Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

CRC Press eBooks

Identical Particles

Jonathan Allday

Published Sep 21, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An atom consists of a nucleus, containing protons and neutrons, with various electrons swarming around the outskirts. The electrons are held in the vicinity of the nucleus as they are negatively charged and hence attracted by the positively charged protons. Although atoms are complicated objects, there are certain situations where they can be treated as simple lumps of matter. Their internal structure has no relevance to the details of what is happening. This sort of situation is exemplified by experiments in which atoms are deliberately smashed into one another at comparatively low energy and as such provide an ideal start in a study of the quantum physics of identical particles. When we are dealing with atoms, there is something more to being ‘identical’ than we can appreciate with larger-scale objects. Atoms of the same type are really identical, measurably identical if you like, which can make a considerable difference in some physically important situations.

DOI
10.1201/9781003225997-10

Related papers

THE ATOM

B. S. Chandrasekhar

Introduction I give in this chapter the quantum-mechanical description of an atom. I look in some detail at the hydrogen atom, which is the simplest atom we have, with just one proton and one electron. From the picture that emerges, we shall be able to see how to describe all other atoms. Before continuing, I need to explain what I mean when I say that the proton and electron have equal and opposite electric charges. It is because of these charges that the atom is stable, and does not spontaneously break up into the two separate particles. Electric charge and potential energy If I take a ball in my hand and then let go, it drops to the floor. This is because of the gravitational interaction between the ball and the earth. The ball had gravitational potential energy when I held it, and when I release it, this energy is progressively converted to kinetic energy as it falls. Gravitation makes two bodies move towards each other, and not away from each other: the gravitational force is always attractive. As a result of many experiments done over the years, we find that there is another kind of force in nature, somewhat analogous to, but in one aspect different from, gravitation. I take two idealized examples, and use them to show the features of this force. First I consider two electrons that I imagine to be pinned down a distance r apart.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 16, 1997•0 citations

The Underlying Simplicity at the Subatomic Domain Can Describe the Diverse and Complex Universe - Where Matter and Energy are the Flipped Side of the Same Coin

The Quantum theory deals with the microscopic structure of the Universe that describes the finer details of nature at the subatomic domain.To a physicist, quantum mechanics is one of the three great pillars supporting our intuition of evocative, bewildering and fascinating natural World as we continuously struggle with the inescapable strangeness of the subatomic domain as if something strange is always afoot.It is well accepted fact that quantum mechanics is a physical theory that describes the way things behave at subatomic level which is quite dazzling in its precision and explanatory power.A test of quantum electrodynamics, the oldest and best understood of the modern quantum theory that involves measuring the way an electron behaves in the vicinity of a magnetic force. Many of the technological and social changes that have revolutionized our lives have actually risen out of the fundamental theoretical research carried out with only motivation to understand the World in a better way than ever. For example, the invention of transistor actually came with the fundamental theoretical research on the Uncertainty Principle which states that the uncertainty of the position of a particle times the uncertainty of its velocity is always a constant. If we double the certainty of the position of the particle, we have to make half the certainty of its velocity and vice versa. Quantum theory is perhaps the prime example of the infinitely esoteric in the sense that it describes a World in which a particle really can be in several places at once and it moves from one place to another by exploring the entire Universe simultaneously-the theory of simultaneity. The diverse and complex Universe is actually made of a few tiny particles according to the rules of quantum theory which is so simple that can be summarized on the back of an envelope. The more we understand about the elemental nature of the Universe, the simpler it looks. We have already discovered that everything in the diverse and complex Universe is nothing but the different assemblies of atoms, and the wide variety of atoms are constructed using the three building blocks at the sub-atomic domain i.e. subatomic particles: protons, neutrons and electrons. We have also discovered that protons and neutrons ate made up of combination of three entities called quarks. And that is where things stop as far as recent discovery is concerned. But the recent progress in particle physics inspiring the quest for the ultimate unified theory of physics that can describe everything in the Universe in one go. The discovery of Boson particle certainty will revolutionaries the Newton's mass concept and gravity into whole new looks. To an optimistic point of view, we must hope the best out of the progress in physics.

International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)•Feb 5, 2016•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics: the Schrödinger Equation

Sander Bais

The first quarter of the twentieth century saw two great scientific revolutions: firstly relativity, which deeply changed our view of space and time, and secondly quantum mechanics, which deeply changed the way we think about states of matter and energy. Quantum mechanics provided a deep understanding of a wide variety of phenomena, from the most fundamental properties of elementary particles to many aspects of chemistry. Quantum theory opened the door to the micro-cosmos, thereby explaining many of the properties of vastly different types of materials such as insulators, metals, semiconductors and superconductors. Modern physics is still deeply involved in further exploiting the ever-surprising worlds of quantum solids, liquids and gases. The quantum revolution implied a radical shake-up of the foundations of theoretical physics. It was caused among others by the inadequacy of the classical theories of Newton and Maxwell to account for the observed structure of atoms. The atom supposedly consisted of a positively charged nucleus surrounded by a number of negatively charged electrons, exactly compensating the nuclear charge. The problem that arose may be explained as follows. Newton told us that in the proposed configuration the electrons would ‘circle’ very rapidly around the nucleus (like a tiny planetary system), and therefore these electrons would continuously be strongly accelerated. Maxwell, however, told us that an accelerated charge would start radiating and thereby losing energy at an appreciable rate, so that in the end the electrons would fall into the nucleus. A little calculation showed that the lifetime of the atom would be something like a billionth of a second. According to our theoretical knowledge, therefore, atoms would just not exist, bluntly contradicting the observations. Quantum theory came to the rescue. Looking back, one of the outstanding achievements of quantum theory is that it explained the structure but also the stability of atoms and molecules, and therefore of all matter. In quantum theory the atomic bound states of the electrons with the nucleus form a discrete set – the allowed states are quantized, with a stable lowest energy state. The theory is based on a number of postulates which are of great generality, providing a framework that should in principle be applicable to any physical system. To put it briefly: our world is quantum-mechanical.

Amsterdam University Press eBooks•Jun 17, 2005•0 citations

Certain About Uncertainty

M. Grant Norton

One hundred years ago the physics that would be necessary to understand how quantum computers work, much less how to build them, did not exist. In the early 1920s electrons were viewed as tiny negatively charged particles—microscopically small spheres—with energies and locations within an atom that were well defined. In Niels Bohr’s Nobel-prize-winning atomic model, electrons moved in orbits around the nucleus with their energy and position both known with, to many scientists, reassuring certainty. Quantum computers rely for their operation on the uncertainty, the “weirdness”, that happens on the atomic scale and below.

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2023•1 citation

Bose–Einstein condensation

John M. Doyle

In quantum mechanics, elementary particles of the same type are considered identical. For example, an electron in an atom could be replaced by another electron and the atom would behave in exactly the same way. Nature has taken particular advantage of this, allowing only two types of elementary particles: bosons and fermions. They differ fundamentally in how a collection of identical particles interact. Identical fermions cannot occupy the same quantum state (only one per state!). Identical bosons can occupy the same quantum state. The statistics of identical particles (how they act in groups) has profound affects. For example, the rich and complex structure of the periodic table arises from the principle that only one electron can occupy each quantum state. The spin and the statistics of particles are closely connected: (fermions) bosons have (half-)integer spin. (Spin is an internal angular momentum measured in units of Planck’s constant.)

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Apr 1, 1997•22 citations

Scattering Identical Bosons

Jonathan Allday

Atoms emit photons when one of their electrons changes its energy state. Stating the process like this, sometimes conjures a specific picture: that the atom is a ‘bag’ containing protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons, and hence when the bag ‘bursts’ a photon flies out. In truth, the photon is created only at the moment of transition and does not in any sense exist before the electron’s energy change. As photons belong to the boson family, we expect them to be bound by some rules. In modern-day technology, the laser has become commonplace, with applications in Blue-Ray players, bar code readers, eye surgery and a wide range of other situations. In its contemporary applications, the laser takes on a range of different, often solid-state, forms. However, it is interesting to see how the original laser design functioned, and how this crucially depends on the physics of identical bosons.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 21, 2022•0 citations
An atom consists of a nucleus, containing protons and neutrons, with various electrons swarming around the outskirts. The electrons are held in the vicinity of the nucleus as they are negatively charged and hence attracted by the positively charged protons. Although atoms are complicated objects, there are certain situations where they can be treated as simple lumps of matter. Their internal structure has no relevance to the details of what is happening. This sort of situation is exemplified by experiments in which atoms are deliberately smashed into one another at comparatively low energy and as such provide an ideal start in a study of the quantum physics of identical particles. When we are dealing with atoms, there is something more to being ‘identical’ than we can appreciate with larger-scale objects. Atoms of the same type are really identical, measurably identical if you like, which can make a considerable difference in some physically important situations.
Introduction I give in this chapter the quantum-mechanical description of an atom. I look in some detail at the hydrogen atom, which is the simplest atom we have, with just one proton and one electron. From the picture that emerges, we shall be able to see how to describe all other atoms. Before continuing, I need to explain what I mean when I say that the proton and electron have equal and opposite electric charges. It is because of these charges that the atom is stable, and does not spontaneously break up into the two separate particles. Electric charge and potential energy If I take a ball in my hand and then let go, it drops to the floor. This is because of the gravitational interaction between the ball and the earth. The ball had gravitational potential energy when I held it, and when I release it, this energy is progressively converted to kinetic energy as it falls. Gravitation makes two bodies move towards each other, and not away from each other: the gravitational force is always attractive. As a result of many experiments done over the years, we find that there is another kind of force in nature, somewhat analogous to, but in one aspect different from, gravitation. I take two idealized examples, and use them to show the features of this force. First I consider two electrons that I imagine to be pinned down a distance r apart.
The Quantum theory deals with the microscopic structure of the Universe that describes the finer details of nature at the subatomic domain.To a physicist, quantum mechanics is one of the three great pillars supporting our intuition of evocative, bewildering and fascinating natural World as we continuously struggle with the inescapable strangeness of the subatomic domain as if something strange is always afoot.It is well accepted fact that quantum mechanics is a physical theory that describes the way things behave at subatomic level which is quite dazzling in its precision and explanatory power.A test of quantum electrodynamics, the oldest and best understood of the modern quantum theory that involves measuring the way an electron behaves in the vicinity of a magnetic force. Many of the technological and social changes that have revolutionized our lives have actually risen out of the fundamental theoretical research carried out with only motivation to understand the World in a better way than ever. For example, the invention of transistor actually came with the fundamental theoretical research on the Uncertainty Principle which states that the uncertainty of the position of a particle times the uncertainty of its velocity is always a constant. If we double the certainty of the position of the particle, we have to make half the certainty of its velocity and vice versa. Quantum theory is perhaps the prime example of the infinitely esoteric in the sense that it describes a World in which a particle really can be in several places at once and it moves from one place to another by exploring the entire Universe simultaneously-the theory of simultaneity. The diverse and complex Universe is actually made of a few tiny particles according to the rules of quantum theory which is so simple that can be summarized on the back of an envelope. The more we understand about the elemental nature of the Universe, the simpler it looks. We have already discovered that everything in the diverse and complex Universe is nothing but the different assemblies of atoms, and the wide variety of atoms are constructed using the three building blocks at the sub-atomic domain i.e. subatomic particles: protons, neutrons and electrons. We have also discovered that protons and neutrons ate made up of combination of three entities called quarks. And that is where things stop as far as recent discovery is concerned. But the recent progress in particle physics inspiring the quest for the ultimate unified theory of physics that can describe everything in the Universe in one go. The discovery of Boson particle certainty will revolutionaries the Newton's mass concept and gravity into whole new looks. To an optimistic point of view, we must hope the best out of the progress in physics.
The first quarter of the twentieth century saw two great scientific revolutions: firstly relativity, which deeply changed our view of space and time, and secondly quantum mechanics, which deeply changed the way we think about states of matter and energy. Quantum mechanics provided a deep understanding of a wide variety of phenomena, from the most fundamental properties of elementary particles to many aspects of chemistry. Quantum theory opened the door to the micro-cosmos, thereby explaining many of the properties of vastly different types of materials such as insulators, metals, semiconductors and superconductors. Modern physics is still deeply involved in further exploiting the ever-surprising worlds of quantum solids, liquids and gases. The quantum revolution implied a radical shake-up of the foundations of theoretical physics. It was caused among others by the inadequacy of the classical theories of Newton and Maxwell to account for the observed structure of atoms. The atom supposedly consisted of a positively charged nucleus surrounded by a number of negatively charged electrons, exactly compensating the nuclear charge. The problem that arose may be explained as follows. Newton told us that in the proposed configuration the electrons would ‘circle’ very rapidly around the nucleus (like a tiny planetary system), and therefore these electrons would continuously be strongly accelerated. Maxwell, however, told us that an accelerated charge would start radiating and thereby losing energy at an appreciable rate, so that in the end the electrons would fall into the nucleus. A little calculation showed that the lifetime of the atom would be something like a billionth of a second. According to our theoretical knowledge, therefore, atoms would just not exist, bluntly contradicting the observations. Quantum theory came to the rescue. Looking back, one of the outstanding achievements of quantum theory is that it explained the structure but also the stability of atoms and molecules, and therefore of all matter. In quantum theory the atomic bound states of the electrons with the nucleus form a discrete set – the allowed states are quantized, with a stable lowest energy state. The theory is based on a number of postulates which are of great generality, providing a framework that should in principle be applicable to any physical system. To put it briefly: our world is quantum-mechanical.
One hundred years ago the physics that would be necessary to understand how quantum computers work, much less how to build them, did not exist. In the early 1920s electrons were viewed as tiny negatively charged particles—microscopically small spheres—with energies and locations within an atom that were well defined. In Niels Bohr’s Nobel-prize-winning atomic model, electrons moved in orbits around the nucleus with their energy and position both known with, to many scientists, reassuring certainty. Quantum computers rely for their operation on the uncertainty, the “weirdness”, that happens on the atomic scale and below.
In quantum mechanics, elementary particles of the same type are considered identical. For example, an electron in an atom could be replaced by another electron and the atom would behave in exactly the same way. Nature has taken particular advantage of this, allowing only two types of elementary particles: bosons and fermions. They differ fundamentally in how a collection of identical particles interact. Identical fermions cannot occupy the same quantum state (only one per state!). Identical bosons can occupy the same quantum state. The statistics of identical particles (how they act in groups) has profound affects. For example, the rich and complex structure of the periodic table arises from the principle that only one electron can occupy each quantum state. The spin and the statistics of particles are closely connected: (fermions) bosons have (half-)integer spin. (Spin is an internal angular momentum measured in units of Planck’s constant.)
Atoms emit photons when one of their electrons changes its energy state. Stating the process like this, sometimes conjures a specific picture: that the atom is a ‘bag’ containing protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons, and hence when the bag ‘bursts’ a photon flies out. In truth, the photon is created only at the moment of transition and does not in any sense exist before the electron’s energy change. As photons belong to the boson family, we expect them to be bound by some rules. In modern-day technology, the laser has become commonplace, with applications in Blue-Ray players, bar code readers, eye surgery and a wide range of other situations. In its contemporary applications, the laser takes on a range of different, often solid-state, forms. However, it is interesting to see how the original laser design functioned, and how this crucially depends on the physics of identical bosons.