Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Some Fundamental Modifications to Einstein’s Model of the Absorption and Emission of Radiation by Matter

W. A. Tiefenbrunner

Published Mar 12, 2026• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In 1916, A. Einstein developed a model of the absorption and emission of radiation from which he derived M. Planck’s radiation law. He postulated light-induced (stimulated) emission, because within the framework of classical physics an oscillator can, depending on the phase difference, both extract energy from the electromagnetic field and transfer energy to it. In a non-coherent field, α = β should hold, where α denotes the kinetic constant of absorption and β that of stimulated emission. This assumption is indispensable for deriving the radiation law from his model. In this context, it is problematic that a certain degree of field coherence follows necessarily from his model, which implies that α ≠ β. Moreover, the model cannot readily be generalised to fields of arbitrary coherence. An alternative model for the absorption and emission of radiation by matter is therefore developed here. On the one hand, it is based on the assumption that, within a blackbody, quanta of different energies may recombine freely; on the other hand, it employs the “pairwise interference model of quantum theory” (PIMOQ). The alternative model of the interaction between light and matter allows the radiation law to be derived for thermal equilibrium in a non-coherent field, under which conditions, according to the model, no stimulated emissions occur. It also describes the behaviour of systems with a coherent field (interference experiment, laser). Furthermore, considerations are presented regarding the energy distribution within a blackbody and the explanatory scope of A. Einstein’s model in this respect.

DOI
10.20944/preprints202603.0962.v1

Related papers

Einstein’s Theory of Matter–Field Interaction

The first quantum theory of light was introduced by Albert Einstein in 1917. He wrote the rate equation for atomic energy levels in a thermal equilibrium with the blackbody radiation and introduced spontaneous emission for the first time. His rate equation with modification for a single mode field surprisingly resembles the modern laser rate equation. In this chapter, we will review Einstein’s theory in terms of A and B coefficients with the former describing spontaneous emission and the later accounting for stimulated emission and absorption. We then use the Schrödinger equation to calculate the transition rate of a two-level atom under a driving field and associate it with the B coefficient and then derive the quantum expression for the A coefficient, which is equated with the radiative decay rate Γ 0 . Lastly, we will discuss the atom and photon rate equations with introduction of the laser coupling constant K in terms of the Einstein A coefficient and the p parameter accounting for the number of cavity modes in the atomic emission linewidth. A lasing threshold occurs clearly when p ≫1.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 1, 2023•0 citations

On the Interpretation of Quantum Physics: Energy Transfer Between Field and Matter According to the “Pairwise Interference Model” and a Quantum-Physical Measurement Problem

Wolfgang Tiefenbrunner

In classical electrodynamic wave theory, the intensity of light is proportional to the square of the amplitude of the electric field; in quantum theory, according to the conventional interpretation, the probability of detecting a light particle (and hence, ultimately, the photon density) is given by the square of the probability amplitude (as prescribed by the Born rule, which itself lacks a deeper theoretical justification). A mathematical formulation equivalent to the path integral provides, within the framework of the Pairwise Interference Model (PIMOQ), an alternative interpretation that is mutually exclusive with the conventional one. According to this interpretation, quantum physics, within the scope considered here, describes the local (at the detector), intrinsically bidirectional, quantised energy transfer between field and matter (apart from quantisation this is in direct analogy with classical physics). In the case of constructive interference, this transfer is unidirectional, occurring exclusively from matter to the field, whereas in the case of destructive interference the two opposing energy fluxes are equal in magnitude. However, it appears that in the macroscopic world only the net balance of these two antagonistic and complementary fluxes is experimentally observable, whereas the individual contributions cannot be measured independently. This limitation is referred to here as a quantum-physical measurement problem. From this perspective, quantum physics constitutes a subdiscipline of thermodynamics with a correspondingly limited domain of applicability. Although the principle discussed is as fundamental as, for example, the principle of conservation of energy, this does not imply that the underlying physical processes must necessarily be identical in every situation in which the principle applies. This interpretation is further elaborated through a discussion of interference experiments employing coherent and incoherent light sources, as well as the generation of coherent light in the laser.

•Jul 20, 2026•0 citations

From the Light Quantum to the Photon: The Evolution of a Physical Concept

Aaron Collavini, Valentina Bologna, Francesco Longo +2 more

This work examines the physical and conceptual evolution of the light quantum from Planck's blackbody theory to the theoretical and experimental developments that led to the quantization of the electromagnetic field. The present study shows that the decisive transition occurred in Einstein's quantum theory of radiation (1916-1917). Absorption, stimulated emission, and spontaneous emission were formulated as elementary probabilistic mechanisms whose statistical balance alone reproduces the blackbody spectrum. In particular, spontaneous emission requires the emission of a light quantum, thereby implicitly proving its physical necessity before its theoretical status was clarified. At the same time, the already existing term photon began to acquire a stable usage following Lewis's 1926 proposal and became increasingly associated with Einstein's light quantum. By the mid-1920s, the central problem had shifted from whether light quanta were physically required to how radiation could be incorporated into the emerging quantum-mechanical formalism. This transition marks a key stage, illustrating how initial debates about the existence of light quanta gave way to their integration into a comprehensive theoretical structure. The resulting asymmetry between the novel quantum description of matter and the still-classical description of radiation, called into question by the phenomenon of spontaneous emission, identifies the physical problem that led to the quantization of the electromagnetic field.

physics.hist-phCross-listedarXiv:2609.04985•Sep 7, 2026

Bose and Einstein – A New Way of Counting (1924)

S. Brandt

Abstract There are two rather different phenomena that furthered the development of quantum theory: blackbody radiation and atomic spectra. In fact quantum theory began in 1900 with Planck’s radiation law and his introduction of the quantum of action h (Episode 7). His derivation of the law was by no means stringent. He assumed the existence of many resonators (atoms or molecules) of different but fixed frequencies ν, which could emit or absorb radiation only in quanta of energy E = hν. Einstein, in his light-quantum hypothesis of 1905, postulated that the energy quantization is a property of the radiation field itself and not due to the material resonators. He found a similarity between a cavity filled with radiation consisting of quanta and a vessel filled with gas consisting of atoms. However, he could not obtain Planck’s law but only Wien’s (Episode 10).

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 22, 1992•0 citations

Stimulated Emission

In this chapter the concepts of spontaneous emission, absorption, and stimulated emission are discussed in a quantitative manner. Blackbody radiation is analyzed in terms of both Planck’s and Einstein’s derivations. Using Einstein’s analysis the relationships between spontaneous emission, absorption, and stimulated emission are derived. Both classical and semi-classical treatments are presented for absorption and stimulated emission.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jun 12, 2017•0 citations

Phase aspect in photon emission and absorption

Markus Pollnau

In the literature one finds several conflicting accounts of the phase difference of stimulated and spontaneous emission, as well as absorption, with respect to an existing (triggering) electromagnetic field. One of these approaches proposes that stimulated emission and absorption occur in phase and out of phase with their driving field, respectively, whereas spontaneous emission occurs under an arbitrary phase difference with respect to an existing field. It has served as a basis for explaining quantum-mechanically the laser linewidth, its narrowing by a factor of 2 around the laser threshold, as well as its broadening due to amplitude–phase coupling, resulting in Henry’s α-factor. Assuming the validity of Maxwell’s equations, all three processes would, thus, violate the law of energy conservation. In semi-classical approaches, we investigate stimulated emission in a Fabry–Perot resonator, analyze the Lorentz oscillator model, apply the Kramers–Kronig relations to the complex susceptibility, understand the summation of quantized electric fields, and quantitatively interpret emission and absorption in the amplitude–phase diagram. In all cases, we derive that the phase of stimulated emission is 90° in lead of the driving field, and the phase of absorption lags 90° behind the transmitted field. Also spontaneous emission must obey energy conservation, hence it occurs with 90° phase in lead of an existing field. These semi-classical findings agree with recent experimental investigations regarding the interaction of attosecond pulses with an atom, thereby questioning the physical explanation of the laser linewidth and its narrowing or broadening.

Optica•Apr 12, 2018•33 citations
In 1916, A. Einstein developed a model of the absorption and emission of radiation from which he derived M. Planck’s radiation law. He postulated light-induced (stimulated) emission, because within the framework of classical physics an oscillator can, depending on the phase difference, both extract energy from the electromagnetic field and transfer energy to it. In a non-coherent field, α = β should hold, where α denotes the kinetic constant of absorption and β that of stimulated emission. This assumption is indispensable for deriving the radiation law from his model. In this context, it is problematic that a certain degree of field coherence follows necessarily from his model, which implies that α ≠ β. Moreover, the model cannot readily be generalised to fields of arbitrary coherence. An alternative model for the absorption and emission of radiation by matter is therefore developed here. On the one hand, it is based on the assumption that, within a blackbody, quanta of different energies may recombine freely; on the other hand, it employs the “pairwise interference model of quantum theory” (PIMOQ). The alternative model of the interaction between light and matter allows the radiation law to be derived for thermal equilibrium in a non-coherent field, under which conditions, according to the model, no stimulated emissions occur. It also describes the behaviour of systems with a coherent field (interference experiment, laser). Furthermore, considerations are presented regarding the energy distribution within a blackbody and the explanatory scope of A. Einstein’s model in this respect.
The first quantum theory of light was introduced by Albert Einstein in 1917. He wrote the rate equation for atomic energy levels in a thermal equilibrium with the blackbody radiation and introduced spontaneous emission for the first time. His rate equation with modification for a single mode field surprisingly resembles the modern laser rate equation. In this chapter, we will review Einstein’s theory in terms of A and B coefficients with the former describing spontaneous emission and the later accounting for stimulated emission and absorption. We then use the Schrödinger equation to calculate the transition rate of a two-level atom under a driving field and associate it with the B coefficient and then derive the quantum expression for the A coefficient, which is equated with the radiative decay rate Γ 0 . Lastly, we will discuss the atom and photon rate equations with introduction of the laser coupling constant K in terms of the Einstein A coefficient and the p parameter accounting for the number of cavity modes in the atomic emission linewidth. A lasing threshold occurs clearly when p ≫1.
In classical electrodynamic wave theory, the intensity of light is proportional to the square of the amplitude of the electric field; in quantum theory, according to the conventional interpretation, the probability of detecting a light particle (and hence, ultimately, the photon density) is given by the square of the probability amplitude (as prescribed by the Born rule, which itself lacks a deeper theoretical justification). A mathematical formulation equivalent to the path integral provides, within the framework of the Pairwise Interference Model (PIMOQ), an alternative interpretation that is mutually exclusive with the conventional one. According to this interpretation, quantum physics, within the scope considered here, describes the local (at the detector), intrinsically bidirectional, quantised energy transfer between field and matter (apart from quantisation this is in direct analogy with classical physics). In the case of constructive interference, this transfer is unidirectional, occurring exclusively from matter to the field, whereas in the case of destructive interference the two opposing energy fluxes are equal in magnitude. However, it appears that in the macroscopic world only the net balance of these two antagonistic and complementary fluxes is experimentally observable, whereas the individual contributions cannot be measured independently. This limitation is referred to here as a quantum-physical measurement problem. From this perspective, quantum physics constitutes a subdiscipline of thermodynamics with a correspondingly limited domain of applicability. Although the principle discussed is as fundamental as, for example, the principle of conservation of energy, this does not imply that the underlying physical processes must necessarily be identical in every situation in which the principle applies. This interpretation is further elaborated through a discussion of interference experiments employing coherent and incoherent light sources, as well as the generation of coherent light in the laser.
This work examines the physical and conceptual evolution of the light quantum from Planck's blackbody theory to the theoretical and experimental developments that led to the quantization of the electromagnetic field. The present study shows that the decisive transition occurred in Einstein's quantum theory of radiation (1916-1917). Absorption, stimulated emission, and spontaneous emission were formulated as elementary probabilistic mechanisms whose statistical balance alone reproduces the blackbody spectrum. In particular, spontaneous emission requires the emission of a light quantum, thereby implicitly proving its physical necessity before its theoretical status was clarified. At the same time, the already existing term photon began to acquire a stable usage following Lewis's 1926 proposal and became increasingly associated with Einstein's light quantum. By the mid-1920s, the central problem had shifted from whether light quanta were physically required to how radiation could be incorporated into the emerging quantum-mechanical formalism. This transition marks a key stage, illustrating how initial debates about the existence of light quanta gave way to their integration into a comprehensive theoretical structure. The resulting asymmetry between the novel quantum description of matter and the still-classical description of radiation, called into question by the phenomenon of spontaneous emission, identifies the physical problem that led to the quantization of the electromagnetic field.
Abstract There are two rather different phenomena that furthered the development of quantum theory: blackbody radiation and atomic spectra. In fact quantum theory began in 1900 with Planck’s radiation law and his introduction of the quantum of action h (Episode 7). His derivation of the law was by no means stringent. He assumed the existence of many resonators (atoms or molecules) of different but fixed frequencies ν, which could emit or absorb radiation only in quanta of energy E = hν. Einstein, in his light-quantum hypothesis of 1905, postulated that the energy quantization is a property of the radiation field itself and not due to the material resonators. He found a similarity between a cavity filled with radiation consisting of quanta and a vessel filled with gas consisting of atoms. However, he could not obtain Planck’s law but only Wien’s (Episode 10).
In the literature one finds several conflicting accounts of the phase difference of stimulated and spontaneous emission, as well as absorption, with respect to an existing (triggering) electromagnetic field. One of these approaches proposes that stimulated emission and absorption occur in phase and out of phase with their driving field, respectively, whereas spontaneous emission occurs under an arbitrary phase difference with respect to an existing field. It has served as a basis for explaining quantum-mechanically the laser linewidth, its narrowing by a factor of 2 around the laser threshold, as well as its broadening due to amplitude–phase coupling, resulting in Henry’s α-factor. Assuming the validity of Maxwell’s equations, all three processes would, thus, violate the law of energy conservation. In semi-classical approaches, we investigate stimulated emission in a Fabry–Perot resonator, analyze the Lorentz oscillator model, apply the Kramers–Kronig relations to the complex susceptibility, understand the summation of quantized electric fields, and quantitatively interpret emission and absorption in the amplitude–phase diagram. In all cases, we derive that the phase of stimulated emission is 90° in lead of the driving field, and the phase of absorption lags 90° behind the transmitted field. Also spontaneous emission must obey energy conservation, hence it occurs with 90° phase in lead of an existing field. These semi-classical findings agree with recent experimental investigations regarding the interaction of attosecond pulses with an atom, thereby questioning the physical explanation of the laser linewidth and its narrowing or broadening.