Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0308153 · Physical Review Letters

Limit to Minimally Destructive Optical Detection of Atoms

J. J. Hope, J. D. Close

Published Oct 25, 2004• 37 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

All optical techniques used to probe the properties of Bose-Einstein condensates have been based on dispersion and absorption that can be described by a two-level atom. Both phenomena lead to spontaneous emission that is destructive at the low energies involved with ultracold atomic systems. Recently, both were shown to lead to the same limit to the signal to noise ratio for a given destruction. We develop a new method for calculating the phase shift of a laser beam and show that no single-pass optical technique using classical light and a three-level atom can exceed this limit. This puts significant restrictions on potential nondestructive measurement schemes.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.93.180402

Related papers

General limit to nondestructive optical detection of atoms

J. J. Hope, J. D. Close

We demonstrate that there is a fundamental limit to the sensitivity of phase-based detection of atoms with light for a given maximum level of allowable spontaneous emission. This is a generalization of previous results for two- and three-level atoms. The limit is due to an upper bound on the phase shift that can be imparted on a laser beam for a given excited-state population. Specifically, we show that no single-pass optical technique using classical light, based on any number of lasers or coherences between any number of levels, can exceed the limit imposed by the two-level atom. This puts significant restrictions on potential nondestructive optical measurement schemes.

arXiv:quant-ph/0409160•Physical Review A•Apr 26, 2005•23 citations

Nondestructive dynamic detectors for Bose-Einstein condensates

Jessica Lye, J. J. Hope, J. D. Close

We propose and analyze a series of nondestructive dynamic detectors for Bose-Einstein condensates based on photodetectors operating at the shot-noise limit. These detectors are compatible with real-time feedback to the condensate. The signal-to-noise ratio of different detection schemes are compared subject to the constraint of minimal heating due to photon absorption and spontaneous emission. This constraint leads to different optimal operating points for interference-based schemes. We find the somewhat counterintuitive result that without the presence of a cavity, interferometry causes as much destruction as absorption for optically thin clouds. For optically thick clouds, cavity-free interferometry is superior to absorption, but it still cannot be made arbitrarily nondestructive. We propose a cavity-based measurement of atomic density which can in principle be made arbitrarily nondestructive for a given signal-to-noise ratio.

arXiv:cond-mat/0302568•Physical Review A•Apr 22, 2003•49 citations

Light propagation in ultracold atomic gases

Stefan Rist

In the present thesis we study several schemes where the detection of the emitted light from an atomic ensemble gives information about the state of the atoms. In chapter 1 we review the basic theory for the light matter interaction in second quantized form. In chapter 2 we show how conservative potentials for the atoms, such as dispersive optical lattices, can be realized experimentally due to the dispersive interaction with a far detuned laser We then review some basic properties of the physics of a particle in a periodic potential. We show that the ground state and the lowest lying excitations of a Bose-Einstein condensate in a dispersive optical lattice can be described by the Bose-Hubbard Hamiltonian. In chapter 3 we study the photonic bandstructure of a chain of fixed pointlike atoms in a biperiodic configuration. We calculate the photonic spectra and the probe transmission if the atoms are in free space and inside a standing wave optical resonator. In chapter 4 we consider light scattering from ultracold atoms in an optical lattice where we calculate the photonic scattering cross section as a function of energy and direction of emission along the Mott-insulator-superfluid phase transition. We take into account the finite tunneling rate for the atoms, when evaluating the scattering cross section of the photons and the effect of photon recoil onto the atoms. In chapter 5 we consider a gas of ultracold atoms trapped at two spatially separated regions in space. Using a two Raman lasers to couple atoms out of the systems we show that it is possible to measure the mean value of the atomic field operator of the two systems by measuring the scattered light intensity of one of the Raman lasers. We show how this setup might be used to measure the temperature of a Bose-Einstein condensate and to monitor the superfluid to Mott-insulator phase transition for a gas of ultracold atoms in an optical lattice.

•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Optimization of Bose-Einstein Condensate Imaging Techniques

Wesley D Cox

Research into Bose-Einstein condensates is currently a thriving field in physics. Much of the experimental research involves the detection of cold atom clouds under various conditions. Consequently, the fundamental and technical limitations of the imaging techniques and technologies utilized will have a dramatic influence on the results of these experiments. Therefore a detailed analysis of the restrictions on a Bose-Einstein condensate imaging system is overdue and will facilitate further developments in the field due to an increase in the signal to noise ratio; hence a greater level of detail available in experimental images. ¶ The work carried out in this thesis focuses on the properties of absorption imaging techniques, in the quest for an optimized imaging system. Optimization was proposed to be achieved through maximization of the signal to noise ratio by any and all means available. A detailed investigation of the diverse influences on the signal to noise ratio was performed with a focus on eliminating technical restrictions and minimizing fundamental constraints. By studying a 2f - absorption imaging system the maximal signal to noise ratio of 35 was calculated. This corresponded to imaging a cloud of 105 87Rb atoms in a (50 micron) square box with a 31.8MHz detuned, 780nm laser at an intensity of 570W/(m.m) for 35 micro-s. These optimal imaging parameters correspond to our imaging system being limited by the well depth of our detector, not by a fundamental physical process. Furthermore, current experimental noise is identified as the most significant inhibitor to the achievement of an optimized absorption image. ¶ This study represents a first analysis of the quality of current Bose-Einstein condensate imaging techniques and limitations.

•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

Quantum optics with cold atoms--nonlinear spectroscopy and road toward single-atom trap

Z. Hu

NOTE: Text or symbols not renderable in plain ASCII are indicated by [...]. Abstract is included in .pdf document. Investigations of optical processes for laser cooled and trapped atoms are described. Fluorescence from Cs atoms in a magneto-optical trap is detected under conditions of very low atomic density. Discrete steps are observed in the fluorescent signal versus time and are associated with the arrival and departure of individual trapped atoms. Histograms of the frequency of occurrence of a given level of fluorescence exhibit a series of uniformly spaced peaks that are attributed to the presence of N = 0, 1, 2 atoms in the trap. In addition, numerical absorption and emission spectra for three-level [...], [...], and V systems under intense radiations are calculated. Absorption spectra for a [...] system is used to explain the probe-wave amplification and absorption spectra recorded for Cs atoms cooled and confined in a magneto-optical trap, in which novel spectral features of narrow frequency widths with single-pass gain exceeding 20% are observed. The consequence of the optical gain is demonstrated to lead to negative radiation pressure, which is investigated together with other mechanical forces in the trap. Various alternative trapping schemes in three-level and two-level atoms are proposed as possible means to compress an atomic sample and demonstrated for a two-level magneto-optical trap.

•Oct 12, 2007•1 citation

Phase modulation spectroscopy: a non-destructive probe of Bose-Einstein condensates

Jessica Lye, Brett D. Cuthbertson, Hans‐A. Bachor +1 more

The measurement of the optical phase of far-detuned laser light by phase modulation spectroscopy is promising as a non-destructive probe of the dynamics of Bose-Einstein condensates. We have developed the experimental technique on a room-temperature Cs vapour cell, and a Cs magneto-optical trap (MOT). We measure column densities with an accuracy better than 7%. A numerical model, including Doppler broadening and transitions between all relevant hyperfine levels, accurately describes the data from the Cs cell. The same model without Doppler broadening gives quantitative agreement with measurements from the Cs MOT. We show that the conditions needed for non-destructive measurements of BEC dynamics are achievable with conventional equipment and a simple, robust experimental setup.

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Aug 1, 1999•20 citations
All optical techniques used to probe the properties of Bose-Einstein condensates have been based on dispersion and absorption that can be described by a two-level atom. Both phenomena lead to spontaneous emission that is destructive at the low energies involved with ultracold atomic systems. Recently, both were shown to lead to the same limit to the signal to noise ratio for a given destruction. We develop a new method for calculating the phase shift of a laser beam and show that no single-pass optical technique using classical light and a three-level atom can exceed this limit. This puts significant restrictions on potential nondestructive measurement schemes.
We demonstrate that there is a fundamental limit to the sensitivity of phase-based detection of atoms with light for a given maximum level of allowable spontaneous emission. This is a generalization of previous results for two- and three-level atoms. The limit is due to an upper bound on the phase shift that can be imparted on a laser beam for a given excited-state population. Specifically, we show that no single-pass optical technique using classical light, based on any number of lasers or coherences between any number of levels, can exceed the limit imposed by the two-level atom. This puts significant restrictions on potential nondestructive optical measurement schemes.
We propose and analyze a series of nondestructive dynamic detectors for Bose-Einstein condensates based on photodetectors operating at the shot-noise limit. These detectors are compatible with real-time feedback to the condensate. The signal-to-noise ratio of different detection schemes are compared subject to the constraint of minimal heating due to photon absorption and spontaneous emission. This constraint leads to different optimal operating points for interference-based schemes. We find the somewhat counterintuitive result that without the presence of a cavity, interferometry causes as much destruction as absorption for optically thin clouds. For optically thick clouds, cavity-free interferometry is superior to absorption, but it still cannot be made arbitrarily nondestructive. We propose a cavity-based measurement of atomic density which can in principle be made arbitrarily nondestructive for a given signal-to-noise ratio.
In the present thesis we study several schemes where the detection of the emitted light from an atomic ensemble gives information about the state of the atoms. In chapter 1 we review the basic theory for the light matter interaction in second quantized form. In chapter 2 we show how conservative potentials for the atoms, such as dispersive optical lattices, can be realized experimentally due to the dispersive interaction with a far detuned laser We then review some basic properties of the physics of a particle in a periodic potential. We show that the ground state and the lowest lying excitations of a Bose-Einstein condensate in a dispersive optical lattice can be described by the Bose-Hubbard Hamiltonian. In chapter 3 we study the photonic bandstructure of a chain of fixed pointlike atoms in a biperiodic configuration. We calculate the photonic spectra and the probe transmission if the atoms are in free space and inside a standing wave optical resonator. In chapter 4 we consider light scattering from ultracold atoms in an optical lattice where we calculate the photonic scattering cross section as a function of energy and direction of emission along the Mott-insulator-superfluid phase transition. We take into account the finite tunneling rate for the atoms, when evaluating the scattering cross section of the photons and the effect of photon recoil onto the atoms. In chapter 5 we consider a gas of ultracold atoms trapped at two spatially separated regions in space. Using a two Raman lasers to couple atoms out of the systems we show that it is possible to measure the mean value of the atomic field operator of the two systems by measuring the scattered light intensity of one of the Raman lasers. We show how this setup might be used to measure the temperature of a Bose-Einstein condensate and to monitor the superfluid to Mott-insulator phase transition for a gas of ultracold atoms in an optical lattice.
Research into Bose-Einstein condensates is currently a thriving field in physics. Much of the experimental research involves the detection of cold atom clouds under various conditions. Consequently, the fundamental and technical limitations of the imaging techniques and technologies utilized will have a dramatic influence on the results of these experiments. Therefore a detailed analysis of the restrictions on a Bose-Einstein condensate imaging system is overdue and will facilitate further developments in the field due to an increase in the signal to noise ratio; hence a greater level of detail available in experimental images. ¶ The work carried out in this thesis focuses on the properties of absorption imaging techniques, in the quest for an optimized imaging system. Optimization was proposed to be achieved through maximization of the signal to noise ratio by any and all means available. A detailed investigation of the diverse influences on the signal to noise ratio was performed with a focus on eliminating technical restrictions and minimizing fundamental constraints. By studying a 2f - absorption imaging system the maximal signal to noise ratio of 35 was calculated. This corresponded to imaging a cloud of 105 87Rb atoms in a (50 micron) square box with a 31.8MHz detuned, 780nm laser at an intensity of 570W/(m.m) for 35 micro-s. These optimal imaging parameters correspond to our imaging system being limited by the well depth of our detector, not by a fundamental physical process. Furthermore, current experimental noise is identified as the most significant inhibitor to the achievement of an optimized absorption image. ¶ This study represents a first analysis of the quality of current Bose-Einstein condensate imaging techniques and limitations.
NOTE: Text or symbols not renderable in plain ASCII are indicated by [...]. Abstract is included in .pdf document. Investigations of optical processes for laser cooled and trapped atoms are described. Fluorescence from Cs atoms in a magneto-optical trap is detected under conditions of very low atomic density. Discrete steps are observed in the fluorescent signal versus time and are associated with the arrival and departure of individual trapped atoms. Histograms of the frequency of occurrence of a given level of fluorescence exhibit a series of uniformly spaced peaks that are attributed to the presence of N = 0, 1, 2 atoms in the trap. In addition, numerical absorption and emission spectra for three-level [...], [...], and V systems under intense radiations are calculated. Absorption spectra for a [...] system is used to explain the probe-wave amplification and absorption spectra recorded for Cs atoms cooled and confined in a magneto-optical trap, in which novel spectral features of narrow frequency widths with single-pass gain exceeding 20% are observed. The consequence of the optical gain is demonstrated to lead to negative radiation pressure, which is investigated together with other mechanical forces in the trap. Various alternative trapping schemes in three-level and two-level atoms are proposed as possible means to compress an atomic sample and demonstrated for a two-level magneto-optical trap.
The measurement of the optical phase of far-detuned laser light by phase modulation spectroscopy is promising as a non-destructive probe of the dynamics of Bose-Einstein condensates. We have developed the experimental technique on a room-temperature Cs vapour cell, and a Cs magneto-optical trap (MOT). We measure column densities with an accuracy better than 7%. A numerical model, including Doppler broadening and transitions between all relevant hyperfine levels, accurately describes the data from the Cs cell. The same model without Doppler broadening gives quantitative agreement with measurements from the Cs MOT. We show that the conditions needed for non-destructive measurements of BEC dynamics are achievable with conventional equipment and a simple, robust experimental setup.