Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:physics/0501054 · Molecular Physics

Evidence from the special relativity and blackbody radiation theories for the existence of photons possessing zero kinetic energy

Robert J. Buenker

Published Jun 10, 1992• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The traditional interpretation of radiative emission and absorption asserts that photons are created and annihilated in such processes. A Gedanken experiment is considered in which kinetic energy from observed photons is systematically removed until a limit of zero is reached. With the help of the relativistic Doppler effect, it is shown that even for infinitesimally small kinetic energies the photons continue to exist, since in other interial systems they will be observed to have a much higher energy/frequency falling in an easily detectable range. An alternative explanation for absorption and emission processes can be formulated on this basis in terms of real photons with exactly zero kinetic energy being present before or after radiative interactions. Bolstering this hypothesis is the fact that the statistical mechanical treatment of photons interacting with oscillators in blackbody radiation theory predicts an infinite density of photons of this energy, both in the original Planck formulation employing Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics and in the subsequent Bose-Einstein description. The Bohr relation, E = hv, also makes clear that it is not possible to observe photons in this E = 0 state because a null frequency (or infinite wavelength) cannot be observed, so no contradiction results on this basis. It is pointed out that the Einstein mass dilation formula indicates that photons with zero kinetic energy can move with speeds less than c, down to and including a value of zero. It can also be shown that ordinary conservation of energy/momentum laws lead to the prediction of quantization phenomena in absorption and radiation processes, because of the much smaller mass of photons vis-à-vis atoms. These considerations demonstrate that the E = 0 state is greatly preferred as the product of absorption because of the requirement to have the interaction occur in a relatively narrow region of space-time. There is thus strong evidence that photons are not created and annihilated in radiative processes but simply have their kinetic energy changed either to or from a zero value. Accordingly, a very high density of zero-energy photons is expected to exist uniformly throughout the universe. Finally, this development suggests that one should subject the creation-annihilation hypothesis to careful scrutiny in other areas of physics as well.

DOI
10.1080/00268979200101331

Related papers

Some Fundamental Modifications to Einstein’s Model of the Absorption and Emission of Radiation by Matter

W. A. Tiefenbrunner

In 1916, A. Einstein developed a model of the absorption and emission of radiation from which he derived M. Planck’s radiation law. He postulated light-induced (stimulated) emission, because within the framework of classical physics an oscillator can, depending on the phase difference, both extract energy from the electromagnetic field and transfer energy to it. In a non-coherent field, α = β should hold, where α denotes the kinetic constant of absorption and β that of stimulated emission. This assumption is indispensable for deriving the radiation law from his model. In this context, it is problematic that a certain degree of field coherence follows necessarily from his model, which implies that α ≠ β. Moreover, the model cannot readily be generalised to fields of arbitrary coherence. An alternative model for the absorption and emission of radiation by matter is therefore developed here. On the one hand, it is based on the assumption that, within a blackbody, quanta of different energies may recombine freely; on the other hand, it employs the “pairwise interference model of quantum theory” (PIMOQ). The alternative model of the interaction between light and matter allows the radiation law to be derived for thermal equilibrium in a non-coherent field, under which conditions, according to the model, no stimulated emissions occur. It also describes the behaviour of systems with a coherent field (interference experiment, laser). Furthermore, considerations are presented regarding the energy distribution within a blackbody and the explanatory scope of A. Einstein’s model in this respect.

•Mar 12, 2026•1 citation

Nothing, Zeno Paradoxes and Quantum Physics

Marcis P. Auzinsh

When the concept of Zero is analyzed, it is frequently related to another equally deep and complicated concept – Nothing. If in science, Zero is closely associated with mathematics, then Nothing is primarily related to the material world. The question of whether Nothing can be found in the real physical world is often discussed in relation to the vacuum which, at some point in the history of the development of physics, is thought about as an empty space. Nevertheless, theories of modern physics have demonstrated that even in a vacuum, when all the matter is evacuated from a certain region of space, and this region is isolated from ordinary fields – gravitation field, electromagnetic fields etc – there still remain physical fields called vacuum zero fluctuations that can not be removed in principle. These vacuum fields are properties of space. In this chapter I will analyze another physics theory – namely, Quantum Physics – and will consider its less discussed relations to the concept of Nothing. One of the very first Greek philosophers, Thales (624–548 BCE) from Miletus, declared that Something can not appear from Nothing and it can not disappear, turning into Nothing. This idea, in some aspects, was further developed by Zeno from Elea (495–430 BCE) when he created his paradoxes of motion. These paradoxes can be understood as an analysis of the possibility of infinite division of time and space intervals. When we come to Quantum Physics, the very first appearance of the idea of the smallest possible portion of energy, quantum, was stimulated by the analysis of the spectrum of radiation of heated body – black-body radiation. German physicist Max Planck (1858–1947) demonstrated in 1899 that if we assume that there exists a smallest portion of radiation energy that can not be further divided into smaller parts, we arrive at the description of spectrum of the black-body radiation that perfectly matches the observable reality. In contrast, if we assume that radiation energy can be divided an infinite number of times and there does not exist the smallest possible portion, we arrive at the radiation spectrum which is in a sharp contradiction with observable reality. This contradiction is so strong that it has acquired a special term – the ultraviolet catastrophe. Certain parallels in Zeno’s reasoning and approach used in Quantum Physics can clearly be seen and will be discussed. In the conclusion, I will briefly touch on a similar situation in another field of physics when at the other extreme, departure from the idea of the possibility of the infinitely large quantities, this time velocities of motion, gave birth to another theory of modern physics – Einstein’s theory of special relativity.

BRILL eBooks•Feb 28, 2024•0 citations

Kinetic capacity effect of photons and rest mass particles, and a relativistic rest mass model

Viktor Schatz

In an Einstein like gedanken experiment, the relativistic changes of energies of a photon and a rest mass particle caused by the same relative movement were compared and it was found, that the same relative movement was causing very different energetic changes on the photons and rest mass particles: photons have significantly more “capacity” for kinetic energy. To explain this phenomena, which could be named kinetic capacity effect, a physical model of a “folded and looped photon” was created and checked quantitatively through relativistic Doppler effect for kinetic and total energies, and for linear momentum. De Broglie’s material wave was identified as modulation wave of two interfering waves of the correlated half photons inside of the particle, resulting in known group and phase velocities. Photons themselves were not changed in physical description, so Quantum Mechanics will stay in use with them, and Special Relativity has now extended abilities for entering into particles, opening a way through discussed model to unify both theoretical worlds. For the moment, the two classical theories, waves and relativity, have confirmed exact the hypothesis of present model.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Semi-relativistic $N$-body quantum mechanics of electrons and photons, with fixed nuclei

Michael K.‐H. Kiessling

It is argued that by the end of the 1920s a quantum-mechanical model could have been in place, that not only produces the atomic and molecular energy levels of the many-body Pauli equation with Coulomb interactions and external classical electro- and magneto-static fields without putting these interactions in by hand, but that also accurately describes the interaction of charged particles with electromagnetic radiation, in particular the transitions between atomic or molecular energy levels associated with emission or absorption of radiation. This model suggests a re-interpretation of Maxwell's electromagnetic field equations on spacetime as quantum-mechanical expected values of wave equations on time X configuration space for photons and electrons. The creation / annihilation formalism for photons emerges without invoking second-quantizing the classical Maxwell equations, and without involving the concept of creation / annihilation, thus suggesting an alternative physical interpretation of this formalism. Furthermore, the model suggests that Lorentz covariance of macroscopic physics models emerges through a law of large numbers from a fundamental microscopic model that is not itself Lorentz covariant.

arXiv:2002.11106•Feb 24, 2020•1 citation

Preliminaries

M.S. Rogalski, Stuart B. Palmer

At the beginning of the century doubts were growing about the whole edifice of classical physics, including the laws of mechanics in their Lagrangian and Hamiltonian forms, of statistical thermodynamics, as formulated by Boltzmann and Gibbs, and of optics, namely Maxwell’s and Fresnel’s theory. Einstein proposed that electromagnetic radiation exists in discrete quanta whilst propagating in space as well as during the emission or absorption processes. Scattering by free electrons is a common interaction connected with the absorption of electromagnetic radiation. If the electromagnetic energy is large compared with the ionization energy, the atomic electron can be treated as free. The characteristic features of the scattered radiation have been explained by Compton, on the basis of an elastic collision of a photon with a free electron, where both energy and momentum are conserved. The concept of the matter wavelength holds for both relativistic and non-relativistic particles, provided that the appropriate form of momentum is used.

CRC Press eBooks•Nov 5, 2020•0 citations

Did Planck, Einstein, and Bose count indivisible photons or discrete emission/absorption processes in a black-body cavity?

Michael Ambroselli, Chandrasekhar Roychoudhuri

Planck, Einstein and Bose all had to introduce statistics, and thus counting, in order to successfully derive an equation for the energy distribution within the black-body radiation spectrum, and what we now call Bose-Einstein statistics. Some of the details involved in the counting procedure vary while still giving the same result. However, the interpretation of what we count may differ dramatically from one another (as, for example, between Planck and Bose), without impacting the final, mathematical result. We demonstrate here a further alternative, which varies both, in the details of the counting, as well as in the interpretation, while still producing the same well known statistics. This approach puts the "quantumness" back into the radiation emission/absorption process, possibly dispensing with the requirement of quantized light, at least in the context of black-body radiation.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Sep 10, 2015•0 citations
The traditional interpretation of radiative emission and absorption asserts that photons are created and annihilated in such processes. A Gedanken experiment is considered in which kinetic energy from observed photons is systematically removed until a limit of zero is reached. With the help of the relativistic Doppler effect, it is shown that even for infinitesimally small kinetic energies the photons continue to exist, since in other interial systems they will be observed to have a much higher energy/frequency falling in an easily detectable range. An alternative explanation for absorption and emission processes can be formulated on this basis in terms of real photons with exactly zero kinetic energy being present before or after radiative interactions. Bolstering this hypothesis is the fact that the statistical mechanical treatment of photons interacting with oscillators in blackbody radiation theory predicts an infinite density of photons of this energy, both in the original Planck formulation employing Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics and in the subsequent Bose-Einstein description. The Bohr relation, E = hv, also makes clear that it is not possible to observe photons in this E = 0 state because a null frequency (or infinite wavelength) cannot be observed, so no contradiction results on this basis. It is pointed out that the Einstein mass dilation formula indicates that photons with zero kinetic energy can move with speeds less than c, down to and including a value of zero. It can also be shown that ordinary conservation of energy/momentum laws lead to the prediction of quantization phenomena in absorption and radiation processes, because of the much smaller mass of photons vis-à-vis atoms. These considerations demonstrate that the E = 0 state is greatly preferred as the product of absorption because of the requirement to have the interaction occur in a relatively narrow region of space-time. There is thus strong evidence that photons are not created and annihilated in radiative processes but simply have their kinetic energy changed either to or from a zero value. Accordingly, a very high density of zero-energy photons is expected to exist uniformly throughout the universe. Finally, this development suggests that one should subject the creation-annihilation hypothesis to careful scrutiny in other areas of physics as well.
In 1916, A. Einstein developed a model of the absorption and emission of radiation from which he derived M. Planck’s radiation law. He postulated light-induced (stimulated) emission, because within the framework of classical physics an oscillator can, depending on the phase difference, both extract energy from the electromagnetic field and transfer energy to it. In a non-coherent field, α = β should hold, where α denotes the kinetic constant of absorption and β that of stimulated emission. This assumption is indispensable for deriving the radiation law from his model. In this context, it is problematic that a certain degree of field coherence follows necessarily from his model, which implies that α ≠ β. Moreover, the model cannot readily be generalised to fields of arbitrary coherence. An alternative model for the absorption and emission of radiation by matter is therefore developed here. On the one hand, it is based on the assumption that, within a blackbody, quanta of different energies may recombine freely; on the other hand, it employs the “pairwise interference model of quantum theory” (PIMOQ). The alternative model of the interaction between light and matter allows the radiation law to be derived for thermal equilibrium in a non-coherent field, under which conditions, according to the model, no stimulated emissions occur. It also describes the behaviour of systems with a coherent field (interference experiment, laser). Furthermore, considerations are presented regarding the energy distribution within a blackbody and the explanatory scope of A. Einstein’s model in this respect.
When the concept of Zero is analyzed, it is frequently related to another equally deep and complicated concept – Nothing. If in science, Zero is closely associated with mathematics, then Nothing is primarily related to the material world. The question of whether Nothing can be found in the real physical world is often discussed in relation to the vacuum which, at some point in the history of the development of physics, is thought about as an empty space. Nevertheless, theories of modern physics have demonstrated that even in a vacuum, when all the matter is evacuated from a certain region of space, and this region is isolated from ordinary fields – gravitation field, electromagnetic fields etc – there still remain physical fields called vacuum zero fluctuations that can not be removed in principle. These vacuum fields are properties of space. In this chapter I will analyze another physics theory – namely, Quantum Physics – and will consider its less discussed relations to the concept of Nothing. One of the very first Greek philosophers, Thales (624–548 BCE) from Miletus, declared that Something can not appear from Nothing and it can not disappear, turning into Nothing. This idea, in some aspects, was further developed by Zeno from Elea (495–430 BCE) when he created his paradoxes of motion. These paradoxes can be understood as an analysis of the possibility of infinite division of time and space intervals. When we come to Quantum Physics, the very first appearance of the idea of the smallest possible portion of energy, quantum, was stimulated by the analysis of the spectrum of radiation of heated body – black-body radiation. German physicist Max Planck (1858–1947) demonstrated in 1899 that if we assume that there exists a smallest portion of radiation energy that can not be further divided into smaller parts, we arrive at the description of spectrum of the black-body radiation that perfectly matches the observable reality. In contrast, if we assume that radiation energy can be divided an infinite number of times and there does not exist the smallest possible portion, we arrive at the radiation spectrum which is in a sharp contradiction with observable reality. This contradiction is so strong that it has acquired a special term – the ultraviolet catastrophe. Certain parallels in Zeno’s reasoning and approach used in Quantum Physics can clearly be seen and will be discussed. In the conclusion, I will briefly touch on a similar situation in another field of physics when at the other extreme, departure from the idea of the possibility of the infinitely large quantities, this time velocities of motion, gave birth to another theory of modern physics – Einstein’s theory of special relativity.
In an Einstein like gedanken experiment, the relativistic changes of energies of a photon and a rest mass particle caused by the same relative movement were compared and it was found, that the same relative movement was causing very different energetic changes on the photons and rest mass particles: photons have significantly more “capacity” for kinetic energy. To explain this phenomena, which could be named kinetic capacity effect, a physical model of a “folded and looped photon” was created and checked quantitatively through relativistic Doppler effect for kinetic and total energies, and for linear momentum. De Broglie’s material wave was identified as modulation wave of two interfering waves of the correlated half photons inside of the particle, resulting in known group and phase velocities. Photons themselves were not changed in physical description, so Quantum Mechanics will stay in use with them, and Special Relativity has now extended abilities for entering into particles, opening a way through discussed model to unify both theoretical worlds. For the moment, the two classical theories, waves and relativity, have confirmed exact the hypothesis of present model.
Semi-relativistic NNN-body quantum mechanics of electrons and photons, with fixed nuclei
It is argued that by the end of the 1920s a quantum-mechanical model could have been in place, that not only produces the atomic and molecular energy levels of the many-body Pauli equation with Coulomb interactions and external classical electro- and magneto-static fields without putting these interactions in by hand, but that also accurately describes the interaction of charged particles with electromagnetic radiation, in particular the transitions between atomic or molecular energy levels associated with emission or absorption of radiation. This model suggests a re-interpretation of Maxwell's electromagnetic field equations on spacetime as quantum-mechanical expected values of wave equations on time X configuration space for photons and electrons. The creation / annihilation formalism for photons emerges without invoking second-quantizing the classical Maxwell equations, and without involving the concept of creation / annihilation, thus suggesting an alternative physical interpretation of this formalism. Furthermore, the model suggests that Lorentz covariance of macroscopic physics models emerges through a law of large numbers from a fundamental microscopic model that is not itself Lorentz covariant.
At the beginning of the century doubts were growing about the whole edifice of classical physics, including the laws of mechanics in their Lagrangian and Hamiltonian forms, of statistical thermodynamics, as formulated by Boltzmann and Gibbs, and of optics, namely Maxwell’s and Fresnel’s theory. Einstein proposed that electromagnetic radiation exists in discrete quanta whilst propagating in space as well as during the emission or absorption processes. Scattering by free electrons is a common interaction connected with the absorption of electromagnetic radiation. If the electromagnetic energy is large compared with the ionization energy, the atomic electron can be treated as free. The characteristic features of the scattered radiation have been explained by Compton, on the basis of an elastic collision of a photon with a free electron, where both energy and momentum are conserved. The concept of the matter wavelength holds for both relativistic and non-relativistic particles, provided that the appropriate form of momentum is used.
Planck, Einstein and Bose all had to introduce statistics, and thus counting, in order to successfully derive an equation for the energy distribution within the black-body radiation spectrum, and what we now call Bose-Einstein statistics. Some of the details involved in the counting procedure vary while still giving the same result. However, the interpretation of what we count may differ dramatically from one another (as, for example, between Planck and Bose), without impacting the final, mathematical result. We demonstrate here a further alternative, which varies both, in the details of the counting, as well as in the interpretation, while still producing the same well known statistics. This approach puts the "quantumness" back into the radiation emission/absorption process, possibly dispensing with the requirement of quantized light, at least in the context of black-body radiation.