Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0307062 · The Journal of Chemical Physics

Robust control of quantum information

Marco A. Pravia, Nicolas Boulant, Joseph Emerson, Amro M. Farid, Evan M. Fortunato, Timothy F. Havel, R. M. Martinez, David G. Cory

Published Oct 31, 2003• 93 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Errors in the control of quantum systems may be classified as unitary, decoherent, and incoherent. Unitary errors are systematic, and result in a density matrix that differs from the desired one by a unitary operation. Decoherent errors correspond to general completely positive superoperators, and can only be corrected using methods such as quantum error correction. Incoherent errors can also be described, on average, by completely positive superoperators, but can nevertheless be corrected by the application of a locally unitary operation that “refocuses” them. They are due to reproducible spatial or temporal variations in the system’s Hamiltonian, so that information on the variations is encoded in the system’s spatiotemporal state and can be used to correct them. In this paper liquid-state nuclear magnetic resonance is used to demonstrate that such refocusing effects can be built directly into the control fields, where the incoherence arises from spatial inhomogeneities in the quantizing static magnetic field as well as the radio-frequency control fields themselves. Using perturbation theory, it is further shown that the eigenvalue spectrum of the completely positive superoperator exhibits a characteristic spread that contains information on the Hamiltonians’ underlying distribution.

DOI
10.1063/1.1619132

Related papers

Incoherent Noise and Quantum Control

Nicolas Boulant, Shunsuke Furuta, Joseph Emerson +2 more

We explore in this paper incoherent processes, which can be modelled as a distribution of unitary processes corresponding to spatially or slowly varying control parameters. Incoherent processes are an important source of errors in quantum information processing. These processes also cause problems and ambiguities for quantum process tomography for which we give examples to illustrate the issues. In an effort to characterize these processes, we develop methods of analysis based on the eigenvalue spectra of superoperators to extract information about the noise source. Examples from nuclear magnetic resonance are provided to illustrate the utility of such information in designing control sequences that directly counteract incoherent noise.

•Dec 12, 2003•3 citations

Incoherent noise and quantum information processing

Nicolas Boulant, Joseph Emerson, Timothy F. Havel +2 more

Incoherence in the controlled Hamiltonian is an important limitation on the precision of coherent control in quantum information processing. Incoherence can typically be modeled as a distribution of unitary processes arising from slowly varying experimental parameters. We show how it introduces artifacts in quantum process tomography and we explain how the resulting estimate of the superoperator may not be completely positive. We then go on to attack the inverse problem of extracting an effective distribution of unitaries that characterizes the incoherence via a perturbation theory analysis of the superoperator eigenvalue spectra.

arXiv:quant-ph/0312116•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 30, 2004•44 citations

Quantum process tomography of the quantum Fourier transform

Yaakov S. Weinstein, Timothy F. Havel, Joseph Emerson +4 more

The results of quantum process tomography on a three-qubit nuclear magnetic resonance quantum information processor are presented and shown to be consistent with a detailed model of the system-plus-apparatus used for the experiments. The quantum operation studied was the quantum Fourier transform, which is important in several quantum algorithms and poses a rigorous test for the precision of our recently developed strongly modulating control fields. The results were analyzed in an attempt to decompose the implementation errors into coherent (overall systematic), incoherent (microscopically deterministic), and decoherent (microscopically random) components. This analysis yielded a superoperator consisting of a unitary part that was strongly correlated with the theoretically expected unitary superoperator of the quantum Fourier transform, an overall attenuation consistent with decoherence, and a residual portion that was not completely positive-although complete positivity is required for any quantum operation. By comparison with the results of computer simulations, the lack of complete positivity was shown to be largely a consequence of the incoherent errors which occurred over the full quantum process tomography procedure. These simulations further showed that coherent, incoherent, and decoherent errors can often be identified by their distinctive effects on the spectrum of the overall superoperator. The gate fidelity of the experimentally determined superoperator was 0.64, while the correlation coefficient between experimentally determined superoperator and the simulated superoperator was 0.79; most of the discrepancies with the simulations could be explained by the cumulative effect of small errors in the single qubit gates.

arXiv:quant-ph/0406239•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Sep 27, 2004•186 citations

Compensation of Incoherent Errors in the Precise Implementation of Effective Hamiltonians for Quantum Information Processing

Amro M. Farid

This thesis sets out to present an algorithm for compensation of incoherent errors in quantum information processing (QIP).In particular, it addresses the incoherent errors that arise from RF inhomogeneity in a liquid state NMR system.It briefly describes NMR's place in QIP experimental developments and explains the need to eliminate the errors introduced by RF inhomogeneity.An algorithm for compensation is proposed provided that one has prior knowledge of the system Hamiltonian and a measurement of the degree of RF inhomogeneity.The algorithm was used to create two sets of RF pulses; an uncompensated set that did not use the RF inhomogeneity measurement and a more robust set that did use the measurement.Simulation results indicate that all of the new pulses reduced the error by approximately an order of magnitude for the measured RF inhomgeneity, as well as for most other types of RF inhomogeneity.This result was verified in experiment, where correlations were improved by 0.024 on average.In total, errors due to RF inhomogeneity were reduced by a factor of six.

•Oct 26, 2002•0 citations

Liquid-state nuclear magnetic resonance as a testbed for developing quantum control methods

Colm A. Ryan, C. Negrevergne, Martin Laforest +2 more

In building a quantum-information processor (QIP), the challenge is to coherently control a large quantum system well enough to perform an arbitrary quantum algorithm and to be able to correct errors induced by decoherence. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) QIPs offer an excellent testbed on which to develop and benchmark tools and techniques to control quantum systems. Two main issues to consider when designing control methods are accuracy and efficiency, for which two complementary approaches have been developed so far to control qubit registers with liquid-state NMR methods. The first applies optimal control theory to numerically optimize the control fields to implement unitary operations on low-dimensional systems with high fidelity. The second technique is based on the efficient optimization of a sequence of imperfect control elements so that implementation of a full quantum algorithm is possible while minimizing error accumulation. This paper summarizes our work in implementing both of these methods. Furthermore, we show that taken together, they form a basis to design quantum control methods for a block-architecture QIP so that large system size is not a barrier to implementing optimal control techniques.

arXiv:0803.1982•Physical Review A•Jul 15, 2008•143 citations

Experimental demonstration of an entanglement swapping operation and improved control in NMR quantum-information processing

Nicolas Boulant, Karina Montilla Edmonds, Jerry Zhijian Yang +2 more

We demonstrate the implementation of an entanglement swapping operation on a four-qubit liquid-state nuclear-magnetic-resonance (NMR) quantum-information processor. We use this experiment as a benchmark to illustrate the progress made in the field of quantum control using strongly modulating pulses and a correction scheme for removing distortions introduced by the nonlinearities in the transmitter and probe circuits. The advances include compensating for incoherent errors caused by the spatial variation of the system Hamiltonian in the NMR sample. The goal of these control sequences is to cause the collapse of the Kraus operator-sum representation of the superoperator into one unitary operator so that the ensemble appears to evolve as one coherent whole.

Physical Review A•Sep 11, 2003•36 citations
Errors in the control of quantum systems may be classified as unitary, decoherent, and incoherent. Unitary errors are systematic, and result in a density matrix that differs from the desired one by a unitary operation. Decoherent errors correspond to general completely positive superoperators, and can only be corrected using methods such as quantum error correction. Incoherent errors can also be described, on average, by completely positive superoperators, but can nevertheless be corrected by the application of a locally unitary operation that “refocuses” them. They are due to reproducible spatial or temporal variations in the system’s Hamiltonian, so that information on the variations is encoded in the system’s spatiotemporal state and can be used to correct them. In this paper liquid-state nuclear magnetic resonance is used to demonstrate that such refocusing effects can be built directly into the control fields, where the incoherence arises from spatial inhomogeneities in the quantizing static magnetic field as well as the radio-frequency control fields themselves. Using perturbation theory, it is further shown that the eigenvalue spectrum of the completely positive superoperator exhibits a characteristic spread that contains information on the Hamiltonians’ underlying distribution.
We explore in this paper incoherent processes, which can be modelled as a distribution of unitary processes corresponding to spatially or slowly varying control parameters. Incoherent processes are an important source of errors in quantum information processing. These processes also cause problems and ambiguities for quantum process tomography for which we give examples to illustrate the issues. In an effort to characterize these processes, we develop methods of analysis based on the eigenvalue spectra of superoperators to extract information about the noise source. Examples from nuclear magnetic resonance are provided to illustrate the utility of such information in designing control sequences that directly counteract incoherent noise.
Incoherence in the controlled Hamiltonian is an important limitation on the precision of coherent control in quantum information processing. Incoherence can typically be modeled as a distribution of unitary processes arising from slowly varying experimental parameters. We show how it introduces artifacts in quantum process tomography and we explain how the resulting estimate of the superoperator may not be completely positive. We then go on to attack the inverse problem of extracting an effective distribution of unitaries that characterizes the incoherence via a perturbation theory analysis of the superoperator eigenvalue spectra.
The results of quantum process tomography on a three-qubit nuclear magnetic resonance quantum information processor are presented and shown to be consistent with a detailed model of the system-plus-apparatus used for the experiments. The quantum operation studied was the quantum Fourier transform, which is important in several quantum algorithms and poses a rigorous test for the precision of our recently developed strongly modulating control fields. The results were analyzed in an attempt to decompose the implementation errors into coherent (overall systematic), incoherent (microscopically deterministic), and decoherent (microscopically random) components. This analysis yielded a superoperator consisting of a unitary part that was strongly correlated with the theoretically expected unitary superoperator of the quantum Fourier transform, an overall attenuation consistent with decoherence, and a residual portion that was not completely positive-although complete positivity is required for any quantum operation. By comparison with the results of computer simulations, the lack of complete positivity was shown to be largely a consequence of the incoherent errors which occurred over the full quantum process tomography procedure. These simulations further showed that coherent, incoherent, and decoherent errors can often be identified by their distinctive effects on the spectrum of the overall superoperator. The gate fidelity of the experimentally determined superoperator was 0.64, while the correlation coefficient between experimentally determined superoperator and the simulated superoperator was 0.79; most of the discrepancies with the simulations could be explained by the cumulative effect of small errors in the single qubit gates.
This thesis sets out to present an algorithm for compensation of incoherent errors in quantum information processing (QIP).In particular, it addresses the incoherent errors that arise from RF inhomogeneity in a liquid state NMR system.It briefly describes NMR's place in QIP experimental developments and explains the need to eliminate the errors introduced by RF inhomogeneity.An algorithm for compensation is proposed provided that one has prior knowledge of the system Hamiltonian and a measurement of the degree of RF inhomogeneity.The algorithm was used to create two sets of RF pulses; an uncompensated set that did not use the RF inhomogeneity measurement and a more robust set that did use the measurement.Simulation results indicate that all of the new pulses reduced the error by approximately an order of magnitude for the measured RF inhomgeneity, as well as for most other types of RF inhomogeneity.This result was verified in experiment, where correlations were improved by 0.024 on average.In total, errors due to RF inhomogeneity were reduced by a factor of six.
In building a quantum-information processor (QIP), the challenge is to coherently control a large quantum system well enough to perform an arbitrary quantum algorithm and to be able to correct errors induced by decoherence. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) QIPs offer an excellent testbed on which to develop and benchmark tools and techniques to control quantum systems. Two main issues to consider when designing control methods are accuracy and efficiency, for which two complementary approaches have been developed so far to control qubit registers with liquid-state NMR methods. The first applies optimal control theory to numerically optimize the control fields to implement unitary operations on low-dimensional systems with high fidelity. The second technique is based on the efficient optimization of a sequence of imperfect control elements so that implementation of a full quantum algorithm is possible while minimizing error accumulation. This paper summarizes our work in implementing both of these methods. Furthermore, we show that taken together, they form a basis to design quantum control methods for a block-architecture QIP so that large system size is not a barrier to implementing optimal control techniques.
We demonstrate the implementation of an entanglement swapping operation on a four-qubit liquid-state nuclear-magnetic-resonance (NMR) quantum-information processor. We use this experiment as a benchmark to illustrate the progress made in the field of quantum control using strongly modulating pulses and a correction scheme for removing distortions introduced by the nonlinearities in the transmitter and probe circuits. The advances include compensating for incoherent errors caused by the spatial variation of the system Hamiltonian in the NMR sample. The goal of these control sequences is to cause the collapse of the Kraus operator-sum representation of the superoperator into one unitary operator so that the ensemble appears to evolve as one coherent whole.