systems, chief among them being the understanding that the decay of unstable quan- tum systems cannot be purely exponential and that there can only be an approximate relationship between the width Γ of a scattering resonance and the lifetime τ of the resonant state whose formation gives rise to it. That such physical conclusions are de- rived from purely mathematical properties of the underlying topological vector space inform the notion that, in choosing a particular space, one is choosing the mathemat- ical representation of the physical universe for the system. With this notion in mind, purely physical characteristics of quantum systems are used to answer the question: “What is the proper mathematical space for quantum mechanical calculations?” In the particular case of quantum scattering, it is shown that this approach casts the choice of the Hilbert space into doubt and motivates instead the use of rigged Hilbert spaces employing Hardy spaces; in these Hardy rigged Hilbert spaces, exponential decay is permissible and the time evolution of decaying states is governed by semigroups. The original theories concerning deviation from exponential decay in the Hilbert space are revisited to reveal how their conclusions flow from a mathematical property whose physical interpretation is problematic. Finally, an application of a Hardy rigged Hilbert space formalism is presented: Time Asymmetric Quantum Mechanics, as developed by A. Bohm, M. Gadella, and S. Wickramasekara.

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations
The Bohm–Gadella theory, sometimes referred to as the time asymmetric quantum theory of scattering and decay, is based on the Hardy axiom. The Hardy axiom asserts that the solutions of the Lippmann–Schwinger equation are functionals over spaces of Hardy functions. The preparation–registration arrow of time provides the physical justification for the Hardy axiom. In this paper, it is shown that the Hardy axiom is incorrect, because the solutions of the Lippmann–Schwinger equation do not act on spaces of Hardy functions. It is also shown that the derivation of the preparation–registration arrow of time is flawed. Thus, Hardy functions neither appear when we solve the Lippmann–Schwinger equation nor should they appear. It is also shown that the Bohm–Gadella theory does not rest on the same physical principles as quantum mechanics, and that it does not solve any problem that quantum mechanics cannot solve. The Bohm–Gadella theory must therefore be abandoned.
Many useful concepts for a quantum theory of scattering and decay (like Lippmann-Schwinger kets, purely outgoing boundary conditions, exponentially decaying Gamow vectors, causality) are not well defined in the mathematical frame set by the conventional (Hilbert space) axioms of quantum mechanics. Using the Lippmann-Schwinger equations as the takeoff point and aiming for a theory that unites resonances and decay, we conjecture a new axiom for quantum mechanics that distinguishes mathematically between prepared states and detected observables. Suggested by the two signs pmiepsilon\\pm i\\epsilonpmiepsilon of the Lippmann-Schwinger equations, this axiom replaces the one Hilbert space of conventional quantum mechanics by two Hardy spaces. The new Hardy space theory automatically provides Gamow kets with exponential time evolution derived from the complex poles of the SSS-matrix. It solves the causality problem since it results in a semigroup evolution. But this semigroup brings into quantum physics a new concept of the semigroup time t=0t=0t=0, a beginning of time. Its interpretation and observations are discussed in the last section.
The states (Schrödinger picture) and observables (Heisenberg picture) in the standard quantum theory evolve symmetrically in time, given by the unitary group with time extending over − ∞ < t < + ∞ . This time evolution is a mathematical consequence of the Hilbert space boundary condition for the dynamical differential equations. However, this unitary group evolution violates causality. Moreover, it does not solve an old puzzle of Wigner: How does one describe excited states of atoms which decay exponentially, and how is their lifetime τ related to the Lorentzian width Γ? These question can be answered if one replaces the Hilbert space boundary condition by new, Hardy space boundary conditions. These Hardy space boundary conditions allow for a distinction between states (prepared by a preparation apparatus) and observables (detected by a registration apparatus). The new Hardy space quantum theory is time asymmetric, i.e, the time evolution is given by the semigroup with t 0 ≤ t < + ∞ , which predicts a finite "beginning of time" t 0 , where t 0 is the ensemble of time at which each individual system has been prepared. The Hardy space axiom also leads to the new prediction: the width Γ and the lifetime τ are exactly related by τ = ℏ/Γ .
Abstract A slight modification of one axiom of quantum theory changes a reversible theory into a time asymmetric theory. Whereas the standard Hilbert space axiom does not distinguish mathematically between the space of states (in‐states of scattering theory) and the space of observables (out‐“states” of scattering theory) the new axiom associates states and observables to two different Hardy subspaces which are dense in the same Hilbert space and analytic in the lower and upper complex energy plane, respectively. As a consequence of this new axiom the dynamical equations (Schrödinger or Heisenberg) integrate to a semigroup evolution. Extending this new Hardy space axiom to a relativistic theory provides a relativistic theory of resonance scattering and decay with Born probablilities that fulfill Einstein causality and the exponential decay law.
Traditional Quantum Scattering theory is built upon a Hilbert space formalism. The nature of the Hilbert space has led to a number of ideas about the nature of scattering systems, chief among them being the understanding that the decay of unstable quan- tum systems cannot be purely exponential and that there can only be an approximate relationship between the width Γ of a scattering resonance and the lifetime τ of the resonant state whose formation gives rise to it. That such physical conclusions are de- rived from purely mathematical properties of the underlying topological vector space inform the notion that, in choosing a particular space, one is choosing the mathemat- ical representation of the physical universe for the system. With this notion in mind, purely physical characteristics of quantum systems are used to answer the question: “What is the proper mathematical space for quantum mechanical calculations?” In the particular case of quantum scattering, it is shown that this approach casts the choice of the Hilbert space into doubt and motivates instead the use of rigged Hilbert spaces employing Hardy spaces; in these Hardy rigged Hilbert spaces, exponential decay is permissible and the time evolution of decaying states is governed by semigroups. The original theories concerning deviation from exponential decay in the Hilbert space are revisited to reveal how their conclusions flow from a mathematical property whose physical interpretation is problematic. Finally, an application of a Hardy rigged Hilbert space formalism is presented: Time Asymmetric Quantum Mechanics, as developed by A. Bohm, M. Gadella, and S. Wickramasekara.