Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:math/0512415 · Infinite Dimensional Analysis Quantum Probability and Related Topics

QUANTUM PROBABILITIES AND PARADOXES OF THE QUANTUM CENTURY

V. P. Belavkin

Published Dec 1, 2000• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A history and drama of the development of quantum probability theory is outlined starting from the discovery of the Plank's constant exactly a 100 years ago. It is shown that before the rise of quantum mechanics 75 years ago, the quantum theory had appeared first in the form of the statistics of quantum thermal noise and quantum spontaneous jumps which have never been explained by quantum mechanics. Moreover, the only reasonable probabilistic interpretation of quantum theory put forward by Max Born was in fact in irreconcilable contradiction with traditional mechanical reality and classical probabilistic causality. This led to numerous quantum paradoxes, some of them due to the great inventors of quantum theory such as Einstein and Schroedinger. They are reconsidered in this paper from the modern quantum probabilistic point of view.

DOI
10.1142/s0219025700000352

Related papers

Quantum causality, stochastics, trajectories and information

V. P. Belavkin

A history of the discovery of `new' quantum mechanics and the paradoxes of its probabilistic interpretation are briefly reviewed from the modern point of view of quantum probability and information. Modern quantum theory, which has been developed during the last 20 years for the treatment of quantum open systems including quantum noise, decoherence, quantum diffusions and spontaneous jumps occurring under continuous in time observation, is not yet a part of the standard curriculum of quantum physics. It is argued that the conventional formalism of quantum mechanics is insufficient for the description of quantum events, such as spontaneous decays say, and the new experimental phenomena related to individual quantum measurements, but they have all received an adequate mathematical treatment in quantum stochastics of open systems. Moreover, the only reasonable probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics put forward by Max Born was, in fact, in irreconcilable contradiction with traditional mechanical reality and causality. This led to numerous quantum paradoxes, some of them due to the great inventors of quantum theory such as Einstein and Schrödinger. They are reconsidered in this paper from the modern point of view of quantum stochastics and information. The development of quantum measurement theory, initiated by von Neumann, indicated a possibility for resolution of this interpretational crisis by divorcing the algebra of the dynamical generators and the algebra of the actual observables, or Bell's be ables. It is shown that within this approach quantum causality can be rehabilitated in the form of a superselection rule for compatibility of the actual histories with the potential future. This rule, together with the self-compatibility of the measurements ensuring the consistency of the histories, is called the nondemolition, or causality principle in modern quantum theory. The application of this rule in the form of dynamical commutation relations leads to the derivation of the von Neumann projection postulate, and also to the more general reductions, instantaneous, spontaneous, and even continuous in time. This gives a dynamical solution, in the form of the quantum stochastic filtering equations, of the notorious measurement problem which was tackled unsuccessfully by many famous physicists starting with Schrödinger and Bohr. It has been recently proved that the quantum stochastic model for the continuous in time measurements is equivalent to a Dirac type boundary-value problem for the secondary quantized input `offer waves from future' in one extra dimension, and to a reduction of the algebra of the consistent histories of past events to an Abelian subalgebra for the `trajectories of the output particles'. This supports the corpuscular-wave duality in the form of the thesis that everything in the future are quantized waves, while everything in the past are trajectories of the recorded particles.

arXiv:quant-ph/0208087•Reports on Progress in Physics•Feb 20, 2002•25 citations

An Analytic Approach to Probability Theory in Quantum Mechanics

Viktoras Rimsha, Laimontas Rimsha

Born’s probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics is commonly assumed to rely on classical probability theory in the sense of Kolmogorov. In this paper we argue that this assumption is methodologically unjustified. We show that quantum probabilities naturally arise from an analytic method fundamentally different from the synthetic approach underlying classical probability theory. In the analytic framework, the whole (the totality of alternatives) is primary, while probabilities of individual alternatives are derived quantities. Interference appears at the level of the realization probability of the whole, whereas conditional probabilities of alternatives remain additive within a given context. We demonstrate that many well-known quantum paradoxes originate from the inappropriate application of synthetic probabilistic reasoning. The proposed formulation is consistent with the Born rule, its extensions developed in our earlier works, and with Birkhoff–von Neumann quantum logic. Classical probability theory appears only as a degenerate formal limit and is not methodologically universal.

•Jan 29, 2026•0 citations

Introduction to Quantum Mechanics

Bala Ramu Ramachandran

Most textbooks say that quantum mechanics came into being when Max Planck, in a desperate attempt to construct a theory that explained experimental data, explored the radical idea of energy being radiated or absorbed by all bodies in discrete packets (or quanta). The energy content of a quantum of radiation is proportional to the frequency of the radiation emitted or absorbed, as in , and the proportionality constant bears the name of Planck. Planck himself was rather uncomfortable with the idea of energy packets, and spent a considerable amount of time in later years trying to “restore” the classical picture of continuous energy exchange between bodies and surroundings. However, in 1905 Einstein was able to use the idea of the quantum to explain the mechanism of the photoelectric effect, which cannot be explained in any other way! This established the reality of the quantum and so, it may be said that Einstein, rather than Planck, is the father of quantum mechanics. Within a few years, Neils Bohr constructed his model of the hydrogen atom in which the electron can only occupy certain special orbits around the nucleus, and any jump between these orbits is accompanied by energy being absorbed or emitted in the form of quanta. The nearly exact agreement of Bohr’s predictions based on the model and observed hydrogen atomic spectra was among the first impressive accomplishments of quantum mechanics.

•Jan 1, 1998•26 citations

Emergence of Quantum Theories from Classical Probability: Historical Origins, Developments, and Open Problems

Luigi Accardi, Yun Gang Lu

After briefly mentioning some achievements of quantum probability during the past 20 years, we concentrate our attention on the emergence of natural extensions of usual quantum theory from the combination of classical probability with the theory of orthogonal polynomials and we discuss some implications, both for mathematics and physics of this fact.

Journal of Stochastic Analysis•Dec 6, 2020•1 citation

Quantum Noise, Bits and Jumps: Uncertainties, Decoherence, Trajectories and Filtering

V. P. Belavkin

It is shown that many dissipative phenomena of "old" quantum mechanics which appeared 100 years ago in the form of the statistics of quantum thermal noise and quantum spontaneous jumps, have never been explained by the "new" conservative quantum mechanics discovered 75 years ago by Heisenberg and Schroedinger. This led to numerous quantum paradoxes which are reconsidered in this paper. The development of quantum measurement theory, initiated by von Neumann, indicated a possibility for resolution of this interpretational crisis by divorcing the algebra of the dynamical generators from the algebra of the actual observables. It is shown that within this approach quantum causality can be rehabilitated in the form of a superselection rule for compatibility of past observables with the potential future. This rule, together with the self-compatibility of measurements insuring the consistency of histories, is called the nondemolition principle. The application of this causality condition in the form of the dynamical commutation relations leads to the derivation of the generalized von Neumann reductions, usharp, instantaneous, spontaneous, and even continuous in time. This gives a quantum probabilistic solution, in the form of the dynamical filtering equations, of the notorious measurement problem which was tackled unsuccessfully by many famous physicists starting with Schroedinger and Bohr. The simplest Markovian quantum stochastic model for the continuous in time measurements involves a boundary-value problem in second quantization for input "offer" waves in one extra dimension, and a reduction of the algebra of "actual" observables to an Abelian subalgebra for the output waves.

arXiv:quant-ph/0512208•Dec 22, 2005•2 citations

Quantum Mechanics as a Reversible Diffusion Theory

Charalampos Antonakos

This paper proposes an interpretation of quantum mechanics, relying on the time-symmetric stochastic dynamics of quantum particles and on non-classical probability theory. Our main purpose is to demonstrate that the wave function and its complex conjugate can be interpreted as complex probability distributions in two complex diffusion equations related to non-real forward and backward in time stochastic motions respectively. We say non-real because Schroedinger forward and backward diffusions describe both reversible (real trajectories) and irreversible trajectories (non-real trajectories). The reversible trajectories are the only real trajectories and are given by the intersection of those forward and backward processes. It turns out that if we translate this intersection using set-theoretic language, we are led to a reversible diffusion described by Born rule probabilities. This proposal is useful also for explaining more about the role of complex numbers in quantum mechanics that produces this so-called "wave-like" nature of quantum reality. Our perspective also challenges the notion of physical superposition and aims at a derivation of superposition principle not based on the linearity of Schroedinger's equation but relying on pure probability theory. Moreover, it is suggested that, embracing the idea of stochastic processes in quantum theory, explains the reasons for the appearance of classical behavior in large objects, in contrast to the quantum behavior of small ones. In other words, we claim that a combination of a probabilistic and no-ontic view (neither epistemic though) of the wave function with a stochastic hidden-variables approach, may provide some insight into the quantum physical reality and potentially establish the groundwork for a novel interpretation of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2502.10523•Feb 14, 2025•0 citations
A history and drama of the development of quantum probability theory is outlined starting from the discovery of the Plank's constant exactly a 100 years ago. It is shown that before the rise of quantum mechanics 75 years ago, the quantum theory had appeared first in the form of the statistics of quantum thermal noise and quantum spontaneous jumps which have never been explained by quantum mechanics. Moreover, the only reasonable probabilistic interpretation of quantum theory put forward by Max Born was in fact in irreconcilable contradiction with traditional mechanical reality and classical probabilistic causality. This led to numerous quantum paradoxes, some of them due to the great inventors of quantum theory such as Einstein and Schroedinger. They are reconsidered in this paper from the modern quantum probabilistic point of view.
A history of the discovery of `new' quantum mechanics and the paradoxes of its probabilistic interpretation are briefly reviewed from the modern point of view of quantum probability and information. Modern quantum theory, which has been developed during the last 20 years for the treatment of quantum open systems including quantum noise, decoherence, quantum diffusions and spontaneous jumps occurring under continuous in time observation, is not yet a part of the standard curriculum of quantum physics. It is argued that the conventional formalism of quantum mechanics is insufficient for the description of quantum events, such as spontaneous decays say, and the new experimental phenomena related to individual quantum measurements, but they have all received an adequate mathematical treatment in quantum stochastics of open systems. Moreover, the only reasonable probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics put forward by Max Born was, in fact, in irreconcilable contradiction with traditional mechanical reality and causality. This led to numerous quantum paradoxes, some of them due to the great inventors of quantum theory such as Einstein and Schrödinger. They are reconsidered in this paper from the modern point of view of quantum stochastics and information. The development of quantum measurement theory, initiated by von Neumann, indicated a possibility for resolution of this interpretational crisis by divorcing the algebra of the dynamical generators and the algebra of the actual observables, or Bell's be ables. It is shown that within this approach quantum causality can be rehabilitated in the form of a superselection rule for compatibility of the actual histories with the potential future. This rule, together with the self-compatibility of the measurements ensuring the consistency of the histories, is called the nondemolition, or causality principle in modern quantum theory. The application of this rule in the form of dynamical commutation relations leads to the derivation of the von Neumann projection postulate, and also to the more general reductions, instantaneous, spontaneous, and even continuous in time. This gives a dynamical solution, in the form of the quantum stochastic filtering equations, of the notorious measurement problem which was tackled unsuccessfully by many famous physicists starting with Schrödinger and Bohr. It has been recently proved that the quantum stochastic model for the continuous in time measurements is equivalent to a Dirac type boundary-value problem for the secondary quantized input `offer waves from future' in one extra dimension, and to a reduction of the algebra of the consistent histories of past events to an Abelian subalgebra for the `trajectories of the output particles'. This supports the corpuscular-wave duality in the form of the thesis that everything in the future are quantized waves, while everything in the past are trajectories of the recorded particles.
Born’s probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics is commonly assumed to rely on classical probability theory in the sense of Kolmogorov. In this paper we argue that this assumption is methodologically unjustified. We show that quantum probabilities naturally arise from an analytic method fundamentally different from the synthetic approach underlying classical probability theory. In the analytic framework, the whole (the totality of alternatives) is primary, while probabilities of individual alternatives are derived quantities. Interference appears at the level of the realization probability of the whole, whereas conditional probabilities of alternatives remain additive within a given context. We demonstrate that many well-known quantum paradoxes originate from the inappropriate application of synthetic probabilistic reasoning. The proposed formulation is consistent with the Born rule, its extensions developed in our earlier works, and with Birkhoff–von Neumann quantum logic. Classical probability theory appears only as a degenerate formal limit and is not methodologically universal.
Most textbooks say that quantum mechanics came into being when Max Planck, in a desperate attempt to construct a theory that explained experimental data, explored the radical idea of energy being radiated or absorbed by all bodies in discrete packets (or quanta). The energy content of a quantum of radiation is proportional to the frequency of the radiation emitted or absorbed, as in , and the proportionality constant bears the name of Planck. Planck himself was rather uncomfortable with the idea of energy packets, and spent a considerable amount of time in later years trying to “restore” the classical picture of continuous energy exchange between bodies and surroundings. However, in 1905 Einstein was able to use the idea of the quantum to explain the mechanism of the photoelectric effect, which cannot be explained in any other way! This established the reality of the quantum and so, it may be said that Einstein, rather than Planck, is the father of quantum mechanics. Within a few years, Neils Bohr constructed his model of the hydrogen atom in which the electron can only occupy certain special orbits around the nucleus, and any jump between these orbits is accompanied by energy being absorbed or emitted in the form of quanta. The nearly exact agreement of Bohr’s predictions based on the model and observed hydrogen atomic spectra was among the first impressive accomplishments of quantum mechanics.
It is shown that many dissipative phenomena of "old" quantum mechanics which appeared 100 years ago in the form of the statistics of quantum thermal noise and quantum spontaneous jumps, have never been explained by the "new" conservative quantum mechanics discovered 75 years ago by Heisenberg and Schroedinger. This led to numerous quantum paradoxes which are reconsidered in this paper. The development of quantum measurement theory, initiated by von Neumann, indicated a possibility for resolution of this interpretational crisis by divorcing the algebra of the dynamical generators from the algebra of the actual observables. It is shown that within this approach quantum causality can be rehabilitated in the form of a superselection rule for compatibility of past observables with the potential future. This rule, together with the self-compatibility of measurements insuring the consistency of histories, is called the nondemolition principle. The application of this causality condition in the form of the dynamical commutation relations leads to the derivation of the generalized von Neumann reductions, usharp, instantaneous, spontaneous, and even continuous in time. This gives a quantum probabilistic solution, in the form of the dynamical filtering equations, of the notorious measurement problem which was tackled unsuccessfully by many famous physicists starting with Schroedinger and Bohr. The simplest Markovian quantum stochastic model for the continuous in time measurements involves a boundary-value problem in second quantization for input "offer" waves in one extra dimension, and a reduction of the algebra of "actual" observables to an Abelian subalgebra for the output waves.
This paper proposes an interpretation of quantum mechanics, relying on the time-symmetric stochastic dynamics of quantum particles and on non-classical probability theory. Our main purpose is to demonstrate that the wave function and its complex conjugate can be interpreted as complex probability distributions in two complex diffusion equations related to non-real forward and backward in time stochastic motions respectively. We say non-real because Schroedinger forward and backward diffusions describe both reversible (real trajectories) and irreversible trajectories (non-real trajectories). The reversible trajectories are the only real trajectories and are given by the intersection of those forward and backward processes. It turns out that if we translate this intersection using set-theoretic language, we are led to a reversible diffusion described by Born rule probabilities. This proposal is useful also for explaining more about the role of complex numbers in quantum mechanics that produces this so-called "wave-like" nature of quantum reality. Our perspective also challenges the notion of physical superposition and aims at a derivation of superposition principle not based on the linearity of Schroedinger's equation but relying on pure probability theory. Moreover, it is suggested that, embracing the idea of stochastic processes in quantum theory, explains the reasons for the appearance of classical behavior in large objects, in contrast to the quantum behavior of small ones. In other words, we claim that a combination of a probabilistic and no-ontic view (neither epistemic though) of the wave function with a stochastic hidden-variables approach, may provide some insight into the quantum physical reality and potentially establish the groundwork for a novel interpretation of quantum mechanics.