Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0509107 · Journal of Modern Optics

Quantum nature of laser light

David Thomas Pegg, John Jeffers

Published Sep 10, 2005• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

All compositions of a mixed-state density operator are equivalent for the prediction of the probabilities of future outcomes of measurements. For retrodiction, however, this is not the case. The retrodictive formalism of quantum mechanics provides a criterion for deciding that some compositions are fictional. Fictional compositions do not contain preparation device operators, that is operators corresponding to states that could have been prepared. We apply this to Mølmer's controversial conjecture that optical coherences in laser light are a fiction and find agreement with his conjecture. We generalize Mølmer's derivation of the interference between two lasers to avoid the use of any fictional states. We also examine another possible method for discriminating between coherent states and photon number states in laser light and find that it does not work, with the equivalence for prediction saved by entanglement.

DOI
10.1080/09500340500106857

Related papers

Retrodiction in quantum optics

David Thomas Pegg, Stephen Mark Barnett

The usual formalism of quantum mechanics is predictive with state vectors being assigned on the basis of past preparation procedures. The retrodictive formalism, in which some state vectors are assigned on the basis of future measurement results is less usual, although it has been known for some time. Although at first sight this formalism may appear to be anticausal and subject to paradoxes, if used carefully it still predicts the same measurable correlations as the more usual approach despite different assignments of state vectors to states in the interval between preparation and measurement of the system. Here we use a procedure which involves retrodiction to examine some quantum optical processes, including a recent state truncation process. The collapse of the state vector occurs at a different time from that for the usual approach underlining the difficulty in regarding the collapse as a real physical process.

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Aug 1, 1999•39 citations

Quantum Models of Light

Hans‐A. Bachor, Timothy C. Ralph

This chapter establishes quantum mechanical models for light that helps to understand the various experimental results and techniques. It reviews the types of predictions one can make about experimental outcomes of quantum mechanical systems and how these are obtained from the mathematics. Quantum theory makes predictions about the results of large ensembles of measurements. In quantum mechanics even ideally prepared systems can exhibit non-zero variance due to the probabilistic nature of the theory. The coherence properties of the light remain similar after attenuation. Coherent states will be used extensively in our modelling of laser experiments. The uncertainty area is a simple, useful tool that can, under certain circumstances, be used to completely characterize the state. The chapter considers photon number measurements of a single optical mode. For a photon number state, there is a unique photon number; it will be exactly the same in every measurement.

Wiley eBooks•Jul 5, 2019•0 citations

Retrodictive State Generation and Quantum Measurement

David Thomas Pegg

Retrodictive quantum states are states that propagate backwards in time from a measurement event. Although retrodictive quantum mechanics appears to be very different from the usual predictive formalism, in that propagation of states into the past appears to violate causality, this is not so. Indeed causality is not manifest in the time direction of propagation of quantum states at all. Instead, causality is ensured by the different normalization conditions applied to the preparation and measurement device operators. It is this difference that introduces the arrow of time into quantum mechanics. Retrodictive states are useful for applications such as measurement, predictive quantum state engineering and quantum communication. Here we show how any optical retrodictive state that can be expressed to a good approximation in a finite‐dimensional Hilbert space can be generated from predictive coherent states, a lossless multiport device and photodetectors. The composition of the retrodictive state can be controlled by adjusting the input predictive coherent states. This allows, for example, projection synthesis for an optical state to be achieved with the exotic reciprocal binomial reference state replaced by a simple coherent state.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2004•2 citations

Atomic retrodiction

Stephen Mark Barnett, David Thomas Pegg, John Jeffers +1 more

Measurement of a quantum system provides information concerning the state in which it was prepared. In this paper we show how the retrodictive formalism can be used to evaluate the probability associated with any one of a given set of preparation events. We illustrate our method by calculating the retrodictive density operator for a two-level atom coupled to the electromagnetic field.

arXiv:quant-ph/0107019•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Aug 2, 2000•22 citations

Quantum Retrodiction

John Jeffers, Stephen Mark Barnett, David Thomas Pegg +2 more

In this paper we have described the retrodictive quantum formalism. We have defined the operator which describes preparation devices, and the retrodictive state, which is simply the normalised measurement POM element. These enable simple evaluation of preparation probabilities given the results of some later measurement event. We have shown how to apply the formalism to both closed and open quantum systems.

Kluwer Academic Publishers eBooks•Feb 24, 2006•1 citation

Optical coherence: A convenient fiction

Klaus Mølmer

We conjecture that optical coherences, i.e., quantum-mechanical coherences between states separated by Bohr frequencies in the optical regime, do not exist in optics experiments. We claim the exact vanishing of optical field amplitudes and atomic dipole expectation values, and we discuss the seemingly contradictory success of assigning finite values to such quantities in theoretical calculations. We show that our conjecture is not at variance with the observed interference between different light sources. The connection to the concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking and the identification of entangled states as pointer basis states is discussed.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1997•218 citations
All compositions of a mixed-state density operator are equivalent for the prediction of the probabilities of future outcomes of measurements. For retrodiction, however, this is not the case. The retrodictive formalism of quantum mechanics provides a criterion for deciding that some compositions are fictional. Fictional compositions do not contain preparation device operators, that is operators corresponding to states that could have been prepared. We apply this to Mølmer's controversial conjecture that optical coherences in laser light are a fiction and find agreement with his conjecture. We generalize Mølmer's derivation of the interference between two lasers to avoid the use of any fictional states. We also examine another possible method for discriminating between coherent states and photon number states in laser light and find that it does not work, with the equivalence for prediction saved by entanglement.
The usual formalism of quantum mechanics is predictive with state vectors being assigned on the basis of past preparation procedures. The retrodictive formalism, in which some state vectors are assigned on the basis of future measurement results is less usual, although it has been known for some time. Although at first sight this formalism may appear to be anticausal and subject to paradoxes, if used carefully it still predicts the same measurable correlations as the more usual approach despite different assignments of state vectors to states in the interval between preparation and measurement of the system. Here we use a procedure which involves retrodiction to examine some quantum optical processes, including a recent state truncation process. The collapse of the state vector occurs at a different time from that for the usual approach underlining the difficulty in regarding the collapse as a real physical process.
This chapter establishes quantum mechanical models for light that helps to understand the various experimental results and techniques. It reviews the types of predictions one can make about experimental outcomes of quantum mechanical systems and how these are obtained from the mathematics. Quantum theory makes predictions about the results of large ensembles of measurements. In quantum mechanics even ideally prepared systems can exhibit non-zero variance due to the probabilistic nature of the theory. The coherence properties of the light remain similar after attenuation. Coherent states will be used extensively in our modelling of laser experiments. The uncertainty area is a simple, useful tool that can, under certain circumstances, be used to completely characterize the state. The chapter considers photon number measurements of a single optical mode. For a photon number state, there is a unique photon number; it will be exactly the same in every measurement.
Retrodictive quantum states are states that propagate backwards in time from a measurement event. Although retrodictive quantum mechanics appears to be very different from the usual predictive formalism, in that propagation of states into the past appears to violate causality, this is not so. Indeed causality is not manifest in the time direction of propagation of quantum states at all. Instead, causality is ensured by the different normalization conditions applied to the preparation and measurement device operators. It is this difference that introduces the arrow of time into quantum mechanics. Retrodictive states are useful for applications such as measurement, predictive quantum state engineering and quantum communication. Here we show how any optical retrodictive state that can be expressed to a good approximation in a finite‐dimensional Hilbert space can be generated from predictive coherent states, a lossless multiport device and photodetectors. The composition of the retrodictive state can be controlled by adjusting the input predictive coherent states. This allows, for example, projection synthesis for an optical state to be achieved with the exotic reciprocal binomial reference state replaced by a simple coherent state.
We conjecture that optical coherences, i.e., quantum-mechanical coherences between states separated by Bohr frequencies in the optical regime, do not exist in optics experiments. We claim the exact vanishing of optical field amplitudes and atomic dipole expectation values, and we discuss the seemingly contradictory success of assigning finite values to such quantities in theoretical calculations. We show that our conjecture is not at variance with the observed interference between different light sources. The connection to the concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking and the identification of entangled states as pointer basis states is discussed.