Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Optical coherence: A convenient fiction

Klaus Mølmer

Published Apr 1, 1997• 218 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We conjecture that optical coherences, i.e., quantum-mechanical coherences between states separated by Bohr frequencies in the optical regime, do not exist in optics experiments. We claim the exact vanishing of optical field amplitudes and atomic dipole expectation values, and we discuss the seemingly contradictory success of assigning finite values to such quantities in theoretical calculations. We show that our conjecture is not at variance with the observed interference between different light sources. The connection to the concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking and the identification of entangled states as pointer basis states is discussed.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.55.3195

Related papers

Comment on “Optical coherence: A convenient fiction”

Julio R. Gea-Banacloche

It is argued here that in a large class of lasers there exist mechanisms by which large coherent fields could be generated, and hence there seems to be no compelling reason to regard optical coherence as a ``fiction.'' Some brief comments on the use of a ``pointer basis'' to resolve statistical mixtures are also presented.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1998•29 citations

Classical and Quantum Interference

Z. Ficek, Mohamed Ridza Wahiddin

Optical interference is regarded as a classical phenomenon and is usually completely described in classical terms, in which optical fields are represented by classical waves. Does it mean that optical interference, which is fundamentally ascribable to the phenomenon of a superposition of wave amplitudes, cannot be applied to test quantum phenomena? The superposition principle is at the heart of quantum physics and one could expect that it should distinguish the quantum nature of light from thewave nature. Our experience based on extensive theoretical analysis and experimental observations shows that classical and quantum theories of optical interference readily explain the presence of an interference pattern resulting from the first-order coherence. However, there are interference effects involving the higher order (second-order) coherence that distinguish the quantum (photon) nature of light from the wave nature. Quantum interference has recently returned to prominence because of its utility in manipulating spontaneous emission and other radiative properties of atomic systems. In this chapter, we present elementary concepts and definitions of both the classical and quantum theory of optical interference and discuss similarities and differences between these two approaches [80].

•Apr 19, 2016•0 citations

Uncertainty in determining the phase for an optical field due to the particle nature of light

Z. Y. Ou, Qichang C. Su

When any two optical fields are superposed, a fringe pattern will be formed if the observation interval is short enough (within the coherent time) and a phase value may be extracted from the fringe and assigned as the phase difference between the fields. When measured against a common reference field, phase can be defined for an optical field. However, when the intensities of the optical fields are low or the observation time is so short that only a few photons are detected, the fringe pattern is unrecognizable due to the particle nature of light. By analyzing the fringe patterns simulated by a quantum Monte Carlo method, we find that there exist uncertainties in determining the phase value. This uncertainty is universal for any optical field with a finite photon number and decreases to zero as the photon number of the field increases to infinity or the classical limit is approached. The existence of this uncertainty in determining the phase value makes it problematic to define a quantum mechanical phase. An interference experiment with coherent state is performed to confirm the theoretical predictions. The implication of the above is that phase is a classical quantity that is associated with a large number of particles and may not have a quantum mechanical analogy.

Laser Physics•Jan 1, 2003•3 citations

Pure Quantum Correlations Between Bright Optical Beams

Yana Shang, Zhihui Yan, Xiaojun Jia +3 more

The pure quantum correlations totally independent of the classical coherence of light have been experimentally demonstrated. By measuring the visibility of the interference fringes and the correlation variances of amplitude and phase quadratures between a pair of bright twin optical beams with different frequencies produced from a non-degenerate optical parametric oscillator, we found that when classical interference became worse even vanished, the quadrature quantum correlations were not influenced, completely. The presented experiment obviously shows the quantum correlations of light do not necessarily imply the classical coherence.

arXiv:0812.1066•Dec 5, 2008•0 citations

Coherence and Statistical Optics

Mayukh Lahiri

The theory of optical coherence has its root in the Young's interference experiment which shows that light emerging from two pinholes may interfere and produce a fringe pattern. This chapter discusses the key foundations of the classical theory of optical coherence and polarization. It also discusses the foundations of the quantum theory of optical coherence. The chapter describes the difference between spatially coherent light and monochromatic light. It shows that the concept of cross-spectral purity plays an important role in distinguishing between complete spatial coherence in the time and frequency domains. To analyze the polarization properties of light, one needs to consider the vector nature of the fluctuating electric field. The chapter also describes the basics of quantum theory of optical coherence to show how some of the concepts introduced in the classical coherence theory can be incorporated into the quantum mechanical version of the theory.

Photonics•Jan 16, 2015•1 citation

The quantum theory of optical coherence

Roy J. Glauber

The concept of coherence which has conventionally been used in optics is found to be inadequate to the needs of recently opened areas of experiment. To provide a fuller discussion of coherence, a succession of correlation functions for the complex field strengths is defined. The $n\mathrm{th}$ order function expresses the correlation of values of the fields at $2n$ different points of space and time. Certain values of these functions are measurable by means of $n$-fold delayed coincidence detection of photons. A fully coherent field is defined as one whose correlation functions satisfy an infinite succession of stated conditions. Various orders of incomplete coherence are distinguished, according to the number of coherence conditions actually satisfied. It is noted that the fields historically described as coherent in optics have only first-order coherence. On the other hand, the existence, in principle, of fields coherent to all orders is shown both in quantum theory and classical theory. The methods used in these discussions apply to fields of arbitrary time dependence. It is shown, as a result, that coherence does not require monochromaticity. Coherent fields can be generated with arbitrary spectra.

•Jan 1, 1986•0 citations
We conjecture that optical coherences, i.e., quantum-mechanical coherences between states separated by Bohr frequencies in the optical regime, do not exist in optics experiments. We claim the exact vanishing of optical field amplitudes and atomic dipole expectation values, and we discuss the seemingly contradictory success of assigning finite values to such quantities in theoretical calculations. We show that our conjecture is not at variance with the observed interference between different light sources. The connection to the concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking and the identification of entangled states as pointer basis states is discussed.
Optical interference is regarded as a classical phenomenon and is usually completely described in classical terms, in which optical fields are represented by classical waves. Does it mean that optical interference, which is fundamentally ascribable to the phenomenon of a superposition of wave amplitudes, cannot be applied to test quantum phenomena? The superposition principle is at the heart of quantum physics and one could expect that it should distinguish the quantum nature of light from thewave nature. Our experience based on extensive theoretical analysis and experimental observations shows that classical and quantum theories of optical interference readily explain the presence of an interference pattern resulting from the first-order coherence. However, there are interference effects involving the higher order (second-order) coherence that distinguish the quantum (photon) nature of light from the wave nature. Quantum interference has recently returned to prominence because of its utility in manipulating spontaneous emission and other radiative properties of atomic systems. In this chapter, we present elementary concepts and definitions of both the classical and quantum theory of optical interference and discuss similarities and differences between these two approaches [80].
When any two optical fields are superposed, a fringe pattern will be formed if the observation interval is short enough (within the coherent time) and a phase value may be extracted from the fringe and assigned as the phase difference between the fields. When measured against a common reference field, phase can be defined for an optical field. However, when the intensities of the optical fields are low or the observation time is so short that only a few photons are detected, the fringe pattern is unrecognizable due to the particle nature of light. By analyzing the fringe patterns simulated by a quantum Monte Carlo method, we find that there exist uncertainties in determining the phase value. This uncertainty is universal for any optical field with a finite photon number and decreases to zero as the photon number of the field increases to infinity or the classical limit is approached. The existence of this uncertainty in determining the phase value makes it problematic to define a quantum mechanical phase. An interference experiment with coherent state is performed to confirm the theoretical predictions. The implication of the above is that phase is a classical quantity that is associated with a large number of particles and may not have a quantum mechanical analogy.
The pure quantum correlations totally independent of the classical coherence of light have been experimentally demonstrated. By measuring the visibility of the interference fringes and the correlation variances of amplitude and phase quadratures between a pair of bright twin optical beams with different frequencies produced from a non-degenerate optical parametric oscillator, we found that when classical interference became worse even vanished, the quadrature quantum correlations were not influenced, completely. The presented experiment obviously shows the quantum correlations of light do not necessarily imply the classical coherence.
The theory of optical coherence has its root in the Young's interference experiment which shows that light emerging from two pinholes may interfere and produce a fringe pattern. This chapter discusses the key foundations of the classical theory of optical coherence and polarization. It also discusses the foundations of the quantum theory of optical coherence. The chapter describes the difference between spatially coherent light and monochromatic light. It shows that the concept of cross-spectral purity plays an important role in distinguishing between complete spatial coherence in the time and frequency domains. To analyze the polarization properties of light, one needs to consider the vector nature of the fluctuating electric field. The chapter also describes the basics of quantum theory of optical coherence to show how some of the concepts introduced in the classical coherence theory can be incorporated into the quantum mechanical version of the theory.
The concept of coherence which has conventionally been used in optics is found to be inadequate to the needs of recently opened areas of experiment. To provide a fuller discussion of coherence, a succession of correlation functions for the complex field strengths is defined. The nthn\mathrm{th}nth order function expresses the correlation of values of the fields at 2n2n2n different points of space and time. Certain values of these functions are measurable by means of nnn-fold delayed coincidence detection of photons. A fully coherent field is defined as one whose correlation functions satisfy an infinite succession of stated conditions. Various orders of incomplete coherence are distinguished, according to the number of coherence conditions actually satisfied. It is noted that the fields historically described as coherent in optics have only first-order coherence. On the other hand, the existence, in principle, of fields coherent to all orders is shown both in quantum theory and classical theory. The methods used in these discussions apply to fields of arbitrary time dependence. It is shown, as a result, that coherence does not require monochromaticity. Coherent fields can be generated with arbitrary spectra.