Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:physics/9904031

A Bit too Far

Joel M. Williams

Published Apr 15, 1999• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the particle in the box problem, the particle is not in both boxes at the same time as some would have you believe. It is a set definition situation with the two boxes being part of a set that also contains a particle. Set and subset differences are explored. Atomic electron orbitals can be mimicked by roulette wheel probability; thus ELECTRONIC ROULETTE. 0 and 00 serve as boundary limits and are on opposite sides of the central core - a point that quantum physics ignores. Considering a stray marble on the floor as part of the roulette wheel menage is taking assumptions a bit too far. Likewise, the attraction between a positive and negative charge at distance does not make the negative charge part of the positive charge's orbital system. This, of course, is contrary to the stance of current quantum physics methodology that carries this orbital association a bit too far.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.physics/9904031

Related papers

Constrained Particles

Jonathan Allday

One of the classic first problems in quantum theory textbooks is that of the particle trapped in a box. Despite the apparent artificiality of the situation, it has quite a few interesting features that we can quickly apply to some more physically plausible situations. The particle in a box is literally an object, such as an electron, trapped inside a ‘box.’ In a realistic physical example, this ‘box’ would be a volume of space bound by some constraining force acting on the particle. For example, an atom is a ‘box’ as far as the orbiting electrons are concerned, with the electrostatic force between the positive protons in the nucleus and the negative electrons providing the constraint. The first move is to assume that the wave function for any particle in the box will have separate spatial and temporal dependencies. One of the key steps in obtaining our wave function was the quantization of the momentum.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 21, 2022•0 citations

Identical Particles

Jonathan Allday

An atom consists of a nucleus, containing protons and neutrons, with various electrons swarming around the outskirts. The electrons are held in the vicinity of the nucleus as they are negatively charged and hence attracted by the positively charged protons. Although atoms are complicated objects, there are certain situations where they can be treated as simple lumps of matter. Their internal structure has no relevance to the details of what is happening. This sort of situation is exemplified by experiments in which atoms are deliberately smashed into one another at comparatively low energy and as such provide an ideal start in a study of the quantum physics of identical particles. When we are dealing with atoms, there is something more to being ‘identical’ than we can appreciate with larger-scale objects. Atoms of the same type are really identical, measurably identical if you like, which can make a considerable difference in some physically important situations.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 21, 2022•0 citations

THE ATOM

B. S. Chandrasekhar

Introduction I give in this chapter the quantum-mechanical description of an atom. I look in some detail at the hydrogen atom, which is the simplest atom we have, with just one proton and one electron. From the picture that emerges, we shall be able to see how to describe all other atoms. Before continuing, I need to explain what I mean when I say that the proton and electron have equal and opposite electric charges. It is because of these charges that the atom is stable, and does not spontaneously break up into the two separate particles. Electric charge and potential energy If I take a ball in my hand and then let go, it drops to the floor. This is because of the gravitational interaction between the ball and the earth. The ball had gravitational potential energy when I held it, and when I release it, this energy is progressively converted to kinetic energy as it falls. Gravitation makes two bodies move towards each other, and not away from each other: the gravitational force is always attractive. As a result of many experiments done over the years, we find that there is another kind of force in nature, somewhat analogous to, but in one aspect different from, gravitation. I take two idealized examples, and use them to show the features of this force. First I consider two electrons that I imagine to be pinned down a distance r apart.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 16, 1997•0 citations

Core Explanation 2 — Measurement, Effects, and Pair Generation of Quantum Wells and Annihilation Pairs

weihui lu

Core Explanation 2 — Measurement, Effects, and Pair Generation of Quantum Wells and Annihilation Pairs (Dual-Channel Quantum-Well Annihilation-Field Model · A sequel to the core manuscript · No new postulates; all criteria carry over Postulates I–VI and the postulate-level laws L1–L6) Author: Lu Weihui A sequel to the core manuscript, collecting the recent discussion of “quantum wells” and “annihilation pairs” Note This document is a sequel to the core manuscript “Dual-Channel Quantum-Well Annihilation-Field Model — A Self-Consistent Derivation from Underlying Postulates to Macroscopic Phenomena”. It collects the recent discussion of “quantum wells” and “annihilation pairs”: the nature of light and of the electron, the basis of measurement, the “opening” of a neutral quantum well, the distinction between physical effects and measurement effects, the criterion of measurability, and the mechanism by which colliding high-energy photons generate a pair of electron and positron. No new postulates are added; all criteria carry over Postulates I–VI and the postulate-level laws L1–L6. Anything that is a further extrapolation is marked as a “special-topic extrapolation / current understanding” and may be revised. As in the core manuscript, this document gives only structures and criteria, and makes no numerical assertions. Convention: wherever the core manuscript has been marked as a “current working understanding / current conjecture / to be determined / not yet certain / left for later,” or is brief or vague, this document first quotes the core manuscript verbatim and then gives a definite interpretation — “what the core manuscript says, and how this document decides it” — so that the two may be compared item by item. Following this convention, this document has inserted, at the corresponding places in Chapters 1–6, the core manuscript's words together with this document's definite interpretation. Contents Note Chapter 1 Starting Point: the Nature of Light and of the Electron 1.1 Light is a positive annihilation pair, surrounded by a negative quantum well 1.2 The electron is a positive quantum well, surrounded by a negative quantum well 1.3 The two are structurally isomorphic; only the core differs Chapter 2 The Basis of Measurement: a particle is necessarily enveloped by the negative layer of the vacuum 2.1 The vacuum is the array of neutral quantum wells 2.2 A particle, once in motion, is necessarily enveloped by the vacuum's negative layer 2.3 This negative layer is the contactable interface Chapter 3 The Neutral Quantum Well and its “Opening” 3.1 A neutral quantum well: equal positive and negative content, with no outward manifestation 3.2 “Opening”: splitting into a positive peak and a negative peak 3.3 Only after opening does it exhibit physical properties Chapter 4 Physical Effects and Measurement Effects 4.1 The two kinds of effect must be kept apart 4.2 Table of four cases 4.3 A pure single-kind structure: it may have a physical effect without a measurement effect Chapter 5 The Criterion of Measurability 5.1 The criterion: an outer negative quantum well + an inner positive quantum well (or positive annihilation pair) 5.2 Three unmeasurable cases 5.3 Relation to L6 (measurement and support) Chapter 6 Collision of High-Energy Photons: generation of an electron–positron pair (special-topic extrapolation) 6.1 Two high-energy photons colliding head-on 6.2 The temporary electron 6.3 The temporary positron 6.4 Consistency with conservation laws and with L6; the naming is left open Chapter 7 Summary of Conclusions Chapter 1 Starting Point: the Nature of Light and of the Electron 1.1 Light is a positive annihilation pair, surrounded by a negative quantum well According to the core manuscript, the nature of light is a positive annihilation pair surrounded by a negative quantum well. What is meant by “one positive annihilation pair” is a reacting unit that is isolated by the negative quantum well, can exist independently, and can run on its own — it does not freeze the “annihilation pair” into a particle, but stresses that it is enclosed by the negative quantum well and isolated from the outside, so that it does not take part in the self-catalytic aggregation of positive quantum wells; hence its mass is far less than that of the electron. [Quote from the core manuscript] Opening note: “The quantum-well structure of light resembles a dynamic electron; its mass may be far less than that of an electron, and this has not yet been demonstrated.” [Definite interpretation in this document] The core manuscript here only likens the structure of light to the electron and states plainly that it “has not yet been demonstrated.” This document accordingly decides: the nature of light is a positive annihilation pair surrounded by a negative quantum well (see 1.1); it is isomorphic with the electron in the form “positive core + negative shell,” differing only in the core; and, being isolated by the negative quantum well and taking no part in the self-catalytic aggregation of positive quantum wells, its mass is far less than that of the electron — this is precisely the definite interpretation of the point left “not yet demonstrated.” 1.2 The electron is a positive quantum well, surrounded by a negative quantum well The nature of the electron is a positive quantum well, likewise surrounded by a negative quantum well. 1.3 The two are structurally isomorphic; only the core differs Light and the electron are structurally isomorphic, both being “positive core + negative shell”; they differ only in the core: the core of light is a positive annihilation pair, the core of the electron is a positive quantum well. This “positive core + negative shell” configuration is the reference configuration on which this document bases its later judgment of “measurable / not measurable”. [Quote from the core manuscript] §1.1, “infinite nesting (the form of light's walking)” (same in §5.1): “As to why the levels of the quantum well are infinitely nested, its finer mechanism is left by this manuscript for later.” [Definite interpretation] The core manuscript explicitly leaves “why the levels are infinitely nested” for later. This document takes from it only the premise that holds here — that light walks along an infinitely nested hierarchy; its underlying mechanism is not treated here, nor answered here on the core manuscript's behalf; it remains left for later. [Quote from the core manuscript] §1.2(5): “On the coexistence of positive and negative quantum wells and their distribution (current working understanding) … this paper, in accordance with the facts, labels it ‘current working understanding,’ to be revised as understanding deepens.” [Definite interpretation] This document accordingly decides: positive and negative quantum wells coexist simultaneously at the same level and are not mutually exclusive; the classes are always only three (positive, negative, neutral); as for the arrangement of the three within a single level, this system does not prescribe it. [Quote from the core manuscript] §1.8: “The Geometric Structure of the Universe: the universe as one giant nested quantum well (current working understanding)”; and its item (4): “This item is a current working understanding and may be revised in the future.” [Definite interpretation] The core manuscript defines the structure of the universe as one giant nested quantum well (nested layer upon layer, constituted by the three classes together) and labels it a current working understanding. This document takes from it only the premise directly relevant here — that light always travels within the interior of this giant quantum well to which it belongs; the remaining geometric meaning is not treated here and remains, with the core manuscript, a current working understanding. Chapter 2 The Basis of Measurement: a particle is necessarily enveloped by the negative layer of the vacuum 2.1 The vacuum is the array of neutral quantum wells According to the core manuscript, the vacuum is not “the absence of reaction” but the outward manifestation of neutral quantum wells: within a single quantum well, two independent annihilation pairs — positive and negative — of equal content are isolated and mutually neutralized (Postulate VI). And a neutral quantum well is itself “half” positive and “half” negative (1.2(vi)); therefore the neutral quantum wells that make up the vacuum inherently contain a negative layer as one of their halves. [Quote from the core manuscript] §1.2(6): “It is not yet easy to define stably at present, so this paper tentatively calls it the ‘empty quantum well.’” [Definite interpretation] At that time the core manuscript made only a “tentative” designation. The object is now stably defined by Postulate VI: it is formed by two independent annihilation pairs of equal content, positive and negative, isolated within the same quantum well, neutralizing outward. Hence the “empty quantum well” and the “neutral quantum well” are one and the same object, and the “vacuum” is its outward manifestation — this document no longer uses the word “tentative.” 2.2 A particle, once in motion, is necessarily enveloped by the vacuum's negative layer Once a particle (light, an electron, or the electron-like structure discussed below) comes into motion and occupies a position, that position was previously occupied by the neutral quantum wells of the vacuum; the particle is therefore necessarily wrapped in a layer of negative quantum well. This negative layer is not something the particle “generates” or “draws out” on its own; it comes with the vacuum — the particle merely makes “explicit” the half that the vacuum already possesses. 2.3 This negative layer is the contactable interface The positive core is enclosed within the negative layer and does not touch the outside directly; whatever the outside (the prober) can touch is always this outermost negati

•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

Quantum-mechanical treatment of two particles in a potential box

G. Mann

Abstract In classical physics, there is a basic principle, namely “A particle cannot be located at the position of another one on the same time.” Which consequences can be derived if this principle is transferred into quantum physics? For doing that, two distinguishable particles are considered to be trapped in a potential box by means of the Schrödinger equation. In result, the particles can necessarily be located only at discrete positions.

arXiv:2507.01916•Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A•Jan 22, 2024•0 citations

A particle in a chemical box

K. Michael Jinks

The conventional quantum mechanical problem of a particle in a one-dimensional box can be made more interesting chemically without introducing any more difficult mathematics by employing a potential diagram rather than the usual infinite well.

Journal of Chemical Education•May 1, 1975•4 citations
In the particle in the box problem, the particle is not in both boxes at the same time as some would have you believe. It is a set definition situation with the two boxes being part of a set that also contains a particle. Set and subset differences are explored. Atomic electron orbitals can be mimicked by roulette wheel probability; thus ELECTRONIC ROULETTE. 0 and 00 serve as boundary limits and are on opposite sides of the central core - a point that quantum physics ignores. Considering a stray marble on the floor as part of the roulette wheel menage is taking assumptions a bit too far. Likewise, the attraction between a positive and negative charge at distance does not make the negative charge part of the positive charge's orbital system. This, of course, is contrary to the stance of current quantum physics methodology that carries this orbital association a bit too far.
One of the classic first problems in quantum theory textbooks is that of the particle trapped in a box. Despite the apparent artificiality of the situation, it has quite a few interesting features that we can quickly apply to some more physically plausible situations. The particle in a box is literally an object, such as an electron, trapped inside a ‘box.’ In a realistic physical example, this ‘box’ would be a volume of space bound by some constraining force acting on the particle. For example, an atom is a ‘box’ as far as the orbiting electrons are concerned, with the electrostatic force between the positive protons in the nucleus and the negative electrons providing the constraint. The first move is to assume that the wave function for any particle in the box will have separate spatial and temporal dependencies. One of the key steps in obtaining our wave function was the quantization of the momentum.
An atom consists of a nucleus, containing protons and neutrons, with various electrons swarming around the outskirts. The electrons are held in the vicinity of the nucleus as they are negatively charged and hence attracted by the positively charged protons. Although atoms are complicated objects, there are certain situations where they can be treated as simple lumps of matter. Their internal structure has no relevance to the details of what is happening. This sort of situation is exemplified by experiments in which atoms are deliberately smashed into one another at comparatively low energy and as such provide an ideal start in a study of the quantum physics of identical particles. When we are dealing with atoms, there is something more to being ‘identical’ than we can appreciate with larger-scale objects. Atoms of the same type are really identical, measurably identical if you like, which can make a considerable difference in some physically important situations.
Introduction I give in this chapter the quantum-mechanical description of an atom. I look in some detail at the hydrogen atom, which is the simplest atom we have, with just one proton and one electron. From the picture that emerges, we shall be able to see how to describe all other atoms. Before continuing, I need to explain what I mean when I say that the proton and electron have equal and opposite electric charges. It is because of these charges that the atom is stable, and does not spontaneously break up into the two separate particles. Electric charge and potential energy If I take a ball in my hand and then let go, it drops to the floor. This is because of the gravitational interaction between the ball and the earth. The ball had gravitational potential energy when I held it, and when I release it, this energy is progressively converted to kinetic energy as it falls. Gravitation makes two bodies move towards each other, and not away from each other: the gravitational force is always attractive. As a result of many experiments done over the years, we find that there is another kind of force in nature, somewhat analogous to, but in one aspect different from, gravitation. I take two idealized examples, and use them to show the features of this force. First I consider two electrons that I imagine to be pinned down a distance r apart.
Core Explanation 2 — Measurement, Effects, and Pair Generation of Quantum Wells and Annihilation Pairs (Dual-Channel Quantum-Well Annihilation-Field Model · A sequel to the core manuscript · No new postulates; all criteria carry over Postulates I–VI and the postulate-level laws L1–L6) Author: Lu Weihui A sequel to the core manuscript, collecting the recent discussion of “quantum wells” and “annihilation pairs” Note This document is a sequel to the core manuscript “Dual-Channel Quantum-Well Annihilation-Field Model — A Self-Consistent Derivation from Underlying Postulates to Macroscopic Phenomena”. It collects the recent discussion of “quantum wells” and “annihilation pairs”: the nature of light and of the electron, the basis of measurement, the “opening” of a neutral quantum well, the distinction between physical effects and measurement effects, the criterion of measurability, and the mechanism by which colliding high-energy photons generate a pair of electron and positron. No new postulates are added; all criteria carry over Postulates I–VI and the postulate-level laws L1–L6. Anything that is a further extrapolation is marked as a “special-topic extrapolation / current understanding” and may be revised. As in the core manuscript, this document gives only structures and criteria, and makes no numerical assertions. Convention: wherever the core manuscript has been marked as a “current working understanding / current conjecture / to be determined / not yet certain / left for later,” or is brief or vague, this document first quotes the core manuscript verbatim and then gives a definite interpretation — “what the core manuscript says, and how this document decides it” — so that the two may be compared item by item. Following this convention, this document has inserted, at the corresponding places in Chapters 1–6, the core manuscript's words together with this document's definite interpretation. Contents Note Chapter 1 Starting Point: the Nature of Light and of the Electron 1.1 Light is a positive annihilation pair, surrounded by a negative quantum well 1.2 The electron is a positive quantum well, surrounded by a negative quantum well 1.3 The two are structurally isomorphic; only the core differs Chapter 2 The Basis of Measurement: a particle is necessarily enveloped by the negative layer of the vacuum 2.1 The vacuum is the array of neutral quantum wells 2.2 A particle, once in motion, is necessarily enveloped by the vacuum's negative layer 2.3 This negative layer is the contactable interface Chapter 3 The Neutral Quantum Well and its “Opening” 3.1 A neutral quantum well: equal positive and negative content, with no outward manifestation 3.2 “Opening”: splitting into a positive peak and a negative peak 3.3 Only after opening does it exhibit physical properties Chapter 4 Physical Effects and Measurement Effects 4.1 The two kinds of effect must be kept apart 4.2 Table of four cases 4.3 A pure single-kind structure: it may have a physical effect without a measurement effect Chapter 5 The Criterion of Measurability 5.1 The criterion: an outer negative quantum well + an inner positive quantum well (or positive annihilation pair) 5.2 Three unmeasurable cases 5.3 Relation to L6 (measurement and support) Chapter 6 Collision of High-Energy Photons: generation of an electron–positron pair (special-topic extrapolation) 6.1 Two high-energy photons colliding head-on 6.2 The temporary electron 6.3 The temporary positron 6.4 Consistency with conservation laws and with L6; the naming is left open Chapter 7 Summary of Conclusions Chapter 1 Starting Point: the Nature of Light and of the Electron 1.1 Light is a positive annihilation pair, surrounded by a negative quantum well According to the core manuscript, the nature of light is a positive annihilation pair surrounded by a negative quantum well. What is meant by “one positive annihilation pair” is a reacting unit that is isolated by the negative quantum well, can exist independently, and can run on its own — it does not freeze the “annihilation pair” into a particle, but stresses that it is enclosed by the negative quantum well and isolated from the outside, so that it does not take part in the self-catalytic aggregation of positive quantum wells; hence its mass is far less than that of the electron. [Quote from the core manuscript] Opening note: “The quantum-well structure of light resembles a dynamic electron; its mass may be far less than that of an electron, and this has not yet been demonstrated.” [Definite interpretation in this document] The core manuscript here only likens the structure of light to the electron and states plainly that it “has not yet been demonstrated.” This document accordingly decides: the nature of light is a positive annihilation pair surrounded by a negative quantum well (see 1.1); it is isomorphic with the electron in the form “positive core + negative shell,” differing only in the core; and, being isolated by the negative quantum well and taking no part in the self-catalytic aggregation of positive quantum wells, its mass is far less than that of the electron — this is precisely the definite interpretation of the point left “not yet demonstrated.” 1.2 The electron is a positive quantum well, surrounded by a negative quantum well The nature of the electron is a positive quantum well, likewise surrounded by a negative quantum well. 1.3 The two are structurally isomorphic; only the core differs Light and the electron are structurally isomorphic, both being “positive core + negative shell”; they differ only in the core: the core of light is a positive annihilation pair, the core of the electron is a positive quantum well. This “positive core + negative shell” configuration is the reference configuration on which this document bases its later judgment of “measurable / not measurable”. [Quote from the core manuscript] §1.1, “infinite nesting (the form of light's walking)” (same in §5.1): “As to why the levels of the quantum well are infinitely nested, its finer mechanism is left by this manuscript for later.” [Definite interpretation] The core manuscript explicitly leaves “why the levels are infinitely nested” for later. This document takes from it only the premise that holds here — that light walks along an infinitely nested hierarchy; its underlying mechanism is not treated here, nor answered here on the core manuscript's behalf; it remains left for later. [Quote from the core manuscript] §1.2(5): “On the coexistence of positive and negative quantum wells and their distribution (current working understanding) … this paper, in accordance with the facts, labels it ‘current working understanding,’ to be revised as understanding deepens.” [Definite interpretation] This document accordingly decides: positive and negative quantum wells coexist simultaneously at the same level and are not mutually exclusive; the classes are always only three (positive, negative, neutral); as for the arrangement of the three within a single level, this system does not prescribe it. [Quote from the core manuscript] §1.8: “The Geometric Structure of the Universe: the universe as one giant nested quantum well (current working understanding)”; and its item (4): “This item is a current working understanding and may be revised in the future.” [Definite interpretation] The core manuscript defines the structure of the universe as one giant nested quantum well (nested layer upon layer, constituted by the three classes together) and labels it a current working understanding. This document takes from it only the premise directly relevant here — that light always travels within the interior of this giant quantum well to which it belongs; the remaining geometric meaning is not treated here and remains, with the core manuscript, a current working understanding. Chapter 2 The Basis of Measurement: a particle is necessarily enveloped by the negative layer of the vacuum 2.1 The vacuum is the array of neutral quantum wells According to the core manuscript, the vacuum is not “the absence of reaction” but the outward manifestation of neutral quantum wells: within a single quantum well, two independent annihilation pairs — positive and negative — of equal content are isolated and mutually neutralized (Postulate VI). And a neutral quantum well is itself “half” positive and “half” negative (1.2(vi)); therefore the neutral quantum wells that make up the vacuum inherently contain a negative layer as one of their halves. [Quote from the core manuscript] §1.2(6): “It is not yet easy to define stably at present, so this paper tentatively calls it the ‘empty quantum well.’” [Definite interpretation] At that time the core manuscript made only a “tentative” designation. The object is now stably defined by Postulate VI: it is formed by two independent annihilation pairs of equal content, positive and negative, isolated within the same quantum well, neutralizing outward. Hence the “empty quantum well” and the “neutral quantum well” are one and the same object, and the “vacuum” is its outward manifestation — this document no longer uses the word “tentative.” 2.2 A particle, once in motion, is necessarily enveloped by the vacuum's negative layer Once a particle (light, an electron, or the electron-like structure discussed below) comes into motion and occupies a position, that position was previously occupied by the neutral quantum wells of the vacuum; the particle is therefore necessarily wrapped in a layer of negative quantum well. This negative layer is not something the particle “generates” or “draws out” on its own; it comes with the vacuum — the particle merely makes “explicit” the half that the vacuum already possesses. 2.3 This negative layer is the contactable interface The positive core is enclosed within the negative layer and does not touch the outside directly; whatever the outside (the prober) can touch is always this outermost negati